* Posts by John Smith 19

16330 publicly visible posts • joined 10 Jun 2009

Bill Gates discusses nuclear development deal with China

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

The economics shoudl be *interesting* to say the least

Nuclear companies do not make money *building* nuclear reactors.

They make it selling the proprietary non standard "fuel elements"

As readers may have noticed this thing does not have *any* of them.

Without an *existing* nuclear construction company "sponsoring" the design it's YANR design. Might be brilliant, might be c**p, but no one is going to put the serious amount of cash on the table to find out.

It's got some of the features of the molten salt thorium concepts and some of their issues.

Time will tell if they have deep enough pockets to get it to do anything.

BREAKTHROUGH: Feisty startup slashes chip power by 50%

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Subtle & sneaky

It's kind of weird, you'd have thought Intel, with it''s *huge* investment in chip fabs, would be looking for exactly this type of approach (clever tweaks of the *existing* tools and processes it uses) to give those improvements.

Instead the start-up using what appears to be a *deeper* understanding of what is going on has achieved this leverage.

I'd guess someone has been caning their HPC hardware to run the sims that worked out the theory in detail.

Thumbs up for this, with the proviso that it has to be translated into *products* first.

Antarctic ice formed at CO2 levels much higher than today's

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

So CO2 falls, -> temperature falls but ice starts at *much* higher ppm level of CO to begin with

First point supports the warming hypothesis.

Second is rather interesting.

And what *started* this cooling in the first place?

Then again does CO2 track temperature or vice versa?

Globe slowly warming, insists 'Hansen's Bulldog'

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

In signal processing it's important to know what is signal and what is noise

I'm not sure this paper does.

On a side note how does this compare with *previous* predictions of the same authors?

About what they always said it was? Vastly bigger? Vastly smaller?

Although they do seem to have included what their assumptions were.

Something the academics of the CRU seemed to have been a bit vague on.

Inside the shadow world of commercialised spook spyware

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

@Ben Liddicott

"No, the question is: Do we want spy infrastructure installed and controlled by US, UK and our allies, or by the Chinese?"

The question is precisely do we want it and (if we do not) *who* does?

The answer is anyone who fears their *own* people.

Any bureaucrat who simply *must* know everything, about everyone, forever. The capability is *grossly* disproportionate to the threat it *claims* to combat. And all of these products will have a "threat" that they *claim* to handle.

Stated like that it is seen not so much as a policy but more a psychosis. I've called it a data fetish, but this is nowhere near as harmless as most fetishes.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

I'd heard you need to build an FO reflectometer to tap a line without cutting it.

Of course stripping the casing and laying the tap fibre around it iw meant to be very difficult.

Japan, Russia in plan for elephant to birth CLONE MAMMOTH

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Kind of surprised they didn't start with the dodo.

Small(ish)

Recently extinct.

Easy to add "McNugget" as a suffix.

Actually *all* of Ian Fergusion's list sounds delicious (suitably prepared).

People who've had cat tell me it's quite gamey, like rabbit (rumored to be sold as rabbit in France).

NASA confirms first Earth candidate in habitable zone

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

600LY, but what is that

In Congressional election cycles.

About the *only* measure of time that the US gov is concerned with.

Blighty promised £43m prang-predicting supercomputer

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

21500 Jeffries does not seem much.

That said it should get a fair sized HPC box.

But how much does the software cost to run on it?

Micron's glass memory monster chews up slowcoach flash

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

@Hungry Sean

"A technology that becomes easier to use with smaller scales is pretty darn neat if you ask me. . ."

Not really.

The actual question is does the power requirement scale *faster* than the thickness of the wires carrying it.

If it does not you also have to produce power conductors with higher aspect ratio to carry the *same* power you needed for the last generation.

'I'm the first to admit that we've made a bunch of mistakes'

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

It's that surprise h in the middle.

Read the headline and thought "Didn't know Craig was a big DS9 fan"

ICO 'too scared' to clobber press for data breaches

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

@Colin Millar

"BB would liek to remind you that "all your crats are belong to us""

Not so.

All those 'crats belong to Rupert.

Give Osborne a shovel: UK economy stuck in deep hole

John Smith 19 Gold badge
WTF?

How about releasing the results of drug tests, *including* the deaths.

Only the UK has a *very* big pharma friendly testing regime.

You don't have to report *all* deaths of patients on a trial. Scouts honor that you will if they are *significant*. Handy if your testing anti depressants and your side effects turn out to cause suicidally inclined people to top themselves, after all they were going to do that *anyway*.

Medical devices (like heart valves) are "grand fathered." After your 10-years-in-R&D-unobtainium-and-fairy-dust design is *just* like all those other heart valves. No need for any sort of *extensive* testing (let alone reporting).

As for "annonimised" health records, Google might have some advice to give them on that.

UK.gov to build child army of software coders

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Bainshie

"Lets program pacman in java!"

I seem to recall that was *exactly* the plan for one of those games programming degrees.

Psst, kid... Wanna learn how to hack?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

The other 99%

Will make various uses of the *official* allowed interfaces and produce results ranging from average to astonishing.

Some will brick it (possibly on several occasions)

Still a very cleverly engineered idea.

It seems to attack Sinclairs problem (good price but *inconsistent* quality) while retaining the keen pricing Sinclair was known for.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

Does the beagleboard need any other comment than

smoking.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

"not much chance of directly poking registers in the hardware,"

This will put off 99% of owners

The results from the other 1% should be more interesting.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Go

AC@13:14

"I think the third world market is pretty well sewn up at the moment with keyboard equipped "Famiclones" - a copy of an 8-bit Nintendo system with BASIC, word processor and some educational software in ROM. "

"a Chumby One/Insignia Infocast which is an ARM based SoC equipped console with 3.5" touchscreen, built in WiFi and USB host."

Fascinating. This is (I suspect) a world most Reg readers know nothing about.

It's the ALL NEW FUTURISTIC WEAPONS Black Friday Roundup!

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

fat, plastic and used to high temperatures

Sounds like a humvee?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

Or a supersonic round with no sonic boom

Sounds quite mad but *is* under development by at least 1 US company.

Note it's *real* payoff is the development of design rules for a "boom free" supersonic plane.

Supersonic research on *anything* bigger than a bullet is pretty tough otherwise.

Chancellor to raid pensions, Whitehall to revamp UK broadband

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

China offers to upgrade *all* UK broadband

While offering free VoIP and CCTV back services.

And will even lay it's own cable back to it's Beijing base routers

What can possibly go wrong?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Meh

@Rob

"can I hope that when using that word they will bung some money to the Grid for water, gas and electric"

You seem to be unaware that *all* of those structures were sold off over 20 years ago. water companies in particular were sold off to *avoid* the govt of the day having to spring for the upgrade costs of the UK's standard method of human waste disposal, the long-pipe-into-the-sea.

Randy plods plundered police records just to get a date

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Holmes

People with access to private information tend to abuse that access

Only politicians *ever* seem surprised at this.

It's an abuse of *trust* which (no matter how much they hate to admit) the public have to have in the police for them to do their job.

Now suppose one of those police persons was actually more of a rapist and looking for people with a history of (say) drink offenses and were viewed as an unreliable witness, or as their attacker would view them "perfect" victims. Note I've made no comment on the gender of the attacker or the potential victim.

BTW North Wales has a fairly extensive history of sex offenses against boys in council care homes.

None of them got investigate until *very* late in the day.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

AC@11:14

"Because you fancy your daughter's girlfriends? Probably not what you meant but you see there are divers possibilities."

You sir (or madame) win this weeks Richelieu prize.

Nice work.

Climategate: A symptom of driving science off a cliff

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

AC@14:24

"Scientists quite frequently code their own simulations, whether that be solo, in groups or collaborations, or in series; whether by postgrads, postdocs, or academics. "

And judging by the previous batch of climategate emails *very* badly.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Big Brother

Passive drinking

Is whatever the *party* declares it to be.

All else is a thought crime. Report all such cases to the Ministry of Truth.

Future of computing crystal-balled by top chip boffins

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

21st century lithography, 21st century materials 1970s instruction set

BTW Atomic diameters are roughly 1/10 of nm. So *roughly* 10 years is foreseeable in terms of density.

The business about the fin shaped transistors having better *off* characteristics is interesting as in principle that should lower the off current by (potentially) quite a bit.

Handy when you've got an effect that's wasting power at *any* clock frequency even when the processor is doing nothing.

And on the subject of Mr (Dr?) Faggin's pessimism on cognitive computing I'd remind people of AC Clarkes observations about leaned men saying what can and cannot be done.

On the whole depressing.

Climategate 2.0: Fresh trove of embarrassing emails

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@Bob J

Leaving aside your prose style (paragraphs are quite useful) I'll make the following points.

1) The CRU *could* have released all of this information but practiced secrecy and deception. the fact that they have released the underlying data means people can see for *themselves* what the trends are, or rather what chain of filtering/running through software with undocumented parameters/deleting outliers were used to produce the final "product".

2) The "Skeptics" could be AGW advocates greatest supporters *if* they were convinced. As more evidence emerges that results were tweaked, the peer review process subverted and a very cozy relationship between the advocates of AGW and the editors of certain journals all the advocates have managed to do is show they *have* mislead the general public, both at the behest and with the assistance of some parts of both governments and the civil service.

When bluntly put as "You (the people) are in danger, give us *billions* to help you (but we can't really explain why )" don't you think people should be skeptical?

The release of this archive could well have some political objective.

Which (given what's *in* it) is likely to be achieved. Which perhaps advocates of AGW might have considered.

Truth is a very deadly weapon.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Trollface

@swarmboy

Do not feed.

Cheap-as-chips kit smashes Intel's HD video encryption

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Nice little earner for Intel.

Think how many companies they licensed it to.

Still not to worry. They will promise "Thinks will be better with HDCP II" and work another round of security-by-obscurity.

Until the next PhD student cracks that of course.

Note the crypto used by Sky Digital *seems* to remain invulnerable.

But as it was licensed from a company set up by one of the developers of the RSA algorithm you'd expect that.

Punters even more dissatisfied by Virgin Media's package

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Flame

Note. *None* of them manages better than 70%.

So a bit less than 1/3 of *all* the subscribers of the *best* ISP think they are s**t.

Let me suggest this will *never* improve *unless* people make it clear *why* they are leaving and what terms they would come back under.

If *enough* people walk a business either starts taking notice or it's out of business.

I personally would blacklist *any* ISP involved with Phorm or anything like it (TalkTalk's friendly deal with the Chinese for example).

Will Mars rover Curiosity be the last of its nuclear kind?

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

US still has a fair number of working nuclear reactors.

I'll take a wild stab that *some* of them could be loaded with the odd fuel element with Neptunium 237, the elements removed and returned to a central processing site.for low volume re-processing to get the Pu240.

Security *should* be manageable and the extraction process is understood. It's hard to believe that given the scale of US gov nuclear research and production facilities there are *no* unused processing cells where the necessary hardware and chemistry could not be set up with the necessary containment and security.

The question is how *much* Pu240 does the US gov need. These are thermocouple generators (*possibly* moving to Stirling cycle systems), not reactors.

Just a thought.

Global warming much less serious than thought - new science

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Science should explain the *past* as well as predict the future.

And this study seems to do *exactly* that, except the *dire* consequences that *should* have happened (with the *current* models) don't.

But note that quote by the study lead author. A 2c *drop* in temperature caused a 120m drop in *ocean* levels.

Which raises 2 questions.

Is there enough ice in the *remaining* Earth's ice sheets to raise the worlds oceans by 120m if it goes the other way?

How much of the world is <120m above current sea levels?

Because if there is and a lot of land is below that level things can still get pretty bad.

A *proper* scientific theory seeks to explain *all* the observations in its field of study, and make *measurable* predictions about what future observations *should* be (if your theory has trouble doing one or other of these things, it's *not* science).

I'd like *all* sides to do more of *this* kind of science.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

CPU

"From that the report cannot say 'ergo' high CO2 levels also means we will not die (Neanderthal "

That is not what they are arguing.

From the abstract they have re constructed the temperature levels and CO2 levels around at the time of the last Ice Age.

They have run (at least one) climate model with *those* starting points to see if the models predict behavior.

They do not.

When you twiddle the knobs the values you needs to get a model that matches *reality* (rather than the other way around) gives an Earth which (when you dial up the CO2 levels) gives an estimated maximum *probable* rise of 2.3K, not the current 3K with a 66% probability of 4.5K but of 2.3K IE new model *worst* case is still below current model most *probable* outcome.

Caveats. 66% (odd choice of number as for a standard probability model 1 standard deviation is for models giving the right value within a range 68.3% of the time) suggests there is still a fair bit of "tail" on either end with extreme values, but the distribution of the new model seems much *narrower*,

It's a moving target but it looks like they have done a lot more *predictive* work (IE running it forward from known levels to see what happens) which does *not* seem to have been done with other models except in the most *dire* of scenearios.

Saints Row: The Third

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

"kidnapping a gimp-wearing BDSM fetishist "

You make that sound like it's a *bad* thing.

It would seem rock star might consider ploughing some of their cash into upgrading the physics engine for their games framework.

Just a thought.

Huge PDP-11 in a lorry: How I drove computers into schools

John Smith 19 Gold badge
FAIL

Extraction, Tranlate and Load

3 Little words that are often forgotten in migration projects (which *essentially* this was. I'd never heard of this IBM thingy till I read the article. It *sounds* quite impressive. Sort of mult-media and hypertext before those ideas really existed).

The answer the manager seems to have come up with in *each* of these cases was "We'll think of something."

*Heroic* effort but icon for the plan being well, stupid..

Boffin's wall of bees shields farms from stampeding elephants

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

Brilliant, elegant and simple.

And as others would have said, any honey harvested is pure gravy.

I'll get my anti-bee suit on the way out.

Gates: Novell are sore losers, Word trounced WordPerfect

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

@ZeldronGG

Look at the document cited in grocklaw 2 or 3 items above you.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

From the Groklaw PDF an MS strategy begins to emerge.

Identify key apps that would encourage users to migrate to other OS's *if* they moved.

Encourage them *not* to move.

Sucker them into using "selected" API's

Dump the API pre-launch crippling the competition and leaving the way clear for your products (whose developers were warned these API's are "provisional" wink, wink).

Obviously if you're the sort of corporate sociopath for whom words like "fairness", "legal", and "competitive" are just words this routine won't bother you in the slightest. MS's past behavior suggests they have managers who fit that description quite well.

While MS *might* be less inclined to do this today that probably owes more to the fact there are fewer market niches that they don't control the #1 player in on windows and so fear what would happen if *that* player moved to another OS *possibly* taking their user base with them.

Moral of this story. If you compete with MS in *any* market, even one they would *like* to be in and your software depends on windows APIs in *any* way keep your documentation up to date (and retain older copies to see what has been air brushed out) and don't hesitate to fire up a debugger (preferably *not* the MS debugger) if anything starts acting odd.

MS moved into ERP a while ago.

I'd suggest Oracle and SAP better watch out for any "surprise" API changes which just happen to kneecap their products under Windows.

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

Curious, what could this OS feature be that puts users systems in mortal jeopardy

Wordperfect.

The successor to "The jobs not done till Lotus won't run?"

BT Engage IT's big cheese shown the door

John Smith 19 Gold badge
WTF?

WTF was BT Engage?

Dittoo for Basilica and Lynx.

Seriously I'm guessing they are some kind of con-sultancy con-tracting operation for Global Megacorps.

In which case they should have some high profile customers they brag about.

Such as....

Steve Jobs had 'personal moral failures', was no role model

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Coat

"parked in handicapped spaces"

Hmm.

Did "handicapped people make handicapped faces"

"I'm an a**hole" "he's an a**hole" "what an a**hole"

That's mine with the Dennis Leary DVD in the pocket.

Cutting-edge Mirasol display finally comes to e-reader

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

A tablet with a 2 week life expectancy

That's pretty good to me.

One thing Ive never understood about portables is why they don't shift the clock frequency.

Full speed for rendering and caching every possible page from *here*, then shut down the processor to a few Mhz.

How much crunching does it take to detect a) someone has touched the screen b) time to do something about it.

Always assuming you haven't put it on slow scroll so it just has to render chunks, DMA them to the screen and shut down.

Smart meters blamed for Wi-Fi, garage opener interference

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Unhappy

coming to the UK soon

Do you *really* think the UK will buy a specific "Designed for UK" smart meter?

Of course not.

Yes they are normally supplied by outside companies (Landis and Gyre IIRC are quite prominent).

*Some* attempts have been made to check their security (reported by El Reg) and showed them pretty vulnerable (no authentication, ID #s sniffed etc. Shades of the remote adjustable insulin pump). but then the meter mfg stopped making samples available to the testers.

Here's a thought. Do the penetration testing *before* you roll out.

UK nuclear: Walking into darkness with eyes screwed shut

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Boffin

A few notes on renewables.

UK energy generation is roughly 56-60GW and UK power stations have historically been in the 1GW range. 20-255 of it is Nuclear.

The British Hydropower Association estimates the UK has 2GW of viable hydro power in terms of micro hydro systems (so probably eligible for renewable support). Some might freeze in the winter (but likely to be fast flowing enough not to) and likely to last as long as Earth has a viable weather system.

In the late 70s Reading U looked at the problem of tapping heat from North Sea oil wells for on board power for the oil rig. They looked at the idea of using *single* wells (so even a dry well counts) with a down well heat exchanger driving an inert fluid driving a turbine(no noxious chemical being released or needing to be re-injected). Indications were each well could drive 500-1000 Kw.

On shore a single well could probably supply 50 houses. No *big* Uk energy company will bother. However a business *could* be made which offered a package of drill well/install (and replace) generating hardware/system maintainence /billing, which might involve taking their costs off the top and any power not being used by the cluster of houses being "exported" to the national grid.

It would mean *some* home owners would loose some of their property for the well head/generating package but this could be rented from them or offset against their bills.

Anaerobic digestion is believed to be capable of supplying 1GW of UK power needs

*But* if electric vehicles take off things get a *whole* lot worse.

Molten salt reactors using thorium seem to be the only ones that can be designed *not* to depend on precision made fuel elements and to burn nuclear wast as part of their input mix, while tapping off the Xenon isotope which is the *biggest* poison whose accumulation is the main reason for fuel element re-processing. .

As others have pointed out it's virtually impossible that *one* replacement (like wind) can meet *all* power needs (and wind is a *very* poor choice if you're going for just one) so a mix of renewable/sustainable (not sure if geothermal is renewable but with a life time in the *millions* of years I'd say it's sustainable).

BTW I don't think PV's are that bad. The US with JPL as lead agency spent *lots* of money in the 70's to radically lower PV (Especially Silicon but various others as well) and I *strongly* doubt the payback period is now 14 years.

Successful space station shift change by Russian rocket

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Happy

I'd like them to find out how long one of these really is good for.

Soyuz is rated at 206 days (IIRC) but *why* exactly? It's better than 6 months but why not go for the whole year?

The even in 1975 was the Apollo Soyuz Test Program (ASTP) although no other tests were done.

Superhero oil-burping algae will save the world

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

Note that bacteria or plants or whatever is being tweaked to make oil

are *not* evolved to make it in the first place.

Evolution selects for *survival* over the conditions that the source species have encountered over their evolution.

It's *highly* unlikely those conditions would have driven their body chemistry to make them *perfect* oil substitute producers, or anywhere *near* that level of efficiency.

Which suggests there is *lots* to play for.

However there is the issue that whatever is produced will need raw materials (including sunlight) to operate.

When geeks turn Green: Performance tune your energy bills

John Smith 19 Gold badge

There's always the old school draguht hunting method.

AKA "The wet finger"

some of the results of this (especially the *very* high speed air blowing through literally *pinholes* in ceilings) can be quite astonishing.

Boffins one step closer to Terminator vision

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Joke

The state of the art

In exam crib sheets.

New 'plasma lamps' to replace fluorescent bulbs, LEDs

John Smith 19 Gold badge
Thumb Up

*amazing* materials science *if* it works

Shrunk a large *rigid* glass fluorescent tube into a flat *flexible* plate.

Eliminated Mercury from the process.

In principle then can leverage the *decades* of work on phosphors and activator chemistry and tailor the output precisely.

Actually as an *idea* it's surprising this has not been tried *decades* ago.

Of course the driver hardware needs work but that is the same with all current CF technology.

*Cautious* thumbs up on this.