* Posts by aberglas

166 posts • joined 22 Apr 2014

Page:

Sure, we could replace FTNN, says nbn™, if you let the unwired wait even longer for broadband

aberglas

Re: "$2,800 to make an FTTC connection"

They should just give the FTTH to everyone that is will to pay, say half the cost, $1,400, up front. That should be easy to do and shut up the Fraudbanders. Then the other 99% of households will be happy with FTTN, plus not having to pay in taxes for services they do not want.

Personally, I would be happy to pay $1,400 for a decent ADSL service. But it will be a long, long time before the NBN gets near my place.

0
0

nbn™ builder prioritises easy premises, because it must work like that

aberglas

Prioritizing those that already have good internet

There is a huge benefit of the NBN for people that have no internet at all.

But so little for people with good ADSL that most would not switch to the NBN if they were not forced to by cutting their copper. (We know that as a fact from trials where they did not threaten to cut the copper.)

So what does the NBN prioritize? Those that do not really want the NBN.

It is the wrong KPI. Number of premises is a worthless metric. How many people with no or bad internet have been connected. That is the KPI that counts.

(And for the "Fraudband" screamers, it would have been as bad or worse under the FTTP plan. And that $42 billion costing was a fairy tale for small children.)

0
2

Dishwasher has directory traversal bug

aberglas

Re: Bewildered. (That's grown-up speak for "wtf")

"If you simply fail to inform your inevitable IoT dishwasher of the password for your household Wi-Fi hotspot, then it's significantly less likely to actually connect."

After 30 days being unable to check for software updates it will refuse to run at all. An essential safety feature to keep you safe.

29
0
aberglas

Re: Bewildered. (That's grown-up speak for "wtf")

To misquote Edmond Hillary, They are connected to the internet because it (the internet) is there.

They can, um, ping your iphone when the dishes are done. Let you check that the kids have run the dishwasher from work. Keep statistics about powder usage. Disable the machine if it is found to be used by terrorists. The possibilities are only limited by your imagination...

The next dishwasher that I buy will certainly be connected to the Internet of Things ... because I won't have any choice.

34
1

Australia: Stop blaming Centrelink debts on its IT systems

aberglas

Multiple points of incompetence

Just because the rules set up by the executives were incompetent, does not mean that the programmers did not also stuff up in other ways.

Given that this is an IBM project, it is safe to simply say that the natural incompetence of the IT department was, in this case, overshadowed by the even grosser incompetence of the management.

Mind you, one should always be wary of claiming that management is incompetent. In this case, I presume that many senior managers got promoted precisely because of their ability to say "Yes" at the right times, without being burdened by facts. Competence is the ability to achieve one's goals.

0
0

MAC randomization: A massive failure that leaves iPhones, Android mobes open to tracking

aberglas

Surely the 4G/Simm provides good tracking anyway?

So why all the fuss about wireless. Just a bit harder to listen in to the 4G traffic.

0
3

RAF pilot sacked for sending Airbus Voyager into sudden dive

aberglas

Flying by Joystick

Seems to be the trouble. Flying an airliner like you fly a computer game.

No little camera is going to clog up a big heavy steering wheel. And if it did the effect would be obvious, wheel pointing in wrong direction.

But a tiny bump being enough to pitch it over. It should take a mighty shove to do that.

The tiny stick has destroyed planes in the past. Air France idiot pilot pulled back the stick and held it. Other pilot did not realize -- no tactile feedback. Stalled it in all the way from 30,000'.

1
16

Passport and binary tree code, please: CompSci quizzes at US border just business as usual

aberglas

How do they assess

"Why of course I'll write a binary-tree balance algorithm for you, right here on my laptop, right now in front of you."

You'd be kicked straight out of the country. The official will compare your scawlings with his listing of the "correct" answer and instantly realize that they do not match. Because you should have used IBM 360 assembler.

6
0

Intel's SGX security extensions: Secure until you look at the detail

aberglas

Protection from SGX Viruses

SGX is the perfect place to write malicious code. I suspect Intel are trying to control who can write SGX enclaves to reduce that risk.

0
0

Competition and wholesale costs, not lack of fibre, crimp broadband in Australia

aberglas

Worst speeds, not average, is what counts

How many people have less than 1 megabit. That is the number that counts.

1 meg is enough to watch Netflix. And also use all web apps.

But less than that and you have no internet at all.

It is the minimum that counts. NOT the average.

Very few people have any need for more that 12.5 megabits. If 12.5 megabits was significantly cheaper than 25 megabits, very few would take up the latter option.

0
1

Australian Internet policy remains years behind reality

aberglas

Parliament picture will need updating

To include the security fences, and machine gun totting guards. Makes it more Australian.

Something like this

http://mogaznews.com/en/collection/275921.html

1
0

Don't pay up to decrypt – cure found for CryptXXX ransomware, again

aberglas

Re: It's fun, because they never learn

Sure they back up. To the cloud even. And once they they have all the encrypted files fully backed up the ransom ware demands payment.

The real issue is just how fragile software systems are. One small hole, one silly mistake by one user, and the whole stack crumbles.

6
0

If at first you don't succeed, send another Mars lander – this time a deep driller

aberglas

Two tonnes is very heavy

Curiosity was only 899kg. And remember that each kg on Mars requires hundreds of kilos on the launch pad.

I'm curious that Curiosity did not dig. I does not seem to be all that much more capable than Spirit and Opportunity.

The ESA does not look like it has an arm. Which I would have thought would be very useful for something that digs. Could also be used to steady itself etc.

0
0

Oracle finally targets Java non-payers – six years after plucking Sun

aberglas

Re: Anything that reduces use of Java, no matter how little

And replace it with what? Junk languages like C/C++, JavaScript and PHP?

Lisp died. The only real alternative to Java for a vaugely modern memory manged, JIT compiled system is .Net/Mono, which has its own problems.

0
10

Russian hackers got Trump elected? Yeah, let's take a close look at that, says Obama

aberglas

Computerized voting

That is the huge issue in the US. Completely unauditable, secretive systems. And the computers mysteriously malfunction or do not turn up in some precincts and not others.

Where fraud has been suggested, it is almost always Republicans doing it.

I am surprised the Democrats did not jump on this when they had the chance.

http://blackboxvoting.org/

11
3

No super-kinky web smut please, we're British

aberglas

Australia killed this (for now) Weak effort Brits

Labor Senator Conway tried ram in through. Most pollies are very conservative so it would easily pass the house.

But the public uproar was deafening. It dominated the news for a while. Conway just waited for the uproar to subside. But it did not. And then the censorship plans were quietly dropped.

The current conservative government would love to reintroduce it. But they are on a thin margin and will not dare.

Weak effort Brits.

0
0

50 years on, the Soviet-era Soyuz rocket is still our favorite space truck

aberglas

One way to the moon would have been much easier

The Soviets could have easily won the space race just by sending somebody one way. They had already successfully landed a probe on the moon, just do another with somebody inside.

It would have made two points. First that they got there first. And second, that soviet life is cheap. In the ICBM games you have to be prepared to lose a few million lives, which would not have bothered the Soviets that much but would have terrified the Americans.

0
0

Emulating x86: Microsoft builds granny flat into Windows 10

aberglas

Re: Baby... Bathwater?

Almost all of the operating system could and should be written in .Net. C/++ is archaic rubbish. .Net is one of Microsoft's strongest assets but they never used it themselves.

Lisp machines did this decades ago. Worked beautifully.

2
12

Australian government lends nbn™ AU$19.5bn to finish the job

aberglas

Number of connections is the wrong KPI

To quickly maximize the number of connected users on the NBN you focus on those that are easy to connect. E.g. near an exchange, have HFC etc.

But most of those users already have decent internet and do not particularly want the NBN, certainly not at $4,000/household tax subsidy.

Meanwhile, people on the outskirts, who are desperate for any broadband (1mbs would do) get nothing.

And the "fraudband" lobby do nothing to help this.

1
0

Swedish prosecutor finally treks to London to question Julian Assange

aberglas

The Swedes can save face

Now that the lesser charges have expired, they can drop this one while still saying that the lesser two were valid. That is all that is going on.

The term "rape" is being abused. It normally implies violence or a threat of violence. There has never been any allegation of this. Assange may be an arsehole, but he is not violent. Some would say that a woman changing her mind after the event is "rape" because the man should have been more caring...

I suspect that this was never a ploy to get Assange to the US, just an incompetent Swedish prosecutor. But I would not bet my life in a small US cell over it. And remember, a US jail is hell compared to a Swedish one.

3
2

nbn™ aces the easiest construction target it will have for two years

aberglas

Use for 100 mbs?

What exactly are people supposed to do with it? Run 100 TVs concurrently? Or 20 ultra high definition TVs? The only reason people buy 25mbs is that it is almost exactly the same price as 12.5mbs, and the latter is not available on BigPond.

Meanwhile, I get by on a 1.2mbs long ADSL line. It is plenty for web, and even development (GIT etc). It can run the TV OK as long as I throttle Windows Update. But the line is slowly degrading. And it will not be improved due to the NBN.

0
3

nbn™ says nobody needs gigabit internet, trumpets XG-Fast at 8Gbps anyway

aberglas

Re: State of the copper?

It is only the last few metres, house to curb. Some of that copper is troublesome. But most works just fine.

0
3
aberglas

Re: Gigabit not needed, what a load of crap!

Sure, some businesses would love it.

But most homes, and SOHOs just don't need a dozen ultra high definition TVs to all run concurently.

0
8
aberglas

Re: Wheres baldrick

How much do you think it costs on average to dig up someone's lawn and put new cabling to an existing house without making a mess? Two men for a day? That is way over $1000.

And for what benefit? If the copper works fine. And will likely continue to work for many decades to come.

0
8
aberglas

Why Nobody buys 100mbs

Because it is not useful.

Not many people have a dozen ultra high definition TVs at home that then need to run concurrently.

25mbs is not very useful either. But it is priced only barely above the 12.5mbs, and 12.5mbs is not even available by Bigpond. If there was an option for 5mbs at half the price of 25mbs I reckon it would be taken up by half of all consumers.

That was always the hole in the concept. There are no applications, real or imagined, that need high bandwidth in homes. You do not need a 25mbs to file a tax return or access health records etc.

Meanwhile, people without any internet at all wait and wait in vain.

The NBN does have a plan to ensure that people use their services though. Cut the copper, and give people no choice.

0
8

Without new anti-robot laws, humanity is doomed, MPs told

aberglas

Re: The UK autonomous weapons

The first autonomous weapons were torpedoes developed 100 years ago. And mines. They have been becoming smarter ever since.

The smarter they become, the less human interaction they need. The less people are required to control them. The more precise they can target.

Modern "torpedoes" could use existing facial recognition technology to pick individuals out in a crowd.

1
0

Assange meeting delayed

aberglas

Put up or shut up

Is what the Swedes would have to do if the meeting ever did take place after all these years. They cannot drop the charge after all this time or they would look ridiculous. They cannot press the charge because they would look ridiculous, especially as the women involved are unlikely to press them.

Maybe it is just an innocent timing conflict. Assange's lawyers busy with a different hot case. But I suspect that the meeting will never, ever take place.

There have been several other attempts to meet. The Swedes have used every device to avoid a meeting, like only applying the day before. This time it looks like Assange's lawyers fault, but I am very suspicious.

And yes, their have been dozens of similar meetings by Swedes with suspects overseas during the time the Assange fiasco has been running.

1
2

NBN is essential, says Essential poll, but not Turnbull's NBN

aberglas

Re: Why, why, why?

We are looking for one, just one, real or imagined application that people will realistically want that requires more than 5 megabits.

2 megabits is plenty for Netflix on a normal TV (I know, that is all I have) provided no teenagers in the house. Nothing else takes bandwidth like television.

And while video compression has improved over the years, it still has a long, long way to go, with fractal based algorithms promising massive reductions in required bandwidth. And engineers have been able to push more and more over old copper as well.

So that is why. There is not point. It is like digging everybody's front yard to give them a 100mm water pipe. Sure, that would enable them to have 50 showers at the same time, but that is not actually useful to most people.

0
4
aberglas

Meaningless question Asked

Correct question:

"You currently get 5 megabits which allows two concurrent Netflix sessions. Would you be prepared to pay and extra $20 per month to get 25 megabits which would enable 10 concurrent Netflix sessions."

90% of people will say NO. The others are either so rich they do not care of have a house full of teenagers.

Do you want more? Yes, of course. Would you pay for more? Hmm. Let me think about that carefully.

(We are currently on 2 megabits which allows one Netflix plus a little browsing. Provided I use our Gargoyle router (recommended!) to restrain Windows Update. I'd pay $10/month more for 5 megabits as I have teenage daughters. I have no use for 25 megabits.)

1
7

Chinese CA hands guy base certificates for GitHub, Florida uni

aberglas

Secure remote password is the answer

The only good thing about PKI is that it allows Verisign et al make money selling certs. And the NSA to subvert them.

The biggest hole is that it relies on end users validating URLs, which does not happens.

Secure remote password is the answer.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secure_Remote_Password_protocol

Or even the simple Nonce/Digest approach built into every browser since Navigator would help.

0
0

If you haven't changed your Dropbox password for 4 years, do so now

aberglas

Nobody tells people how to manage passwords

Lots of stupid advice about adding %X99 to them to make them hard to remember. But never the basic thing.

Use (a few) strong passwords on sites you care about.

Use a weak password everywhere else.

0
0

Oracle reveals Java Applet API deprecation plan

aberglas

We need browser based PHP with Pointer Arithmetic

PHP's elegance is no doubt the reason that it is the number one language for writing web applications today. (Way more sites than Ruby, Java, .Net.)

The only real problem with PHP is that it does not allow pointer arithmetic. Having to do p[q++] is just obviously so inefficient compared to p++.

That is a language that would change the world.

0
2

NBN delivers boring, solid result for 2015/2016

aberglas

Bandwidth is based on the Pricing

E.g. Internode basic plan is $50 for 12/1, $55 for 25/5.

So for most people, might as well pay an extra $5 even if they have no use for the extra bandwidth. (I would be one of those if the NBN is ever delivered to my area before the money runs out.)

It would be interesting to see what people chose if the pricing was something like $30 for 5/0.5 (ADSL speeds) $50 for 12/1, and $70 for 25/5. I reckon 5/0.5 would be over 50% except in richer suburbs.

And I do not have to reckon. When the first trial of NBN was done in Hobart, very few people took it up at all. It was a well serviced inner-city area, and people's ADSL did the job for less. That is why the NBN had to force people to cut the copper. Otherwise very few would bother with the NBN at all.

(The advent of Netflix might change that a bit, but not much. 2mbs is plenty for Netflix.)

0
1

Australia's Telstra and Optus outed as two of the world's six most expensive ISPs

aberglas

How does it actuallly work?

An explanation of how packets more and who pays would be interesting.

Is this saying that Telstra charges CDNs to deliver data to Telstra's customers? That would be very dubious, as Telstra is also charging its customers.

0
0

Julian AssangeTM to meet investigators in London

aberglas

There never was a credible charge to answer

That is why they Marianne Ny never hopped on the plane. If she did she would have to put up or shut up. Politically, she cannot drop the charges after all this time. But if she presses them in detail they will look ridiculous.

Assange was initially questioned in Sweden and allowed to go. The use of the word "rape" is very misleading, sexual misconduct might be better. But even that is hard to sustain when the victim gave a lobster dinner for Assange afterwards.

Whether the US really would extradite Assange is probably doubtful. But would you want to bet your *life* on that?

This thread is full of sell-righteous rubbish based on total ignorance.

And yes, the Swedes have inteviewed dozens of other suspects overseas during the last few years. If they had real charges, they could have done this long, long ago.

2
0

#Censusfail aftermath: Here's what's happening inside Australia's board rooms this morning

aberglas

You cannot sue IBM

The clever thing that IBM did for the Qld payroll system was to promise to fix everything and make the problem go away for the minster provided the government agreed never to sue them. And paid them even more money. And at the end of the day they sort of eventually got the nurses paid somehow.

This is just business as usual. Except that this time the stuff up is more public. Normally the stuff ups are in backroom ERP systems that nobody sees.

5
0

Apple says banks can't touch iPhone NFC without harming security

aberglas

Nice of Apple to look after their customer's secruity so well

You buy the phone and Apple buys you.

1
10

Microsoft extends bug bounty to cover Edge remote code exec

aberglas

It should be $150,000!

A "remote code execution" presumably means that you browse to a website and it takes over your entire computer. That is not just something more to patch next Tuesday, it should be considered to be something that cannot happen. Period. For it to happen there is something very wrong with the technology that is being used. (e.g. like using C/C++ instead of .Net!)

0
1

Australian Banks ask permission to form anti-Apple cartel

aberglas

Apple is outrageous

Using their App jail to lock out competitors. Totally unscrupulous, and exactly the type of vertical monopolizing that we do not want to see. It would be like the big for banks only accepting their own credit cards at eftpos terminals, forcing a monopoly.

For this one I am in with the banks. And I am surprised that they have not been able to take on Apple directly over this.

0
1

Australia to spend a billion bucks and seven years on SAP project

aberglas

Billion dollars buys a lot of clerks

It is of order a thousand dollars per recipient.

You could process all the payments by hand for that. Perhaps with a very simple fund transfer system and a few spreadsheets.

It is interesting that the Tax office consumes roughly 1% of GDP, which is exactly what it consumed back in the 1950s before any computerization.

The bigger the project, the less likely it is to succeed. A billion dollar project has no chance at all.

13
0

Drone bloke cuffed after gizmo stops firemen tackling forest inferno

aberglas

Sounds like nonsense to me

Since when does a 500g cause aircraft to drop out of the sky? And remember that the pilots are also equiped with eyes. And how was one aircraft, drone or otherwise, blocking the entire area?

We do not know the details, but this sounds very much like the way airports are shut down if somebody farts. Total over reaction for largely political reasons.

(And I am an amateur pilot, mainly gliders, so I know how to keep watch. There are birds up there as well, some of which attack!)

14
73

Telstra restarting long-stalled ADSL investment

aberglas

Good news. The NBN will take many more years.

For many, the NBN has been a disaster because it killed investment in the existing infrastructure. This meant some people have needed to wait many years without any internet at all, and will likely wait many more years for the NBN.

The NBN promisies speeds over 10mbit, whereas many ADSL lines struggle to provide 1.5 megabits. But without that 1.5 megabits people have no internet at all. The extra 8.5 megabits of NBN enables ultra high definition TV, but that is a marginal benefit compared to having no internet at all.

One wonders how many of the NBN zealots live without internet. And would be happy to wait 10 years or so without internet just to be able to have ultra high definition TV.

0
2

Quigley: FTTP wasn't a failed project

aberglas

Secretive Nonsense

Build FTTP for AU$43 billion! Quigley can make all sorts of crazy claims safe in the knowledge they will never be tested.

It is obvious that digging up everyone's front yard is more expensive than using the existing infrastructure. It might be well argued that the extra cost is worth it, but it is nonsense that it is cheaper to do FTTP. Two men for half a day per (easy) household is $800.

But both the old and new NBN are so secretive that there is no real way to test any numbers that either of them pull out of the air. The only certainty is that it will end up costing a lot more and take a lot longer than originally planned.

1
7

Wikimedia boss scoops $100,000 payrise – after stepping down

aberglas

Wikipedia works well, for all of its flaws.

It really is the best source of information on many topics. Thanks to a vast army of volunteers that could never be paid properly.

It is based on goodwill and a positive outlook on human nature. That more people are mostly good than mostly bad. It is the antithesis of bureacratic thinking, and it works amazingly well.

Sure there are many issues. But on the whole it works.

And the money involved is infinitesimal compared to the good that it does.

3
5

Is Windows 10 ignoring sysadmins' network QoS settings?

aberglas

My home network unusable

Installed windows 10 + office, and there are dozens of gigabytes of downloads. New C drive went from 12 gig after install to 50 gig now and growing.

On a 2 megabit ADSL, and it clobbers everything.

There are rumours that gsedit can throttle the BITS, but did not work for me.

Also llnw downloads, is MS using them too? All hidden behind the svchost.

Anyway, Gargoyle to the rescue, throttles the IP, seems to work despite this article. ALthough Gargoyle itself has been crashing recently.

4
2

Walmart sues Visa for being too lax with protecting chip cards

aberglas

Zip code for non-US cards

One annoyance of the US system is that some places like gas stations demand the entry of a zip code instead of the non-existent US pin. And that means that they do not accept foreign credit cards.

6
0

A modest proposal: dump the NBN mess on Telstra

aberglas

Re: Get over it!

You are forgetting that the first set of bullshit numbers saying that the FTTP could be built on time for 42 billion were totally reliable, whereas the all the subsequent bullshit numbers are bullshit. So it is perfectly valid to compare pie in the sky estimates as to what Fibre to the Premises would have cost and how much the current mess is actually costing.

But what I really want to know, is how did you get 25mbs fixed wireless without the NBN? What strings did you pull? And how can I get it?

3
0
aberglas

They actually paid to Cut the Copper

The NBN had to pay Telstra for the copper even if they did attempt to lay fibre to the premises (although access to the pipes would be helpful).

The payment would have been needed because once the NBN was available to a household, they MANDATED that the copper be cut. So that people could not choose to remain on the copper. And to do that they had to pay Telstra compensation for making their network illegal.

Why on earth would any sane person wish to remain on slow, broken and horrendously evil copper when they have a choice of fibre? Well, it turned out that when they did the initial roll out in Tasmania the vast majority of people stayed on copper because in the areas targeted by fibre the copper was good enough for what people used it for. Maybe Netflix will change that, maybe not.

But competition with copper would have killed the economics of the NBN if most people did not use the new service. And that is why they made the copper illegal. And that is why Telstra could hold them to ransom.

So they had to buy the copper regardless of whether they used it. Quite different from what the article says.

The correct solution was to focus on the broadband black spots and make 2mbs a mandatory requirement on Telstra, like phones already were. Then cheap technologies like loop extenders could address that. Once everyone has that, then crank up the speed to 5mbs, which is plenty for Netflix. Then reassess options based on newly available technologies.

2
3

How to evade the NSA: OpSec guide for journalists also used by terrorists

aberglas

How would Trend Micro know?

It is 100% fluff.

In truth, terrorists mainly just hide in the crowd (facebook, twitter, email) using simple techniques like code words. If you hear that the bride is on time then run!

That said, when encryption was rare, then it could be profiled. But once everyone start using it then that fails. Ubiquitous encrypted email would be the nightmare. (Encrypted messaging can be compromised at the proprietary servers.)

There is a real question here. If you discovered that the NSA was making spyware out of dead babies, how would you get the word out without going to jail?

2
0

Government tips last dollars into NBN

aberglas

$20,000 per household!

If reading between the lines $20 billion has been spent, and 1,000,000 households connected.

Sure, there is more to it than that with ramp up costs. But it does look like they spent almost all of the budget before delivering much at all. And many of those 1,000,000 are greenfield sites which were wired up by the developer and not NBN. (And probably even less would be delivered with FTTP, but that is a separate issue.)

Canceling would be the worst possible outcome. Without the NBN the ADSL black spots would have been addressed and we would all have passable if not spectacular broadband. But a cancelled NBN means we get nothing at all.

Great article by the way. Thanks for being the only decent source of IT news down here.

0
0

Page:

Forums

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2017