* Posts by Neil Barnes

6254 publicly visible posts • joined 18 Apr 2007

Please do not scare the pigeons – they'll crash the network

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: We had a laser link between two nearby buildings

Heh. I had to teach reporters to use those high-speed (64k!) satellite data links - including, of course, how to use the fancy maps on the top to select the appropriate geostationary satellite, set up an approximate aim, and then use the signal strength meters to get the satellite right on line.

I used to take them on top of Bush House to teach them, and the North Atlantic satellite was the one of choice - nicely lined up over the Houses of Parliament so an easy target even without the maps. I managed to convince some of them that I could see the satellite in daylight, and that there was something wrong with their eyes...

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: We had a laser link between two nearby buildings

A slightly different issue at our Delhi office: the satellite data downlink used to fail, often but not consistently, around lunchtime. Took me a week to discover a vulture was landing on the LNB arm and pushing it out of the dish focus.

Never did discover where the vulture used to eat its breakfast and dinner...

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: 10base2 outside of the building you said?

Triax? Triax is for wimps - TV101 is a connector for men!

(and yes, you don't make the engineers happy when you lay your camera cable over a stretch of 'unused' railway and they have to make the two hundred and two connections to rejoin the cable together again, only four foot eight and a half shorter...)

Tech can do a lot, Prime Minister, but it can't save the NHS

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: Much of the NHS problems, are a result of other issues

It's a funny thing, but any of the big hotel chains can provide rooms for fifty quid a night and still make a profit. While there are further costs ensuing from care requirements (as opposed to medical issues better to be treated in hospital) why on earth does it cost so much more to get sheltered accommodation than a hotel room?

Gordon Ramsay's father-in-law gets six months for hacking sweary super-chef's computer

Neil Barnes Silver badge

There must

have been some interesting conversations with the missus, of late...

Meteor swarm spawns new and dangerous branch

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Mushroom

Oh dear.

Better buy a hard hat then...

Break crypto to monitor jihadis in real time? Don't be ridiculous, say experts

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Black Helicopters

Re: The Elephant in the room

Easy. We want to seek needles in haystacks. Let's simplify matters by making the haystack bigger.

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: "The former policy wonk -

Sadly, 'tis true. He was talking bollocks but she really wasn't helping her cause.

Earth resists NASA's attempts to make red and green clouds

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Off message

Now if they'd instead proposed that the soft-drink-can-sized containers generated a red and white cloud in the shape of a well know, er, soft drink can, a well-known soft drink company would probably have thrown enough money at it to get all the other clouds out of the the way first.

(other well-known soft drinks are available, but probably not in such easy colours.)

Retirement age must move as life expectancy grows, says WEF

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: When they came for the rockclimbers...

@Mad Mike:

I do agree. However, if someone becoming fat is a personal choice and causes load on the NHS, then you paragliding is also a personal choice that could put load on the NHS.

But everything is a personal choice. I drive around twelve hours a week just commuting; I'm much more likely to have an incident driving to a flying site than I am when I get there. I've put a significantly lesser load on the NHS due to flying activities than for other issues in the same time.

And indeed I find my views on getting fat being a personal choice have modified over the years. Yes, it might be down to what you eat vs what energy you expend, but it's arguable that what you eat is very largely controlled - whether you like the idea or not - by people who want to sell you high-profit products, which get that way by being laden with nice cheap fats and sugars. And they are very very good at pushing your buttons and persuading you to purchase...

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: When they came for the rockclimbers...

Paragliding... as you say, when it happens, it hurts. But mostly it doesn't happen at all :)

When it happened to me, I got a nice ride in a volunteer-funded helicopter (and raised a chunk of cash for them later); when I fly abroad I make damn sure that I have insurance that includes search-and-rescue cover as well as the medical needs. But in the UK, we have a free-at-point-of-use medical service paid by me and thee, at ten or eleven percent of our gross salaries. It applies to everyone - child injured by third party, 100mph motorbike crash driver, paraglider pilot, even the failed suicide attempt victim.

There is *nowhere* I can see to apply a line to say 'you do this, therefore you don't get medical care' with the possible exception of 'if you are this overweight/smoke this much/similar, this operation is likely to leave you worse off than you are now, or dead'.

I still fly...

Amazon granted patent to put parachutes inside shipping labels

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Black Helicopters

One of the things you can't do in the UK

under the Air Navigation Orders, is to cause anything to be dropped from an aircraft other than pure water or clean fine sand (ballast, basically). The military get an exemption for go-bang stuff, and parachutists are considered aircraft in their own right (but who on earth would get out of a perfectly good aircraft and hope theirs starts to work on the way down?).

Hard to see which category a parcel of books fits into.

Boffins find evidence of strange uranium-producing bacteria lurking underground

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Mushroom

Re: yes the Uranium is being used as metabolic fuel for the bacteria.

Now if the bacteria absorbs U235 preferentially things could get interesting.....

Only briefly.

Bixby bailout: Samsungers bailing on lame-duck assistant

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Permanantly disabled

Not disabled, removed. One thing that really irritates me about new phones is removing (or not) all the manufacturer's crap that comes with a new one - my current Sony has dozens of default applications I don't use, don't want to use, and don't want to fill up the memory with - but which I can't remove and which Sony spend one day a week updating.

Pointless.

All a phone *needs* is a basic dialler, text messager, and possibly a browser - and a way to access the application store. Let the user decide what he wants on it, rather than filling it with crap he'll never use. Yes, I'm quite aware that my needs are not the same as those of a fifteen year old, but that's rather the point, isn't it? Let *me* put on the phone those things I need, not sell me something, half the memory of which is full of unremovable cruft. (One of the things I really don't need or want is voice input - maybe I'm too old...)

Google to give 6 months' warning for 2018 Chrome adblockalypse – report

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Pay per view

Think of it as evolution in action. We'll very soon find out just how much people want to view clickbait sites.

Social media vetting for US visas go live

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: Then there are the company email addresses

Think you've got fun? I used to work in various hot-spots of the world building TV and radio studios - by definition almost always in the less salubrious areas of the world, usually just before the war started.

Even Miami and New York, come to think of it...

Microsoft's cunning plan to make Bing the leading search engine: Bribery

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: 'duckduckgo is my search engine of choice'

My concern with duckduckgo is that I haven't been able to find out where the money comes from. Searches don't produce a lot of useful information - indeed your comment about Yahoo partnership is the first time I saw it.

Sons of IoT: Bikers hack Jeeps in auto theft spree

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: Alarms

Hah.

I discovered the hard way that the electronic locks on my car can be defeated by a kitchen knife: a cut through the bundle going into the door persuades the controller that the mechanical lock has been properly opened using a key. The controller then politely opens all the deadlocks.

At a guess, the maker used cheap logic on the controller input: either ground or pull-up (so the cut wire gives a pull-up) instead of using the elementary security input of two resistors and an analogue input that would pull to half rail in the case of an open circuit wire...

No names, since the flaw is almost certainly common across the entire range of vehicles from this manufacturer, with whom I am still in discussion.

NASA Sun probe named for solar wind boffin Eugene Parker

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: Sun Probe

Ye gods and little fishies - I remember watching that episode of Thunderbirds in, what early seventies?

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Happy

So presumably, to avoid the high temperatures,

They'll be going at night?

EU axes geo-blocking: Upsets studios, delights consumers

Neil Barnes Silver badge

So will we be able to see the full BBC iplayer site through Europe now?

See title... could be some interesting negotiations coming up regarding repeat fees and the like.

I suspect that the net effect of this might be to decrease, rather than increase, the amount of material viewable across Europe.

US laptops-on-planes ban may extend to flights from ALL nations

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: secure storage

As above; using a laptop on a plane is a good way to get the screen broken, but for sure it's not going in the hold as is.

But it seems not beyond the beyond the bounds of possibility to have some sort of locker system, perhaps mounted into a standard hold carrier; I give them the laptop, they scan it, stick it in a spare slot, and give me the key to that slot (and perhaps a voucher for a replacement laptop :)

The issue about hand luggage is annoying but obvious: if airlines want to charge for hold baggage, of *course* people will take things for free into the plane. The majority of 'hand baggage' isn't - it's there simply because it's cheaper and quicker to get out at the other end, if you don't have to wait for the carousel. Maybe there are options here to explore regarding what may be taken into the cabin.

Fat-thumbed dev slashes Samba security

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Interesting...

My mint machines got a samba update last night/this morning - is this the fix for the issue or something else? It wasn't listed as #1 critical.

Try not to scream: Ads are coming to Amazon's Alexa – and VR goggles

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Megaphone

OK, you can scream now. ®

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaagh!

Opposable thumbs make tablets more useful says Microsoft Research

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Why?

Why would you want to increase the 'productive capability' of a device intended mostly as a sales channel, with the user as the target?

Amazing new boffinry breakthrough: Robots are eating our brains

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: @ The Onymous Coward

Indeed.

There's something a bit ridiculous that we're working patterns that have survived basically unchanged from agricultural times; when you had to work all the hours of daylight every day (time off Sunday to go to church, so you could be lectured about your unimportance in the great scheme of things) just to make sure you had enough to eat in the cold dark days of winter.

Sometimes I wonder just how many (or how few) jobs are actually necessary - would we really, for example, be any worse off if some of the technical toys had never been invented?

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: The workforce of the future?

Thanks, Mats - for some reason I had Daniel F Galouye in mind, but couldn't place it.

Neil Barnes Silver badge

The workforce of the future?

Welcome to the post-scarcity society... it's being swept under the carpet but we're going to need to think about it.

Since I was a child in the sixties I've been promised (along with energy too cheap to meter and flying cars) so much leisure time that I won't know what to do with it. I'm still waiting, but it might just come along just after I retire, in time to stuff things up royally for granddaughter unless it's *very* carefully managed.

The export of jobs to cheap labour/zero contract gig economy is not a lasting solution because sooner or later there aren't any cheap labour pools left - and if you have a world-wide economy that relies on people buying stuff they don't need and throwing it away, you'd better make damn sure that people have money to buy things with.

For some reason I'm thinking of a science fiction short story in which robots are making widgets in one building, and in the next, robots are busily using them up and wearing them out...

We are 'heroes,' says police chief whose force frisked a photographer

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Bollocks.

The police should know better than to ask the question - the police should know the law.

I am a photographer. I am not a professional photographer and neither am I a journalist, but nonetheless I have exactly the same rights as any other person in a public place. If the police are not trying to arrest me, or in hot pursuit, I don't even have to say hello to them - though politeness dictates I probably would.

But there is exactly *no* reason why I should *ever* be required not to be a dick to avoid a kicking. My avoidance of dickness is for my own self respect, not because the police would give me said kicking.

tl;dr: stand on your rights and make sure *your* public servants observe them

p.s. want to see my images, officer? Certainly, they're be ready when I develop them. And no, you may not withdraw the dark slide.

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: About time the photographers struck back

I've never been bounced by the police while engaging in photography or filming, even as part of a news crew (though they have on occasion politely pointed out that my vantage point was perhaps more exposed than they considered safe from known-to-be-armed suspects).

I have however been bounced - quite properly, though for laughable reasons - by security guards. Most recently, from a large outdoor shopping area of some architectural interest, in which I was using a 4x5 camera on top of a seven foot tripod. Taking images with that equipment takes several minutes just to set up, and I had made half a dozen images from various locations within the site when the security chap came up, identified himself, and politely told me that the area was private property. As such, the owners had the right to forbid photography within it - so I moved. No issue - though he did not have an answer to the question of mobile phones and the cameras therein. Also no issue taking a very similar image from outside the boundary - unmarked, but only a couple of feet from where I was,

Nice to meet a fellow in a sometimes tricky job doing it well and also properly briefed on the rules. As the article states: it is permissible to photograph anyone or anything visible from public land, with very few exceptions - in particular, if a building or area is covered by the official secrets act it is clearly marked 'thou shalt not photograph'.

As others have pointed out - in this case, the police employee was strictly in the wrong. If she had concerns about the photographer's actions, she should have asked one of her police colleagues to deal; as it was she was throwing her weight about, and that's not acceptable.

He was certainly in the right and in spite of the senior officer's later comment there was neither need nor requirement for him either to explain his actions, give his name, or accompany the employee anywhere. He might be considered a bit of a dick for standing on his rights but I don't blame him - I would have done the same and for a simple reason: if you don't stand on your rights, somehow they mysteriously disappear.

I wonder how long the lady in question was bollocked for behind closed doors?

Linux homes for Ubuntu Unity orphans: Minty Cinnamon, GNOME or Ubuntu, mate?

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Mint Cinnamon security defaults?

Scott, could you elaborate on this please? Perhaps in a different article?

First cardboard goggles, now this: Google's cardboard 'DIY AI' box powered by an RPi 3

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Terminator

Well, indeed.

I want an AI that can look at the windows I have open and make sense of them, e.g.:

"hey, take that block of cells from the spreadsheet that define my state machine table and turn it into a C array, complete with all the squiggly bits in place and some sane comments, please."

Yes, I know I can code something to do that, but that's rather the point, isn't it: an AI to be more than a gimmick requires a lot of free context as well as the intelligence to know what to do with it. The task itself isn't difficult; understanding what the task is, is.

Gig economy tech giants are 'free riding' on the welfare state, say MPs

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: Time for a turnover limit on IR35?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2tWwHOXMhI

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Finally someone's noticed?

It's been obvious for years that companies who insist that their 'employees' are free-agent contractors are doing it mostly to avoid the legal requirements of an actual employment contract with all the rights and requirements that this would encapsulate. Y'know, the little things that hardly matter like sick and holiday pay, job security, pensions and the like. Things like requiring these 'contractors' to pay consolidated damages when they can't provide their contracted service is surely only a courtesy detail...

But it has the wonderful advantage that it's not the company that's underpaying their 'employees'; it's their 'contractors' who aren't working hard enough, or who have failed to negotiate a suitable rate - and of course it's the 'contractors' who are blamed because they suddenly have to go cap in hand to the welfare state. It's not the company's fault, naturally...

That someone in full-time employment, no matter how it is disguised, requires state aid to live is unjust, inequitable, unfair, and a damned disgrace. The sooner this sort of employment is at least severely curtailed, the better.

'I feel violated': Engineer who pointed out traffic signals flaw fined for 'unlicensed engineering'

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Career...

So, over forty years, I've:

- started as a trainee engineer with three years of on-the-job and formal training

- held the posts of engineer, senior engineer, and engineer-in-charge

- been a project manager

- and for the last few years I've been doing embedded hardware and software engineering

Yes, I've got graduate and post-graduate degrees (in maths and computing) - but none of those posts relied on them; most of my career was in broadcasting. And I was never a chartered engineer, though a number of previous bosses have offered to sponsor me.

When I started out, I couldn't even spell 'enginner' and now I are one. Except in Oregon, it seems.

Last year's ICO fines would be 79 times higher under GDPR

Neil Barnes Silver badge

The problem is...

that a massive fine that potentially kills the business both puts a lot of people out of work, and removes a service that presumably a lot of people are using. It might not be the best service there is, but it's the one they've got.

What they should be doing is making the directors responsible and fining/jailing *them*.

Uber cloaked its spying and all it got from Apple was a slap on the wrist

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: @Buzzwords Symbiotic relationship

>> So what would happen if Uber suddenly lost 30-40% of its customers?

At a quick guess, I'd assume they'd just lose 30-40% less than they're currently losing.

Linux 4.11 delayed for a week by NVMe glitches and 'oops fixes'

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Good lord, man, testing software?

What's wrong with just throwing it out there and letting the punters find the bugs, like everyone else seems to?

Base specs leak for Windows 10 Cloud – Microsoft's wannabe ChromeOS assassin

Neil Barnes Silver badge

I wonder if this hardware

will allow replacement of the OS? I'm not holding my breath...

Farewell Unity, you challenged desktop Linux. Oh well, here's Ubuntu 17.04

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: Good riddance, but..

Quite. Gnome 2 had it right; Unity and Gnome 3 didn't (for me; your mileage may vary and that's why we like Linux!) which is why I moved to Mint. With all the effects turned off.

PACK YOUR BAGS! Boffins spot Earth-size planet most likeliest yet to harbor alien life

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Flame

Re: Of course, any life found anywhere would be super-duper exciting anyway.

Call me a dumb Earth-chauvinist, but I am having a hard time envisioning what would thrive at that gravity, outside of very primitive lifeforms.

Anything floating in water? They shouldn't have an issue. Except possibly with fire - bit of a bugger when the smoke's too heavy to get out of the way of the flame you're trying to keep going on a pond...

Back to the future: Honda's new electric car can go an incredible 80 miles!

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Mushroom

Re: Not all that silly

"Also, how much energy is used to make hydrogen?"

About a universe full.

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: One of the factors I'd be interested in

Back of the envelope calculation: In the UK there are about twenty million cars, doing perhaps 12,000 miles a year (okay, it's a conservative envelope; I do three or four times that but never mind), It seems to take about thirty or so horsepower to cruise at 70mph; call it 20kW. Maybe 15kW as an average? And a finger in the air 30mph as an overall average?

So, 12,000 / 30 hours * 15kW * 20e6 = 120e12Wh - 120TWh. According to Wikipedia, the UK generates around 335TWh a year. Which implies that to move completely to electric cars, the UK would need to increase its generating capacity *and* all its distribution infrastructure by a minimum of 30% - and that doesn't even consider vehicles other than cars.

Troll it your way: Burger King ad tries to hijack Google Home gadgets

Neil Barnes Silver badge

Re: I'm getting tired of people constantly playing the victim role...

Other other people leave their voice dictation on and get upset when other other other people actually say something to which the system responds. Of course it's those other other other people who are to blame, right?

I'm not sure the victim *is* to blame here. He is sold something which, to those who are unaware of the technical details, appears to be the electronic equivalent of the perfect human secretary/PA - knows everything about your which is relevant to the job, but maintains a discreet silence about it outside the office. Knows when your partner's birthday is, and will arrange flowers when you forget. Knows which set of books to show the revenue... knows how to spell the words you don't; remembers all the things you ought not to forget, but do.

But as the man said, sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. For most people, that's what it is. They're sold a spell which doesn't work quite as expected, made by some of the brightest and best magicians in the world, and I don't think it's unreasonable that they blame the wizard when it goes wrong. c.f. The Sorcerer's Apprentice...

BT's spam blocker IDs accident claims as top nuisance call

Neil Barnes Silver badge

it could divert 1.6 billion nuisance calls a year.

"if all its customers signed up to BT Call Protect"

Surely it could do this without its customers having to sign up?

FCC kills plan to allow phone calls on planes – good idea or terrible?

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Headmaster

There seem to be two main sorts of mobile phone users

- those who feel the details of their pointless business activities are so important that they should be shouted all over the public arena, and

- those who can't wait to tell our Sharon what our Kev said last night

People actually using the phone as a means to communicate *important meaning* are so rare as to be invisible. In general, using a phone in public is the audible equivalent of writing graffiti on the walls. With poor spelling and grammar.

Alabama man gets electrocuted after sleeping with iPhone

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Alert

Re: everything's a lot better nowadays

Think of it as evolution in action.

The early years of electrical use in the home are a catalogue of interesting ways to die, often because the original installers had no idea that there would be any use beyond lighting.

Lochs, rifle stocks and two EPIC sea gates: Thomas Telford's Highland waterway

Neil Barnes Silver badge
Headmaster

Indeed.

Please keep to the original measures, and to the original precision: e.g. 35lbs ~= 16kg.

Recruiters considered really harmful: Devs on GitHub hit with booby-trapped fake job emails

Neil Barnes Silver badge
WTF?

Not so much 'why's it still possible' as 'why was it ever...'

I must be some sort of Luddite.

After playing with computers for, what, forty years now, I *still* am unable to fathom why anyone, ever, thought it was a good idea to build software that allows this kind of thing. A word processor is for tangling/mangling words, not for downloading random software.

Since Joe Public (and probably most Reg readers) lack the time, inclination, or ability to see what a macro is going to do once it's opened, they're going to click 'allow' anyway. It's not that Joe is stupid, it's that he doesn't expect what he gets: in his eyes, getting something like this from opening a document is on the same order of things as sticking bread in the toaster and getting a fried egg back. It's not something that should even be able to happen.

Strange Mirai botnet brew blamed for powerful application layer attack

Neil Barnes Silver badge
WTF?

What is it with all these malware writers?

Not enough toilet doors to scribble on?