* Posts by ThomH

2518 posts • joined 18 Jun 2009

Sleek Nokia Lumia details EXPOSED ahead of Thursday's disrobing

ThomH Silver badge

Re: I'm still unclear who the target audience is

"What's the correct phone shape? A 5.5" Galaxy Note?"

Candybars seem to be the preferred shape. Candybars with bits poking out not so much.

"Says who?"

DPReview, DxOMark, pretty much all the objective reviews. It's the best camera-in-a-phone on the market by a healthy margin but it was found lacking compared to the modern compact cameras. It's a small sensor and a tiny lens. Nokia can't beat physics.

"First you're saying it's not as good, now you're saying it is better but no one cares - which is it?"

You failed to comprehend the point I attempted to make. It's worse than a dedicated camera. It's better than other cameraphones. But it's less convenient than other cameraphones, and the lesson of MP3s is that convenience trumps quality.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Optics...

But! They've paid all that money to be able to print 'Carl Zeiss' on their lenses! So that makes them better, right?

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Lens Resolution

You don't gain large files; the large number of megapixels are processed to produce an ordinary resolution output. So what the device primarily gains over an ordinary 5MP sensor is colour resolution, for better post processing.

I guess it's easier to make photocells more sensitive (as is necessary to make them smaller because they'll receive less light) than to give them a greater overall range?

ThomH Silver badge

I'm still unclear who the target audience is

So it's not really conveniently shaped as a phone and its photos aren't as good as a real camera? I can't help feeling this is like producing an MP3 player that can output 400Khz audio or something like that — yes, most people could tell the difference in a blind test but, no, nobody is sufficiently bothered about it to put up with the inconvenience.

So I guess it's just supposed to help attach better-than-usual photography to the Nokia brand and not actually to sell?

Samsung Galaxy S3 explodes, turns young woman into 'burnt pig'

ThomH Silver badge

Re: And THIS is why you bu an iPhone.

This is a risk with all lithium-ion batteries; Apple uses the same chemistry as everyone else.

Assuming external chargers are available then technically this is a reason to pick the Samsung over the Apple — the S3 (and indeed the S4) both have removable batteries so you could keep the phone next to your bed in case of emergencies on one battery while your other charges in some other part of the house. Charging tends to heat batteries so therefore is an occasion when the risk of combustion very slightly increases.

Apple creeps up on Android in US smartphone sales

ThomH Silver badge

Re: So who was it (@JEDDIDAH)

What are you talking about? Apple is clearly taking over... all of BlackBerry's former marketshare.

BBC abandons 3D TV, cites 'disappointing' results

ThomH Silver badge

Re: It was "stereoscopic", not "3D".

"Um, unless you have a number of cameras arranged spherically around a given point of interest capturing the subject simultaneously, the image captured - whether using a lightfield camera or not - will always be from the point of view of the camera."

An ideal light field camera captures every ray of light hitting a surface as direction + colour. An ideal screen would reproduce those rays. So the hypothetical reproduced image is the same as looking through a window at the original scene.

I don't know about you, but I would consider the view through my window to be 3d, even though it doesn't project anything into my room and I can't move it.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: It was "stereoscopic", not "3D".

Lightfield displays* have been invented for true 3d images, they're just beyond realistic mass-market manufacture and there's no content whatsoever.

* if implemented in an artificially ideal capacity they would capture every ray of light that hits a plane — recorded as colour plus direction — and reproduce those later. So it's the rays of light that are reproduced, not a projection (or two projections) of them; you're free to focus for yourself, to tilt your head however you want, etc. They're achieved that with an array of micro-lenses in front of an image plane, so at each point that would be a single pixel on a traditional screen is a lens and which of the inner pixels you see depends on the angle between your eye and the lens. But that means multiplying up the panel resolution by a very large number and then producing and aligning the microlenses with sufficient quality.

The Lytro camera does this in reverse, which is why its photos can be refocussed after the fact and also why they're so low resolution compared to the output of ordinary 2d sensors.

Samsung isn't alone: HTC profits take a huge dive

ThomH Silver badge

On the contrary, it confirms that playground name calling isn't always well received. Especially when you have to shoehorn in the topic.

INVASION of the UNDEAD ANDROIDS: Hackers can pwn 'nearly all' devices

ThomH Silver badge

Re: I sense...

What? American keyboards?

Douglas Engelbart, PC pioneer and creator of the mouse, dies at 88

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Revisionism must be challenged

Apple invented drag and drop, pull-down menus and lots of other things we consider now fundamental but it did so only after paying Xerox for access to its work and in an environment where the fundamentals had already been established by Engelbart and others.

So the revisionists that claim that Apple invented the GUI, mouse, etc, are way off the mark but since they tend to end up in arguments with [lower-order] revisionists on the anti-Apple side it's not worth holding your breath for a balanced view to emerge.


ThomH Silver badge

Re: ZX80

I got 90% of the way towards hacking it but then a heavy breeze wobbled the RAM pack and I lost everything.

Prince of Persia: Baggy trousers and curvy swords

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Don't forget the C64 fan version

Pfff... in the Sam Coupe world they managed to get their fan version completed and released commercially back in 1992. By pausing the Amiga version frame-by-frame and hand copying the graphics, if memory serves.

Bjarne Again: Hallelujah for C++

ThomH Silver badge

Re: The usual non-USA cost bias.

But it's currently selling for a third below its usual price on Amazon US and only 12% below its usual price on Amazon UK.

The US price is ordinarily $75, which is £47.98 at today's exchange rate. The normal UK price is £47.99. Once you add some tax, it ordinarily costs more in the US.

Surprise! Intel smartphone trounces ARM in power trials

ThomH Silver badge

The competition is embeddable cores. Samsung, Apple, et al pick the ARM core, the GPU and everything else, lay out the silicon (or let a computer do it) and hit print. It's very mix and match. As a result, competition is healthier than it has been in years. ARM is likely to persevere both on momentum and because you don't have to go begging cap in hand any time you want a custom fabrication.

Girls, beer and C++: How to choose the right Comp-Sci degree for you

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Experience always varies!

I'm no particular fan of Forth for practical use but I can't recommend the Thinking Forth book strongly enough — it transcends the language it was written for, teaching fantastic lessons about structure and development cycles.

NSA: 'Dozens of attacks' prevented by snooping

ThomH Silver badge

Then surely the NSA could justify tying everyone up in their homes all day?

My feeling is that doing so would substantially decrease the crime rate?

Ex-Palm CEO Rubinstein wishes HP sale never happened

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Numbers Game

It was $1bn in cash and Facebook stock. So you can cut more than a third off probably a large chunk of that.

Cold, dead hands of Steve Jobs slip from iPhones: The Cult of Ive is upon us

ThomH Silver badge

Re: copying Googles mistakes?

I heard they kicked off the flat icon craze at Xerox PARC by having only two colours.

ThomH Silver badge

Umm, except that iPhone sales are up 40% year-on-year. It has decreasing marketshare in a rapidly growing market, not really allowing us to conclude anything much about the individuals.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Re:iPhone keyboard (@thesykes)

At least in iOS 1–6, you just long press the letter and a popup shows the options. Slide your finger to the one you want and release. Options for the long press on a are aàáâäæãåā. The copyright symbol seems to be available only on the emoji keyboard as far as I can see, @ is accessible on the symbols page and I failed to find a superscript but that doesn't mean it isn't in there. I'd have been unlikely to guess that § is paired with & for example.

Magpie Apple plunders the competition for cosmetics, as egos run wild

ThomH Silver badge

Re: "Ripping off" is a subjective matter

The Metro interface was so named because it was modelled after the design language of mass public transit systems, specifically including the King County Metro that serves Redmond and Seattle amongst others. So it's a little disingenuous to give credit to any of these computer company upstarts.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: That Symbian 2010 look

I trust a site called AllAboutSymbian to be as objective about iOS vs Symbian as, say, AppleInsider.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Copying (@Charlie Clark)

Creative Labs (hierarchical menus versus the iPod), then Nokia (swiping on a touch screen versus the iPhone), then Apple, Apple, Apple, Apple.

Tim Cook: Android version fragmentation is 'terrible for developers'

ThomH Silver badge

Re: 5 screens sizes

The iPad Mini has the same 4:3 aspect ratio as the big iPad (and similar to that of most sizes of paper). Though that does still differ from the 16:9 of the latest iPhone and the 3:2 of the previous ones.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: RIght...

I think he just meant that the average amount of time an iPhone user uses his or her device for is 50% greater than that an Android owner does.

Apple at WWDC: Sleek new iOS, death of the big cats, pint-sized Mac Pro

ThomH Silver badge

Re: It's not when they came out, it's when they stopped selling them.

*cough* the final version of iOS available for the iPad 1 is 5, not 6.

The toy of tech: The Mattel Aquarius 30 years on

ThomH Silver badge

Re: What?

The Sinclair ZX81 and Spectrum were amongst those using ULAs — a bit like write-once FPGAs you bought off the shelf, a custom step imprinted your logic and then they were delivered. So they were custom in all reasonable senses. Acorn used the same method to shrink the BBC into the Electron.

Apple unveils hints of Monday's new-product announcements

ThomH Silver badge

Re: does anyone even care what Apple do these days?

That's because Google fixed the maps. There's actually quite a lot of precedent for OSs shipping with applications that many feel are better implemented by third parties: TextEdit, MS Paint, Internet Explorer, Safari, etc, etc.

MYSTERY Nokia image-mangling mobe spotted in public

ThomH Silver badge

But surely that still allows it to be too big?

You cannot fit an SLR into a smartphone. So you're going to have to accept lesser image quality. In that case why is something bulbous preferable? A lot of people would argue that it just falls between two stools — it's not compact enough to fit well with a mobile phone and it's not large enough to do all that much better than what does fit in other mobile phones. So it's too large for anything people want in a phone.

It's the same sort of logic that allows people to conclude that e.g. a 6" screen is too large for a mobile phone.

Study: US iPhone owners tend to be rich, educated, white

ThomH Silver badge

I think the vendors are quite open about the fashion side

Samsung are probably most explicit with their adverts full of 'haha, these people are sheep' (ie, thoughtlessly following the prevailing fashion) or 'of course they use an iPhone, they're old' (as old is the antithesis of fashionable per advertisers), but that's only because they explicitly want to put the negative association onto the competitor. Apple's adverts are just as much about fashion — the iPhone is sleek and modern — but less explicitly because it doesn't work if you just stand up and plainly claim to be fashionable.

Firefox OS: Go away fanbois, fandroids - you wouldn't understand

ThomH Silver badge

Re: And in the east too. (@AC)

The Kantar figures you're citing are for the USA only — see http://www.kantarworldpanel.com/global/News/news-articles/While-Android-Leads-iOS-and-Windows-Are-Growing-At-A-Faster-Pace — and show Android ticking up a little year-on-year, iOS ticking down a little and Windows Phone eating BlackBerry's share.

Gartner run the figures worldwide and, taking smartphones in isolation, report a 69.7% share for Android and a 20.9% share for Apple. If you include all phones then Apple's share drops to 7.5% so I guess the Android number would fall proportionally (source: http://www.gartner.com/newsroom/id/2335616 ).

Possibly also of interest, Apple's absolute sales figures are up by almost 50% year-on-year totalling an increase of 40m and Samsung's are up more than 20% but that's about 70m. Nokia managed to lose a bit more than 20% of its custom during 2012, RIM about 33%.

So duopoly is questionable but it's obvious that both iOS and Android are relevant and neither is going anywhere any time soon. Can you confidently say the same about the other platforms?

Microsoft offers free keyboard covers for Surface RT

ThomH Silver badge

Re: MS is playing Follow the Leader

To me Microsoft's current efforts feel rather like Apple suddenly deciding to license the Mac operating system after Windows 95 had come out.

Google whips the sheet off new Gmail interface

ThomH Silver badge

They've reinvented the portal!

Remember how one of the reasons to abandon Altavista/etc and start using Google was the minimal page design that helped to keep the information you're actually interested in more prominent? Google doesn't.

Anonymous 'plonks' names, addresses of far-right EDL types on web

ThomH Silver badge

The EDL is considered, rightly or wrongly, to be far-right because of its deeds rather than because of its words. On several occasions, the EDL has planned a protest only for it to descend into hooligans who self-associate with the EDL smashing up private property. People like those caught on video here: http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=794_1369521652

The public perception has therefore become that EDL marches are likely to descend into hooligans destroying private property. People also generally associate hooliganism with right-wing sentiments, probably because of the serious problems football has had with both hooliganism and with racism, tying the two things together in the public imagination.

Even taking your argument as accurate, and starting from the premise that the connection is a misperception, EDL supporters like yourself further cement the conclusion by blaming it on "the liberal left wing". Where is a group that despises the liberal left wing most likely to be on the political spectrum?

To a much lesser extent there's the 'English' in 'English Defence League'. Where do groupings that explicitly reference England, Britain or the United Kingdom in their name tend to fall on the political spectrum?

Those are the reasons that the EDL is perceived, and continues to be perceived, as right wing. If, as an EDL supporter, you want to shed the label, those are the problems you want to address.

Here's a test: I strongly dislike the EDL. From that statement in isolation, where would you assume my political beliefs lie?

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Well

Yeah, that's how it works. If I see a Conservative Party political broadcast that tells me they'll fix the economy but then don't vote Conservative then that must mean I want to break the economy?

ThomH Silver badge

The problem with guaranteeing free speech is that you can't hold it up as the be all and end all while simultaneously saying that the EDL have the right to say anything they want but Anonymous don't have the right to say that person X is a member of the EDL.

At some point you have to balance the rights of one group against the rights of another. In this case I think the defamation angle is the right one to follow. If Anonymous has misidentified anybody then those people will likely be subject to a heavy adverse reaction. It's the rights of those individuals that should properly restrict the right to free speech.

So, yes, I'm against what Anonymous has done. I'm also against the EDL but that's neither here nor there. But I disagree with what's happened not because I think free speech is an absolute right but rather because I think that limitations are justified in specific limited cases.

PC market facing worst-ever slump in 2013

ThomH Silver badge

Re: There will always be a market for powerful PCs

I'm not so sure about gamers — it could go either way. Without a middle tier of people that don't care if they play at 20fps with low-quality textures to pump up the sales, there's just not all that large of a market. So then what are people going to buy the high-end computers for? It'll become an ever shrinking niche.

Another way round of phrasing it: 90% of games are going to be developed for tablets and similar devices. Those games are not going to scale well. So why bother spending the money to try?

Happy 23rd birthday, Windows 3.0

ThomH Silver badge

If this is really the way the conversation is going, it's pretty easy to rattle off the systems that were technologically superior in many respects to Windows 3.0 in 1990. Off the top of my head: The Amiga Workbench, RISC OS (both as already mentioned), NextStep, OS/2, NeWS, X + e.g. OpenWindows.

Of those, NextStep, OS/2 and NeWS are probably the ones worth singling out for special praise. All three are preemptive, use a protected memory scheme and provide the sort of user-land libraries that we now usually consider to be part of an OS.

The iWatch is coming! The iWatch is coming!

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Watch out!

The iPhone isn't dying now, but the iPod wasn't dying in 2007. Modern Apple likes to get each new cash cow up to speed before the previous goes into decline.

That said, if a watch is all they can come up with then the future's probably not bright.

Intel's answer to ARM: Customisable x86 chips with HIDDEN POWERS

ThomH Silver badge

The Z80 (and 6502, and others) undocumented opcodes were merely relics of the decoding process — they weren't intended to be hidden. The reason they became well known was that one or two of them were found to do useful things in computers where a single supplier had provided the same model of CPU for the entire production run.

For example, there's 'shift left and insert a 1 in the least significant bit' on the Z80 that can be used to make a faster scroll in some cases and to help with certain methods of sprite compositing. It's a relic of shift right arithmetic and fills a pretty obvious numerical hole in the instruction map. So if you know that every 48k Spectrum uses a Z80 with that instruction then why not use it?

So this is unlike the classic situation because the motivation is different — the new operations are hidden on purpose.

Things that cost the same as coffee with Tim Cook - and are way more fun

ThomH Silver badge

Re: I heard

"Haha, all our money comes from markets you don't compete in — but we hear Samsung are getting rich off phones"?

Microsoft: YES! You can have your desktop back again for FREE!

ThomH Silver badge

Re: “advance the bold vision”

I quite like the ribbon and don't fully understand the dislike for it. Especially once you've set it to automatically hide, it's a pull-down menu that has icons as well as words. Then once you can rely on people's ability to discern pictures more quickly than words, you can go back to the old-school approach of putting things in the drop downs rather than in toolbars. One of the reasons they did that was that screens used to be smaller; now laptops are the predominant form of computers, screens are smaller again.

I guess the counter argument is that the icons don't add anything to the words or the words don't add anything to the icons so one or the other just acts as visual noise, spreading everything out so as to make navigation more laborious? I can't say I've faced that problem but I'm hardly a power user — in Word I use little beyond style sheets and am sufficiently fussy that I expect not to set them up in way that satisfies me very quickly.

'Ultimate nerd chick’ prompts C64 clone cancellation

ThomH Silver badge

Sorry to be the carrier of bad news, but she isn't. Her LinkedIn profile says she left in February 2013 — no doubt in that big round of layoffs they did.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: kickstarter kicked!

If you give me $150,000 then I could give you some of my time trying to figure out how to recreate old arcade machines.

'Liberator': Proof that you can't make a working gun in a 3D printer

ThomH Silver badge

Re: A few points of order

Straw man begets straw man:

Yes, silly us in the rest of the world. We forgot that the death penalty and free access to guns are inalienable requirements for democracy. That's why there aren't any democracies in Europe — we're all just oppressed socialists because we have things like universal healthcare.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: Won't someone think of (@Frankee)

It probably doesn't say anything but the American Constitution recognises rights rather than granting them, so that really just means that it doesn't take an explicit position. Probably the argument that it'd be a bit ridiculous if the right to bear arms were recognised but not the right to make them usable is the more persuasive.

Look ma, no plugins! Streaming web video with just JavaScript

ThomH Silver badge

Re: ???

I think they just mean that, in the style of Citrix, OnLive, VNC or a host of others, you could use their streaming to stream a moving picture of a computer program rather than moving pictures of actors. That program would probably be hosted as a virtual machine on the originating server. Which gives them a neat extra buzzword vaguely to attach to their software.

ThomH Silver badge

Re: WebGL

Apple has a working implementation of WebGL under iOS — it's enabled for iAds (which are vetted) and can be enabled across the system on jailbroken devices and/or in individual web views through undocumented API calls. Guesses for it not being on by default range from it being insufficiently secure for the main browser (ie, the Microsoft argument) to Apple not wanting to lose app store revenue (ie, the anti-Apple argument).

So, anyway, if killer WebGL apps come along then Apple needn't allow its OS to be left behind.

AMD reveals potent parallel processing breakthrough

ThomH Silver badge

Re: No more worrying about Graphic card memory

By putting the GPU behind the MMU it does technically reduce one of the video memory concerns — you could have a single graphic however many gigabytes in size, memory map the file and call that the texture. Attempts by the GPU to read sections not currently paged would simply raise the usual exception, which would be caught by the OS in the usual way and handled by the existing paging mechanisms. You no longer have to treat texture caching as a separate application-level task.

That said, as others have noted the main point of the design is that when you write a parallel for loop in your language of choice to perform some vector operation — especially if it involves no branching — the GPUs can be factored into the workload just as easily as any traditional CPU cores, but so as to perform the work much more efficiently. So writing programs that take advantage of all the available processing becomes a lot easier. Collapsing virtual memory to a single mechanism that your OS vendor has already supplied is just one example.

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2019