@ rich
Geared at Rich's comment:
Rich I believe your kind of missing the point which the Pirate Bay members are pointing out. Lets say there is a link on google which is indexed to an online MP3 file which is hosted somewhere else. Google linked me to the file and was the road map so to speak to allow me to find that file so why is the site which is hosting it the only one to be brought into court?
Convert that into this case....
Sure the piratebay's site may link to illegal content but so does google, yahoo!, MSN search and just about any other indexing search engine. The argument here is that the files and data are not housed on any pirate bay servers. You may personally see it as technical crap but at the end of the day it is a very big deal. A case like this sets the foundation for a lot of other cases in the court of law. The fact that the lawyers are dismissing the 4 main gentlemen in this cases' technical claims as just technical red tape is in it self as you put it a load of "bollox". The technical aspect of this case is above all the most important.
IT? angle....Simply because it seems it was lost somewhere along the lines with this case.
"Nonsense
By Rich Posted Monday 2nd March 2009 14:35 GMT
While I dislike the various record industry's tactics, what with suing 6 year old girls and grannies and such like, I really can't see how anyone can seriously consider the Pirate Bay as legit. It's not. Simple. It's purpose is to facilitate the copying of pirated stuff. Shit - they even call it "Pirate" Bay for goodness sake.
It reminds me of the interviews with The Shamen about their song 'Ebeneezer Goode'. In interview after interview they denied it had anything to do with drugs.
Of course, years later, when asked the same questions they answered "of course it was about drugs". And of course it was - EVERYONE KNEW it was. It was just convenient to deny it at the time (so that the BBC etc didn't take it off the air). Good song too :-)
The PIrate Bay is the same thing - everyone knows they're talking bollox when when they say "of course it's got nothing to do with piracy". Ask them all the same question in 20 years time when it's all long gone and all but forgotten about.
"