* Posts by Dave Bell

2133 publicly visible posts • joined 14 Sep 2007

TalkTalk gears up to 2012 YouView roll-out

Dave Bell

My experience suggests the Switchover will improve things. I don't have a clear view of the nearby Belmont transmitter; like most of the village, we have to point our aerials at Emley Moor. The power increase meant that we could stop using aerial amplifiers, and we were also getting a strong enough signal from Belmont, about 100 degrees off-axis to be get viewable oictures. So it might be worth the wait for you.

Doesn't matter which ISP you're with, it's the strand of copper between you and the exchange which is the key. Your's sounds pretty decent. Maybe the evening choke-off will ease, as capacity is added to cope with YouView. I'm not sure I want any more TV, but will I have to subscribe to be able to get useful bandwidth?

I have some "hard" questions which the sales-droids never seem able to answer. That could easily be another, but since they will be advertising the hell out of YouView, I doubt it will be as difficult as learning whether there are plans for IPv6

Enormous orbiting solar raygun power plants touted

Dave Bell

The energy cost of a launch to GEO is trivial. This system will only need to run for a few hours to cover that.

But there are people who will see the figures, with all those zeroes, and scream and point about greenhouse gas production.

Similarly, some will make a fuss about the system pumping more energy into an overheating planet. Well, the Earth is pretty big, and the extra surface area is a tiny increase. Figure in the reduction in greenhouse gases: just make sure you use the "right" model for the effects.

In the end, this depends on being able to do the construction work, and, wonderful though the ISS is, this is something that is going to depend on robots. Not the mechanical men of so much sci-fi, but remotely operated machines, well beyond the automatic docking of a supply ship to the ISS.

NASA spent huge amounts on spacesuits to get a man's hands on the job. They might have made a better return on a mechanical hand, and the control and feedback mechanisms to let a human hand control it. Even if the astronaut had to be in the Shuttle (communications lag), did he really need that awkward personal spaceship?

BT Tower falls over, crushes X Factor hopefuls

Dave Bell

I don't watch X-Factor. I am on the Internet.

Never lose that .uk again: Decade-long renewals OK'd

Dave Bell

There are ways to set up the domain so that email to the domain goes to an account held elsewhere. It's what I do. If i changed my ISP, I'd need to change a few redirects from my personally owned domain name, but I am my own tech support.

If a business has a domain set up by somebody who doesn't document this stuff, that somebody didn't do a competent job. An annual reminder is possibly a good idea anyway. Mention any new services, if you like. If you're selling domain-name services it's worth keeping in cont#act with your customers--few people deal direct with Nominet.

Actually, that last point can reasonably prompt hollow laughter. Who are Nominet's customers?

The new touchy-feely Doctor Who trend: Worrying

Dave Bell

Moffat has managed to make all the awkward details that RTD used into irrelevances. The Time War, the Master ruling Earth, all the twists and turns between Nine admitting he's the last Time Lord and the whole damn lot of them coming back to bring about the end of time.

Oh, some of the tricks were quite logical, but I doubt RTD could cope with the lack of a definite ending in the DW format.

Is Moffat better? He's picking up stuff from all over written SF. He's not afraid to write for an audience that actually thinks about what's happening. DW has picked up some of the same appeal as a really good detective mystery.

There has been a change. I've been watching this show all my life, and I can understand why the discomfort about the shifts. But looking back at how I was trying to figure an answer to the problem that was set up back in April, I really want to know what this guy does next. Because He's set it up so the Doctor has to be discreet, has to be more subtle, has to save the day without making a big splash.

I think it is going to be interesting.

First scientific paper filed from Spaaaace published today

Dave Bell

And, because of the interactions between the plasma and the magnetic field, a magnetic containment probably messes with the speed of sound.

This can't be the first scientific paper to have come out of work on the ISS, and maybe it's a little bit of a stunt, but having one of the authors in space when it is submitted and published; that is one of those little signs that things are changing.

Expert: 'Right to be forgotten' could cause problems for publishers

Dave Bell

There some of the stuff that's being talked about in connection with the looming EU Directive which sounds very useful, if you're not in the data mining business.

Is this inept thinking about the plans going to lose us the good stuff?

BOFH: Licence to grill ... stupid users

Dave Bell

This story is horribly unrealistic.

The support-thing should not be speaking with an intelligible accent

Mozilla updates to Firefox 8, disables add-ons

Dave Bell

After reading the story, I do feel the wording of the headline is misleading.

One of the add-ons I use is "No-Script", and my experience suggests that a good many of the hassles, such as delays and hang-ups, come from the multiplicity of web-page scripts being thrown at me.

Fast release-cycles maybe do some things well, but, to use a TV-script term, sometimes I wonder if there's a story-arc. One of the outfits I deal with, in the USA, has a weekly release cycle, but has just announced that releases will slow down for the rest of this year, with staff taking leave for Thanksgiving and Christmas and New Year and other seasonal stuff. So how do Mozilla expect to pull it off?

Production electric motorcycle breaks 100 mile range

Dave Bell

I've had a few too many accidents to feel interested in a bike, and I can see how it wouldn't suit everyone, but with that range, performance, and lifespan, it does make sense.

New plastic telescope ammo machine gun is light as a rifle

Dave Bell

Short bursts is standard for any machine gun. Better control of ammo usage. Even a Vickers didn't fire a 250-round belt as one single burst. Though a 10-gun company of Vickers guns did fire a million rounds in 12 hours.

I doubt this particular infernal machine is up to that standard

Dave Bell

The heat in the breech is mostly from the combustion of the propellant, so whatever the case is made of, the heat has to flow through the case into the chamber wall. More thermal resistance from the plastic, less heat in the chamber wall.

And that may be why a plastic case is better than caseless.

Now, I understand the M249 has an easy-to-change barrel and so really is a machine gun. That feature is maybe more important that the effects of plastic ammunition, even if modern barrels can stand far more heat than those of WW2.

UN set to dump GMT for tech-friendly Atomic Time

Dave Bell
Flame

And these things are so unexpected, aren't they.

If the systems can't cope with a near-annual leap second, the occasional 61-second minute, why should they do any better with leap minutes?

This machine has to have the clock reset once in a while, re-synced to a time server somewhere. I've not noticed anything breaking when I do that. Most of us, I suspect, don't care. If we're in a situation where a continuous sync does matter, not coping with leap seconds is just plain stupidity. If it happens almost every year, anything that might break will have broken, and then been fixed.

Oh, I can see some advantages in going over to something like counting seconds from some arbitrary start point, when you're managing atomic clocks and comparing them to calculate a coordinated time standard, as we do. And if you want that, don't forget to specify what happens when the account rolls over.

But in the end this is about a nationalistic gutter press running a scare story. Greenwich isn't going to stop being the Prime Meridian, and when did they ever get a tech story right anyway? On past form, they'll blame the ITU on "Europe", that amorphous bogey-man of the ill-informed nationalist.

US decommissions massive Cold War nuke

Dave Bell

Look it up, guys.

It used the W54 warhead, with a yield of 20 tons TNT. and there were two different launchers. with a maximum range of 2.5 miles. Using the short-range launcher would have been a tad hairy because the effects seems to have depended on the immediate radiation effects (it wasn't a neutron bomb, but the idea was similar).

It was about as small as you could make a nuke, and the scary thing seems to be that they were controlled by Sergeants. (Who probably have more maturity than the average 2nd Lieutenant, but they're still not officers.)

Dave Bell

On that incident, it would be tempting to suggest that the offending mariners might have been better treated by the Iranians that they might have been by the Portsmouth Plods, but on what I hear, the average RN sailor tends not to riot in bars.

Open-sourcers suggest Linux secure boot block workarounds

Dave Bell
Linux

I have a Windows serial number on the packaging for my distribution copy. I need to type it in the install Windows. It's enough hassle that I can see why MS might want to move to this new system.

But if I get a computer with this locking and Windows installed, and I still get the Windows serial number, it's rather obvious to use that serial number to authorise switching off the protection. Then I could install Linux, or whatever. And if the system is properly coded, it's going to be hard for the black hats to install their root-kits and stuff, because they can't know what my system's Windows serial number is.

No, it can't work. It's so obvious. I must be wrong.

Halloween Hardware

Dave Bell

I've been knee-deep in Zombies for the past three weeks, and you wait until now to tell us about this stuff?

German boffins BREAK LAWS OF THERMODYNAMICS!

Dave Bell
Headmaster

May I recommend the following edutational video to the staff of The Register.

http://youtu.be/VtEqn-5XHpU

Job-seeking university bods panic over incriminating online info

Dave Bell

Multiple addresses

The number of times I have heard of the problems arising from a previous resident at an address, not even with the same name, I wonder how ex-students can ever get approved for credit. It took several years before we stopped getting advertising, both by post and from foreign-based call centres ignoring the TPS, aimed at the previous occupiers of this house.

It's become very easy to get old and useless data about people, and nobody seems to care about maintaining the sort of current and correct records expected under the DPA. I'm not surprised that students worry, and I'm not surprised that some might be trying to stay off the radar.

Are IP addresses personal data?

Dave Bell

I'm sure, when I was looking at this subject earlier this year, that the ICO's advice was to handle IP addesses as though they were personal data, because you didn't know, as your server wrote it to a logfile, whether it was coming from an internet cafe or from a home. It was, I think, pointed out that it was a lot like a telephone number in that aspect.

Nipples and teen lesbians sexy even when ironic, ASA rules

Dave Bell
Headmaster

Or watch one of the original St Trinians movies.

St. Trinians v. Duke Nuke'em? We know how that will end

Three questions that could put out Amazon's Fire

Dave Bell

The USA is different

The USA does have some laws covering the same territory as the Data Protection Act, but there is far less legal protection than there is in Europe. I've seen a couple of instances of people in the USA exploiting this lack of protection: one involved somebody who was still banned from using computers after being convicted of an internet-based fraud. The company whose services he was exploiting took a long time to take any notice that he was gathering personal data on their paying customers.

I don't think it's a coincidence that the big data-theft stories come out of the USA.

Ubuntu's Oneiric Ocelot: Nice, but necessary?

Dave Bell

I use Ubuntu 10.04 on my netbook. It's the LTS version so it should be good for another 18 months, and the Netbook option is a good interface for the limited screen space.

10.10 wasn't so good. Is it even worth trying 11.10 on that sort of limited platform?

Winning new UK pylon design may never be used

Dave Bell

It does look more practical than some of the other designs that were shortlisted.

They do talk about using better insulating materials, but 400 kV will be enough for a pretty long arc through the air, or along the insulator surface on a foggy day.

400 kV RMS to earth is more like 700 kV between phases as I recall. I think the electrical engineers will have something to say about these.

Apache insists OpenOffice is alive, well, and flush

Dave Bell

OpenOffice works.

I tried LibreOffice, and had a few problems with getting it to open a file in Windows. The Linux version was fine. That's one of the reasons I started using OpenOffice, the same program for both Windows and Linux, so I switched back to OpenOffice.

NHS orgs not keen on UK gov's mega-intranet

Dave Bell

Misunderstanding the Environment

Since there are several non-NHS organisation-types which will routinely want to talk with the NHS, and pass on personal data, expecting the network to be NHS-only seems a silly idea.

An example from family experience: my mother was receiving carer support from the local Adult Social Services department. The carers were supplied by a private company. The first time somebody wanted to arrange a check by an NHS physiotherapist (or was it an occupational therapist?), we ended up getting several forms to fill in, giving various people permission to pass on my mother's personal data to anybody. It was a generic form, very generic, and the covering letter didn't even explain what had triggered this request.

"Data Protection Act".

It seems to me that it ought to have been obvious that the Social Services department needed to be able to pass information on to medical professionals, if only to arrange appointments, and it surprised me that the council's data protection registration didn't cover this. And after that form was signed, they had permission to supply data to anyone and everyone, such as a commercial operation making up a mailing list to send out a catalogue of disability support products, or a catalogue selling porn movies.

The NHS needs to talk to outsiders. It's often a statutory requirement, and there were times when it seemed that my mother was spending time in hospital because Social Services couldn't pick up the phone. From what I have seen, the NHS doesn't have that many DPA problems, it's essentially the same as the medical confidentiality that they were used to. But some of the outside operators, frankly, just don't get it.

An NHS-only network doesn't solve those problems. Signing up to another network is no guarantee of security. And this morning's report of Oliver Letwin's handling of mail suggests that there is a huge gap to bridge. But better communications in the health field is going to depend on a far better awareness of privacy and responsible data handling.

WHSmith launches e-book reader rivals to Amazon Kindle

Dave Bell

The big problem

Printing and distribution are quite a small part of the cover price of a book or magazine, and since the electronic version attracts VAT, there isn't much room to cut the price when you sell to a e-reader.

Do you want works of the same quality as now? Some of those freebies and ultra-cheap ebooks are of awful quality.

Energy minister gives grudging nuke endorsement

Dave Bell

How time flies

A decade ago, I was talking with a bunch of farmers, and Chernobyl had hit farming in some places quite hard. You wouldn't expect them to be nuclear enthusiasts. But there was all the pressure to grow crops for fuel, and a tendency for these schemes to collapse between sowing and harvest. And farmers do tend to think long-term, more so than MBAs.

Nuclear power was something we knew how to build and operate. It was, ten years ago, clearly the best option available. It would take time to build, but everything does.

Fuel crop schemes still struggle. Wind farms are working. Tidal and wave power are still at little better than the prototype stage.

And we've wasted ten years on waiting for more nuclear power.

Some of the big coal-fired stations will now be worn out before any nuclear power plants can be built to replace them.

London 2012 Olympics: 17000 athletes, 11000 computers

Dave Bell

OS Variety

I was surprised to see Windows XP mentioned, but I can see how it might make sense for some specific uses. It lingered in low-power notebooks when Vista was the latest Windows.

A lot of the servers could be running on Linux. I wouldn't be greatly bothered by having to use a web browser running on a Linux box, but a lot of people would be bewildered. The same for a machine with an office suite, too many people can't get away from the Microsoft packages, and they wouldn't want to be learning how in the middle of a major event.

It's good to know Acer are staying up to date on their OS choices.

But they have to settle their plans in good time to make sure everything works together. I doubt they'd risk, for instance, the looming Ubuntu upgrade.

Chaos feared after Unix time-zone database is nuked

Dave Bell

Just how significant it this?

When I've installed an OS, it's always asked me which time zone I'm in. It's sometimes made a suggestion (which was correct) but it's never been completely automatic.

Was this really so vital a service?

Can general relativity explain the OPERA neutrino result?

Dave Bell

It's the speed of light in a vacuum that's the constant. Your recollection is correct. Relativity comes from a need to explain why the speed of light doesn't depend on the direction the observer is moving.

Strictly, faster than light gives mathematically valid results, but has other implications.

I wouldn't worry about this result until we get an outbreak of blue phone-boxes.

NASA to recruit fresh batch of astronauts

Dave Bell

It's more the complexity, and the sometimes limited time to react to a problem. And I can see NASA having work for astronaut-trained test pilots. They could do basic astronaut training, then work as a test pilot (with time for refresher courses), and go back to full-time astronaut when they are assigned a mission.

That's possibly too simple. But doesn't the RAF and USAF have pilots spending time doing desk jobs? Not just paperwork on the Squadron.

Better Business Bureau offers rogue script browser peril

Dave Bell
Holmes

Over the years, I have seen several reports, on American websites, suggesting that the Better Business Bureau is rather dodgy. Typically, the allegation is that they will let anyone join, on payment of a fee. So the BBB logo on a web page is pretty meaningless. All you can be sure it means is that the company using the logo han't been caught.

But the BBB is a sort of franchise organisation. Read the blog post below, but remember that the problems implied by the examples may be limited to a few places and times.

http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/005609.html

Deciding who to trust is hard.

Firms are RUBBISH at payment security

Dave Bell

World-wide survey?

US, Europe, and Asia, so there won't be many British operations.

In the last week, I've made orders through both British and US companies.

In both cases they were companies I had dealt with before.

The British company did ask for the 3-digit security number from the back of the card.

The US Company was satisfied with my username/passowrd combo.

Neither used the sort of checking scheme (e.g. "verified by Visa") which was being hyped last year.

Schoolteachers can't teach our kids to code, say engineers

Dave Bell

DOS Batch Files fell wll short of Unix shell scripting, but they can be used to do some fancy stuff. Old-time Demon customers, who used the KA9Q-based DOS package, might recall the demon.bat file.

I don't recall any clear explanations of the overall processes in any MS-DOS manual, it wasn't even presented as a coherent set of commands, but there was a useful programming language there.

As for typing, there's nothing new in experienced people saying it should be properly taught in schools. My great-uncle Albert was saying much the same in the 1920s.

Dave Bell

Apparently, that sort of thing is hard.

Or the teaching/explanation is dreadful.

People vary. I hit a brick wall on math somewhere about the details of calculus, but username/password is right down at the level of basic literacy and numeracy.

Amazon intros $199 movie Kindle

Dave Bell

Tax dodging corporates

In the USA, mail-order has been able to avoid local sales taxes for many decades, and Amazon takes huge advantage of that.

They don't get away with it here so you need to add 20% VAT to the US price

I reckon the NHS is worth it.

Poll: Porn-watching, net-savvy kids are a myth

Dave Bell

Statistics & Survey Design

This is an old problem in designing a survey. Partly, you ask different questions than the obvious. Partly you try to convince the people you're asking that teachers or parents will not see the answers.

FCC's net-neut rules now official

Dave Bell

With the requirement to be "open" about how they manage traffic, I can see why some ISPs will squeal. I know it doesn't apply here in the UK, but I'm sure that everyone can recall instances of less than open advertising and management here. What does "unlimited" mean? Is it "open" to have usage limits or charges without having a tool to inform users of how much of the limit has been used?

My ISP, back in 2005, had such a tool, and a usage cap. Then they dropped both. They've had a quite large usage cap for a while now, but no accessible measurement tool.

As I said, not UK law. Not that strong. And things will have to be argued out in court. But a bit of honesty from the ISPs seems to be what the regulations are trying for. Only a bunch of crooks would squeal about these requirements.

Xbox Live patrols hit by ugly SWAT attacks

Dave Bell

I'm certainly getting sick and tired by the ease with which intrusive advertising phone calls can arrive here with no way of identifying where they came from.

"The Caller Withheld Their Number"

Gmail, I can tag an email as spam, and if enough people do that, it gets automatically tagged as from a spam source.

I'm not sure I want that for phone calls, but I'd like to be able to tell the telco that a caller has been abusing their system. They're ignoring so many of the protections we can have. They're outside OfCom rules. Why can't I press a number on my phone and tell the telco that I don't want further calls from this anonymous source?

MS denies secure boot will exclude Linux

Dave Bell

Or the utility to load the disk image onto that shiny new drive...

It potentially kills a lot of legitimate system management tools used both by DIY enthusiasts and large commercial operations. Booting from a network image might be workable. Or does the software have to be signed by some central key authority? And is that Microsoft?

BOFH: No, the Fabinocci sequence

Dave Bell

Interesting...

Halon itself isn't significantly toxic. You need the fire to produce the interesting chemicals such as Phosgene.

If I were the H&S bod, I'd explain how I have a cousin who sells the sorts of respirator needed for protection, and advise the BofH/PFY to get the gear and go on a proper training course.

Win-win situation.

CERN's boson hunters tackle big data bug infestation

Dave Bell

I'm looking at the timescales here, and wondering what you could have picked from. I suspect, for one thing, that if Windows was even involved, it was NT, and the reality was mostly some form of Unix.

And you wanted something that, as a programming environment, would be available for a long time.

The world looks a bit different now. I had a few megabytes of storage then. Now we talk in terabytes. I reckon they didn't so so badly, if they only found 40,000 bugs.

Dave Bell

Clifford Stoll, wasn't it? But if you get a scientist problem-solving on something new, it's hard to tell where engineering takes over from science.

EC: New principles agreed for out-of-print book licensing

Dave Bell

At the end of the day, book production is relatively inexpensive, compared to movies. Sound recordings are somewhere in between. But the costs of making an adequate copy have changed a lot in the last twenty years.

Print-on-Demand, and the effect on rights reversion, does worry authors. That "loophole" is already there. If I recall right, the usual terms put an absolute time limit on the contract, with a conditional reversion if the book stays out of print. The awkwardness is that many publishing companies are components of large media conglomerates, and head office imposes policies on ebooks and PoD which are designed for big-budget movies. The people in the publishing houses don't want to get a bad reputation with authors, and using PoD to get around a reversion clause on a book you're not really selling is not good business.

This can all fit rather well with what libraries do, keeping material available. It might also fit well with systems such as PLR. There's no reason why authors of old books shouldn't be able to get some money out of it.

The big problem is that some authors are still bemused by computers, and some inheritors of rights are clueless about publishing. There are authors who can set up their own ebooks, as the rights revert. They don't really get much, if anything, from this. It's all the stuff that's locked away by ignorance where we might, as readers, gain from this.

Dinosaur-murdering space boulder family found innocent

Dave Bell

Vague guess, inadequate data.

I don't see how anyone can know enough about the break-up of the Asteroid and the collision with the Earth to pin this down. Maybe there's detectable iridium: at least that would make these mega-boulders a candidate.

So just what has the change in timing been? 15 million years is a lot of time, and the dinosaurs might just have been very unlucky. The collision might be more likely to have happened 50 million years ago, with the new data, but I can't see how that translates into an impossibility.

Blighty's slow-crawling broadband streets revealed

Dave Bell

OK, so what are contention ratios like? You can see the effects in my neck of the woods.

I wonder when these places first had broadband? Is there some black box in the chain from customer to wider internet that just isn't good enough for current usage?

Whatever the cause, I hope this prompts the responsible telecom companies to check for problems, and fix them.

Prosecutor calls poker site 'global Ponzi scheme'

Dave Bell

Different games, different math. But it is, after all, the Americans who introduced the double-zero to roulette wheels.

Poker is a game where it can be argued that skill plays an important part, maybe enough that in some places it is not, in law, a game of chance. Part of that skill is in calculating the odds of winning against what you have to bet, and the value of the pot. So math does matter, and a good Poker player is less of a gambler than you might think. But judging the reactions oif the other players is also part of the game, and that isn't the same on-line.

On the other hand, I know how a bookie works out the odds on a horse race. It reflects what is bet on which horse, not a horse's chance of winning. Blackjack, there's card counting which can beat the house advantage, but if they think you are doing it, they will invite you to leave the casino.

There are ways to come out ahead, but they depend on the system being honest. And that's where this outfit seems to have gone wrong. But how convenient for gambling operations in the USA that they were able to find out.

Games review site goes titsup at launch

Dave Bell

They do seem to be trying to push some very particular buttons, that's for sure. and they both look to be something of a cliche.

It all makes me wonder if the game is any good.

LOHAN deluged with Reg readers' interjections in REHAB

Dave Bell

I'll note that the percentage difference in chamber pressure at sea level and at umpteen thousand metres might not be so much, once the motor is burning.

The SRB apparently ran at 900psi at liftoff, so the effects of losing the vacuum would be less than 2%. I don't expect you're using a motor achieving quite so much pressure, so the pressure difference might matter. On the other hand, it might mean that you don't need the vacuum for a useful ignition test.