* Posts by Colin Millar

1241 publicly visible posts • joined 7 Jun 2007

Fujitsu CTO: Flash is just a stopgap

Colin Millar

Not comparing like with like

Archival permanence of digital files is not an issue of media but of accurate data replication and backup of the original data source.

Photographic negatives are a unique item which cannot be copied to other media without some degree of data loss.

Anonymous hacks US gov contractor, airs dirty laundry

Colin Millar
Happy

9 out of 10 for effort

You just need to add some random capitalised words and a few more rambling, contradictory sentences along the same lines and you will have passed Conspiracy Theory 101.

Adobe outs un-Flash web animation tool

Colin Millar
Holmes

It will be free?

I should think so - it doesn't actually do anything.

If you can write html you can do any of that stuff without some Adobe tool getting in your way and then ending up with files a hundred times larger than they need to be cos of all the pseudo-proprietary crap and tons and tons of standard generic code specifying default values they will bung in just to start with.

If it ends up being only as bad as MSWord doc>html tool I would be very surprised.

Hopefully HTML5 will signal the beginning of the end for Flash - now lets get PDF firmly in the sights.

BT on site-blocking: Every case will need a court order

Colin Millar

What an irrelevant waste of time

Looks like the lawyers all got paid and nothing changed.

If a UK court tells BT to do something they will do it - great - what's new?

Whatever BT does or doesn't think about this hardly matters - ISPs have continually tried to dodge any sort of responsibility for anything and if they end up inside some complex, expensive and unsuitable legal/regulatory system it's their own stupid fault (although we will all end up paying for that).

And why do the rights associations think this sort of move is of any use at all? Their current business model is based on a monopolistic approach which every other economic sector has written off as failed. They need to move into the 20th Century (or even the 19th would do). Their economic and trading strategy is pretty much straight out of the British East India Company handbook.

It's official: IE users are dumb as a bag of hammers

Colin Millar
Boffin

No correllation for higher IQ/browser shown either

Not in the way this is being interpreted by some on here

The real correllation is ONLY that people with lower IQs ("individuals on the lower side of the IQ scale ") are more likely to be using ie - NOT that people with higher IQs are likely to be using something else.

Anyone who jumped to such a conslusion based on no evidence whatsoever is as dumb as a bag of hammers.

News leech loses appeal on High Court copyright case

Colin Millar
FAIL

@ TV

Nah - I can't imagine the BBC or ITV bothering to comply with all that copyright protection malarkey.

Colin Millar

@ Not good

You are missing the point.

A headline is not a fragment - it is an entire element that is created completely as a single entity.

Further - even if it was a quote frrom a larger element that would still be copyright protected, and rightly so, except for fair use purposes. There is nothing about headline scraping that falls within any definition of fair use (i.e. criticism, comparison, exemplar).

No need to get the vapours about setting precedents as the judgement itself is very narrow in scope and, quite properly, addresses itself to the particular circumstances of the case and makes it clear that it doesn't apply to individuals

The webscrapers in this case were using the outcome of other people's creative processes to gain a commercial benefit to themselves. if the web is ever going to emerge from its own primordial ooze and become something worthwhile then it needs to protect the rights of people who add value and not those who simply leech off of everyone else.

Higgs Boson hiding place narrows

Colin Millar
Megaphone

Hiding place narrows?

My guess is it's in Pakistan next door to where they found Osama.

@Destroy all monsters

"Not only were the data processed and calibrated in no time; they were also validated and analyzed basically overnight."

So - plenty of scope for backtracking built-in - that's the way I like my analysis - not too definite

Ofcom in screeching U-turn on BSkyB, begins probe

Colin Millar
Mushroom

Another rat scurries for cover

What is most telling about this stuff is the piddling amounts it appears to cost to buy the British establishment. Its embarrassing. I can just see the Feebs having a right laugh when the do their FCPA investigation - "Call that corruption? - No wonder none of you can afford proper dentists"

Chinese lecturer demands his students acquire iPads

Colin Millar
Facepalm

Sadly he is right

Employment in financial services does require a complete submission of substance to perception so you may as well start early

Four illegal ways to sort out the Euro finance crisis

Colin Millar
Thumb Up

@ PT - and unlike the other illegal options

It will be run mostly by bona fide criminals

But hey - thats what politicians do best - ignore reality until it threatens to swamp them and then declare war on it.

World+Dog to favour dual-core laptops through 2014

Colin Millar
Pirate

The death of the laptop

Is not a certainty - it's one of the most succesful form factors ever and looks set to continue for some time yet.

The Cloud doesn't even know what it is yet and has a long way to go before some thin client/cloud setup is even a practical solution for day to day laptop replacement never mind a marketable alternative.

The real need for quad core has to be marginal or non-existent for most laptop users given the lack of current software than can actually take advantage. The practicality of using the power of a quad in most laptops likewise doesn't pan out and you could probably shorten the life span of the unit with the extra heat which is a significant factor in the laptop form.

However, if the price differential falls (which it always does) then the shift to quad is as inevitable as the shift to dual.

Microsoft COO: Our greatest enemy is old Windows

Colin Millar
Facepalm

Speadsheet size limitations removed

Easy - use a proper data solution instead of graph paper on a screen

Most Adobe Reader installs are out of date

Colin Millar
WTF?

Must be a record

6 posts in and someone has come up with a reason why Acrobat being crap is MS fault

I thought acrobat was crap because adobe can't build software

The only decent products they ever had came out of buying Macromedia

Heat sink breakthrough threatens ventblockers

Colin Millar
FAIL

@Fried Mice

RTFA - or even just RTF headline

It is a heatsink that spins

If it stops spinning it will be a heatsink that doesn't spin

Colin Millar

TEC - It works

But not very well - almost anything is better than a peltier - about the only use they have in computers is no space, no noise environments.

Colin Millar
Thumb Up

Back to basics

Surface area and temperature differential is still all that is involved.

Bringing more hot surface area into contact with cooler air.

Seems to me that this device gets its efficiencies from higher speed airflow which improves the differential.

Be interesting to see the actual for energy usage (with some proper controls).

Noise presumably won't be that much of an issue as this is currently a long way from the domestic market.

I could see a domestic application using a slower rotating heatsink passing through an air flow - the major price there would be space.

Of course with space to trade in a domestic box you could always increase the heat sink surface area by using both sides of the mobo

News Corp kills BSkyB bid amid 'difficult climate'

Colin Millar

FCPA

Be interesting to see if that gets followed up - that's a long scrutiny process.

5-10 years in the sunlight that an outfit like NI might not find very comfortable.

Wikileaks loses briefly-open Icelandic payment channel

Colin Millar

Maybe

St Julian should go to the States and lodge a legal challenge?

MS to WinXP diehards: Just under 3 more years' support

Colin Millar
Boffin

Security reliant on the OS?

Anyone who relies on their OS for security is insane.

Colin Millar

"At that point you will need to upgrade machines"

So leave it to that point and not before - in fact - do a cost benefit on all the options and see if you can do without the new add-on.

MS point about time to replace something that is good enough with something that is better is not going to chime with how many businesses are feeling right now - in fact "good enough" would be a luxury to a lot of businesses who work with not quite good enough equipment and software because they can't afford even "good enough" never mind being amongst the aspirational acquirers of the latest and greatest.

'Being cyber-stalked is as bad as being raped, or in a war'

Colin Millar
Boffin

"frustrated with the lack of help and support"

Poor dears - here's some help:

Turn the phone off

Will News of the Screws reappear as Sunday.co.uk?

Colin Millar
Big Brother

Is it just me?

Or is Dave looking a bit pale?

Having been pushed into an inquiry and then pushed into starting it before hell freezes over and now saying that BskyB decision will be delayed I think he might be getting a bit worried at how much further Rupe will allow this to run before venting his displeasure in some way.

Big Brother - now outsourced to people who get their kicks rummaging through your underwear

NHS told: freeze all Microsoft spend

Colin Millar
Big Brother

Just goes to show

You CAN fool all of the people all of the time - all you need is a government that is totally opposed to any form of localism or decentralisation.

Big Brother can't be arsed watching you today - please video yourselves for the next 24 hours and hand in the recordings at your nearest police station.

90% of visitors declined ICO website's opt-out cookie

Colin Millar
Boffin

Building a profile from sessions

If you can do this then you ain't using session cookies.

Does it pay to be bad? Silver Lake's Skype sale fine print

Colin Millar

They were only playing leapfrog

(to the tune of John Brown's body)

One rapacious money grabbing corporate type jumped right over an other rapacious money grabbing corporate type's back.

Mosman Council Website copied by Anonymous

Colin Millar
Mushroom

OK - someone with a computer objects so lets smash things up a lot

A bunch of people stand up publicly and ask other people to vote for them. The one's that get voted for to do stuff on behalf of their community do so by taking decisions in public which can be challenged through appeals processes and judicial processes (again - in public and accountable). If the people that get voted for take decisions that piss off their community they can be not voted for next time round.

Now, in the real world we all know that there's lots of stuff that makes this elected representative system less than perfect.

However, whatever its flaws, replacing it with a bunch of anonymous, unaccountables who may or may not have any actual connection to the community affected has got to be about the dumbest suggestion I have ever seen from a commentard on these boards.

And as any regular knows, the standard around here isn't exactly high.

You have to have standards – or do you?

Colin Millar
Megaphone

I fought the avalanche

............and the avalanche won.

Standard methodologies are just that - standard - the terminology doesn't suggest mandatory and indeed suggests non-universal by definition.

There is no point at which standards become mandatory - the two concepts are utterly alien to each other. The standard way of doing things may become the legal way of doing things but it is false logic to see the latter as an extension of the former.

Galileo 'can deploy 24 satellites with existing funding'

Colin Millar
Flame

Really

It makes it worth 4.8bn?

In the middle of a massive recession where whole countries are collapsing into economic ruin it's worth it so that you don't lose your precious GPS signal?

And where is the money coming from - oh yeah - the agriculture budget - not that food prices have been spiking recently or anything.

I am sure there's loads of Greek people at this very moment cheering at the prospect of a more accurate satnav.

ITU Gen Sec: Why not speaking English can be a virtue

Colin Millar
Big Brother

Who needs to wait a decade

We have the answers to his questions already

what constitutes a crime? - whatever Uncle Sam says

and what should happen to anyone committing one? - see above

Bitcoin collapses on malicious trade

Colin Millar
Holmes

Show the dog a bone

Derivative Is the model they are aiming for but they haven't worked out what their angle is so they are not attracting the scale needed to provide stability. They need to tell the punters what the bet is and get them to the table in large numbers.

They need to have a market thousands of times larger than any event which can be trigerred by an individual in the market or they will never be stable. It doesn't matter whether or not the event was malicious - a market shouldn't have to make that distinction - in fact it isn't a market if it is capable of making that distinction.

Aunty squirts serendipity into TV apps

Colin Millar
Boffin

wishful thinking?

The second TV in homes is still a TV - by a truly massive degree.

His figures really only mean that fondelslabs are installing iPlayer at a greater rate than PCs - which is hardly surprising given that it is one of the core reasons for buying the things.

Kindle Store awash with auto-generated crap 'books'

Colin Millar
Coat

auto-generated crapbooks

Its gardly amazons fault - WH Smith have been selling Tom Clancy and John Grisham for years

Meerkats face financial regulation

Colin Millar
Thumb Down

Going after the small fish

And letting the real sharks continue rob us blind.

Endowment mortgages

Payment protection insurance

Arbitrary bank charges

Small print designed purely to provide denial of claims

Financial regulation authorities have happily sat back and ignored (and even endorsed) these scams for years. Financial services companies rely on jargon and opaque terms and conditions to hoodwink their victims so they want to see the comparison sites shut down.

"Terms and conditions of insurance policies are often too complicated to expect customers to disclose all the relevant information to the insurer, and to ensure that they have bought an appropriate policy, the regulator warned."

Don't ever make the mistake of thinking that FSA is a consumer protection body - its purpose is to promote confidence in the UK financial services sector and it does this by applying liberal amounts of lipstick.

Apple iCloud: Steve Jobs' own private internet

Colin Millar
Thumb Up

&Cheese

"Thin clients have their place" - Absolutely - and that place is in a skip

Online tools to 'end the scandal of empty homes'

Colin Millar
Badgers

Another silver bullet

Identifying empty properties has never been that difficult.

Identifying areas of housing need - ditto

The difficulties in returning empty homes to use is not an inability to identify them.

Generally the problems are

a) the completely distorted housing and property market

b) property developers and their lawyers

c) the expectation amongst (b) that after a bit of a recession the nature of (a) will reassert itself early in the recovery

d) a complete lack of any real powers for local authorities to do anything about any of it

Still - I bet it all looks pretty cool with all those overlays and GIS tagging. Maybe it could get a layer in Google Earth.

Cabinet Office shakes up PSN

Colin Millar
Big Brother

Jeff Parris - what a joker

" individual (local) authorities could be influential in determining the services to be offered"

I like that "could" just slipped casually in there - translation "could, if hell freezes over,

Looks like this is just a continuing exercise in lining up ducks anyway.

Big brother would be watching you but he's got some pencils to sharpen right now.

EU belatedly cancels funding for Symbian OS

Colin Millar
Coat

Not the title

Where's the Symbionese Liberation Army when you need em?

BT cheerfully admits snooping on customer LANs

Colin Millar
Boffin

What's all this second router crap?

Do some people just like buying cable?

If you have 1 trusted router and 1 untrusted router put the trusted router on your line and the untrusted router on ebay.

UK.gov 'falls short' of legal obligation to enforce EC cookies Directive

Colin Millar
FAIL

So

A website can comply with the cookie law by relying on browser settings?

But you can't regulate browsers to make sure they offer the necessary functionality.

So how this going to work - maybe websites will refuse to work with non-defined browsers - remember those bad-old days "You need {browser} to view this website"

Maybe the EU will introduce some law requiring browser standardisation - that should be fun to watch.

Gadgets give granny disease to kids

Colin Millar
Boffin

The stupid - it hurts

That's all

Euro report slates wireless comms, recommends smoke and mirrors

Colin Millar
Alert

Off the scale!!!

Thye ought to ship that report (and the rest of the EU) down the road to the LHC to see how much concentrated stupid it takes to create a black hole.

€1bn handout from the EU targets ambient nagware and robot pets

Colin Millar

Quick mavis

Pass me the UKIP membership form.

Such an astounding gulf between the EU organisation and its citizens is quite depressing really. We are used to patronising politicians telling us that we reject their policies because we don't understand them. We accept that Government will always waste public money on monolithic projects designed to line up their soldiers more neatly. We know that their idea of democratic engagement is them telling us about jam tomorrow and us just getting on with the constant upheavals of education, social services, health care, transport etc.

But a billion being blown on stuff like this? At this particular moment in the economic life of our plant?

Their contempt for their supposed citizens grows clearer by the day.

Journos 'risk charges' for covering Parliamentary debates

Colin Millar

Bill of Rights 1689

Has nothing to do with individuals though - just the rights of the other 2 estates which was converted to parliamentarians by reason of their provenance as clergymen and nobles - comoners never got a look in.

The point at issue isn't parliamentary privilege - it is a misapplication of a public interest test which is creating out of nothing a de-facto judicial oversight of the press.

@Graham Marsden

I am not referring to a behavioural norm - if there is such a thing.

We shouldn't even be considering the public interest when someone publishes something UNLESS someone is claiming that it is in the public interest to suppress the information. The press should not have to show a public interest in publishing anything - it should be for the censors to show the damage to the public interest - that is the norm that I am talking about.

In other words the question should be "Why should we not allow publication?" but the question being posed is "Why should we allow publication?" - a presumption of suppression that runs directly counter to the principle of freedom of expression.

Colin Millar

Missing the point

A public interest test should be applied when one is planning to step away from the norm.

We don't have a bill of rights in the UK and the pols and judges tell us there is no need because we live in a permissive society (i.e. you can do anything you are not specifically prohibited from doing). If this is true the rule should be that anyone has the right to publish anything unless it can be shown that it is in the public interest to suppress.

What the judges are saying is that you must show that it is in the public interest to publish.

Right now they are basing this on some interpretation of the adoption of the Human Rights Act and applying it to individuals but we have a history (and indeed a common law) which allows corporations to be treated as individuals.

See where this is going yet?

Media, industry and cops baffled as Qld Police return hack’s iPad

Colin Millar

Room for some nuance

Yeah - we used to have that - the nuance was called intent and it used to appear in all good laws.

Problem is zero-tolerance makes for better sound-bites while completely failing to address the actual problems.

And as we all know - no-one gets elected these days by prioritising substance over style.

Super-injunctions 'unfair' cos of Twitter gossip, says Cameron

Colin Millar
Big Brother

Strange way to use public interest

I would have thought that the courts are using it the wrong way round. Usually you use a public interest test to see if you should stray from the normal course of action.

So I am assuming that the judges are saying that our current laws establish a norm which is to suppress information.

Looks like judges and politicians using freedom of expression in a game of handbags at twenty paces.

Google gets ready to crush quote-comparison websites

Colin Millar

@fridaynightsmoke

Not really - What you get is their price for pretty much a fixed product - I was looking for some element of bidding against each other in the mix and a shift in emphasis from supply push to demand pull.

Maybe car insurance isn't the best example because it is one of the more transparent financial products but one of the reasons why the financial services industry was allowed to blow up the world was that very few people understood the products they were buying.

IT suppliers fear new GP consortia will 'create difficulties'

Colin Millar
Grenade

Why blame GP commissioning?

GP commissioning won't make a hoot of difference to the strategy free zone that NHSIT has been for some decades now.

Still - at least when the GPC model utterly fails and we get to where we are really aimed at the IT industry will have some nice insurance companies and accountancy consultants to deal with - should be a bit more comfy for them.

Government hires Guardianista as digital chief

Colin Millar
Big Brother

Needed

- a strategy for talking to the middle classes.

We haven't needed one of those since the vote was extended beyond the landed gentry.

Can whoever has reversed the direction of time please stop now - its not funny anymore.