* Posts by Richocet

302 publicly visible posts • joined 24 May 2017

Page:

Ex-Brave staffer launches GDPR sueball in Germany over tech giants' real-time bidding for ad inventory

Richocet

Previous approach

Contextual advertising was used before the technology was in place for personalised ad targeting which is now standard practice.

So contextual advertising is not so much an alternative, but turning back the clock.

Advertisers somewhere will know if contextual performs as well as personalised.

One key difference between the two is the vast array of agencies, brokers and businesses earning revenur from selling, implementing, and supporting personalised advertising because it is much more complex and at least one order of magnitude more effort. This will likely impact the industry's enthusiasm for changing.

FBI paid renegade developer $180k for backdoored AN0M chat app that brought down drug underworld

Richocet

Re: A job well done

The uncertainty fear, and paranoia would cause the crims to explore a number of theories about why they keep getting busted. They wouldn't trust each other and it would really slow down their activities. So I don't know why it was revealed how they did it, unless there is another goal by doing so.

Richocet

Re: Mystery dev

If that information about his history is accurate.

You got a smart speaker but you're worried about privacy. First off, why'd you buy one? Secondly, check out Project Alias

Richocet

Re: you could simply not put the creepy things in your home

Dragon naturally speaking has been around for more than a decade and does exactly that. Listens to your voice and turns it into text accurately.

Naunce, the company that developed this product has since made big money selling this technology to Google etc to run their speech recognition and digital assistants on large scale servers.

I find it suspicious that speech recognition isn't implemented on the devices with some specialised hardware and send the transcript to servers. Plus it is unnecessary use of your internet connection to basically stream audio to a server. There must be a whole lot more valuable data that can be obtained by anaylsing the raw audio.

PrivacyMic looks to keep your home smart without Google, Alexa, Siri and pals listening in

Richocet

So what exactly is the benefit to the purchaser of these devices? Why would you buy a device to listen to ultrasound in your home and send it yet-to-be-identified companies that would want to purchase that data.?

You can't solve your insecurities about not keeping up with technology by showing off the device to your friends.

Basecamp CEO issues apology after 'no political discussions at work' edict blows up in his face

Richocet

Re: Politics is a virus.

Most companies donate to political parties these days to buy influence. I don't think it's practical for any of them to stop doing that. Then the questions of who they are donating to inevitably come up, so beings the politics debate in the workplace.

Not saying you should but we're told it's possible to land serverless app a '$40k/month bill using a 1,000-node botnet'

Richocet

Re: Cloud services

Add to reasons for not having a cloud

5) The cost of having people procuring the hardware

6) Maintaining a data center, and patching the servers.

7) The one-off costs of upgrading old hardware can be much harder to get approved than a higher steady cost of renting capacity. I've seen plenty of examples of production systems running on obsolete unsupported hardware and OS because it was never cost effective to upgrade it.

Key Perl Core developer quits, says he was bullied for daring to suggest programming language contained 'cruft'

Richocet

Re: Cult and control

UI is not subjective. It is contentious.

It is possible to quantify how well a UI performs:

How fast can a user perform the key tasks?

How long does it take a new user to figure out and perform the key tasks?

How many mistakes or wrong turns does a new user take when performing a key task for the first time?

They can also be surveyed subjectively on how frustrated they got, and how well this preformed compared to other software they have used.

A bad UI will score low all of the above. 0% subjective.

What usually happens is that nobody bothers to do the above because of cost, time, don't know how, don't value it. In the absence of data, UIs are subjective, everyone has an opinion, and most people's guesses of UI quality are way off-base.

The exception is that experienced designers accurately predict software usability. However I have seen people argue with them until the above tests provide the concrete evidence, and even after the tests are done that they were 'rigged' LOL. It's a wasted opportunity to get an experienced designer in and then argue with them and accuse them of falsifying data.

Best case scenario is: Experienced designer. No expensive testing. Key design recommendations. Implement all except the most costly. Better product from the user perspective.

I agree with Terry's point on this topic.

Richocet

Re: Cult and control

I know well what you went through.

User experience design is time-consuming expensive and there is a shortage of people who can do it well. It can make a piece of software superior to it's competitors just because it is easier to use, without having more features.

There is also a cost to implementation of the design changes, but it's rarely high.

The problem is the psychology. The developers think that they are smarter than the average user, and know more about the software because they built it. So they take the view that they can anticipate what users want better than you or I or a designer can.

This is a fallacy, because everyone knows less about the software than they do, so they can make things too complicated or hard to figure out or time-consuming to use, and are not capable of noticing (unless it is also too complicated for themselves). This psychology explains the arrogance of "who are designers to tell me how to build a better software product".

Luckily I am usually in the position of managing the developers, so I insist that they implement the designs. Once this is grudgingly completed, they are happy to share in the credit and accolades for the success of the product.

Letting the developers do it their way, and learn the hard way is too slow and expensive, and there is the principle of paying them to redo something that they refused to do in the first place.

Ex-Geeks staff lose legal bid to claw back withheld training costs from final paycheques

Richocet

Re: I'd challenge the Director Cost

Charging management and supervisors time to any employee is unreasonable.

If that employee was not a trainee or intern, they would still be supervised and managed.

So management is not a benefit to the employee it is a necessary and normal component of business operation.

Everybody makes mistakes, so it is not appropriate to financially penalise employees for making mistakes. If you want to have a bonus scheme that rewards employees for not making mistakes, that would be fine.

Mentoring is usually not paid, so that situation should have been made clear to the employee before providing it and incurring a debt to the employee. I don't know whether it was or not.

Richocet

Re: What's the fuss?

Yes it is different. You don't buy a job. That defeats the purpose!

Richocet

Difference in salary

The difference in salary could also indicate that this person was being underpaid before they changed jobs. IF the training was good it would have increased the person's value a bit but not doubled it.

DoorDash delivery drivers try to manipulate the food biz's payment algorithm to earn a living wage in gig economy

Richocet

If the majority of delivery people refuse to take low paying jobs, then it will push up the average price. This is common in other market places. It's not really gaming the algorithm. And the algorithm is nothing mysterious, it-s just another calculation of market prices.

If Doordash are unhappy with the waiting times experienced by customers then this is also fixed by the delivery drivers being offered higher prices which they will rapidly accept and action.

There is no solution to get fast delivery cheaply without exploitation. Anything that looks like it solves that 'problem' is just disguising the exploitation.

Ex-IBM staffer files lawsuit claiming company stole his cloud computing tech IP

Richocet

Well he didn't invent this while working at IBM - it was beforehand. So it's not open and shut that IBM owns it unless the contract says otherwise.

You only need pen and paper to fool this OpenAI computer vision code. Just write down what you want it to see

Richocet

Great thumbnail photo

The terminator facepalm was LOL for me.

US consumer protection bureau goes after tech support scammers' alleged payments processor

Richocet

Re: Good

No. Always go after the finance people or both.

It's important for all the finance businesses to have integrity and consistent rules to prevent money laundering and deny criminals and terrorists access to banking services. This makes them work hard to try and get around it, and slows them down. It only takes one or two weak links to compromise all the protections, so prompt and harsh action is necessary when someone doesn't play ball.

Google says once third-party cookies are toast, Chrome won't help ad networks track individuals around the web

Richocet

Third party data brokers

The third party data market is a swamp. Data gets laundered so you don't know who collected it and anyone can buy personal data if they are prepared to pay. That means organised crime, the Kremlin, stalkers, fraudsters, anyone can access it without identifying themselves. So I will be happy to see that go away. Strengthening Google and Facebook's position for advertising is a bad side-effect though.

Flagship Chinese chipmaker collapses before it makes a single chip or opens a factory

Richocet

Re: More to this than meets the eye

The United States of America rampantly copied European products, designs and technologies after independence, viewing the European system of copyrights and patents as unfairly onerous. It doesn't mean that copying is fine, but this illustrates that perspectives are different.

Richocet

Re: More to this than meets the eye

Well Chinese culture could be a factor. Forced labour is not going to translate to producing innovation and high quality products. The rampant corruption in China is also going to hold them back, however the increasing corruption in Western Democracies is evening that playing field .

I agree that it is an arrogant mistake to think "people in my country are smarter than people in that country". There has always been another less obvious cause for discrepancies.

And the Chinese government is capable of pursing long term strategic goals, whereas most democracies change direction when a new president is elected e.g. the Paris Climate accord and the Iran Nuclear agreement.

Pyrrhic victory: Co-Op wins £13m from IBM over collapse of £175m Project Cobalt insurance platform contract

Richocet

Re: Certainly not blameless

LOL. Is this still true?

Four women seek release from forced arbitration to sue Infosys for widespread gender discrimination

Richocet

Re: Forced arbitration should be illegal

Undue process?

It's been a day or so and nope, we still can't wrap our head around why GitHub would fire someone for saying Nazis were storming the US Capitol

Richocet

Re: The problem

This is nitpicking, but lawyers are almost certain to get disbarred for lying in court and/or to judges, so I think this is why they were reluctant to bring election fraud cases to trial, and struggled to substantiate those claims in court.

I agree that there is a double standard - people are quick to sling insults such as 'communist' and 'libtard', or falsely accuse pedophilia or terrorism which is swept under the carpet, whereas calling people who are members of neo-nazi groups or carry nazi flags nazis and people who are open racist bigots is censorship, outrageous and unacceptable.

Privacy pilfering project punished by FTC purge penalty: AI upstart told to delete data and algorithms

Richocet

Re: Inconsistent decision is concerning

@Doctor Syntax . If you change "and" to "or" then I agree.

I don't think that both decisions are wrong - in which case there would be some third outcome which which is better for both cases somehow.

Richocet

Re: Inconsistent decision is concerning

Bad precedents should be overturned. But this is rare, and should be rare.

Something goes to court and an expensive process takes place in which judges consider the laws and the evidence and make a decision.

Everybody expects the next case of the same time to have a similar outcome. This is good for judges, lawyers and the entities subject to the laws.

That is one reason I was so surprised at the outcome here.

Richocet

Inconsistent decision is concerning

So they allowed Google to keep the models they developed after privacy rules were broken, but not this smaller company.

The Google decision set a precedent, so why make a different decision afterwards?

This decision creates an unfair playing field. Google benefits from both decisions and the smaller company can't compete with Google because of the decision.

Is it because Google is bigger?

For me it raises a larger concern about the integrity of the whole process, decision-making and penalties. Why did a larger and wealthy company get a more favourable decision?

Let the chips fall where they may: US Commerce dept whacks Middle Kingdom firm SMIC on naughty list

Richocet

Re: This will cause more pain in the long term

The Chinese are actually pretty crap at high tech - they are good at copying and mass production.

Their ethics of product substitution, pollution, forced labour and race to the bottom for low quality are a substantial part of the problem and are not easily changed. I'm not sure how much this is due to the government lying, mismanagement and corruption, but the government is not going to change any time soon.

Japan and Taiwan have some sort of motivation to produce higher quality products and eventually succeed. Korea has too (surprisingly). But I not confident that China will succeed.

A bridge too far: Passengers on Sydney's new ferries would get 'their heads knocked off' on upper deck, say politicos

Richocet

Re: not very good at bridges in Australia

I did it for you. Yes, that is a fine looking bridge.

Richocet

Re: I heard that everything in Australia will kill you.

We have the deadliest asbestos and uranium FTW.

Richocet

Re: They could

Having worked in the Australian government before, my theory for the likely cause for this was an elected politician (naturally unaware of the height requirements) deciding / influencing who got the contract.

In Australia elected politicians are not allowed to do this, the decisions must be made by 100% by public servants according to procurement rules. However the rules are frequently circumvented.

By default the procurement team remain accountable for the decision. And then we see comments in El Reg, social media etc about them getting beheaded as punishment.

Richocet

Re: They could

At least one of those bridges are the London Bridge opening type that are never opened anymore.

It's an uphill battle with sea level rising at 3.4mm per year.

Also for those unfamiliar with the Parramatta river, the section that the ferries travel in is is salt water and tidal. Drinking it is not recommended.

Huawei and top Chinese AI startup accused of building 'Uyghur alarm' facial recognition scanner for govt

Richocet

Sundar Pichai insults engineering

His apology letter has me seeing red with his references to "Engineering Culture". Pichai is referring to his idea of the culture at Google.

Engineering culture is about being honest, and accurate, don't cover up flaws and weaknesses. Ask for and accept peer review. Continuous improvement.

The Boeing 737-MAX is the perfect example of where Google-style engineering culture was substituted for professional engineering culture - and the result was planes falling from the sky and many deaths.

Labor watchdog accuses Google of illegally firing staff in union-busting push – as AI ethics guru Dr Timnit Gebru is pushed out

Richocet

Re: We strongly support the rights our employees have in the workplace

I think you got all of those downvotes because you don't understand how academic research works.

At the start the researcher, the funders of the research and the hosting institution agree the topic of research and commit the funds. The research progresses and a paper is written containing the findings.

The researchers have a very high quality bar to reach - verifiable evidence, apply numerous of error management techniques e.g. 'double blind', no opinions. The paper is peer reviewed by other researchers who are experts in that field. Any patents etc are registered if applicable. The funders and the hosting institution get to review the paper and ask questions. They don't get to bury the paper if they don't like it, they don't get to demand changes, or edit it. Firing one the researchers is outrageous. The worst thing any stakeholder can do (and should be allowed to do) is find flaws in their research or methods or data - which is tough if the researcher is competent.

AWS is fed up with tech that wasn’t built for clouds because it has a big 'blast radius' when things go awry

Richocet

Re: Strange terminology

You round the numbers

Richocet

Any of the proposed solutions are better than the IT company next door that switches to a diesel generator every Friday morning when they "run backups". The exhaust of this points into my back yard. Any washing I have on the line is toast and if they run it for more than an hour my house starts to fill with diesel exhaust fumes. These do not smell nice FYI.

Pure frustration: What happens when someone uses your email address to sign up for PayPal, car hire, doctors, security systems and more

Richocet

The latest excuse is that COVID-19 makes it impossible to respond to support enquiries. Totally disingenuous unless the workforce is actually infected or dead, and even then there are no shortage of people available to replace them.

Uncle Sam sues Facebook for allegedly discriminating against US workers in favor of foreigners on H-1B visas

Richocet

I graduated as an electrical engineer in 1995 as one of hundreds. At least 80% of my class were very good. We were one of the last years where there were good employment opportunities.

Since then, the practice of bringing in cheaper labor from another country has filled much of the demand for technical skills. Local STEM graduates now have difficulty finding work when they graduate, even though there are fewer graduates these days. So in Western countries few students enrol to study STEM because it is hard, expensive and has much more limited career prospects than it used to.

I have hired and managed cheaper labor foreign contractors and local IT graduates. I am still amazed at how good the local graduates are and am more than happy to give them that first opportunity to get into the job market. The technical education levels of Indian Universities is noticeably lower in my experience.

Richocet

Re: This court case is so un-american

If you extend this from monopolists to include oligopolists and duopolists you have painted an accurate picture of US capitalism.

Wireless screen in estate agent window just begging for someone to fill it with mischief

Richocet

So this is a hypothetical prank

Am disappointed that Kate didn't take the opportunity to pull a hilarious practical joke.

Love Minecraft: Java? You'll have to learn to love your Microsoft account as well – it will be required next year

Richocet

Until you have unreliable internet. Then your computer and becomes an unusable brick because all your software is locked behind online logins and license checks .

If this are so great at preventing software piracy, why is software more expensive now?

It creates an ongoing incentive for pirates to hack software to get around protections that have a big impact on users of the software.

For example I have watched pirated DVDs when I own the legitimate version, just so I am not forced to watch the company logo and copyright message.

Richocet

This sucks so much when my internet goes out more than 20 times most days.

Playing online games results in me immediately getting kicked out and often have trouble login back in because the server hasn't timed-out my last login. It wastes a lot of time.

Facebook is leaky, creepy, and trashy. Now it wants to host some of your customer data

Richocet

Re: Am I the only one still sane?

But can you write faster than you can speak? Most people can't, and that's why text and email is usually inefficient.

Beware, drone fliers, of Scotland's black-headed gulls. For they will tear your craft from Mother Nature's skies

Richocet

I can't wait until a vulture takes out a drone.

We will hear it at El Reg first I am sure.

Email-spamming COVID profiteers deleted database with 'key evidence' when UK watchdog came knocking

Richocet

Re: Insufficient

The punishments have to be in proportion to the crime. As an example to consider, the alleged activities of Prince Andrew.

Guess whose app store claims to champion 'choice, fairness and innovation'. It's Microsoft's, funnily enough

Richocet

Since games are widely player by a younger* demographic, it is really sad to see Microsoft doubling down on not being interested in making console conditions fair. Sad that exploiting vulnerable people is normalised in business these days.

*I understand that a broad range of people use game consoles not just young people.

Google contractor HCL America accused of retaliating against unionized techies by shifting US jobs to Poland

Richocet

Re: IT skills are fungible

China uses forced labor on a mass scale - mostly from people selected on ideological, religious, or ethnic grounds. Nobody should be expected to compete with that to be more attractive financially as an employee.

Key-cutting machine borked sideways after visit from the BSOD fairy locks things down

Richocet

The accuracy is a function of the machine capabilities and the wear on the cutting blade. The most common reason for low quality in cheap CNC'd parts is that the manufacturer will keep working with a worn cutting blade instead of replacing it more frequently. This saves money, but definitely affects precision.

Huawei's UK code reviewers say Chinese mega-corp is still totally crap at basic software security. Bad crypto, buffer overflows, logic errors...

Richocet

Script kiddies could do much of the hacking, but writing reports is not their strong point.

Richocet

Re: Huawei's attitude seems very odd

For me this is an eye-opening insight into the culture of the company. How they build things, and what they care and don't care about.

If this culture is common, it explains the river of terrible quality products flowing out of China.

Is today's AI yesterday's software routines with better PR? We argued over it, you voted on it. And the winner is...

Richocet

Re: Is this like triple-A mortgages

I used to work in that industry. The trick is to make the thing gratuitously more complex until the legal system and then the regulators can't keep up with it.

The evidence is that when people are taken to court over fraud etc. that the cases get thrown out (because the judge doesn't want to look silly), or it is too hard to convince a jury that deliberate crime was committed because the complexity, and they empathise that the perpetrator accidentally made a mistake.

The sales technique is the usual one that the complexity is why it is better, why relies on magical / alchemy thinking. Other examples of this sales technique are crypto currencies, and radium cure-alls.

In Steviebucks example of the wrapping, it's derivatives of derivatives of financial instruments.

Page: