* Posts by Dave Bell

2133 publicly visible posts • joined 14 Sep 2007

Microsoft makes good with a 23-fix Patch Tuesday

Dave Bell

Re: Another Big Patch Day, and a Week of Start Up Repair Routines

My ancient EEE came with Linux, out of the box.

It was OK, but ASUS cocked up the support a few months later, and I switched to Ubuntu.

Pirate island attracts more than 100 startup tenants

Dave Bell

Re: Not a new idea ...

If they're using a laser to a shore station, they have to be in line-of-sight. The horizon would be about 17 miles from the ship. The shore station wouldn't be on-shore, but would have more height. You're not going to get clear of the 200nm economic zone. That would need a 20,000 foot tower.

About the only advantage I can see is the possibility of in-person visits by US nationals to external programming teams. And getting the non-US personnel to the ship looks tricky.

As far as pay and tax collection go, I suppose that there are precedents for the crew of ships.

It all sounds a bit far-fetched. I wonder how much money will be spent on the "planning" before the investors in the company notice nothing is happening.

NAO: 1 in 5 of Whitehall's mega projects at risk of failure

Dave Bell

Re: Ooh, it's sooo difficult!

Er, you do know how long we have had those things for?

Even the Ministry of Defence is older than the Prime Minister.

Canada failing to sufficiently protect IP rights – US report

Dave Bell

Re: Ohboy.

I am not sure whether that means that the Canadian rules are too strict for US corporations to wriggle around, or whether it means the Canadian system doesn't get suckered by exaggerated claims for losses.

ARM creators Sophie Wilson and Steve Furber

Dave Bell

Re: Great article

I agree, it wasn't Acorn and the ARM which failed.

But there is something about the British industrial and financial environment which seems to let the winnings from these works of genius drift away out of reach.

Its not just globalisation, and some factory that is so expensive to build that there can only be one on the entire planet. And we can't expect to spot the right investment choice every time. But what is it about this country which turns a successful entrepreneur into somebody fronting a TV show that tests how people can run a market stall in Essex?

Software functionality not subject to copyright: EU court

Dave Bell

Copyright and Patents

Essentially, this says nothing directly about patents. It just means that the longer-lived copyright protection cannot apply. And there are a huge number of questionable software patents.

I don't think it makes a lot of difference. Though stuff patented in 1998 should be seeing protection expire around now. On the other hand, some look and feel elements might be protected by other long-lasting IP methods. Whatever the options are, the problems come from abusive, rent-seeking, human behaviour.

CPU and RAM hogs overstaying their welcome? Here's a fix

Dave Bell

Is this driven by GPL fears?

Is a part of the reason for this a reluctance to entangle a product with the GPL license used for the kernel?

EA unplugs Rock Band for iOS

Dave Bell

Serious question

What does Rock Band depend on a server for?

What happens to player data?

Pilots asking not to fly F-22 after oxygen problems

Dave Bell

Re: F-22 and Anoxia / Hypoxia

What I remember is John Noakes getting training from the RAF before making a high-altitude parachute jump. They gave him experience of anoxia, in a way that demonstrated just how much he didn't realise he was suffering the effects.

I'm not claiming to be any sort of expert, but that memory makes me wonder what's wrong with the higher ranks in the USAF. Not every pilot would make a good ngeneral, but that's why you need pilots in the higher ranks. Or maybe Blue Peter viewers.

Barnes & Noble plans instore NFC Nook-book bonk-buying

Dave Bell

Re: "Publish to Nook" button in Word?

The Nook uses the ePub format, which can be produced from a Word file by free software. And past experience of Word outputting HTML files (which are the basis of the ePub format) more than curbs my enthusiasm.

The example of the Amazon Vanity Slush-Pile doesn't help.

How politicians could end droughts forever But they don't want to

Dave Bell
Boffin

Stpupid Reactions

We're officially in a drought.

Beckton should be running flat-out, 24/7, until the drought stops.

Dave Bell

Re: JG Ballard and tilting at windmills.

Just guessing here, from my days studying chemistry, but I would expect the plant to take brackish water and produce a stream of pure water, and a larger stream of more saline water. You'd have to site intakes and outlets with a bit of care, but is it any different in the end from taking more water out of the upper reaches of the Thames drainage system, and putting it through a set of kidney-filters?

Your point about using such things as a sink for surpluses of wind-generated energy is a good one. If the electricity demand can be quickly changed, it would help stabilise the system. But it might have to run in a steady state.

Now on Freeview HD: Olympic arts channel that's tough to watch

Dave Bell

I admit it, I would be curious about the Shakespeare productions, which I suppose are that series of foreign language productions being put on at the Globe. The guy wrote some good stuff, and too much has been messed with by school teachers.

It sounds like he may be responsible for the only good stuff that ever gets shown on that channel.

Google's latest webspam crusade 'breaks' search results

Dave Bell

Re: They're definately screwing things up

I think that one may be a difference between the US and the USA. Do you see a difference between google.com and google.co.uk?

But it does look as though a checking system is over zealous. That does seem an obvious case where Google should give results for the search term as entered, while giving the option for the alternatives. I know the typing errors I make.

Investors circle Barnes & Noble as it plans Nook spin-off

Dave Bell
Holmes

Re: good. Now perhaps they will sell it outside the USA

One of the problem is that the right to sell a book is often (not always) held by different publishers in different regions. Some authors let a publisher buy all the rights, some find they can earn more by exploiting the region-split, and then there are translation rights. So B&N may not have the right to sell many ebooks into the UK or the EU.

Amazon is rather careless about what they advertise, physical books or ebooks.

With the news that at least one large publisher, with both US and UK labels, is dropping DRM, there's a potential for the Nook to exploit. It's an ePub reader, B&N have an internet sales and delivery system for eBooks, and they don't have the same bad rep in the business that Amazon has. Getting the Nook reader, and the ebook business, into a different branding to the bookstore business, could be a smart move.

Selling off a profitable part of the business to raise cash to improve the balance sheet is a very short-term plan. The Nook is the centre of what has a chance of surviving.

Expert: UK would break its own rules with web-snoop law

Dave Bell

I suspect this is partly why some factions make such a fuss about the Human Right Act and the European Convention on Human Rights. They falsely blame all the trouble on the EU as well.

And some of the rights can easily conflict. That's why we have courts, but oh! the screaming about interfering judges.

They're not investigating crimes. They don't have a suspect to point to. They can't exploit the wiggle room that is built into all these things. This isn't just collecting the information that a Police State collects, and far more. It is setting up the privileged apparatus that is essential to a Police State.

E-health FAIL: £1.59 iPhone apps dole out drugs to kids in A&E

Dave Bell

Re: Sadly the reality is that the life of a child may depend on an iPhone app

I wouldn't trust mental arithmetic.

I'm one of the last generation to have used a slide rule in exams. You need to know what you're doing, arithmetically, to use one of those. You have to at least estimate the order of magnitude. These days, everyone punches the buttons on a calculator, me included. And, while I am slower than I was, I can still stop dead, seeing an answer which screams "wrong", and wonder if I pressed the wrong button.

I would be very wary, myself, of an application doing this sort of thing which doesn't log every calculation. I don't expect it to get the arithmetic wrong. It's inevitable that data entry will be imperfect.

Major science fiction publisher to zap DRM

Dave Bell
Linux

Re: If only they could make a decent website

The look of the Baen website isn't the best, but it works. By my definition, that's a decent website.

Your eyeballs may vary.

Dave Bell

Both the US and UK announcements seem to describe the same scheme, a three-month transition to DRM-free, and I suspect new releases, after a week or two, will be DRM-free from both.

I'm not finding it easy to find anything published by Tor books on Amazon, they don't appear to have a search-by-publisher option. They've had hissyfits with Macmillan before, but I could just be using the wrong search terms.

They tell me that nothing in the Kindle Vanity-Slushpile is DRM-free. Back to Gutenberg, I suppose.

Suspected freetloaders to face piracy letters in 2014

Dave Bell

Re: prince of darkness

And they really don't like it when you tell them you've noticed it's a form letter. Why do they think they can get away with claiming such a lengthy and carefully phrased reply was typed up in ten minutes?

Dave Bell

Re: I've searched the organogram carefully

As it happens, I do know a civil servant who can play a banjo.

Home Office 'technologically clueless' on web super-snoop law

Dave Bell

Re: Of Course They're Cluless

It could kill some of the spam phone calls, like the foreign call centres which try to persuade me that they're some sort of "Windows Technical Centre". But how do I report the fraud attempt to anyone who will take a blind bit of notice?

'I'm no visionary': Torvalds up for $1.3m life-changing gong

Dave Bell

Re: @Lockwood

That's not how I read the report. They're the two nominated finalists, not the winners.

It looks as though it is going to be hard to choose.

Oracle v Google could clear way for copyright on languages, APIs

Dave Bell

Isn't WIPO a treaty, and hnce...

Since this seems to be covered by WIPO and other international treaties, and such treaties have a special status under US law, somewhere between statute law and the Constitution, how can Oracle win?

Cameron 'to change his mind' on the one thing he got right in Defence

Dave Bell

Re: He we go again ...

I've seen arguments that it's the electric and magnetic fields in the vicinity of the catapult that would be an issue. It might need some things kept further away from the catapults. That has some plausibility, and i wouldn't want to route a data cable alongside a catapult. But the thing is going into a steel box. Is it really going to be a big problem with that sort of inherent screening?

(I bet BAE will tell you it's going to cost a lot to be sure.)

Dave Bell

Re: Missing the point entirely

There are arguments that we should be looking at these issues on an EU-wide basis. What do we gain from the rest of the EU? What can we best provide them? There's more to a Navy than tradition, that's worthless without effective ships, but we could do a good job of being one of the naval specialists. The service we have the least need for is an Army.

It's division of labour, all very sensible, but i can't really see the Conservatives wanting to cooperate with the EU

Dave Bell

Re: Erroneous enemy assessment maybe?

You'd probably want a Marine Commando on board for deck security, maybe with a squadron of tanks in support. Give a few cavalry-types green-beret nragging rights.

Dave Bell

Re: Putting the boot in

That sounds a little bit too much like something one might make work in a game of "Harpoon", and possibly requiring loaded dice.

If you can execute the mission with support from land-based tankers, you don't really need carriers.

Lesser-spotted Raspberry Pi FINALLY dished up

Dave Bell

Don't look too much at the past

Out of the box, this might be enough turn a modern TV into a proper computer. It's tight for RAM, but so were those ultra-cheap Linux boxes which were coming out of China, two or three years ago. You have HDMI and a USB port to power the 'Pi

What this really needs is multi-player Elite.

Dave Bell

Re: Really?

Probably they have the customers for all the things they are being supplied with. Selling something you don't actually have yet is for the likes of Amazon.

NHS trust loses personal data of 600 maternity patients, kids

Dave Bell

Er who?

So what is a "data controller employee"?

AFAIK, "data controller" has a specific legal meaning under the DPA, and this all feels a funny way of saying IT worker, implying a pretty direct chain of authority. It's almost as if there's some outsourcing going on here. And what the heck are they doing to the data? Selling it to Mothercare?

And, now, I don't see how the government's brilliant plans to put GPs in charge are going to help. Based on my experience, GPs don't seem able to attain reliable communications, never mind secure coimmunications.

'Don't break the internet': How an idiot's slogan stole your privacy...

Dave Bell

Re: A highly specious argument.

I can see what you're getting at, but I think you are mistaken.

Copyright is essentially about documenting who owns something. In the old US system. there was a requirement to register copyright, just as there are registers of land ownership. It's a sometimes imperfect extension of the ideas of property and real estate. You can, especially in the digital age, drag in some sometimes non-obvious economic theory. You can steal a printed book, because the person you steal from can no longer use it. If I were to "steal" a file from your computer, you would still have the original.

Privacy also depends on ownership rights. And sometimes gets complicated: when you rent a hotel room, do you have a right to privacy? In English law, there is a conflict between the right of a tenant to privacy, and the rights of the landlord to protect their property. There have been court cases. There are are words such as "reasonable" in the statutes. But at the heart of that balance is a clear identification of the parties to the contract.

I suspect we all are over-simplifying a bit, and the whole idea of an absolute property right can be challenged. If you want to blame William the Bastard for it, feel free. But, in the world we have, it isn't stupid to associate privacy with property rights, and some way of documenting ownership.

I don't want my privacy to depend on registering copyright with some government office. Which is why I dislike some of the assumptions that seem to be common amongst Americans. Some of them don't seem to have realised that US Copyright Law has changed to implement the Berne Convention. They have the same automatic copyright as us unfortunate Europeans.

But, wherever we are, it seems that money talks. Google can make money out of playing fast and loose with our privacy. And, too often, money shouts, screams, and throws the mother of all temper tantrums.

As far as privacy and copyright go, the various corporates and collectives are getting away with acting like spoiled children.

Think of the adults, please.

Dave Bell

Re: lets be honest

SMS too short?

Creativity not seen?

Justice is blinded.

Minecraft maker plots ultimate videogame for coders

Dave Bell

So what is this like?

In some ways this sounds a lot like Second Life. The big similarity is the dependence on user-created content.

Second Life has its own scripting language, relatively high-level, and few people can use it well.

Just the idea of an emulation of a 16-bit computer being a vital component for game success is scaring me. I once wrote something in Assembler, for an early microcomputer which used the Z80 processor, but it was a long time ago, and in another country. Add the potential for "griefers", and I think I shall give this oine a miss.

It's a game for an intellectual elite of coders. I cannot see how it can be made to pay.

Arizona bill makes it illegal to 'annoy or offend' online

Dave Bell

This one is tricky.

It is a change to an existing body of law, extending limits on telephone calls to all electronic communication. So at least the lawyers and the courts know what has been classed as "annoying". It may very well not match how we use the word.

One possible example: telephone sales. If the some telephone sales calls have been classified as annoying, under the earlier law, we might have an anti-spam law here.

I don't think this is as crazy as it sounds.

Browsium rescues HMRC from IE6 – and multimillion-pound bill

Dave Bell

So what are the numbers?

Just how much will this cost per computer?

Even if all it does is buy time, and let them use current replacement hardware/OS systems, it sounds as though the cost is remarkably low. I've just upgraded to Win 7 myself from XP, and I am not 100% convinced it was a good move, but XP just can't get the best out of current hardware. Trouble is, Win 7 can still do some things horribly slowly, even if some things are incredibly faster than under XP on the same hardware.

Google plonks reCAPTCHA on Street View, makes users ID your house

Dave Bell

Other unreliabilities

If you're an Opera user, don't bother trying to comment on a blog that uses ReCaptcha.

European Parliament votes against ACTA legal review

Dave Bell

But who can we believe?

I don't think I would particularly trust either side on their claims about ACTA, but I do have some sympathy with the point that ACTA would mess up any hope of a reform of copyright law.

If it wasn't for the use of old black-and-white movies to fill TV schedules, there wouldn't be any value in the old stuff.

Amazon sets date for Kindle Touch UK touchdown

Dave Bell

Re: Kindle Touch

It is the same as the current version of the Kindle, a USB lead which also allows you to transfer .mobi files from your computer, such as those available from Project Gutenberg. The touch screen doesn't have much appeal for me, but it's a natural enough upgrade. How does it work with a screen-protector film stuck on?

Paedophiles ‘disguise’ child abuse pages as legit websites

Dave Bell

Re: Do you have children?

That case was relatively local to me, and a week or two after I saw it reported, it was reported that the laptop had been returned and the restrictions ended.

The man, it seemed, might have had his laptop exploited by Malware, and used as a distribution site. I don't claim expertise on such things, but most of the news media are capable of getting computer stuff badly wrong. Are Social Services any better at understanding the story they have?

Game closes 277 stores

Dave Bell

Re: "this is too little, too late."

I've had the chance to compare prices for the same goods from both the Channel Islands and the High Street, and the price difference is a lot more than the 20% down to VAT. Though sometimes the pricing might be a little lower than the seller would like, because it gets under the limit.

The VAT exemption is a great thing to scream about, but it's a long way from all the story.

BOFH: Dawn raid on Fort BOFH

Dave Bell

Re: Box

If the mouse-mats are in good condition, they might be sort of collector's item. Or frame them and use them as a retirement memento for the old-timers. But they're probably worn out.

Scammers exploit new Dr Who girl with Twitter smut video

Dave Bell

It's said by some that a long-term Doctor Who viewer's favourtie depends who had the role when the viewer hit puberty.

Dr Who scores new companion from Emmerdale

Dave Bell

Re: Who's better, Who's best

Sarah Jane has to be on any sane shortlist. Who might win from such a shortlist maybe depends just how old we were when they first appeared.

Osborne names UK cities to land £100m broadband bonanza

Dave Bell

Is it really the wires?

Wouldn't it do more good to increase the network capacity on the ISP side of the exchange. Contwention ratios have more effect on me than the nominal speed of my ADSL line. I'd rather double the worst 10% of my daily speed-time plot than double the best 10%.

Readers suggest LOHAN mount single mighty rod

Dave Bell

Launch rails for rockets are an established tech, and certainly work. They have done since the days Biggles was flying Sopwith Camels.

Lawyers of Mordor menace Hobbit boozer

Dave Bell
FAIL

Re: I'm all for...

SZC bought the "non-literary" rights from Tolkien well before he died, and while it looks a poor deal now, he was apparently happy enough. Considering Tolkien's age at the time, I don't think Saul Zaentz could claim to have a clear conscience over the deal.

When the Bakshi animated film came out the Tolkien Society had to spend time and money on pre-emptively registering some very limited trademarks, and a curiousity I recall was that the SZC subsidiary, Tolkien Enterprises, registered trademarks using the spelling "hobbite". There was a wheat variety around at the time called "Maris Hobbit".

I've lost count of the number of houses I have seen which are named "Rivendell" I don't recall seeing any nestled away in a steep-sided mountain valley.

LOHAN's fantastical flying truss takes to the air

Dave Bell

Re: Boffinry

I understand that the boffinry qualification test in the rocketry department has to include hydrogen peroxide and cardigans, Bonus points for Morris Dancing.

UK kids' art project is 'biggest copyright blag ever' – photographer

Dave Bell

Re: Merely a case of extending the logic of Corporate Web 2.0

The usual web-site copyright grab makes some sense as an attempt to allow the website to function: think how much copying happens as the data is viewed. And I don't think there's much chance of removing the data from any back-up system. So they end up having to talk about some sort of perpetual and non-exclusive right.

It's one of the non-piracy reasons why current copyright law isn't a good fit with the internet.

There are parts of UK copyright law where it matters who provided the raw materials, photography is one. There are probably more court decisions than any non-specialist can know of which could be applied to this contract. My own view is that we're all suffering from the side effects of the aggressive IP enforcement which happens these days. Projects such as this one would rather be mocked than sued.

A smart lawyer can probably draft a better contract in their sleep. Too many people don't even realise that publishers only need a licence.

Copyright 2012 David G. Bell

(The Register looks to do this sort of stuff right.)

Apple wants ebook price class action suit thrown out

Dave Bell

With Amazon controlling 90% of the ebook market at the time the iPad launched, I wonder just why they're not being investigated too.

Or maybe they are, and you haven't reported it.