* Posts by Baldrickk

649 posts • joined 26 May 2016


Should a robo-car run over a kid or a grandad? Healthy or ill person? Let's get millions of folks to decide for AI...

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Brake or steer

I'm not talking about inaction.

You still make every possible attempt to avoid the incident.

You just don't choose to kill something else.

That's the key here.

When we have a situation where an incident becomes unavoidable, do you make the decision to targetthat granny on the sidewalk?

As harsh as it may sound, if a kid ran out in front of a car within its breaking distance, its an accident. That car choosing to mount the pavement to hit Great Aunt Ethel instead? That's choosing to take a life.

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Final solution many years from now

I think they were thinking more along the lines of removing the roads from pedestrian areas - over/underpasses or pedestrian zones in city centres.

Baldrickk Silver badge

Brake or steer

And this is the essence of what the real answer should be:

- Avoid all possible collisions outright.

- Mitigate collision as much as possible if not possible to avoid

It seems that while he did not discuss it directly, another possible principle is being discussed here - one of the key points of the trolley problem is not that you have to pick left or right - in fact you are already on one of those paths - you instead have the choice whether to change who you hit.

At which point, you have the option of actively choosing to run over someone, or ending up hitting someone in a terrible accident.

I don't know about you, but I wouldn't want to choose and so have that (or those) deaths on my hands, were I standing at the junction in the traditional problem, or programming an autonomous vehicle, and would focus on stopping or improving my sensory capability and keeping the vehicle within the limits of control given the outside situation.

Anything happening that cannot be avoided by doing so, e.g. a grand piano falling from the sky, sinkhole opening up or someone jumping off the curb? Its unavoidable and you react to it as best as you can given the emerging situation.

Microsoft promises a fix for Windows 10 zip file woes. In November

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Great new search feature!

I know my dad keeps getting his documents redirected to the one-drive documents directory and not his user documents directory.

He then can't find them when he needs them, and potentially sensitive documents have been copied onto the internet...


I've now nixed One-Drive on his PC as he didn't want or need it, but Windows keeps redirecting his saves there when it recreates the directory... sigh.

Motorola: Oops, phone busted? Grab a spudger and go get 'em, champ

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: I think my next phone will be a Motorola

Being home repairable suggests that its been built to be easy to repair.

That's the reason for supporting it. It may very well be that you take it to a shop for the actual repair to be done, but the faster and cheaper it can be done, the better, right?

Back in the not so distant past, that battery replacement would have been £20 for the battery and £0 for taking the backplate off yourself and just swapping the old for the new.

Happy 60th birthday, video games. Thank William Higinbotham for your misspent evenings

Baldrickk Silver badge

Not really sure it could be callled machine learning.

More like adding an additional node to a binary tree.

Pixel 3 XL reveals innards festooned with glue and... Samsung?

Baldrickk Silver badge


wait, 13Wh? what's that in mAh? How does that compare to, lets say the 3000mAh battery in my S7 that is coming to the end of its contract?

Correct me if I'm wrong, but at 5V, that would be a worse battery? but at say, 2.5V it would be a better one?

What voltage/s does the Pixel run on?

World's largest CCTV maker leaves at least 9 million cameras open to public viewing

Baldrickk Silver badge

OEM devices can be recognised by xxx

But no examples on how to make that check?

Self-driving cars may not have steering wheels in future, dev preview for PyTorch 1.0 is here, etc

Baldrickk Silver badge

Cars have to have steering wheels

I guess if we stop calling stage 4 autonomous vehicles cars we could avoid the steering wheel requirement? The lack of a driving position is a considerable difference to every car on the market today...

Day two – and Windows 10 October 2018 Update trips over Intel audio

Baldrickk Silver badge


Isn't this the update that they rushed out because there was very little in it without going through the usual process?

Surprise meter has a low reading.

Send up a satellite to zap space junk if you want Earth's orbit to be clean, say boffins

Baldrickk Silver badge

yes but

ours is in space already for testing.

sometimes simple is better - I mean, it's not rocket science is it? or maybe it is ;)

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Centrifugal force

Why call a web page with writing on it an article, or a piece of paper with writing a letter?

Why have male and female instead of having "Humans with parts that go inside another, and humans with parts designed to take other humans parts inside them?"

Its the definition of a term to define a common situation, in this case an apparent force, which allows for succinct communication.

Martian weather has cleared at last: Now NASA's wondering, will Opportunity knock?

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: RE: second only to the voyagers

Hardly "floating"

well, yes, "floating" - it's not thrusting at all. It's just floating quickly.

Baldrickk Silver badge

RE: second only to the voyagers

I'd rate Opportunity above the Voyager probes.

Yes, Voyager 1&2 have been active for longer, but they've not exactly had as much to deal with.

Life is pretty uneventful floating out there in the void...

Microsoft pulls plug on IPv6-only Wi-Fi network over borked VPN fears

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Catch 22

"Sorry your internet connection doesn't support online gaming/VOIP/whatever because your connection uses CG-NAT".

Unfortunately, with things like skype going cloudy and not peer to peer, that won't be affected.

Might have an issue with torrents? IDK, one would assume that someone has been working on a way around that.

Hosting your own server though, that's the kicker.

Do not adjust your set, er, browser: This is our new page-one design

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Out with the new, and in with the old

well I'm here for the content (and the comments) so no driving me away, but a less nice design makes it a little less nice to browse.

Really, what is up with the ads?

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Doesn't seem to work

only problem is my screen is a fraction over 4x that...

Microsoft accidentally let encrypted Windows 10 out into the world

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: a single "well qualified" in IT person that participates

I do, but none on their main machines, and none at work.

icon: because, well, the effect of potentially volatile beta code

Vodafone cops ads rap over Martin Freeman's vanishing spaceship

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: The only useful measure

I've been able to max out the thinkbroadband speed test over wifi, let alone wired - getting higher throughput from other services.

Granted that was ~130Mbs so plenty enough for Voda's advertised speeds, but still...

Microsoft: You don't want to use Edge? Are you sure? Really sure?

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Links to resolutions, will work with any browser

Gaming should be very much improved under Linux itself now with proton https://github.com/ValveSoftware/Proton/ which should be better than vanilla wine for gaming on linux.

I've yet to try it myself, but reports have been positive.

Solid password practice on Capital One's site? Don't bank on it

Baldrickk Silver badge

Single figure entry

There are other annoying ways for banks to really put a spanner in the works.

For me, the biggest is requiring specific characters from your password.

You can't just copy and paste that either.

Easy to put in if you have a short password that you remember 1-5-7 of "Abcd123"? "A13" not too hard.

What about 8-14-17 of "u[==sPDOD`w>d&]nVaUYOU-em+wY:N" erm... well first I need to open up the entry in the password manager, un-hide the password (so it's now in full view of shoulder surfers) and now count the characters, make sure I get the right ones and put them in. er... "O&V"

I mean, it's not hard to do, but it circumvents filling the password and makes it easier to get your password wrong by miscounting characters.

Also how do they store the combinations required? Is your password encrypted and not hashed (bad)? or is there a finite set of hashes of character combinations (terribly inefficient with space, and it's doubtful that they are going to pre-calculate every possible combination)

Y'know what? VoIP can also be free from pesky regulation – US judges

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Vonage and 911 (US-specific, sorry)

They do. Mine even allows calls to specified contacts without unlocking the phone - useful if you have a specific need or want your home/next of kin to be contactable.

Space station springs a leak while astronauts are asleep (but don't panic)

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Then they're hurt or killed

eveything in:

California might kill you

Australia wants to kill you

Mozilla changes Firefox policy from ‘do not track’ to ‘will not track’

Baldrickk Silver badge

Agreed. If they all played by the metaphorical book, then there wouldn't be a problem.

I block ads because of the sheer number that are **** annoying, be they playing videos, pop-ups, pop-unders, self expanding banners... Not to mention the scope for malicious ads, and the tracking they do (it's not even useful - if I buy, lets say, a bench online, I then have one. Adds for more benches isn't going to convince me to buy another one when I now have one and only have enough room for one).

If I were to come to a tech site, and was served ads that were static images with a link, and tailored to the experience not by tracking me, but by going "hey, it's a tech, site, lets provide a "techy" ad" then that would be perfectly acceptable, and useful.

When you go onto what should be a fairly innocuous site, and there are 400-500 trackers active on a single page... Who are all these people, and why should they have access to information about me?

No need to code your webpage yourself, says Microsoft – draw it and our AI will do the rest

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: I do wonder...

When I worked behind a till, the reason for me to do it that way was that coins were less likely to fall between fingers and all over the floor if the note is beneath forming an impenetrable layer that holds the coin.

As a customer, it's really not hard to either pull the notes out from underneath, or just turn everything on it's side in your hand and just pick up the notes from next to the coins.

Teardown chaps strip away magic from Magic Leap's nerd goggles

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Meanwhile the other Leap is also hard at work

Technically, the lighthouse system is also inside out tracking - the lighthouses do none of the tracking, unlike the Occulus / PSVR solutions where the tracking is done using external cameras

It liiives! Sorta. Gentle azure glow of Windows XP clocked in Tesco's self-checkouts, no less

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: BBC Micro

We have one of these in the workshop at my company. Its doing the same job as it always did, running tests on new/refurbished hardware.

It'll only get replaced if the company we are doing the work for stumps up the cash to replace it, the problem being that if it were to break, we're out of replacement hardware for it...

The Register's 2018 homepage redesign: What's going on now?

Baldrickk Silver badge


I wonder what the stats are - how many people opted in to see the change, and how many are still using the new layout?

Self-driving cars will be safe, we're testing them in a massive AI Sim

Baldrickk Silver badge

re: Evidence

And how many incidents that the waymo vehicles have been involved in were caused by human drivers?

Phased out: IT architect plugs hole in clean-freak admin's wiring design

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Huh?

If you're really, really lucky the entire team ends up working on the morning of Christmas day.

At a TV transmitter location? not likely - can't miss the Queen's Speech!

An early tuesday morning maybe, say 02:00 would seem more likely, some time when the least viewers possible could be affected.

Baldrickk Silver badge

The worst I've seen was in the atrium of the "Hub" building at University. 4 floors high, with offices all up one side, fully wired for Wifi.

Including a few phone hotspots, a Wifi scanner found 262 unique access point/SSID combinations (each access point provided access to three or four SSIDs, so that's 65-85 different visible access points providing the same networks, all on 2.4Ghz)

IPv6: It's only NAT-ural that network nerds are dragging their feet...

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Obvious need for..

What you do is create a compatible protocol so that:


For all the excitement, Pie may be Android's most minimal makeover yet – thankfully

Baldrickk Silver badge

Only option to stay sane...

Seems to be to ignore the data slurp - give in to it...

Trying to lock everything down just makes you go crazy, paranoid and stressed at the same time, and the only way to stop it seems to be to become Amish.

I'm not comfortable with my phone screen scraping everything I look at - as boring as it is. But what can you do to stop it?

The only viable option would be to go to another system, but the only viable one would be an iPhone, but there are other reasons why I don't want to go there either.

Most recently being my iPhone using sister with a video to send to me, resorting to sending via an online service because the iPhone doesn't support point to point file transfers over bluetooth. I mean, how hard is it?

Google are just after your data, Apple want to lock you down too much. I really, really want a third option.

Ubuntu touch and sailfish seem like good ways to go, but neither support my phone right now, and are not quite viable for day to day use yet, but I really want them to be!

Sur-Pies! Google shocks world with sudden Android 9 Pixel push

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Survey...

I have three or four distinct routes I could take to work, all take about the same time.

More, when you take in other alterations over short sections.

Google maps does a good job at directing me onto the least congested.

The only thing it doesn't realise is that I have cloned the access token for the back entrance to the business park, which cuts a good 10mins off of my 1h commute which is only accessible through one of the main routes....

Top tip? Sprinkle bugs into your code to throw off robo-vuln scanners

Baldrickk Silver badge

Obscuring the real bugs

Because we all know that security by obscurity always works...

ZX Spectrum reboot latest: Some Vega+s arrive, Sky pulls plug, Clive drops ball

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: It looks a bit... "cheap"

Watching the reviews on YT only make it worse...

Damage from build and construction, really bad control quality - stiff and with no tactile feedback, constant crashes on menu screens, paper logo under the screen cover, the list goes on...

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: German tank problem

I hope so. That's a wonderful bit of maths.

Baldrickk Silver badge

It looks a bit... "cheap"

As title, insert appropriate four letter word as applicable

Hmm, there's something fishy about this graph charting AMD's push into Intel's server turf

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: (misleading stats)

It'd be "fine" if the scales were the same, but they're not making it impossible to understand properly. You can't even compare the gradients / rate of change.

Castaway hacker guilty of sedating children's hospital computers

Baldrickk Silver badge

picked up by Steamboat Willie?

Early experiment in mass email ends with mad dash across office to unplug mail gateway

Baldrickk Silver badge

I'm yet to send an accidental email like the ones above, but the number of times I forget to attach something yet realise 0.025s after hitting the send button...

LG G7 ThinkQ: Ropey AI, but a feast for sore eyes and ears

Baldrickk Silver badge

My G3 was fantastic. It still runs fine, though only if I use a USB-OTG and screen mirroring to my smart TV - I smashed the screen just before my 2 year contract ran out. I had no problems with the phone itself, and would have gladly gone LG again...

...but the S7 was on a very steeply discounted contract so I picked one up instead.

Now the question is, when my contract is up in a few months, should I actually look at upgrading to this, or any other new phone from this year, or stick with my S7 which is still going strong (and put LineageOS on it to get updates)?

It doesn't feel like I'm really missing out on anything except the bokeh effects from dual lenses. I'd prefer to buy a decent camera instead tbh.

Wearable hybrids prove the bloated smartwatch is one of Silly Valley's biggest mistakes

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: The Number of the Beast

It's not really that the processors are too powerful for the job - they do the job fine. The bigger problem is that they are too powerful for the batteries you can fit in them...

If batteries could deliver ten times the power for the same volume, then the drain would be less of a problem.

Baldrickk Silver badge

When I'm driving...

I have a clock on the dashboard, failing that the radio has one, failing that, the phone is mounted for use as a sat-nav and displays the time.

Failing that, and only when looking isn't convenient - "OK Google, what is the time?"

Sad Nav: How a cheap GPS spoofer gizmo can tell drivers to get lost

Baldrickk Silver badge

I don't know about "Mainly" but our Discovery 3 falls back on inertial guidance when it loses GPS.

It's accurate enough to show your rough position while in a tunnel, or get you past a junction in a black spot, but the accuracy degrades pretty quickly beyond that.

It fixes itself once it starts getting updates from GPS again.

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Luckily

It can be a good way around an incident. Recently skipped 40 minutes of stationary traffic by use of a side-road and a car-park with an exit onto that road and the road I wanted to get onto by following some locals. Turns out there had been a smash across the junction that I avoided.

I typically learn my route beforehand. The GPS is a backup to my brain and a convenient way to see traffic levels, plus there is always an atlas at hand in the car as the next fallback.

It walks, it talks, it falls over a bit. Windows 10 is three years old

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: block any specific up/down traffic via firewalls?

Sure, you can, but that's a bit like seeing everything as a nail, right?

Really an OS should just behave itself.

Baldrickk Silver badge

Re: Windows Update on 10

True, but how often do you end up being forced to reboot Windows as opposed to Linux?

The megalithic kernel in Windows ends up being rebooted far more often.

'Fibre broadband' should mean glass wires poking into your router, reckons Brit survey

Baldrickk Silver badge

They should/could have kept using coax > telephone wire and left "fibre" to full fibre connections.


Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2019