* Posts by Carneades

12 posts • joined 5 Oct 2014

As Tesla hits speed bump after speed bump, Elon Musk loses his mind in anti-media rant

Carneades

Hmm...

Surprisingly heavyweight and even deep for the Reg. Wonder if anything will change...anywhere...ever...at all?

Which? leads decrepit email service behind barn, single shot rings out over valley

Carneades

They're good at spending money - and losing it. Lost £33m in the last ten years alone.

Carneades

the Which? Betrayal...

What's not is the article is the fact that Which? had no way of terminating the service as they hadn't written it into the Ts and Cs - so they altered the Ts and Cs the day before they sent out the email. Great way for the 'consumer champion' to behave, eh?

Let's go live now to Magic Leap and... Ah, still making millions from made-up tech

Carneades

Re: Bless you all...

Oops...

Carneades

Bless you all...

Wonder if Kieren realises that his entire article could just as easily refer to the history of the Christian church? But then, the Wizard of Oz is an allegory...

Doctor Who's tangerine dream and Clara's death wish in Last Christmas

Carneades

I suspect this episode was a hint. Making everything a dream is, after all, the only way to explain some of the plot absurdities we've suffered this season, so at least some will continue watching to see if there's any sort of resolution.

Doctor Who trashing the TARDIS, Clara alone, useless UNIT – Death in Heaven

Carneades

I wanted to like this series - I really did. But I suppose I only enjoy Science Fiction.

Reg hacks see the woods or the trees In the Forest of the Night

Carneades

They're here:

http://www.doctorwhotv.co.uk/doctor-who-series-8-ratings-accumulator-66394.htm

Carneades

Almost there

A much better episode all round. The essential plot about producing excess oxygen to combat the solar flare was silly, however, and unworthy of kids. Had a whiff of eco-saviour in there, somewhere, but they could easily have made the solution or the reason far more compelling and even believable.

I thought the kids worked. Yes - some fought with their stage-school accents, but on the whole this was old-school Who and they acquitted themselves pretty well. But yes; the final reveal will have to be unheard-of astonishing to work, although I harbour (almost certainly forlorn) hopes that Clara will morph into Amy Pond…

Doctor Who's Flatline: Cool monsters, yes, but utterly limp subplots

Carneades

Change is all around...

This episode was definitely better than last week's. But Who is supposed to be Science Fiction, so one might reasonably expect it to use some science from time to time.

The concepts were indeed interesting, although not original, and the pace this week was significantly improved. But two things occur: in the real world I sometimes believe the US approach to writing would be better. Teams, rather than individuals, frequently produce better content, and although there are always exceptions, by and large British drama has always suffered from (often rather ropey) character centred plots, which is exactly what good science fiction avoids.

The other factor is that the show really should aim to deliver as much accurate science as possible, otherwise it becomes just another Magic show. It does a disservice to intelligent youngsters by not at least attempting to explain how and why some things happened. How did the normally invincible TARDIS lose energy to the 2Ds? And how was it very nearly destroyed?

The teaser about Clara (monster, villain, the next Dr?) seemed almost tacked on, and makes one long for the return of Riversong, but it was a far better episode overall than last week, and that’s at least encouraging.

Here’s an idea: the most compelling episodes of Dr Who have (to me) always centred around discovery and a sense of wonder. To that end, perhaps the show should start looking at established Sci-Fi writers as sources for ideas and move the Dr away from the current space/time position. Lots to see at the end of the Multiverse…

Doctor Who becomes an illogical, unscientific, silly soap opera in Kill The Moon

Carneades

Re: I have to say...

It's the one thought that's been nagging at me since watching the episode. Capaldi hinted at it with an aside "This might not be the moon - our moon..." so it might yet turn out to be someone's fevered nightmare. Here's hoping.

Carneades

And so it begins...

There's nothing quite like TV Sci Fi for stirring the emotions. On Amazon, for instance, the most passionate, informed or simply plain daft reviews are always, always about a Sci Fi film. And so it is here. Contributors becoming exercised about the factual content of a fictional show is nothing new, but there just might be an underlying currency to their views in this case.

Science Fiction fans tend to be brighter than the average and often hail from real world science careers, and it's the intellect of the fan base that makes it so hard to write good Sci Fi. As both an author and enthusiast I know that only too well, but Brid-Aine's observations about the lack of hard science in this latest episode ring true. It's true we accept the TARDIS, and a Time Lord, but there's good reason for that: both are aspects of a science well beyond our comprehension, at least for now. The problem with this latest episode was that it deal with science that most bright youngsters understand; mass, pressure, orbital mechanics and simple life forms, and it fell down through a combination of either poor research and even poorer costuming, or through a horrendously slashed budget.

Missed opportunities abounded, too; why were the Doctor's space suits so ropey? We know in the real world that intense research is being undertaken on skin-tight suits for use in low-pressure environments, or even in space. But from the look of the Doctor's suits, there wasn't even any pressure differential.

I'll stick with Dr Who, as I have since the original series, and the darkness around the Dr is curiously fascinating, but if Moffat et. al. treat a generation of youngsters with the disdain shown in this latest episode then the time might even come to revert to Star Trek.

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2019