* Posts by Dave Bell

2133 publicly visible posts • joined 14 Sep 2007

Fairness FAIL: When small print contradicts the big print

Dave Bell

Trying to be fair...

The trouble is that they can't give a 100% guarantee, even before hardware failures and the like which can afflict any communication service. OK, there are things that can be done to cover the initital situation, where it becomes apparent that the customer can't get a reliable connection to the network. But that's a whole different sort of problem from them messing up business admin. It's a shift from "Ye cannae break the laws of physics," to the Ferengi Rules of Acquisition.

Conviction overturned for abuse images bought from bookshop

Dave Bell

Not really new, is it.

It's not that hard to find examples of the UK Police chasing after books by the two photographers named in the article. It's been going on for decades. If their books are on open sale, it would be barely credible that the publisher hadn't checked the legality.

Court OK's Assange Sweden extradition, given 7 days to appeal

Dave Bell

And what will the USA do?

There's a lot of political stupidity in the USA, even suggestions Assange should face the death penalty. And I'm not sure |I could rely on a British court, faced with an extradition request from the USA. Sweden, on the other hand, doesn't have that "Special Relationship" fetish, and this case has put them on notice to be very careful about the Americans and what they might request.

Is it a cunning plan? Who knows.

Jacqui Smith 'shocked' to discover we're drowning in sea of porn

Dave Bell
Big Brother

Here we go again.

There are certainly aspects of porn which need attention.

Is censorship really the only available tool?

It's possible that some of the questionable aspects, such as the apparent attitude to women, arise from there being an audience that will pay for it, and just eliminating the porn will not change that attitude. It will still get passed on as part of the package of "manly" behaviour. And some of that was around in the far more constrained days of "Page three of The Sun".

Make your own guitar with a 3D printer

Dave Bell
Go

The big question

To some extent, you're paying for bragging rights.

There are places which sell guitar kits: if you put the effort into the finishing, you would certainly have something unique which you could be confident of sounding good. It depends what you think your time is worth, but there is that personal feeling about making it. It becomes a little more special.

Interesting tech-geekery: there are solid-state circuits out there which emulate valves, so that you can make a working "valve" amplifier which doesn't need obsolete batteries or spares.

Anonymous security firm hack used every trick in book

Dave Bell

Who to believe?

Even if HBGary have originals which are safe to publish, they've "had these emails for days": which is the fake?

Boffin breakthrough doubles Wi-Fi speed

Dave Bell

Reality is a complicated place,

This works with the direct signals from the Tx aerials, close to the wi-fi box, which are also the strongest signals. A few metres away something is reflecting the two signals, fillinf in some of the gaps in the pattern. Yes, that can of cola on my desk is necessary to provide a good signal on the other side of the office,

I used to be able to tell if a truck was coming down the road because of the effect on the digital TV signal. I got a better signal by pointing the aerial at the church tower.

Paleontologists: Standardise 3D laser image files, for pity's sake

Dave Bell

Wavefront .obj format.

Yes, it is plain ASCII.

It's not perfect. For one thing, there doesn't seem to be any way of recording the scale (except as a comment in the file). 1 unit in Poser is around 8 feet (it's changed between versions for no apparent reason), while in other systems it might be a metre or a foot or a half-fathom.

There's usually three sub-sections to the file. First, the set of vertices. These can be referenced by the modified line-number. Then the UV coordinates of each point (Mapping the 3D point onto a 2D texture--limited use here). Finally the polygons, made up of edges defined by pairs of vertex numbers.

Poser uses 6 digits after the decimal place, which for a scale of 100 inches per unit means you can define a shape to 1/10000 of an inch. Is that excessive detail?

There are elements of the format, such as defining the material of a polygon, which have little obvious use. In the example of the dinosaur footprint one might want to distiguish the footprint from the surrounding surface. And the UV map data might be useful for rendering software, allowing 2D images to be mapped onto a 3D model.

It's maybe easier to translate to some future format than some file formats are. Does it record enough the right data for this use? I've noticed quite a few resolutely proprietary formats in the world of 3D models. They can be a pain in the butt.

Latest boffinry: Feeding TNT to sheep

Dave Bell

Maybe it isn't the sheep that are the problem.

People have been talking about plants to concentrate soild contaminants for a long time. It's one of those Tomorrow's World gee-whiz revelations that seems to never arrive. I suspect that one of the problems is in harvesting the crop.

The sheep get around that problem.

Finding the right grass, and making sure it grows, that's hard. They're trying to bypass a lot of evolution. And somewhere such as Salisbury Plain is ecologically valuable because all the explosive stuff scattered around the landscape keeps the humans from messing around.

First reports on XM-25 Judge Dredd smartgun in A'Stan

Dave Bell

Mass-production?

I doubt the rounds are what we would recognise as hand-made. It's going to be low-production, not highly-automated, and expensive, The fuse assembly might get screwed into place by hand, rather than by a machine: WW2 mass production, not hand-made.

Besides, how do you hand-make an IC? A very tiny hammer and chisel?

ROBOT COP scatters LIVE GRENADES in San Francisco STREET

Dave Bell
Grenade

Grenades...

There are three main possibiliities.

1: Inert training grenade, which might be identifiable by the paint scheme.

2: Un-fused grenade, the way in which they were normally shipped, with no fuse.

3: Fused, and so likely to be very dangerous with age.

The trouble is that it may not be easy to tell whether the thing is fused

Carrying something like this in a paper bag seems a trifle reckless.

ICO Deputy exposes Data Protection law wish list

Dave Bell
WTF?

Meanwhile, in the USA...

How many of us have had dealings with companies based outside the EU? Right now, I have an account with a US company which is trying to persuade customers to sign up with Facebook so as to find out what is happening.

World shrugs as IPv4 addresses finally exhausted

Dave Bell
FAIL

The ISPs don't seem to care.

My ISP isn't officially giving any advice on IPv6. I'm not sure that the hardware it supplies to customers has any ability to handle IPv6. Not saying anything seems terribly short-sighted. Especially when Windows has supported IPv6 for most of this century.

DWP seeks data for identity verification service

Dave Bell

Doesn't add up...

That figure for 2 million quid for 2 years, and around 200,000 claimants a year needing the extra data, I find it hard to believe. It begins to look as though they've hit the point of diminishing returns, and risk spending more than they could save.

Especially if there are the usual budget overruns on an IT project.

US Wikileaks investigators can't link Assange to Manning

Dave Bell

Not just mislabelling

There's a strip of non-existent woodland on one OS map. I know, because I measured that field up for IACS purposes, after somebody questioned the area marked on the OS 1:10000 mapping.

Pirates: Good for Microsoft, great for open sourcers

Dave Bell

Baen work at it...

Baen Books is a pretty determined operation, and they've been working the internet hard as a publicity source. Free books, and free sample of books, as well as a paid-for ebook service. They include CD-ROMs with hardbacks, giving you ebook versions of a whole series with the new novel.

I have a substantial stack of printed versions.

And, you know, publishers have always had people giving away their products, letting them be read for free. These heinous criminal have a special name: "librarians".

Leica S2 professional medium format DSLR

Dave Bell
Thumb Up

No Surprises

It's a Leica.

The price is breath-taking.

So is the quality.

Anne Hathaway slips into catsuit

Dave Bell

Costuming matters a lot

I have to agree.

Halle Berry's performance was pretty good, I thought, but she looked her best in the semi-improvised costume she wore mid-film, rather than in the "designed" costume worn later.

Yes, I know that both were "designed", and neither was inconspicuous, but that mid-film outfit was something you could believe she could use without a convenient phone-box to change in.

Dave Bell

Obvious lines

If I were writing the script I would be trying to sneak in a line about a "second best bed".

Who are the biggest electric car liars - the BBC, or Tesla Motors?

Dave Bell

A useful stunt?

There's certainly some excessive hype in this affair, but both journeys tell us something. Perhaps it would have been worth mentioning that Jeremy Clarkson drove a car from London to Edinburgh and back on one tank of diesel. And perhaps it would have been worth mentioning that electric cars, when the infrastructure exists, will potentially reduce pollution within cities.

I'm reminded of the way that LPG was promoted as a fuel, and I remember how few places there were to get it. Locally, there was an agricultural machinery dealer (who would also convert your vehicle), and the district council transport depot. Ten years later, it's still two places, a different two, as far as I can tell (and the site I checked for that goves a price comparison from Novermber 2009).

But the ugly reality is that electric cars are going to be for those in well-paid jobs, and the rest of us will, as fuel costs rise, become dependent on public transport. It was Tony Blair who linked his name to the phrase "joined up writing", and failed to deliver on the promise of more-coordinated government. This lot don't even seem to be trying.

Yorks cops bust Bradford guinea pig farm

Dave Bell

Chorophyll

I'm not sure of the exact spectrum that chlorophyll absorbs to power the growth of plants, but remember that the green we see is what is not absorbed. And green plants do reflect a lot of red light. Maybe there could be a more efficient source of the right colours of light than a simple hot-filament bulb, but it is going to be something special.

Render farming is hot!

Dave Bell

Legionnaire's Disease?

This should be a a well-known risk, and should be manageable with the right routine maintenance, but if you're not used to dealing with water evaporation as an air-cooling method, I can see it catching somebody by surprise.

The Girl with the NSObject Class Reference tattoo

Dave Bell

Non-sucking tech in novels.

Charles Stross does a good job.

Ford unveils all-electric Focus for 2012

Dave Bell

Waste Heat

There's always going to be heat generated in the motors and batteries. Even with liquid cooling for the battery, that heat has to be dumped into the air eventually.

And besides, this is a modification of an existing vehicle design. Don't expect big bodywork changes. The next generation of vehicle might be designed differently.

Feds relax export curbs on open-source crypto

Dave Bell

Curious Side Effect?

There's quite a few companies and products that rely on closed-source encryption. Is the encryption for region-locking of DVDs officially open or closed? An Xbox?

The potential market increase for any of these is relatively small, and language differences get in the way of American exports. At most, it clears up any doubts about licensed manufacture outside the USA. Whoever makes Arabic-language DVDs and DVD players, they've a chance of being in the clear now over the sales to Syria.

Footie fans in 'cunthorpe Utd' calendar shocker

Dave Bell

Older than Hotmail

As I recall, it was AOL who banned Scunthorpe. The customer who they almost lost then signed up with the name of one of the villages which were combined to form Scunthorpe.

Frodingham: it rather sounds worse, doesn't it.

BT fibre-up-your-exchange poll in 6-way Mugabe style pileup

Dave Bell

More of the usual

So it's the normal broadband speed advert?

Up to infinity, and beyond!

British-born NASA astronaut Piers Sellers becomes OBE

Dave Bell

Did anyone see the original PDF from the Beeb?

The version out this morning had a terrible layout: obviously broken, rather than poor design.

When did they notice?

Apple patent endangers unbiased product reviews

Dave Bell

Clarke's Communication Satellite ideas

They were published on the October 1945 issue of Wireless World. Not a novel, a technical paper in a technically-oriented publication, with some calculations of such things as the power needed. That's a different thing to a novel.

Dave Bell

Wasn't this in "The Shockwave Rider"?

And thus terribly old. 1975, and DARPA, the Mad Science arm of the Pentagon, were going toi implement it as the Policy Analysis Market.

DARPA is likely better prior art under patent law than a 1975 novel.

Diary of a Not-spot: The readers speak

Dave Bell
Boffin

The point about transformers

OK, so a transformer has an input at 240v RMS and puts out, for instance, 12v RMS. That then gets rectified and smoothed, etc. But even if the AC outputs got out of the box, and were on different phases, we're only talking about 20v or so.

This is well within the limits of the built-in isolators. Somebody ought to check, but if they're supposed to be useful protection against accidents, it makes sense that they'll protect against the mains voltages. Lightning strikes are a whole different problem.

You can still have nasty things happen if you run an extension lead over. So don't.

Feds raid server farms in bid to root out PayPal DDoS perps

Dave Bell

Headline English

This sounds like a quite technically competent investigation. It's not storming in the wguns and taking away everything that might be computer.

FBI Raids aren't what they used to be. And what did they actually "seize"?

ACPO exec wants 'ugly mugs' database to protect sex workers

Dave Bell

I've very mixed feelings about the issues

In the end, there seems to be something fundamentally misogynistic about the sex industry, whether within the law (such as porn) or not (prostitution). And it all reinforces some rather ugly thinking about women, with depictions of fun activities overloaded with hatred.

Yes, all this stuff about the failings of the law needs to be sorted out. But Las Vegas was built with money from organised crime. Legal gambling didn't get rid of the bad guys. It needs a much more radical solution, if only because some police officers will always be finding ways to use the law.

As it happens, I met a sex worker once, though she seemed to be more on the porn side of the line of legality, but what maybe makes her significant was that she was a union organiser as well. Look up anarcho-syndicalism and consider how that might work out: it's the sort of control that would be needed. implicit in the idea of prostitutes banding together for mutual protection. Without it, all we do is re-label the pimps. Human resources managers?

Vulture falls asleep in front of Christmas TV

Dave Bell

A reminder...

http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/012790.html#012790

Councils show true grit in the face of ... FOI requests

Dave Bell
Coat

Scylla and Charybdis

It is pretty bad of the councils to be claiming commercial confidentiality on this. Maybe there should be a timing policy, so they don't talk about the current financial year, but anything longer is a bit excessive.

And I can't say that the Taxpayers Alliance all that bright. As pointed out above, transport costs vary, and councils also vary in the miles of roads they cover. My local council publishes info on which roads they grit, and which they give priority. If you don't get that data for each council, publishing the total spend is ridiculous point-scoring, essentially meaningless in making any judgement of the quality of the council's purchasing process.

It's been a few years since I needed to keep track of transport costs for bulk loads. There was a while when distance from the ports could make the difference between profit and loss for a wheat farmer. since haulage distance affected the price at the farm gate. The cost per tonne for road salt is much lower: transport will make a huge difference.

Oh, and there are regulations in force now which make it difficult for bulk haulage to switch between certain sorts of load. I can recall loading grain onto a 20-tonner which had carried coal to a nearby power station, during the miner's strike, but you'd have problems doing that now. If you can't get that back-load, it doubles the cost.

(Army-surplus combat jacket with hank of baler twine trailing from one pocket.)

Double-clicking patent takes on world

Dave Bell

Patent Failure Modes

I'm not sure that this is a good idea, because it would make all patents harder to get. But if the prior art is as obvious as it seems to be in this case, which suggests incompetence on the part of the USPTO, maybe they should have some liability.

In this case, the prior art is something that is widely used. Is it really plausible that a patent examiner had never come across this double click trick on a computer they were using. I mean, I've just used it in Windows XP, and that was released in August 2001.

Since the defendants in this case will be doing the job the USPTO should have done, it doesn't seem crazy that the USPTO should be paying at least some of their costs.

'Porn lock' heralds death of WikiLeaks, internet, democracy, universe

Dave Bell

"Think of the Chirldren"?

Just what does that mean?

There are people old enough to marry who are classed by the law as "children". They can bonk their brains out, but they can't look at pictures.

Prosecutors kick Phorm case upstairs

Dave Bell

Nervous about Europe

If they decide not to prosecute, their answer will have to satisfy the European system, but I really don't like the idea of the European administration forcing a prosecution. A big chunk of the system is based on the National Governments writing and enforcing their own laws to comply with an EU directive. And I doubt that other countries would like any precedent being set.

2010: The year open source went invisible

Dave Bell
Linux

Mixed blessings.

There's a bug that's been in OpenOffice for several years, where it gets the word-count badly wrong if you routinely use certain characters. Somebody has finally gotten around to fixing it. It won't be fixed in the next release, apparently: the bugfix is too late.

How important was it? Luckily, I hit my NaNoWriMo target with time to spare. Do professional writers rely on WP word-counts? Often not: in the publishing business the word-count is often an estimate that is more to do with the space taken up by the text. But I reckon the bug was fixed pretty quickly when somebody started work on it. It just took a couple of years to start.

I'm a user, not a programmer. To me, access to the source code is useless. In the end, we're still stuck with a management process: somebody making a choice of what gets fixed and gets into the current source. And I know of one company which has open-sourced one of its products, sees other people modifying that program with the new code under the open-source licence they use, and still requires a specific contract agreement before they feed any outside bug-fixes into their official source code.

As a user, I have to trust somebody not to do something dangerous with the source code, I know of instances where developers did some nasty stuff with closed-source libraries. At least with open source outsiders can check. As I user, I depend on the good management of projects. But I'm left wondering if all the open source in the commercial world is quite what it seems. Does Open Source need a two-way flow of code? How many of these commercial efforts get anything from the outside?

David Attenborough dino doc shows limits of 3D TV

Dave Bell

Flying Dinosaurs vs The Doctor

Oh, really, we already know it's going to be flying sharks. The press have been gabbling about the preview screening all week.

Asus Eee PC 1015PEM

Dave Bell

Was Linux a mistake for Asus?

I can't say I've found Linux to be a problem, though I've sometimes had to do a lot of hunting for info. But I don't think that Asus made a good choice: the Linux distro they chose was somewhat obscure, they had to provide support, and it all turned sour.

After an upgrade to Firefox, via Asus, prevented a couple of other programs from working, and there was no way to back out, short of reinstalling from the DVD, I switched to Ubuntu.

I suspect that Asus didn't have enough sales of Linux to maintain the staff needed to support it. I wonder how much of the hardware could have had the drivers open sourced. Did they try to keep Eee PC Linux under their control, and missed the point of Open Source?

Windows, on the other hand: no supplier of chipsets is going to ignore Windows support.

US Navy achieves '100 mile' hypersonic railgun test shot

Dave Bell

And also...

USS Lexington (CV-2) for one.

Also one of the ships Robert A. Heinlein served on.

Dave Bell

Old trick

That's what schrapnel does.

(The word usually gets applied to any random fragments from an shell, these days.)

US Air Force studies fruit-flies to build killer insect swarm drones

Dave Bell

Scaling Problems

Biological bugs are feeding all the time. I wonder where these things will be able to recharge.

Blighty's kids nosedive down global reading, maths rankings

Dave Bell
Headmaster

The context changes.

One thing I've become aware of is that, since I was at school, we know a lot more about how children learn. There are certainly bad things arising from the over-emphasis on exam result, but it would be a mistake to assume that the teachers are no better at their job.

I think I survived a couple of teaching fads that were pushed on the schools I went to, by less than adequate teachers in a position of power. I find it quite easy to believe that the modern system has removed the worst of the teachers. But when the money is in the school's exam results, they're going to do everything they can to get the pass-rate up.

97% of INTERNET NOW FULL UP, warn IPv4 shepherd boys

Dave Bell
Coat

Not just home users

It's not just the home routers that need IP addresses, there's the ISP's internal hardware. I've seen reports that some US ISPs are struggling with that sort of internal addressing, because the biggest block of private addresses isn't big enough. Some of the problem may be an inefficient use of IP addresses which might be hard to resolve: if a particular location needs 10 IP addresses, it may work best to allocate a block of 16.

I do wonder if some of the "free router" deals are compatible with IPv6. On one hand, it's a way of getting compatible hardware out there (and simplifies support). On the other, it's a way of dumping kit that no sensible IT department would install.

[Coat... Semaphore flags... I'm just going outside. I may be some time.]

Dave Bell

How is this different?

Face it, when the internet explosion started, fifteen or so years ago, it was a nerd thing. There's now a lot of stuff on top of the basic IPv4 that hides it from the customer. The ADSL router gets its IP address from upstream. The computer gets its IP address from the router. If those machines can handle IPv6 then why should I care as the user?

Yes, there are things that I, specifically, would need to be careful of. I have a hard drive on my network, and occasionally run a server on localhost. But I don't use IP addresses directly.

Oracle claims trademark on Hudson open source

Dave Bell

Oh well...

I only just made it to my NaNoWriMo target, there's apparently an OpenOffice word-count bug that's been around for a long time. Hardly Oracle's fault, but I suppose I should check the fork.

There's open sourced stuff out there where the "official" version hasn't been so much forked as been presented with a canteen of cutlery, Never mind the legal tricks, Oracle have to deliver on the goods.

Cryptographers crack system for verifying digital images

Dave Bell
Boffin

Close-up Lens

Photographers have been doing this for a really long time.

OK, if the focus mechanism uses a sensor which doesn't look through the lens, life gets complicated, but all you need to do is hold a magnifying glass in front of the camera lens.

'Smear agricultural land with human poo'

Dave Bell
IT Angle

Real Threat, for once.

I used to be a farmer.

This problem is real.

And, as far back as twenty years ago, sewage works were struggling to find somewhere to dispose of the solid residues, which were a valuable fertiliser that scared the supermarkets shitless.

The Soil Association can be a bit controversial: they've been allowed to define "organic" without much apparent external influence. Farmers are uncertain about their motives and, sometimes, the quality of their science. But, on this topic, they're on pretty solid ground. We can argue about just when the supply of phosphates will tighten, and nitrate fertiliser may be a bigger problem that hits sooner (it's the energy input), but it's going to hit.

And the sewage sludge is a useful source of phosphates and other nutrients.