* Posts by dotdavid

1712 publicly visible posts • joined 28 Jul 2010

Why Android houses should give Google the 'fork you'

dotdavid
WTF?

What?

"Try as they might, they can't seem to generate sufficient "wow" with their hardware/Android combinations to muster much brand loyalty and, in return, chunkier profit margins."

Oh please. Samsung, LG and the like can't even manage to code a simple launcher replacement, what makes you think they'd be capable of forking Android and doing a good job of it? Amazon might succeed with their fork but only in using Android as a locked-down but quite-functional firmware replacement - not as a credible mobile OS.

Like it or not, Google do a lot of the heavy lifting when it comes to Android. It wouldn't make much sense for these companies to fork it now. Maybe by "Ice Cream Sandwich" when it's a credible phone *and* tablet OS it will be more forkable as a lot of the hard work will have been done, but right now I doubt it. Plus when they do fork it they need to retain compatibility with the vast number of Android apps available otherwise people will shun the fork like they shun Windows Mobile and WebOS.

Of course if Google starts throwing their weight around with Motorola things might change. I'm sure they're being watched closely. But it's a bit too early to predict the death of the Open Handset Alliance, methinks.

iRobot Roomba 780 automated vacuum cleaner

dotdavid
Boffin

Needs a revolution not evolution

Apart from the bigger bin and better battery, this doesn't seem much of an improvement on my Roomba.

Looks a bit like they *are* resting on their laurels a bit. I'd love one of these with some kind of automatic bin-emptying system (no I have no idea how that would work) - it might be a worthwhile upgrade then.

And they really should do something about the price. As others have said you can get more capable competitors for less now.

Dole-office civil servants allowed Twitter but no Facebook

dotdavid
FAIL

Trust your employees...

...not to slack off. After all, blocking Facebook isn't going to block a determined slacker.

There's always El Reg's forums for example... er...

Rubbing an iPhone on your face won't cure acne - FTC

dotdavid

Mosquito repellers

Sounds similar to those apps that claim to repel mosquitos using ultrasound, except there's plenty of free apps for people not stupid enough to pay good money for that sort of unproven pseudo-science.

No idea whether it worked on the mosquitos, but it certainly repelled my cats.

Al Gore wants to borrow your Facebook and Twitter accounts

dotdavid
FAIL

Friends who become spambots for Gore...

...will soon become ex-Friends methinks.

Oracle rejects Google's man for mediation

dotdavid
Joke

Does Google really need *that* big a shot?

...after all, it's unlikely to have to fork out too much for Oracle's groundless IP-trollery.

*ducks*

Three complains to Brussels over NFC exclusion

dotdavid
Facepalm

Operators

The operators will screw this up, just like they seem to screw everything else up.

I can see either one of the payment companies succeeding, or maybe Google. But not an operator.

Amazon solves wait-at-home-for-deliveries problem

dotdavid
Unhappy

Hmm

I think the lockers would need to be located in (open) shops and other businesses to avoid theft and vandalism. As my local post office at least tends to be shut most of the time, it's less than ideal for this.

Court bans man called Peter from calling himself Peter

dotdavid
Facepalm

"not to participate in any internet relay action"

Am I the only one that mentally put a "hot" in that sentence? Am I? Anyone?

Oh ok then.

Dixons drops Motorola Xoom price... again

dotdavid

Xoom

Remember the EU Xoom has the added problem of being nothing like the US Xoom, in that the software is out of date and probably will always be. "Avoid" has been my advice to those that ask me.

I still think the Transformer is the best "premium" Android tablet option. As for a budget one, you can get a refurbished Vega for £140 from Dixon's ebay outlet and shove an unofficial Honeycomb build on it.

MySociety marshals griping commuters to fix UK transport

dotdavid
Unhappy

Transport

Think it'll take more than a complaints site to fix my transport. First Crap Con, I'm looking at you...

Last ever batch of TouchPads isn't coming to Blighty

dotdavid

Cost

They've seen they can get more money for completed tablets (even at discounted prices) than for the individual components, is my guess.

Tablet wars set for Apple vs Amazon head-to-head

dotdavid

I dunno

I'm waiting with bated breath to see what the AndyPad people release tomorrow. I don't mind a dodgy screen for sub-£200 as long as it's reasonably responsive - battery life is more of a concern for me as I'd want it to last all day with quite intensive use, and it's another failing of these cheap nasty Android tabs.

Plus I assume that component cost is for a 10" screen. I suspect Amazon might not necessarily limit themselves to that - a smaller screen would be fine for a tablet/e-reader combo and would cost less.

Toshiba gen-three tablet set for IFA intro

dotdavid
Trollface

Excite?

More like the Toshiba Yawn.

"Hmmm our tablets aren't doing so well... I wonder why. Must be because they're *NOT THIN ENOUGH*! Eureka! Back to the drawing board lads!"

DARPA wants a working manned starship for $500k

dotdavid

Resources

I don't think it takes *that* much.

AFAIK (and I'm not at all sciency) the biggest cost of space is getting out of the Earth's gravity well. Presumably most of the distance to Alpha Centurai is covered with very little effort, it will just take a long time to get there.

Paper Camera

dotdavid
Unhappy

Absolutely

I also feel that a developer can't be worth much if they don't take the time to learn the platform well enough to implement App2SD support. If they can't even get that right, why am I supposed to expect they get more difficult things like battery usage right?

Another commentard said this was originally an IOS app. Half-assed port perhaps? It would explain the lack of support for Android-specific features like App2SD.

Unfortunately on Android we're getting more and more half-assed IOS ports (*cough*linkedin*cough*)...

HP Pre 3 punters peeved as expected price cut is a no show

dotdavid
Facepalm

HP

HP probably thought "ah, no need to discount the Pre3 now, we had *loads* of sales of that tablet thingy we sell" completely forgetting that those sales were driven by the price cut and the price cut only.

What they should be trying to do is working out how to sell these things cheaper, as they obviously do sell at lower price points.

Google's anonymity ban defied by Thomas Jefferson

dotdavid
FAIL

Google making a meal of things

I don't understand why they can't require full names, but then have a field for a nickname and have a setting that means you only show your nickname to people. Then they have your real name to do, er, no evil with, but the average punter is relatively happy as they can continue to feel nice and anonymous behind a pseudonym.

Hell, they even already have the nickname field in Google Profiles *now*.

Why are they making things so difficult for themselves.

HP's UK PC boss: We're going nowhere

dotdavid
Joke

Ahah!

"We are now working on ensuring everyone that owns a webOS device has a positive experience"

So *they're* the source of the recent leaks of Android for the TouchPad.

I joke... I joke...

dotdavid
Thumb Up

Cheap Tech

"Same with netbooks. They were popular when they were cheap and cheerful small Linux notebooks. Once they were specced up to run Windows 7, with a price-tag of a full laptop, they stopped being as popular. Industry insiders figured that noone wanted netbooks anymore.

To the contrary, people want cheap tech."

Sorry, your point was so good, I just wanted to quote it again.

Microsoft unveils file-move changes in Windows 8

dotdavid
Thumb Up

Obligatory XKCD

...oh you've already done it. Nevermind then.

appToyz appWheel

dotdavid

Wii Wheel

This looks a bit like my Mario Kart Wii wheel thing, I used it for all of two races before ditching it and just using the Wiimote by itself as it provided no utility.

Still, as you say, I can see this being a popular stocking filler regardless.

AlertMe network power-meter kit: Suitable for techies?

dotdavid

To elaborate

I can understand why this thing has a web interface - it's so no-one needs to faff around with dynamic DNS, DMZ's or port forwarding on their router to be able to access their data - and that's all well and good.

But £20 a year? For basically use of a (hardly complex) website?

Not to mention the fact that if they go out of business, that website goes down and you're left with useless hardware and no access to historical data, plus any privacy implications there may be.

dotdavid

Subscription

£20 a year for a web interface? Hmm, not convinced.

BBC crowdsourced mobile map: A bit quirky, but useful

dotdavid

OpenSignalMaps

Instead of fragmenting the groups of people willing to run these (inevitably battery draining) signal mapping tools, couldn't the BBC have rebranded the OpenSignalMaps application for the purposes of this survey?

At least they give a nod to the project in their write-up so perhaps more people will take part.

Myself I installed the BBC app then forgot about it, but now the results are in I'm probably going to remove it for the sake of improved battery power.

Misco reaps harvest of rage in Twitter Touchpad debacle

dotdavid
FAIL

Sold out?

Let me guess... thousands of punters heard of an imminent price drop on Tweeter, and in an effort to beat the rush bought up stock at full price in the hope that Misco would refund them the difference when the price drop came into effect...

I suspect Misco are going to have a lot of returns shortly.

Cerberus

dotdavid

Ignorance is our first line of defence

Fortunately a lot of these petty phone thieves are quite ignorant and often don't bother resetting the device.

Android provides a "device admin" role which I think prevents a normal reset (it certainly stops users simply uninstalling the app, unless they have the unlock code/password). And rooted phones have even more protection Of course you can bypass this sort of thing by reflashing or whatever, but it's another step the phone thief has to go through.

dotdavid
Thumb Up

AndroidLost

That looks good. Previously I bought SeekDroid but it doesn't play very nicely with multiple devices. I'll give AndroidLost a try instead.

Someone should make an open source one of these considering how much trust you need to place in apps of this type.

Four months' porridge for 20-minute Facebook riot page

dotdavid
FAIL

OTT

For a tasteless one-liner am I the only one who thinks this is a little excessive?

A caution, fine. Maybe even a fine. But four months in prison?

I always assumed this sort of law was to stop people who actually, well, incited this sort of behaviour - and I can't see the words "Let's start Bangor riots" posted to a private social network for 20 minutes as being a particularly effective incitement.

Facebook, Twitter: Doing better than before Google+

dotdavid
Unhappy

Disillusioned

I've been a bit disillusioned by G+ ever since the "real names" debacle started and still hasn't finished. When G+ launched there was a real feeling Google were listening, and making solid improvements. Unfortunately while the dev team seem to be much more approachable the People Who Make The Policy Decisions are still uncontactable and unaccountable.

I had hoped that Google had gotten over the lack of communication with users that they had during their Nexus One support days, but the lack of a decent justification of their real name policy has shown me that nothing much changed.

Although I must admit, Facebook are hardly better.

iPhone app tracks Android-equipped Surrey cops

dotdavid
Thumb Up

Excellent news

Now we just need an app for tracking the criminals too. Care to supply one, Huawei?

Neato Robotics XV-15 vacuum cleaner

dotdavid
Unhappy

Good in theory...

...but in practice, these robotic vacuum cleaners don't really work that well. I have a Roomba and in my experience;

1) Perhaps it's because I'm particularly slovenly or because of my two cats but you have to empty it a lot. I dunno, but having to keep a watchful eye on the little machine to make sure it hasn't filled up seems a little beside the point to me.

2) It's good for a quick sweep around but doesn't have a particularly powerful vacuum so you need to vacuum properly now and then.

3) Because of 2), and the fact that the Roomba can't do stairs, you need another vacuum cleaner. I have one of those little Dysons, initially for doing the bits the Roomba couldn't but recently I just do the lot.

4) Occasionally cat hair gets in the little cogs and you have to do a full disassembly, clean, oil and rebuild job. iRobot make it quite easy but still, I've never had to disassemble any other hoovers I've owned.

5) My Roomba lacks the LCD screen that the Neato product has, which alas means you have to look up a lot of the little warning beeps and boops it makes when things go wrong.

6) Alluded to in this article, the Roomba sometimes fails to navigate properly back to the charging point or doesn't quite sit on it right when it gets there, meaning it dies and looks a little pathetic.

7) You have to keep your place relatively tidy, as alas it lacks a human's "hoovering around crap" skills and can easily get stuck on random objects.

Because of all this I've basically stopped using the Roomba and just use my little Dyson.

I really hope the technology moves on and one day there is a robotic cleaning machine that just gets on with it. Unfortunately we're not there yet.

Networks, handset makers vie for mobile dominance

dotdavid
Flame

It was you!

"As Head of Enabling Software this was your correspondent's role at O2."

If I were you I'd be wary of admitting stuff like that to this lot. From what I remember of that era, "enabling" software was the kind of bloatware that disabled a lot of smartphones' best features.

Flame icon because the lynch mob will be using it.

Sony Ericsson outs social music smartphone

dotdavid
Megaphone

Chavs on trains

I've always thought a funny comedy show sketch would be a bunch of OAPs jumping on a train, leering at the commuters then playing Mozart very loudly on their mobile phones to the general annoyance of the rest of the travelling public.

Still I've often wondered why I get so easily annoyed by noise on my morning and evening commute. I commute on a line with a lot of tunnels and I take a stupid amount of pleasure when we go through them and some loud-mouthed fool's telephone conversation with his mate is cut off suddenly. I hope all these teens switch to Spotify streaming or similar soon so I can get a similar thrill when their hippity hop music is cut off.

Megaphone so I can shout "get off my lawn" louder.

New Apple move against Galaxy Tab on Euro front

dotdavid
Stop

Samsung are the most successful Android OEM

Latecomer Samsung may be to tablets, but Apple are picking on Samsung because they're selling the most "Android stuff" and thus pose the biggest threat to their iPad/iPhone business. Notice how as well as the tablet, Apple is also targeting the phenomenally successful Galaxy S line of phones in other lawsuits.

No, I get the impression that Apple are quite scared really and are trying anything they can to get one over on the competition. And with the next version of Android due before the end of the year things are only going to get worse for them if that's the way they continue to behave.

dotdavid
Childcatcher

Seriously, Apple...

...you're not even trying to appear non-evil are you?

At least most supervillains in film and TV have *hidden* evil schemes.

Icon because with that top hat he looks a bit like a stereotypical baddie.

Brits buy more e-books than other Euro readers

dotdavid
Holmes

Localisation?

I wonder how much this has to do with language. Maybe there are more English ebooks around. And a bigger range of titles definitely makes the whole ebook concept more attractive.

HP chief bows to Jobsian cult

dotdavid
Facepalm

HP + WebOS

HP never really knew what to do with WebOS, I think their thought process went something like this;

1) Apple is making loads of money in tablets and phones.

2) Android is doing pretty well, but each OEM is making less money. I wonder why this is?

3) Must be because Apple both own hardware and software!

4) Hey if we buy Palm we'll have hardware and software. Then we'll be just like Apple and make loads of cash!

Hopefully they'll sell WebOS to someone else. I'm guessing some of the less-successful Android OEMs will be interested, if there's any truth to the rumour that they're wary of Google now they own Motorola.

Apple augments reality, tells you where to go

dotdavid
Unhappy

Prior art

Yep, I agree - probably plenty of prior art.

But that's not really the game here.

1) Register lots of patents, even if they're of dubious legitimacy.

2) Patent office approves them or most of them.

3) Sue everyone you can that you think can't afford to fight.

4) Profit!

A lot of this prior art will have been made by small firms who could never take on Apple in court. Hell, even Google until recently was having problems.

Google+ bans real name under ‘Real Names’ policy

dotdavid
FAIL

Google's faults

Google+ is really highlighting Google's main fault - that they don't listen to their users (even users of a so-called "test" service) and are very very bad at communicating when they've made a mistake. They really need to sort this out as otherwise Google+ is quite a nice system.

As for this chap's name, how about telling Google is it "Mynameis Stilgherrian"?

HARRY POTTER CHAINED to new Sony reader

dotdavid
FAIL

EPUB

The Sony Reader may "use the industry standard EPUB format", but you can bet your bottom dollar these books will be crippled by Adobe's Digital Edition DRM scheme which will effectively lock the books to a Sony device.

Just another reason why DRM is so great.

dotdavid
Stop

So...

Do you think that purchasers of a shiny new NON-Sony ebook reader who want to read Harry Potter books will;

a) Say "oh dear, I can't read Harry Potter books on my ebook reader. I'd better wait until 2012."

b) Sell their ebook reader in disgust (or never buy it in the first place) and/or buy a Sony Reader.

c) Say "oh well, I'd better go to The Pirate Bay for my Harry Potter fix then".

It baffles me why Sony thinks the answer will be b). Even a) seems more likely to me.

Apple changed shape of Galaxy Tab in court filing

dotdavid
Devil

Evil Steve Icon

El Reg changed it to this one, as the original is "a straight rip-off of Cupertino's Steve Jobs" and they were worried that Apple's legal team would get El Reg's forums banned throughout the EU in a closed court hearing to which they were not invited to present a defence...

US breakthrough in Oz bomb hoax case

dotdavid
Unhappy

NSW

Am I the only one that keeps reading NSW as Not Suitable for Work?

People don't want tablets, they want iPads

dotdavid
Joke

iPad Sales

Judging by the number of "win an iPad" competitions there seems to be around nowadays, I wonder whether most of the sales are from companies buying them up to give away as prizes...

Google lands patent for, um, estimating shipment time

dotdavid
Thumb Up

Not sure this is a big deal

"Google loves to whine about how bogus the whole patent-protection racket is, even as they play the game to their own benefit."

Personally I don't have a problem with silly patents, until they're used to launch silly lawsuits. Google haven't done so yet, so I'll reserve judgement.

Cabinet Office allocates £1.6m for single government domain

dotdavid
Joke

alpha.gov.uk

...is a stupid domain name. As it's a site about the UK government, not about very early test versions of the UK government. it should be called gov.gov.uk or something.

Google told to delete people from search results

dotdavid

Robots.txt

"Spanish law forces the information to be included in the official gazette, Jesús Rubi, deputy director of the Spanish DPA said, according to the report.

“The law obliges us to put this info in the gazette. But I am sure that if the law was written today, lawmakers would say 'OK, publish this, but it should not be accessible by a search engine',” Rubi said."

So, er, add the gazette to robots.txt? Although granted that would only protect the information from the reputable search spiders.

Heavily-looted mobile phone barns issue 'safety first' missives to staff

dotdavid

IMEI

I always thought the IMEI could be used to bar the phone. And I suspect it would work well in this case due to the opportunist nature of the thefts.

But I was speaking to a T-Mobile store franchisee when buying the OH's mobile who said when they got thefts (surprisingly regularly, it seemed to me) usually nothing really came of it as the crims flogged the phones abroad where the IMEI's weren't blocked.

Would be nice to have some kind of international agreement. Surely the GSM association or someone could set one up?

London rioters should 'loose all benefits'

dotdavid
Holmes

Let loose

I think the benefits should be loosed into a fund to compensate riot victims ;-)

In all serious though, while I really don't like paying for these scumbags' lives, I wonder whether the loss of benefits will mean they're even more likely to commit crimes. I suspect it's a more complex issue than the petitioners have realised.

Sherlock because he's not exactly needed to identify a lot of these rioters as they post their own photos on Twitface.