* Posts by localzuk

1653 publicly visible posts • joined 25 Jul 2011

Grab a pick: Space mining's the next generation gold rush

localzuk Silver badge

How long...

How long before we have ships competing for resources on an asteroid, and start taking pot shots at each other? After all, who's gonna stop them? Space police?

Get-rich quick trick Twitch snitch: Bots sued for fake video views

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Here is the problem...

If a broadcaster has 500 viewers, they are highly unlikely to have 500 subs. More likely around 10-20% that number at most. So, your calculation is well off.

Realistically, a 500 viewer stream is going to be looking at $125 - $250 income per month, plus tips etc...

This is how the EU's supreme court is stripping EU citizens of copyright protections

localzuk Silver badge

Re: I don't fully understand...

Sorry Andrew, once again you are chasing a reality that should not exist.

A hyperlink is the equivalent of someone saying to a room full of people that something exists and where it is. That isn't a crime, even if they are telling them where copyrighted material exists. They haven't themselves disseminated the copyright material. If it were a crime, it'd be absurd. It could even be argued that banning such a link would be an infringement of the right to freedom of expression.

So, why does that suddenly change when it is a link on a website? The link itself doesn't contain any illegal material. It is a quickdial on a phone.

Your view leads to the conclusion that hyperlinks are a crime unless they have the express permission of the owner of the copyright of that destination. Something that would make the internet a pointless place.

In obesity fight, UK’s heavy-handed soda tax beats US' watered-down warning

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Aspartame

Aspartame is safe. It has had more research done into it than pretty much any other food stuff due to the obsession with it. I'm happier drinking a drink with aspartame in it than refined sugar, that's for sure.

localzuk Silver badge

Re: "the obesity epidemic"

The obesity epidemic where 68.8% of the US population are considered overweight or obese.

The obesity epidemic where 61.7% of the UK population are considered overweight or obese.

The obesity epidemic that has meant hospitals have had to buy in reinforced furniture for patients, and weighing scales that wouldn't look out of place for weighing elephants...

That epidemic.

Java API judge tells Oracle to suck it up, quit whining about the jury

localzuk Silver badge

I don't get why this is carrying on

In order to provide compatibility with Oracle's APIs, Google had no choice but to implement the APIs as they exist. There isn't some other way to do so - if you change any of it, then you're no longer compatible and no longer using the API.

So, surely in the sense that there is no other way to do this, it would be fair use?

Sophos U-turns on lack of .bat file blocking after El Reg intervenes

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Hmm

Note - I stated that .bat files can't do any harm if the right permissions are in place on the client side... So, yeah, still don't see how a batch file could cause damage if they're restricted from running on the client.

localzuk Silver badge

Hmm

Surely things like .bat should be blocked on the endpoint anyway, not just blocking it from being downloaded.

I'm not particularly aware of any harm that a batch file can do if the users have restricted access rights on their clients anyway.

No 10's online EU vote signup crash 'inevitable' – GDS overseer

localzuk Silver badge

Still don't understand how this happens

We now live in a world of cloud hosting everything. Scaling a site like this should be as simple as spinning up more instances for the front end and database. You should even be able to automate it "if demand reaches X, spin up Y new instances".

Ok, that's a vast over-simplification, but it is still how it should work!

PC market sinking even faster than first thought, thanks to Windows 10

localzuk Silver badge

I wouldn't blame Windows 10

I'd blame the increase life expectancy of modern computers.

Gone are the days of 3-5 yearly refreshes being a necessity. A first generation core i5 machine with an SSD is still perfectly fine for business use today, so why bother replacing it?

The market is just adjusting to this really, which is why it'll stabilise.

Bin Apple's $500m patent judgment, US DoJ tells Supreme Court

localzuk Silver badge

Yeah, wrong rant. The fight is not against patents in general. Its against the specific notion of "design patents". Patents that cover the "look" of something.

They really are an anachronism, especially in the technology world.

Why Oracle will win its Java copyright case – and why you'll be glad when it does

localzuk Silver badge

Seem to be missing the "fair use" part of it all

Your entire argument for Oracle's ultimate success is that Google copied code. Which then leads to a fundamental misunderstanding of copyright. Copyright isn't just a "that's mine, you can't use it" tool. It has exceptions, it has nuance. And in this case, that nuance is fair use. That's what the courts are now deciding. There's a reason for what they did. There's a reason why it absolutely is necessary that Google wins this case, and it won't weaken copyright when they do, it'll ensure interoperability of systems continues without issue - FOSS or not.

Saying "Google stole code" is, quite frankly, irrelevant now.

Foxconn to slurp loss-making Smart Technologies for $200m

localzuk Silver badge

"Revenues at Smart peaked at $800m in 2011, but things have taken a turn for the worse since as the global economy remained stuck in a rut."

Don't think the economy had anything to do with it. Since 2011, SMART has fallen behind its competitors. They stuck to their high price model, and complicated licensing model far too long. Competitors such as Sahara and BenQ have produced superb alternatives to their interactive displays, and offered them at a much lower price.

OK, SMART's pricing has dropped lately, as they finally seem to have realised that the market has changed, but them reacting far too slowly is what has done this.

I know I'll be questioning whether we buy SMART gear ever again at the Multi Academy Trust I work for.

Are EU having a laugh? Europe passes hopeless cyber-commerce rules

localzuk Silver badge

I smell lobbyists

This has the stench of lobbyists all over it. What could've been a good set of rules to open up trade has been watered down by companies and countries that are still thinking in an isolationist/protectionist manner.

Hillary Clinton broke law with private email server – top US govt watchdog

localzuk Silver badge

Re: "Printing and filing those records"

I wonder if the policy applies to junk mail too?

Even without junk mail, they'll have some pretty huge document warehouses around the place. Great when it could all fit on a couple of hard disks.

Queen’s Speech: Digital Bill to tackle radicalisation, pirates

localzuk Silver badge

Re: That's just cover

History is not on your side here Andrew. Whilst the government are saying "oh, it won't be used for XYZ" we have decades of experience of laws being applied far further than they were originally intended to be used. It isn't paranoia, or persecution, it is evidence based conjecture.

On top of that, this law change (it is a change of copyright law, as sentence maximums are set in the laws themselves, whilst sentencing guidelines within those maximums are not in the laws themselves), is absurd. Sharing some files online, even in bulk, is not the same as selling physical copies.

I will guarantee nearly 100% that "egregious" won't actually end up in the law at all. Its highly likely instead that the law will merely have a new maximum sentence in it. Also, egregious, is a completely variable term, depending on the person looking at it, and whether they understand the technologies involved (for example, would someone who uploads a lot based on the fact they're part of a private tracker be classed as engaging in egregious infringement?). Its a washy term that means very little in law. Its why things are defined properly in legislation, and when they aren't, we end up with decades of court cases.

Home Office declares: Detained immigrants shall have internet

localzuk Silver badge

Makes sense from a "protecting your own ass" POV

Why would the government want people's posts to potentially go viral on social media sites if/when a detainee posts something that embarrasses the govt?

Its all about trying to keep them quiet.

Gov to pull plug on online ID verification portal Gateway in 2018

localzuk Silver badge

Wait, what?

So, they're shutting down Gateway, but the new one doesn't do as much as Gateway did, plus it doesn't seem to work properly for the things it can do?

What fool designs a replacement system that doesn't actually fully replace the old system?

Kill Flash now? Chrome may be about to do just that

localzuk Silver badge

Someone please tell education sites!

Flash is still heavily used in educational sites. To the extent that Flash not working in Chrome would be the end of us supporting Chrome in school here.

Every online testing site we've ever used here uses Flash. BBC Bitesize uses Flash. Cool math 4 kids uses Flash. Gridclub etc... The list goes on.

ICANN knifes Africa's internet: New top-level domains terminated

localzuk Silver badge

Kinda makes sense

I somewhat agree with the time-limit to get the gTLDs up and available to be honest. It stops organisations bidding on them and stopping them being used.

That said, it maybe should be done on a case by case basis, as some areas of the world may work a little more slowly than others!

Getty Images flings competition sueball at Google Image Search

localzuk Silver badge

Re: I think they have a point here

Not how it works though is it? If you are looking for an image, and the search engine provides you a 10 Megapixel version of the picture there and then, you're unlikely going to click "Visit Page" are you? You're going to copy it and move on.

At least, that's how every person I've ever seen use it...

localzuk Silver badge

I think they have a point here

The idea of an image search is great, but it shouldn't the end of the process - it should be pointing you to the place where the image is hosted.

SpaceX is go for US military GPS sat launch, smashes ULA monopoly

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Science SpaceX is go for US military GPS sat launch, smashes ULA monopoly

Don't think it does. There's nothing to stop ULA from modernising and reducing their costs. There's also potential for other providers to do the job too.

Shares down?! But, but, but ... Apple just made $50bn – that's the way the Cookie grumbles

localzuk Silver badge

Idiotic economic system

Constant growth is impossible. There is a limit to how many of anything that can be sold.

The idea that Apple's performance was in any way bad is moronic, and symptomatic of the short-termism that infects our economies. Apple made $10.2bn profit in Q2. That's a shed-load of money!

Investors should be looking at that and saying "well, we made a lot of money", not "we didn't make enough money".

Charter can gobble TWC for $78.7bn ... if it bins monthly download caps

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Which brings us to "The tragedy..."

Connections without caps seem to work for plenty of ISPs around the world, including the one I'm using. Caps actually appear to be a relatively new thing, introduced as a way to reduce investment into infrastructure.

Sure, we buy contended connectivity but its now 2016. If an entire housing estate can't all watch the latest episode of Game of Thrones on Netflix at the same time, then the ISP is doing it wrong.

Kent Police handed domestic abuse victim's data to alleged abuser – a Kent cop

localzuk Silver badge

Indeed. It will likely mean reduced staffing. What it should mean though, is a pay cut for all the management above the person who made the mistake, and the firing of that person.

Embattled 123-reg flings six months' free hosting at angry customers

localzuk Silver badge

6 months and then...

Will they delete all your stuff again after the 6 months are up? If I delete all the data at my job, I would lose my job and be sued...

Netflix's $1.81 billion Q1 disappoints markets

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Want my money? Stop the geoblocks

Geo-blocking is enforced by the licensing agencies and rights holders. As you have pointed out, it can actually make money for Netflix to allow VPN access. But it means that the need for regional or country by country licensing agreements is weakened, which is bad for the licensing agencies in those countries.

So, shout at them, not Netflix.

US anti-encryption law is so 'braindead' it will outlaw file compression

localzuk Silver badge

Killing off the tech industry in the USA?

Why would the tech industry stay in the USA if this bill came to pass? They'd all move to a more liberal country, like China...

Admin fishes dirty office chat from mistyped-email bin and then ...?

localzuk Silver badge

Would have to report it

In my job, there's no question about it, I'd have to snitch. Them's the rules, and I'm not risking my job over their indiscretion.

Hey, tech industry, have you noticed Amazon in the rearview?

localzuk Silver badge

So, so true.

I stick with one of my suppliers because they're fast and no-nonsense. I want XYZ, I ask for a quote, they get back to me within an hour or so. Usually I can then get an order in that day, and can have thousands of pounds worth of equipment here the next day.

Compare that to some of the software companies I have to deal with. We have a contract with one web based software provider, and we are likely going to expand it to cover half a dozen or more additional organisations in the next 6 - 12 months. I can't just get the same deal for each school. Instead, I have to meet a rep, get a 40 page contract, sign it, send it back. Whole process several weeks. For access to a website.

Other companies have it down. AirServer? I want a license? I click buy, stick a card number in and voila I have it!

UK cops trial £250k drone squadron

localzuk Silver badge

Expensive

Why such expensive machines? Surely they could get some off the shelf consumer models, and upgrade them (for secure transmission/control)? It wouldn't cost £49k to do that, that's for sure!

They'd be able to have a heck of a lot more of them if they did that!

Met cops shop for £150m IT system. Must have: Data centre ops

localzuk Silver badge

There are quite a few systems for such things. http://www.capterra.com/law-enforcement-software/ gives a random list of related systems.

There's gotta be thousands of police forces world-wide, so I'd be shocked if they couldn't get what they needed off the shelf.

Nest's bricking of Revolv serves as wake-up call to industry

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Here's how the competing IoT market will shake out

With the "savings" from things like the Nest thermostat, I don't understand how that actually happens.

Our heating is turned on, manually, when the house is cold. It is set to turn on in the morning, when cold, before we get out of bed to warm the house up, and again at night before we get home.

I don't see how having a fancy thermostat would reduce the heating bill? It only gets turned on when its cold at the moment. What's it doing that saves money?

Govt: Citizens, we know you want 10Mbps. This is the last broadband scheme for that

localzuk Silver badge

Re: All homes and businesses can now access basic broadband at speeds of 2Mps

Have you spoken to a satellite internet provider? That's what the government means by their statement really - you can get it but not via a wire.

Met police commissioner: Fraud victims should not be refunded by banks

localzuk Silver badge

Not very good at his job then...

My email account was compromised a while back during one of the many bulk hacks/releases of logins that've happened. OK, I spotted it within an hour and updated all the security credentials but if I hadn't? Would I be to blame for that? It wasn't my security that was lax. Email accounts are a big risk, as so many other services will reset their passwords by a simple email.

If they'd used that to reset some of my other accounts, with real money involved in them, would that be my fault?

HP Inc won't shake you down for ink in 3D printer era, says CTO

localzuk Silver badge

Re: I'll believe it when I see it. . .

The type of 3D printer you are referring to doesn't allow for much in terms of multi-colour printing, high detail printing etc... I've used such 3D printers and the end results are great in terms of a prototype, but are just not great.

The sort of device HP are talking about here is several steps up from that it seems, allowing per voxel printing! That's pretty amazing if it can be done cheaply.

So where has the legal 'right' to 10Mbps broadband gone?

localzuk Silver badge

Re: That is not competition

BT are a big ship and as such they turn slowly. They are very much wedded to their existing way of doing things.

The extra 5% could be connected up using a variety of different technologies such as point to point wireless, satellite, and even fibre. Just look at organisations like B4RN and how they're rolling out 1Gbps to farm houses in the middle of nowhere. It just takes some thinking outside the box.

BT won't do things like that though.

UK.gov's Major Projects Authority ain't saving us any money, say MPs

localzuk Silver badge

Retaining staff?

Might be easier for them to hire and retain staff if the government wasn't obsessed with cost cutting at every turn. When your job is permanently hanging in limbo, most people would be happy to take a slight pay cut for more security.

Not to mention the government's penchant for outsourcing everything.

Spotify to cough up royalties, just toss your copyright claims over there ... in the bin

localzuk Silver badge

Re: $1.3 billion turnover but a loss of milions

Don't believe the reported profit/loss. Spotify is part owned by a bunch of major record labels. Have no doubt that the rather interesting music industry accounting methods will be in use there.

Met Police cancels £90m 999 call command-and-control gig

localzuk Silver badge

Unique system?

There are thousands of police forces around the world. All of them will have some form of command and control system. Why does the Met need a bespoke solution?

Would it not make sense for there to be some form of standard?

Feds tell court: Apple 'deliberately raised technological barriers' to thwart iPhone warrant

localzuk Silver badge

Re: If code is free speech then Apple can't tell developer what to write...

It isn't "free speech" that's the issue here. Its "compelled speech". Something that is illegal for the US government to do.

localzuk Silver badge

Re: If code is free speech then Apple can't tell developer what to write...

The person writing code for Apple doesn't own it. They are contracted to create something for Apple, and as such Apple is the one exercising their free speech. If the person doesn't wish to write it, they can quit. Apple isn't forcing anyone to write code for them.

localzuk Silver badge

Re: The mat and potatoes

You are directly related to the requirement to pay taxes. You are a party to the process.

Apple are a third party to the case. All they did was manufacture something. Are you saying that companies should always be responsible for the actions of those who use their products, and therefore are required to bend over backwards to create things for the government when demanded?

localzuk Silver badge

Re: The mat and potatoes

A court is limited by the laws of the land. It doesn't have carte blanche to order people or organisations to do whatever it damn well pleases.

A court should NOT have the power to compel anyone do work that they themselves wouldn't do. That is slavery, plain and simple.

If they order them to hand over evidence in a case, then sure, that is fine. But ordering them to build something for the government? No. Just no.

localzuk Silver badge

Really?

"As Apple well knows, the order does not compel it to unlock other iPhones or to give the government a universal 'master key' or 'back door'."

Do the DOJ/FBI think we're idiots? Once the software exists to do what they want, it is in fact a "master key" or "back door". All it would take is for another warrant to say "you did it for XYZ case, so the tools exist, so you can do it for this case".

Do they not have a grasp of the security concept "any exploit is a total exploit"?

FBI says NY judge went too far in ruling the FBI went too far in forcing Apple to unlock iPhone

localzuk Silver badge

How can a government have this right?

How can a government have the right to order a company to do work for them? I can understand if it were the case that Apple had this feature and version of iOS ready and working and the government were demanding access to that ready made tool, but if it doesn't exist, how can they be forced to do work for them?

Surely that on its own would be a form of slavery?

BBC telly tax drops onto telly-free households. Cough up, iPlayer fans

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Jim'll fix it and you

@Grease Monkey, the law agrees with him entirely.

The law is that you must have a license if you have a device that can receive live broadcast television, and is set up to do so. So, if you don't have an aerial plugged in and/or the TV isn't tuned then your TV is not set up to do so.

I have a TV. I don't have an aerial. I don't need a license. TVL agrees with me on this.

GDS gets it in the neck from MPs over Rural Payments Agency farce

localzuk Silver badge

Re: Internal IT

Realistically, GDS could be a great resource for moving government to the digital age, but they've been badly implemented.

Instead of giving them control of things, would it not be better to have them work as a co-ordinator of developers? So DEFRA need a new IT system, they say what they need it to do and GDS would then assign a team to the job based on an assessment of its technical needs, under DEFRA's control, with the rest of GDS available for advice and specialist technical requirements. That way, DEFRA is in control of the project rather than people that, quite frankly, have no idea about the project?

Photographer hassled by Port of Tyne for filming a sign on a wall

localzuk Silver badge

Re: @unwarranted irrelevance: In other words...

Legally? Yes. There is absolutely nothing you can do to stop someone on a public highway taking a photo of your property front. I would have no qualms about someone doing this either.