* Posts by alain williams

2469 publicly visible posts • joined 29 May 2007

KDE maintainers speak on why it is worth looking beyond GNOME

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Notsomuch.

I did - it is much better than Gnome 3; but a few things still annoy me.

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Notsomuch.

Sorry, but this sort of appeal isn't going to move me away from MATE.

I have just upgraded my desktop, I was running CentOS 6 which has reached end of life after 10 years.

CentOS 8 comes with Gnome 3, Mate is not an option. Gnome 3 is, for me, unusable - so after running RedHat/Centos since 1995 I have switched to Debian + Mate. A few teething issues, but works well.

Hopefully I will soon have a nice stable environment that I will not need to fiddle with for another decade.

Panic in the mailroom: The perils of an operating system too smart for its own good

alain williams Silver badge

50 years ago ...

you could call the company in question, speak to a real, live human being who could probably deal with it.

Today: you probably can't find a 'phone number, if you do you wait for ages listening to crap music and end up speaking to some inane bot - or if you are really lucky someone in Mumbai who has not got a script to deal with your problem.

Progress :-(

New lawsuit: Why do Android phones mysteriously exchange 260MB a month with Google via cellular data when they're not even in use?

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Don't assume malice here

Maybe the El Reg reporter should have asked Google for information by means of a Subject Access Request - Google has to respond, as a matter of law.

If the user has not agreed to this data to be transferred out of the EU then that is another breach - depending on T&Cs agreed.

What if someone buys a 'phone and uses it as one - ie does not agree to T&Cs for play store, etc, as well - does the data still go ?

Brit Conservative Party used 10 million people's names to derive their country of origin, ethnicity and religion according to ICO report

alain williams Silver badge

So what did they think of Boris ?

It says here that Boris is Bulgarian or Russian so will he be under special surveillance?

Ericsson warns investors: This Biden fellow coming into the White House may look to resolve China trade dispute...

alain williams Silver badge

It is more than a trade war

There are aspects of world political dominance. China has become an economic super power, that has given it the clout to throw political weight around and worry less about the consequences, think: Hong Kong, Uighurs Muslims, actions against Taiwan, ... There is a strong direction of travel and we need to look at where that will go to in 20, 50, 100 years time.

I know that the USA has bullied as well, but it is politically much freer than China. You can say things in front of the White House that would have you removed if you said similar in Tiananmen Square.

Decisions like this have many more facets than first meet the eye.

Your Microsoft reseller can now predict when you’re ready to buy more stuff or dump Redmond

alain williams Silver badge

Is this part of the purpose of telemetry ?

"Your customer is doing has installed xxx so sell them Microsoft xxx-enterprise".

Lots of things to be gleaned by looking at what is installed on a machine, even more by looking at web browser logs ... Who knows what they take as the telemetry information is encrypted before being sent to Redmond and there is not a tool that the user can use to decode it.

Apple cracks down on iOS terminal apps because they can download code

alain williams Silver badge

Who owns the frigging machines ?

Apple or the person who bought it ?

You can forget your fancy ERP customisations because that's not how it works in the cloud, SAP's Oliver Betz tells users

alain williams Silver badge

Try the Open Source route

There are Open Source ERP systems. Take a look, do they do enough of what you need ? If so: write the bits that are missing (ie customise) and move over.

Yes: it will cost you, but it costs millions to migrate to SAP and then pay annual license fees - which costs more.

No support ? Work with others who use your chosen ERP to your mutual benefit. Push up to github/where-ever the code that you write: others will use it (if it is any good) and fix bugs and add features - which is to your benefit.

Some IT directors will refuse for the same reasons that they bought IBM & Microsoft.

BBC makes switch to AWS, serverless for new website architecture, observers grumble about the HTML

alain williams Silver badge

Server side rendering is as it should be

The current trend of building the page with javascript in the browser is wrong. It just complicates things for the browser and means that the browser has to run javascript from all manner of places.

Server side rendering means that for the browser it is KISS.

Alibaba trying to take China’s Singles Day shopping frenzy global to make Bezos & Co look like sales small fry

alain williams Silver badge

Re: a scam

An example of how the marketing bods have succeeded in persuading many to spend money in meaningless ways, often by hijacking some event and making it seem that the only "proper" way of doing it was by spending lots of money. Other examples include: black Friday; Valentine's day; mother's/father's day, ...

I am not churlish: I went to see my mum, often taking a plant for her garden; she appreciated that far more than over priced cut flowers.

Did you know that the 'tradition' of a man giving his girl a diamond engagement ring is the result of a 1930's De Beers marketing campaign. How impressionable we are!

Google's plan to make User-Agent string even less useful breaks our device detection tech, says NetMarketShare

alain williams Silver badge

Re: We expect this change to improve compatibility...

The browser should, rather than identifying itself, identify the most recent version of the standard(s) with which it is fully compliant.

It does not work like that.

To start with browsers have to implement many standards that are independent of each other and churn out new versions at their own pace: HTML, CSS, Javascript, image formats, network protocols, ...

Next: each of these new standards 'version' come up with many new features or varying difficulty. Eg look at Javascript. Should the browser wait until they are all implemented before making a new release ? No: they will come out with them as they are ready.

It is much more complicated than meets the eye.

alain williams Silver badge

Re: We expect this change to improve compatibility...

Trouble is which version of the standards ... 'the standard' is not so meaningful in a world where they are continually evolving and browsers implement features in different orders over time. See https://caniuse.com/

Listing all of the features supported (maybe partially) is hard as there are so many of them. So, if you are at the bleeding edge browser+version+browscap-database might be what you have to do -- or resort to javascript magic.

Screen/viewport size ... should not be needed, CSS can handle that.

If the browser lies: well, in theory, if things go wrong the will blame the browser - in practice the user will blame the web site.

Marriott fined £0.05 for each of the 339 million hotel guests whose data crooks were stealing for four years

alain williams Silver badge

To stop it happening again ...

which should be one of the ICO's aims, should they not have insisted that Marriott be audited by an independent White Hat type organisation for 10 years ? Hopefully the WH types would kick up a fuss at poor/sloppy practice and make them fix it.

I do not know if the ICO has the power to order this, if not then time to get a quick bill through parliament.

Can we stop megacorps from using and abusing our data? That ship has sailed, ex-NSA lawyer argues in new book

alain williams Silver badge

"cumbersome to read, difficult to understand"

These privacy policies are obscure by design and so long that most give up reading them - the companies that have them do not want people to understand them.

There needs to be an agreement written to be easy to read and given aka kite mark which shows that it is reasonable, fair, etc. There should be several varients to cover different sorts of relationship and be capable of having a schedule attachment to cover things like "how many days to deliver", "postage", etc.

Much like the British on holiday, NHS COVID-19 app refuses to work with phones using unsupported languages

alain williams Silver badge

Surely you just press buttons harder ?

Is that not what the typical Brit does when in Costa del something ? It usually seems to work; but the words for wine & beer are usually well understood.

Oh, wait: we are talking about non English speakers ... so, these people know that volume in not a key to universal understanding - apologies!

NASA trying to stuff excess baggage into OSIRIS-REx after too-successful asteroid scoop

alain williams Silver badge

Why only 2 oz ?

Can anyone enlighten me as to why NASA would send an 880 kg space craft on a 7 year mission and only bring back 2.1 oz ? Would it really make much difference to the machine to have a bigger suitcase and so be able to give a sample to more labs when it gets back ?

Maybe take samples from different places on Bennu.

'This was bigger than GNOME and bigger than just this case.' GNOME Foundation exec director talks patent trolls and much, much more

alain williams Silver badge

Damages

I was going to add "get damages from the patent troll". A great idea, but it would mean that a large, well funded corporate with expensive lawyers would use the threat of damages as a way of blasting small patent holders into giving them free use of what is patented. It is hard enough as it is for the small guy to get the corporates to play by the rules without giving them another cannon.

alain williams Silver badge

Re: I'm just rebuilding my desktop ...

I want a stable system. I put a lot of work into getting it just as I want, then get on with other things.

I will have an instance of Fedora running as a virtual machine.

@MacroRodent I did consider Mint (which I run on a laptop) but its installer had problems with me wanting LVM over RAID-1.

Time waste: with 2 x 4TB disks I should have used gpt partitioning & EFI - but naff firmware refused to boot. I know that I got it right as it worked under qemu :-(

alain williams Silver badge

I'm just rebuilding my desktop ...

I have been running RedHat or Centos since about 1995, currently on CentOS 6 - which is dropping out of support soon. CentOS 8 would have been the natural upgrade but it comes with Gnome 3 - which is, as far as I am concerned, unusable. Mate (AKA Gone 2) is not available, XFCE doesn't quite make it; Fedora - I don't want to have to upgrade every year; so I am installing Debian - Mate is an option.

Love Minecraft: Java? You'll have to learn to love your Microsoft account as well – it will be required next year

alain williams Silver badge

What do you need to tell ...

to open an account ? If it is username & email address then meh [burner emails are easy], but name, address, would get me worried; credit card info would ring warning bells.

They seem to want to charge 10c but only for those under 13 years. Hmmm

Another Chromium browser for Linux? Microsoft Edge arrives in preview form, no love for Arm yet

alain williams Silver badge

What is the advanage to Microsoft ?

What local information does it 'leak' back to Redmond ?

I suppose that it might be a good test: if they can get a browser working on Linux then they will have cleaned up many components needed to get other ported to Linux as well.

Linux 5.10 to make Year 2038 problem the Year 2486 problem

alain williams Silver badge

Fish in 2486

If we are not careful there will be few fish left [due to over fishing and climate change] and most of them small, not big!

'Facebook simply would not exist today if not for Bletchley Park,' says social network – but don't hold that against it

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Facebook simply would not exist today if not for Bletchley Park

The traffic analysis was done by Gordon Welchman who also worked at Bletchley Park.

Morgan Stanley hit with $60m penalty for failing to properly decommission old kit hosting 'wealth management' data

alain williams Silver badge

ISO 9000

I'll wager that Morgan Stanley is ISO 9000 "compliant", but this is often a box ticking exercise that means jack all if nobody bothers -- except when it is certification time.

California outlaws wording, webpage buttons designed to hoodwink people into handing over their personal data

alain williams Silver badge

Re: "how does that even work?"

So it is broken from the outset. It should be opt in - ie user data only once the web site has got permission.

I suspect that we will see games played along the lines of "Last week you opted out for purposes x, y, z. This week we are doing a, b, c and you need to opt out of that separately."

Remember the days when signs were signs and operating systems didn't need constant patching?

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Why Windows?

This is a perfect use for a Raspberry Pi, glue it to the back of the display.

Global Privacy Control emerges as latest attempt to let netizens choose whether they want to be tracked online

alain williams Silver badge

Will this just not make Google richer ?

This stops "sharing or selling of personal data", it does not stop use of data that has been collated by looking at & collating who does what on many, many web sites.

They will just say "we track everybody so we understand everything about everybody. GPC means that we cannot tell you anything, but we have new services that we can sell you that: do anything on your behalf & so let you do almost anything to anybody. So you will reap benefits of all our tracking of everybody (and we get lots more $$)" ?

If I visit a web site I kind of understand that they will learn something about me from that visit. What I do not want is:

* data from the many web sites that I visit collated to draw up a profile about me.

* the use of spooky/subversive techniques (more that just cookies) to identify me, eg abuse of ETags.

Maybe I do not understand but I think that this is naive and will not be much more effective than DNT ...

Selling hardware on a pay-per-use or subscription model is a 'lie' created by marketing bods

alain williams Silver badge

A big problem with opex ...

is that you need to be able to continue to service the on-going cost. This is especially painful when your income suddenly drops - maybe due to a certain virus. If you have bought the hardware outright then no one can take it away because you stop paying them. OK you do need to pay when something breaks, but that does not need to be who you bought it from (unless you bought a John Deere tractor).

Yes: capex means that you need to be able to stump up the cash when you buy it, this can be especially hard for a new/growing org.

Email-spamming COVID profiteers deleted database with 'key evidence' when UK watchdog came knocking

alain williams Silver badge

ICO seems to have grown some teeth recently

Long may this continue.

I don't know if it will start to deal with some of the evil ones who track us from web site to web site when we have explicitly set Do Not Track in our web browser. It would be nice, but I don't know what legal basis it could use.

Heads up: From 2022, all new top-end Arm Cortex-A CPU cores for phones, slabtops will be 64-bit-only, snub 32-bit

alain williams Silver badge

Presumably also less power usage ...

No 32 bit instructions so less silicon. Less silicon so less power needed.

Big Tech to face its Ma Bell moment? US House Dems demand break-up of 'monopolists' Apple, Amazon, Facebook, Google

alain williams Silver badge

If the orange one is re-elected ...

this report will sink beneath the waves

Fujitsu gets ready to eat its own dogfood as company-wide digital transformation project kicks off

alain williams Silver badge

"customers' best partner in digital transformation,

This means that customers will need to change how they deal with Fujitsu to fit in with the new SAP \w ERP system.

Suppliers will be similarly afflicted.

And you thought Fuzzilli was a pasta... Google offers up $50k in cloud credits to fuzz the hell out of JavaScript engines

alain williams Silver badge

Javascript security flaws ...

You could start by pointing out that loading any javascript from google-analytics.com results is a loss of privacy about the person who is web browsing.

Tokyo Stock Exchange breaks new record. Sadly, not a good one... its longest ever outage

alain williams Silver badge

Nice to see someone taking the blame

made it plain that mess was the result of its own mistakes and key technology provider Fujitsu was not at fault.

Wow - someone not trying to blame someone else for their cock up. Please promote whoever said that!

Microsoft touts its Surface Laptop Go as 'cheap' option – but that price quickly goes up for useful RAM and storage

alain williams Silver badge

4GB is plently enough RAM

for what I use a laptop for: something to take out & about, a bit of web browsing, ssh, libreoffice. It has a small 12.4" screen which makes a nice fit for my rucksack. I assume that I will be able to upgrade the OS to Linux Mint or similar.

My main machine at home is more powerful. El Reg reviewers always assume that everyone needs a lot of grunt, not true.

£550 is a tad expensive for a small machine to use on walkabout, there are others that are cheaper. Finding a small screen is harder.

Huawei's UK code reviewers say Chinese mega-corp is still totally crap at basic software security. Bad crypto, buffer overflows, logic errors...

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Can we do this for all manufacturers

Just provide the source code and be done with it. Huawei makes its money selling hardware, by opening its code (even if that is just to its large telco customers) it would increase trust that it does not have back doors.

I doubt that their algorithms are vastly better than the competition.

If it does not want to do that then publish the complete hardware specs and customers could install their own firmware ... OK: something would need to be obtained, but once done, and shared with telcos world wide, we could have something robust.

The same should apply for Nokia, Cisco, etc.

It's 2020, so let's just go ahead and let Amazon have everyone's handprints so it can process payments

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Hey Amazon

I will give a clue: my palm is facing towards me and only two of my fingers are extended.

The perils of building a career on YouTube: Guitar teacher's channel nearly deleted after music publisher complains

alain williams Silver badge

Capricious abuse of power

The likes of google give themselves judicial like powers and then act in a way that can materially affect people. There is hardly any real oversight in the way that they use these powers, very often the decisions are done so as to cause them as little work as possible.

They have global reach and so should be subject to court decisions in the countries where they are visible.

Windows to become emulation layer atop Linux kernel, predicts Eric Raymond

alain williams Silver badge

If this were to happen ...

it would mean that devices for which there are only Windows drivers (Eg strange wifi cards) should cease to be a thing of the past - ie I should have no problems upgrading from MS Windows to Linux when I buy a new laptop.

In reality there will still be some kit (probably from China) that ships with proprietary device drivers for which they refuse to release the source code - completely breaching the GPL and them not caring.

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Sadly... this is the beginning of the end

Linus will be pushed out and the job will be done... well part of it.

If he is forced out it will be fascinating to see Linus forking the Linux kernel to keep a free version.

But I doubt that this "MS take over" will happen - there are too many others who depend on the Linux kernel.

Scre-EE-m if you wanna go faster: BT's mobile network reigns supreme in UK-wide speed and latency tests

alain williams Silver badge

Two other metrics ...

that are important with mobile networks:

* coverage - how many not-spots ?

* uptime - how few are the times when the network fails or degrades ?

Proposed US fix for Boeing 737 Max software woes does not address Ethiopian crash scenario, UK pilot union warns

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Making bricks fly

Not a Boeing

You will never see that on a flight booking form.

The airline might say "we fly Airbus" or similar but then change a flight due to one of a hundred reasons. What are you going to do when you realise as you board the air plane ? You won't be given a refund if you refuse to get on.

alain williams Silver badge

Re: What might be harder to ignore...

I have read most of the exec summary in the report. A large part of the problem was the watering down of the independence of ARs (Authorized Representatives) who are supposed to be the eyes & ears of the FAA (Federal Aviation Administration), but many were concerned about their job security if they made negative comments - many being paid by Boeing.

So: governance put in as a result of learning from earlier problems - dismantled to reduce costs and, presumably, as those who understood why the governance was put in had retired.

This reminds me of the watering down of banking regulation put in after the banks wrecking the global economy in the 1920/30s being watered down in 1980s - the "big bang". This allowed the meltdown of 2008 to happen.

I suspect that unchecked corner cutting will be found to be one of the causes of the Grenfell fire.

Search for bonfire of regulations to see that this is still happening.

Onwards! To the airport and adventure! And this rather lachrymose Linux screen

alain williams Silver badge

Re: "A Scottish airport"?

Why do you not tell us ?

Adidas now stands for All Day I'm Disconnecting All Servers as owners of 'smart' Libra scales furious over bricked kit

alain williams Silver badge

At point of sale ...

by law all devices that depend on some server, that the purchaser does not control, should have PROMINENTLY marked that this is so AND the earliest date at which the server might be withdrawn.

iOS 14 suffers app preference amnesia: Rebooting an iThing resets browser, email client defaults back to Safari, Mail

alain williams Silver badge

So iOS is now better than Windows 10

MS Windows only resets preferences after an upgrade, iOS does it after a reboot.

Do you think that MS will take this as a challenge and reduce the times that preferences stick ?

As we stand on the precipice of science fiction into science fact, people say: Hell yeah, I want to augment my eyesight!

alain williams Silver badge

Re: Like...

The smartphone in your head that got an "upgrade to ensure free service" by continually beaming adverts into your mind ... :-(

Family wrongly accused of uploading pedo material to Facebook – after US-EU date confusion in IP address log

alain williams Silver badge

Re: FFS

No: the ! told which was the next machine to send email to via UUCP, the final part was the username. For this to work you needed to know which machines talked to which other machines. At one point I had an A3 sheet above my desk with a world map, 100 odd machine names & lines connecting them.

So your routing path would have looked like: machine1!machine2!jsmith123 ... this is the email address that you gave to the mail or mailx program.

alain williams Silver badge

Re: FFS

Yes: country code first was a JANET thing.