* Posts by John Smith 19

16330 publicly visible posts • joined 10 Jun 2009

NSA: Secret 'Perfect Citizen' project does not spy on US

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@tom 24

"It's job is to provide the tools to spy on us."

I maybe wrong but somehow I feel many Americans are not exactly reassured by such a statement.

Just a wild guess.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Threat assement of embedded control systems?

I didn't know Raytheon even *did* this.

I would have thought Honeywell a *much* better outfit for this due to their extensive product range in various bits of plant control hardware and software.

And of course someone with quite a lot of penetration detection and prevention experience (complete with lots of the sort of ex US govt employees with rather vague CV's and foreign trips on their passports) like SAIC should also have been in the frame.

The name is *pretty* sinister for what it's meant to be. If it's a code name in principle even *that* information would be classified (so why publish it). It looks like something generated by pulling random entries from different word lists (historically if the first word was "have" it meant a research project to either acquire or improve a capability and "senior" was strategic reconnaissance system. IIRC senior trend was one name for the SR71)

A mystery wrapped in an enigma inside a conundrum.

Guess that's how the NSA like it.

Barnet and West Sussex breach DPA

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Optymystic

"Look at what happens when the personal data gets used e.g. in child protection cases for which purpose it is distributed through unencrypted public email."

Now that *is* interesting. It was my understanding that pretty much *all* the relevant players in a social services case who would need a *detailed* file would be professional bodies whose staff would be part of some kind of corporate email system (NHS, relevant police service, solicitors) with the relevant backup, security and in principle ability to set up a desktop to desktop secure data transfer.

Yes the parents *might* not have anything but a hotmail account but they presumably already *know* the details. An obvious options is a VPN link into a server PC (real or these days virtual) to view or change (but *not* download) the state of play. Another option is delivery by encrypted file attachment with the password sent some other way or an obscure but generally known one (IE the password is the case file no of the sending organization. Not that many people need to know that and all *should* be interested parties)

"We want to take that child into care "

A local authority that actually does this in the UK?

"because the father is a maniac, "

If you're taking the children into care that's not exactly a vote of confidence in the mother either. And I thought the absolute belief that females plumbing *guarantees* they will make naturally *better* parents was hard coded into the UK legal system. I live and learn.

"When you see what is done with the data you will realise there is no point trying to secure it anyway."

Translation. "The system leaks like a sieve anyway why try to do anything about this bit first"

Ah the apathetic tone, the sense the data does not *really* belong to the people its about. and anyway it's not really our fault.

Social worker by any chance?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

Need to work out who to punish.

Make staff *personally* liable for data loss?

So you get bottom up pressure to improve security (or give them access to ways to improve their *own* security as it's their neck that's in the noose)

Make head of department (personally?) liable?

The head of the department in the Baby Peter case did not reckon they should go despite 60 odd contacts over 3 months (that's more than some "problem" families might get in a *decade*) and a very dead toddler on their hands.

It should be a department heads remit to fight for the resources to do their departments job and *nothing* get the attention like the prospect of loosing a big chunk of their *personal* assets if they fail to do so.

Council IT department.

Did they make it *clear* why carrying sensitive data on unsecure laptops is a *bad* idea and that there are simple cost effective options which prevent the data being misused?

Did they suggest other ways to access the data which didn't *need* a copy to be carted around?

If they didn't that suggests they should take some of the blame.

I'd go for the head of department. they're likely to have some understanding of why this mattes.

The council itself.

Tricky. Again what part of the budget to fine? Or make councilors *personally* liable?

As a pragmatist I know institutions take time to change. I think some kind of graduated response is needed. Loosing data is bad. Loosing data *repeatedly* and issuing some "Lessons will be learned blah blah blah" handout BS means the ICO response needs to be escalated.

Waterfall Niagara speakers

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

Yeah

But are they a patch on the Dominator XL?

Russian spies dumped in Vienna after swap

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Wonder if this plot idea was ever done

I had it back when there was a Soviet Union but I suspect it would still work now.

I pictured some cube rat in the Finance section of the department dealing with illegals. He sets up new accounts for them, makes sure their pay goes on time etc.

One day he gets to thinking "What if I added an agent or two. Let the salaries pile up then bring them home." Little by little he puts the plan together, works out ways round the security (getting his boss to sign off the paperwork etc) and put's it into effect.

Finally it's running like clockwork. He's not a greedy man and he's just about ready to shut it down and have the money disappear when he's called to equivalent of Internal Affairs.

The officer from IA has put it together. He's looking at a bullet to the head and an unmarked grave.

OTOH says the officer, we could just double the number of your illegals.

The End.

The End.

Lindsay Lohan: The interactive court drama

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

Nice

Looking forward to the rest.

Women's prisons offer so much opportunity for drama and friendship (from the original reform school girls to prisoner cell block H).

ISPs mark disapproval of the Digital Economy Bill

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Alert

Once I heard EU law treats ISP's as carriers

Can't understand how that POS legislation *ever* got drafted.

But remember, The Dark Lord's followers are taking names and notes.

They believe their master will rise again.

Council websites falter on business services

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

Turn the best ones into a template the rest can copy?

Yes inventing something from scratch is *hard*, so why not copy one that works?

Seriously how much variation in legal forms is actually *allowed* between the different levels and regions of UK local authorities?

Just a thought.

For sale: Dr No's Scottish bunker complex

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@Nathan Price

"All redundant too, there's two of every system down there."

Given its intended purpose I don't think you'd want you life to hang on a breakdown in the aircon or the gennie.

Europe approves mass data transfer to US

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

109 MEPs voted against it.

That's a start.

I wonder how many of them would not have if El Reg readers had not written to them?

Thumbs down because this is a *bad* treaty and is *highly* asymmetrical.

Telco sets honey pot for nuisance marketers

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

What a *brilliant* test environment

For both real time speech generation and real time connected speech recognition.

The challenge. The *most* convincing simulation of a caller with most authentic "voice" (neither robotic nor pre-sampled speech) and plausible questions and answers.

Let the games commence.

Reverse engineer extracts Skype crypto secret recipe

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

How open source is VoIP

Skype is the one everyone recognises, but are there less well known (better?) but compatible options ?

Just asking as I imagine some Reg readers have been benchmarking this stuff.

Parliament misled over Climategate report, says MP

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

You want *absolute* truth?

Read the holy book of your chosen deity.

You want the best known (as of right now) model of the physical world. Do Science.

But *if* you choose that option make sure you see *all* the caveats, uncertainty limits, gaps in theory etc.

Confidential report reveals ContactPoint security fears

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@sheila

You'll tak our homes, but no our we'ans details. *

*Braveheart has a lot to answer for.

BBC chief acknowledges DAB flop & internet radio

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Down

Both options seems to have drawbacks.

Internet radio basically needs a broadband connection.

DAB are *heavy* battery users.

Lumping *all* of this together as "digital" radio seems *extremely* misleading.

SCO rises from the dead (again)

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

It would seem

that only getting *all* the lawyers and senior execs involved in a big room and with several Claymore mines in the centre would end this.*

Not of course that I advocate this because that could be seen as inciting a terrorist incident (use of a military weapon) just saying that only *something* on that scale would seem to be able to end this once and for all.

NSA setting up secret 'Perfect Citizen' spy system

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Black Helicopters

Highly appropriate

"Perfect Citizen"

The *only* kind they expect to have left once the system has gone live and all "anomalies" have been eliminated.

Black helo's. I think so.

UK.gov scraps stop'n'search terror power

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Shock news. UK Gov does what they are *legally* obliged to do by European Court

They might consider reviewing their behavior on the DNA retention of *innocent* people as well..

Thumbs up because stroking a politician sometimes works and they need to be given all the positive reinforcement they can.

All gov jobs to go online

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Thomas4

I believe the pinnacle of the profession in the UK is "Keeper of the Queen's Heads," responsible for ensuring that every crapper at Buck House is fit for the Royal We (that's Liz and Phil).

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@Charles Calthrop

"and at a stroke the government kills off the advertising for the leading non right wing paper → #"

Err, you do know the Grauniad looses c£100k per day and that it is kept afloat by the takings from "Autotrader," right?

This was mentioned when ol' Rupe decided to put a pay wall around the Times and the Grauniad editor (Rusbridger?) said they were planning to *expand* access to their online content through a new content access API.

Lindsay Lohan goes down for 90 days

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

drink + drugs + fast cars -> trouble.

Whereas drink + drugs (in own or friends home) = who gives a s@$t.

I'm sure Ms Lohan will use her time constructively to make many new friends, no doubt some of whom have felt her to be quite a role model for their lifestyle.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Sorry that handle is already taken

"She's looking pretty rough for 24."

I think the word your looking for is "Gingery." *

yes I know my chances of getting this one past the moderatrix are slim but it's worth a shot.

Professor warns Aus firewall is undemocratic

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Interesting quote

"The authors argue that it is time to review Australia’s complex and inconsistent media content regulation system to take account of the online era."

And the same could probably said of *any* major economy's laws on the same subject.

Should different media be governed by different laws? Same laws? Same laws (with exceptions)?

She makes a valid point. It'll be interesting if any one pays attention.

FLYING CAR, full hover, fairly quiet, offered to US Marines

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Very impressive systems thinking, if it works.

And what a big if that is.

The duct thing sounds like an application of the "ejector" principle, a bit like the Dyson air mover, treating the shroud as not just a pit of safety screening to stop meatsacks walking into the props but a subtle integral part of the airflow management.

This problem was so enormously tricky and complex that only by considering *everything* working together would it be solved in anything like an affordable way. That includes the whole making a chopper handle with near car like controls.

Thumbs up if it works.

Phorm issues shares to raise cash

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

Phorm. Last of the unflushables.

I hope not.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

shorting?

Start a roll

Downward.

BT and TalkTalk threaten court to kill Mandybill

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

So EU states ISP's are carriers *already*

IE they just provide the pipe.

What goes down it is *none* of their business.

AFAIK EU law supersedes members national law *every* time on subjects where the EU is *allowed* to legislate in the first place.

WTF allowed this law to *ever* get to 1st reading given this 1 *simple* fact.

I guess cash is *the* lubricant for legislative intercourse.

Flames for this law *ever* being allowed into law once that single fact is known. A very grudging thumbs up to BT Retail (AKA Phorm UK) for doing the right thing.

New 3D displays use falling water drops as 'voxels'

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@TRT

"Those solenoid valves must burn out quickly. Driving them at 60Hz is quite a challenge. It must be very noisy."

I'd bet they're using some kind of multiple ink jet set to get the high definition.

That stuff's rated to *millions* of cycles of operation.

Those drops are *pretty* small.

Most new 2009 EU powerplant was wind oops, gas

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@r81miller

"I guess it was the same in Windscale, but that was in a frenzy to get NUKES NOW."

Windscale was *never* a nuclear power site. It's reactors were for testing or the production of Plutonium for the UK bomb programme.

The Windscale fire in IIRC 1957 was a Pu production reactor producing *no* electricity but several MW of heat.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Coal has many uses.

It's quite a good chemical feedstock (and was used as such for a long time before oil came along).

It has one characteristic which UK governments find uniquely hostile to handling.

Miners.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

A reminder that "gas" can be renewable

And at present the biggest aerobic digester is in Germany. The technology is scalable, controllable and very well understood. In the UK there are provisions to sell gas (IE Methane) into the national grid in the same way electricity is sold (if the provisions are *activated* in the relevant legislation).

Getting in to bed with Dobby Putin is likely to end in tears.

Data.gov.uk troupe gets shirty about standards

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@spodula

"As for Extraction, writing something to do extraction should be a one-off thing, which shouldnt take a competent programmer long. In my experience, its never writing the data extraction that takes a long time,"

Don't be too sure. Contractor friend of mine told of a project where Team leader sank *weeks* of time working up this super-duper ETL tool to do a *single* one time extraction to populate a new database. Know fixed O/P database known fixed database to be input to.

I've used import tools that should have a simple decision table internal design but had a rats nest of and/or logic instead to parse the file and route the records (yes I know awk or perl could probably have done the job but where do find perl on an i-series?)

John Smith 19 Gold badge
WTF?

So WTF is Spikes Cavell?

Well....

They claim to have been running 18 years and sincs 2004 "Help public sector organisations transform their procurement"

Which sounds like they got first dibbs on some obscure (but *highly* informative) datasets from civil servants who *apparently* did not realise how valuable the information is to the right people.

BTW isn't allowing ad-hoc programs the ability to understand complex structured date the *whole* point of XML?

London hospital hosted grumble flick shoot

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

Women MP has since of humour shock.

Full story in article.

Fusion reactor eats Euro science budgets

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

But fuion *already* produces

An inexhaustible supply of PhD's in Plasma Physics.

Oh you want it to produce more electricity than it consumes.

That's going to cost a bit more.

ATM hack presentation ditched after legal threats

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

So vendors and banks *know* ATM's have vulnerabilities

That just don't want Joe citizen to realize it.

What's that? Nothing to hide, nothing to fear?

Funny how you never hear that from a corporation.

BTW Skip the online version. It's been sanitised.

PARIS in hot glue gun action

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

Wood pistons used as running repairs in Africa

Remember IC engines are pulse heating systems. The piston of any given cylinder remains fairly cool most of the cycle.

Now making the whole *block* and cylinder head out of wood is a whole different thing.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@TeeCee

"Any idea what they stick tiles onto Space Shuttles with*?"

NASA calls it "Room Temperature vulcanizing" adhesive which AFAIK is the description of the stuff people use to stick wall tiles up for bathrooms and kitchens.

It's high temperature limits is not quite as high as you might imagine. (IIRC it's something like quite low. I'm pretty sure the tiles would fall off before the maximum use temp of the aluminium body is reached, which is 183c). It's big feature is it can handle the on orbit soak temperature while remaining flexible, which is *very* low, something like -150c to -200c (in theory it could be down to the universal background of 3k but a fair bit of heat leaks out of the orbiter)

The temperature gradient from front face to back face of tile is high.

Mega new climate science: 'Runaway' effect exaggerated

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Shock news. Scientists do science and downgrade a threat

This is what science is *supposed* to do.

Have model, obtain data, verify or discount a hypothesis, narrowing the range of uncertainty in a model.

It *could* have also gone the other way, and there are other "tipping point" scenarios this does improve or resolve. It does beg a few questions.

What *have* climate modelers been using as values for these factors?

How many *other* variables are there (or rather "suspected" variables as this has turned out not to be one)

Has the list of things climate modelers don't know/can't bracket been published?

I'd settle for the just the ones they know they don't know. The inability to extend weather forecasting models beyond 5 days suggest there are a few they don't know about.

thumbs up for scientists doing science, *not* politics.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

AC@12:07

"So we need to find the global thermostatic PID algorithm based on historical data, and then we'll be able to predict what the temperature will be in future!"

Good thinking. However I remember back in my dim and distant days (*very* dim, *very* distant) napping through a lecture on limit cycle oscillation and how it tends to be a feature of non-linear control systems. Linear PID types are either quite expensive or lack the crisp response of a bang-bang system. The classic example being the domestic central heating thermostat, which actually keeps the room in a *band* around the desired temperature because it has no idea about boiler output Vs house temperature rise.

The "bang" in the Earths climate could be volcanic eruptions, sunspots, asteroid impacts or the introduction of a large scale energy using civilisation.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Troll

AC@12:48

Check his other posts.

You've been trolled.

First true submarine captured from American drug smugglers

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Use for Astute class after all.

Who'd have thought it.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Vladimir Plouzhnikov

And it means "Shark" in Russian...

That sound more like a name for a class of submarine.

I presume you mean the Type 971 attack know in Russia as pike class.

NAO slams 'redundant' MoJ finance systems

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

"more than £10bn of expenditure" "£37Bn to Scottish and Welsh administrations"..

Or rather we *think* they did.

It sounds like there is no way to actually *know* how much they administered and who to.

Home Office promises spycam review

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Grossly disproportinate for stated task

Sounds like a DPA violation.

I think only the people who had been involved would have a reasonable case.

RAC prof: Road charges can end the ripoff of motorists

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

@Graham Bartlett

"Solution: a flat fee for every landing of every non-UK-registered truck. This is perfectly within EU rules - countries are required to allow free movement of goods without applying duty on goods, but there's no rules against an entry tax for the vehicle carrying them."

I like this. Not sure what the haul would be but sounds reasonable.

Superpowered energy-storing wonder stuff created in lab

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

@Steve Jones

"I've no doubt the machine required to produce this pressure is huge in comparison to the amount of energy in the compressed material."

Quite possibly right. Diamond anvil cells are actually quite small (literally handheld) but only because the experimental volume is more cubic micrometers than cubic cenitmetres. They are also used to simulate the compression levels found in implosion nuclear weapons.

As others have pointed out *releasing* that energy in a controlled manner is the tricky bit.

Generically this would come under "Highly Energetic Matter" which the USAF and NASA have looked at for some time. It is the only foreseeable way to get *big* improvements in rocket performance without switching to mad fuels like Hydrogen/Florine (or for barking mad billionaires with a penchant for world domination and a total disregard for human life Hydrogen/Florine/Lithium)

OFT to disqualify unwitting directors to deter competition abuses

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Keeping piggy out of the trough may be the only effective deterrent

BTW IIRC there are provisions in the UK Companies acts for "Shadow directors," who don't have a seat on any board but excercise substantial influence.

The *only* fine that would make any sense would be one scaled to the excess profits the company made. But this divides the interests of the company from those of the directors.

Cartels and price fixing are *always* good for companies in the know. But this punishment makes sure the people who actually *form* the company get it right in the neck. This should be a strong *personal* disincentive to think twice about playing such games.

Robotic cargo spacecraft misses rendezvous with ISS

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

To be a little bit serious

It is *highly* unlikely that ISS supplies would be allowed to fall to the level where they are 1 ship away from starvation, hence the "Not essential" comment.

I looked up the Soyuz on board computers and they are beasts. USSR mfg chips and weigh about 70Kg (roughly late 60's TTL near as I can tell). The docking hardware is likely to be a *bit* more up to date. In some ways this is a bad thing as the smaller geometry makes it *more* prone to single even upset by a stray particle releasing holes and electrons in the wrong place. It's still doubtful this would have caused the fail.

Weather this is what happened or if its a simpler explanation, (dry PCB joint, loose aerial connection) will probably have to wait for a board of enquiry. it is *very* curious that ISS should loose telemetry data at such short range from the transmitter.