* Posts by dtl

3 posts • joined 20 Oct 2017

Only one Huawei? We pitted the P30 Pro against Samsung and Apple's best – and this is what we found

dtl
Alien

The available space to gather as much or even more light than a "normal" lens is there on a smartphones back, it just isn't fully used yet. The rest is "just" processing power which is still growing but might hit a quite hard physics wall in regards to battery capacity and heat efficiency soon.

Human StarCraft II e-athletes crushed by neural net ace – DeepMind's AlphaStar

dtl
Pint

Not fair

I'm not saying I'm not impressed, but doing a bit of machine learning research myself I can see how this is possible. However, StarCraft is intentionally hard for human players to control. You have to remember a ton of things, both long term and short term, you have to manage your attention and you have to train physically like a piano player to translate your actions into keyboard/mouse clicks.

The combination of these leads to a steadily growing learning curve the more time you put into the game, which is of course exactly what the game is designed for.

Now you want to test if your neural network (I refuse to call it AI, it's nowhere even close to that) can do strategy, so you give it a much simplified interface to work with. That's OK for this part of research, and it's also OK to pit it against human players to see how it performs, but don't interpret too much in the results. We will talk again when this neural net can move under it's own power in front of a screen and a keyboard and play the game under the same conditions as a human pro player.

Until then, we will have to learn how much processing power the bot needs after training (i.e. to just execute the neural net). This is usually far less then required for training the network, so if some better bots come out for us humans to train against, I wouldn't mind, especially if you can select the version of it. For example you have trouble defending against a certain strategy and can select a bot which implements it well.

Your data will get hacked anyway so you might as well give up protecting it

dtl

Re: You'll be revived on mars, or worse...

If you want to see that idea spun into a exciting book, I recommend "We Are Legion (We Are Bob)" from Dennis E. Taylor.

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2019