* Posts by Robert Hill

563 publicly visible posts • joined 11 Apr 2007

Page:

Pain ray really killer ray gun, many goats dead, says 'expert'

Robert Hill

@Steve Mann

ROTFLMFAO...now you just need to explain to our Yank readers what a "rasher" is...

HINT to our US readers: it has nothing to do with a skin condition, more like a pig that has lost his skin...

Customers give Dell the finger over keyboard screw-up

Robert Hill

Want the "China Price" on your equippment???

Then get used to keyboards designed by Chinamen that don't touch type with the Roman alphabet. I would bet £10 the reason for that screw-up is because the supplier wanted to use the same keys for the left and right shift, one mould rather than two. Probably saves $0.05 per keyboard.

And you can get lead paint on your children's toys, contaminated heparin, and anti-freeze in your toothpaste.

Oh, yeah, and massive layoffs in your own country.

You get what you buy people...

Asus Eee PC 900 Linux Edition

Robert Hill
Go

@ Michael

As a serious amature photog, I can make the case that ANYTHING less than a quad-core, 4 Gigs of RAM, RAID-equipped desktop with dual 24" screens is insufficient for photo and video editing. Really - try it once and you can never go back.

But the average user doesn't have that, and uses various amounts of patience, the hand tool, and zooming to accomplish their tasks. Gets the job done (unless working with high-def video streams in real-time, for which there IS no solution other than what I described above). The 701 and such just demands MORE patience and zooming...OK, not great, but doable certainly.

I can almost guess that you are an American, unused to the mobile society that we have here in the EU (and exists in Asia). When the population uses mass transit as much or more than cars, then portability matters a great deal. The 701 is the perfect machine to take in a small messenger bag (even a manbag) while walking around a city and not even know it is there. You pack it as an accessory, not as a laptop - that is what I see as it's true value.

No, I don't own one - my Toshiba M200 still works for me too well, and I like a tablet form factor sometimes. But if I replaced it, I would definately get the Asus.

For everyone debating the 900, you can view it as Asus already HAS the 700, and is just expanding their model line-up and price points. From a marketing point of view, choice is always good. I would not be surprised to see an upgraded 750 or something in a few months, with a larger screen in the same 700 body perhaps...selling at £240 or so. Maybe with the Atom.

Posting with GO, as it's the least used symbol on the forum and feels discriminated against.

Lesbians turn on lesbians in battle of Lesbos

Robert Hill
Paris Hilton

Webcam...

All I want to know is - who has the URL for the Eressos resort live webcam!?!?!

I'll be on Google the rest of the day, methinks...

Paris, just because she has as little to do with IT as this story.

HP pulls memory Missing Link from bottle of beer

Robert Hill
Boffin

CLOUDS???

Why do computing clouds even fit in this dicussion? I mean, the one place you DON'T need persistant power-off memory is a 24x7 shared compute cloud, which presumably you would never want to turn off anyway. And standard DRAM seems to work just fine there.

Now, on portable, non-cloud computers, this stuff sounds interesting. Laptops with insta-on rather than sleep, mobile smartphones that don't take 3 minutes to boot, solid-state airplane blackboxes that never lose their memory, etc. A thousand and one uses, really.

But NOT in compute clouds...

Plasma TV components applied to password cracking

Robert Hill
Black Helicopters

@ MarmiteToast

LG probably didn't rush them out the door (although they are far from my favored brand of anything). It's just that the use of FPGAs allows software updates all through the development and production cycle - which probably was a concern in the early HDTV days, with the possibility of standards changes and incompatibilities arising. Also, while an ASIC would be cheaper per chip (and used less power), they have large design and setup costs, which may not have been worthwhile in something that didn't sell in very, very large numbers (i.e., first or second generation plasma TVs).

WRT the article, it appears that the tinkerers have finally managed to do something that NSA probably did about 10-15 years ago...woopie. Makes you wonder what they have been listening in on all this time. I am beginning to think that paper, a toothpick and lemon juice is the only secure communications protocol available these days...

Supermarket offers phones for a fiver

Robert Hill

That Nokia 1112 is actually quite good

Small, easy to use, and has a great battery life...used one loaned by my company for a while, and was quite impressed. Even one of my gadget hound friends used one for a year or two because it was so retro.

Two points against El Reg author though, for not saying if these were bundled with a contract, pay as you go, or SIM bare.

Robert Hill

Ooops, yes he did...

include the plan, sorry.

AMD to intro 45nm quad-core Phenom this quarter

Robert Hill

Yawn...

These quad cores are great, but until they can actually give a clock speed 150% higher than my current, aging AMD64 4400+ (@2.2 Ghz), it's just not worth upgrading. So few apps really use more than one core it's hard to see the benefit over a dual-core. And don't talk to me about "multiple apps": when you run move than one or two apps, your disks, video card and memory usually become the bottlenecks, not just the CPU.

QUAD CORE: the solution to a problem very few home users actually have...but a great marketing win for someone.

Ubuntu man Shuttleworth dissects Hardy Heron's arrival

Robert Hill
Thumb Up

@ steogede

ROTFLMAO...wishing I caught that too...

I was in Redmond for the first time in 1989 for OS/2 corporate developer's conferences, so it was pretty obvious there was no NT, and wouldn't be for a few years until MS abandoned partner IBM and then developed NT on their own using the base of OS/2 technology cross-fertilized with VMS when Cutler joined from DEC. So, yeah, you nailed that one perfectly...

Robert Hill
Flame

@ Don Mitchell

You want an OS that is "novel and innovative", and you claim to work in the IT field? Where have you been hiding matey?

There was BE OS, the most multimedia friendly OS ever designed. There was NEXT STEP, one of the most original OSes ever developed, the decendent of which is now OS X on the Mac. There was Plan 9, designed for networked machines to operate in parallel. There was AmigaOS, possibly the best desktop environment ever designed for the home.

The list goes on and on...the world has not suffered from a lack of novel and innovative OSes. The sad fact is that the more innovative and novel the OS, the less the public acceptance of it - that even goes back to the days of Windows 1.0, the DOS community screamed bloody murder.

We, the public, have a terrible history of dissing and rejecting "novel and innovative". The IT community does not want to trust it or pay for it, and user's don't want to learn. The ONLY exception I have seen to that is, ironically, the Macintosh - I remember queues to get onto the Macs in my university busienss school comp lab, even with rows of empty PCs running DOS. Those non-IT majors really flocked to Excel instead of Lotus 1-2-3...

So how does a new OS come to market? Well, firstly it must have a history that IT can trust, with inbuilt security and application availability. It must be also be VERY low cost - IT budgets aren't getting any larger. And lastly, it must be something that users can accept easily - and that means looking and feeling like what they are familiar to.

Ironically, Ubuntu happens to fulfill those criteria better than anything else on the market right now. Linux is known secure and industrial strength, and the major IT applications support it - everything from massive database apps to personal productivity desktop applications. In terms of cost, it is mostly support training for the IT staff, and THAT is actually getting cheaper all the time as people grow up learning Linux. And lastly, what many see as copying Windows is Ubuntu actually just providing a nice, warm welcome to those switching.

That's not a bad strategy, and frankly Shuttleworth is admirable for getting a lot of it right. I CAN do low level work with a traditional Linix distro (used RH/CentOS a lot on servers), but frankly I have no desire to. I want an environment that is graphical and friendly as possible, so that I don't have to work as hard. I like the ability to still call up python and write a script, or even do some C development for some stuff...but day in, day out, I want it graphical.

And I await HH with baited breath...

Robert Hill
Flame

@ Antoinette Lacroix

Ubuntu is much more than "almost-Windows", and I say that as someone who started using and writing app code for Windows in oh, 1990 or so.

The body of community software in Linux that is available for Ubuntu is very impressive - not always the most polished, but usually very capable and in some cases exceeding any Windows equivalent. This is particularly true of academic, scientific, and other niche applications. But it also applies to common office apps - OpenOffice is a great alternative to MS Office for nearly any user (yeah, I know it runs on Windows too...).

Moreover, Linux actually has a MUCH better 64-bit environment - a lot less code knashing and compatiblity layers. There are parts of XP and even Vista that contain code to maintain compatibility with old 16-bit Windows 3.1 applications...very grungy, and very creaky, and very slow.

And we won't even get INTO the DRM stuff in Vista - there are so many "tumblers" and critical timing detectors running in the background in Vista to maintain DRM in all audio and video channels that the performance even on good hardware takes a HUGE hit. I happen to be a supporter of DRM, I happen to believe in the enforcement of copywrite to ensure that we will have a good source of music and movies that are well-produced and not amatuer crapola. However, the MS way of ensuring it wreaks havok under the covers of the OS, results in massive performance hits, and is almost unstable in some instances.

Lastly, Compwiz gives so much of the swooshy Aero type interface for Ubuntu - but doesn't need a next-generation video card to power it. It runs just fine on my 7600GT, even with all effects, transparencies, and rotating cubes enabled. WHY can't MS get Aero to do that on older cards???? I can see needing a 3D card to play excellent 3D games, but just to run the desktop?

So yes Virginia, er Antoinette, Ubuntu really DOES have some large advances on Windows, rather than merely being a copy of it. And that is why when 8.02 is out I will delete my dual-boot partitions and install a Linux-only environment with VM Ware to keep XP running in it's own little box for when I absolutely need it (Eve-online and Photoshop for home, and Visio and MS Project for work).

You can not give anything you like, but you are in luck - ignorance is cheap. Just like Paris...

Pirate Bay-probing cop on Warner Brothers payroll

Robert Hill

So much garbage in this thread...

1) Region coding exists for one simple reason: every studio wants to release their blockbusters during the peak movie-going times of the year. Only one problem - each area of the globe has DIFFERENT peak times! In the US the months of June through August are peak...but in the EU most people avoid the movies and go on vacation. The peak in the EU is actually around the winter holidays. In the southern hemisphere, things are of course reversed again... It has nothing to do with subtitles or production issues - it is PLANNED. Anyway, as much as I hate region coding, I can understand why studios do it - to support and protect the cinemas from extinction in areas that lag the US in their peak times. (BTW - if you all didn't know about peak viewing times across the globe, get off the computer and do some travelling...)

2) Watching a documentary on The Who the other night, it re-iterated that they had an absolute shite contract for much of their early career, even by the standards of the day. Hmmm. They still all drive much better cars and live in much better castles than I do (R.I.P. Keith Moon however). Saying that you refuse to pay for your music in "protest" of how little the artists get is just laughable coming from a bunch of guys that couldn't even afford to pay their bar tabs for a weekend if given a year to do it.

3) As mentioned by AC above, EVERY artist now has the total ability to opt-out of the record company system. EVERYONE can self-record, self-promote, and distribute content via the internet. The fact that so many artists still opt to be involved with record companies indicated that a) artists need the financial investments that record companies make early in their career and b) desire the long-term stability that a contract can give with a label later in their careers. Look at El Reg's IT readers : how many of you are genuine contracters for yourselves, working for your own company rather than working for someone else? Why is that, given that contract positions generally pay more? Why do you think musicians are any different in their outlook?

If musicians thought that recording contracts are such bad deals, these days they would opt-out of the system in droves. The fact that only a handful of high-profile artists have opted-out (and like consultants, it's usually very established ones) shows that most ranting here about "artists rights" are really about "freetards rights". So shut up and pay the people that wrote, funded and produced the content you are enjoying...or it won't be there forever, at least not as you know it now.

Ballmer bitch slaps Vista

Robert Hill

Thanks for the advice Stevie B...

What I actually have arrived at by your "come to Jesus" whinging is the following software aquisition strategy:

1) Format harddrives

2) Install Ubuntu 8.04 64-bit on primary partition

3) Install VMWare for Linux (just purchased)

4) Install Windows XP under VMWare for when I need it

5) Use Compwiz for my eye candy (which runs just fine on my current nVidia 7600GT graphics card) rather than bloated Aero....

Again, Steve, my thanks for being open. I met you in 1990 at a corporate developer's meeting in Redmond...my opinion of you hasn't changed one bit...

Korean astronaut recounts 'ballistic' Soyuz re-entry

Robert Hill

@Aubry Thonon

You must remember, she was the BACKUP Korean astronaut, who went up after the primary candidate disgraced himself during training by removing some "classified" training documents from the training center and brought them back to his dorm to study at night...

Good marks to the American astronaut, who didn't even blanch when confronted with homespun Russian astrotech...10gs ain't pretty, and even harder for a woman who has been in orbit for a long period of time to deal with. Too bad Danica Patrick got all the press for woman's achievement's this weekend...

Olympus µ1010 compact camera

Robert Hill

Should have reviewed the u1030SW...much more interesting camera..

and the problem with your memory cards is that there are FOUR types of xD cards:

- standard grade, which are slow and have no extra functions enabled

- Type M : which are faster and enable panorama features (even Fuji's cards work if Type M I believe)

- Type H : High-speed, for faster shot to shot, and panorama (rare to find, and expensive)

- Type M+ : coming out in the next month, will enable high-res video recording without the current 10second max record time, until card memory runs out.

I suspect you had a cheap standard grade card, which has been outdated for at least two years. Anyone with a recent Oly wants a Type M or M+ to get access to the features.

The Oly 1030SW is the camera you should have reviewed though - a 28mm wide-angle lens with internal 3.8x optical zoom, shockproof, waterproof, and same sensor. A much more interesting and unique camera...

IBM smacks rivals with 5.0GHz Power6 beast

Robert Hill

@Valdis Filks

Hitachi and Amdahl pushed air-cooled solutions because they were competing with IBM on price, whereas IBM was compteting on having better performance. IBM knew that Emitter-Coupled Logic (ECL) was a faster clocking solution than CMOS or NMOS at the time, and that despite the heat they would have a performance advantage on the very heaviest workloads.

Eventually, CMOS and NMOS gained in clock speeds, and even IBM made the transition - but acknowledged that the individual processors were slower than their predecessors. Today's energy-efficient CMOS processors require massive paralleization to compete with either more complex CMOS designs (i.e., the original scorching Pentium IV, et al) or ETL successors.

And what has the parallization of processors brought? An acknowledgement that for many sorts of problems, we can't effectively write parallel code. That's why Intel and others are crash-researching parallel coding techniques. That is why IBM continues to push the speed of individual processors, even to the point of resucitating water-cooling in the data center.

Now, that's not to say that MANY problems don't decompose well into parallel solutions: parallel databases have revolutionised data warehousing, clusters are wonders of mainstream application hosting, etc. But for several, important, and PROFITABLE types of workloads (esp. some scientific work and mathematical work, as well as some database solutions) individual processor performance are the limiting factor.

Lastly, I would be curious to see how the water cooling on these corresponds to the watercooling in old mainframes. Are they running the pipes within the case to radiator fans (as in a watercooled PC), or running them external to the case via datacenter cooling lines as in the old mainframes? In short, what is the real level of complexity?

HTC Touch Dual smartphone

Robert Hill

Original TOUCH rocked...for the day

Wow, El Reg manages to say that a Version 2.0 phone that was introduced nearly a year ago is BETTER than the original, and therefore the original sucked?

Wasn't the Touch the phone that LAUNCHED HTC as an independant vendor of phones, rather than an OEM-only provider? A phone so cutting edge at the time that it frankly had no competitors in the small, like, sexy, touch-oriented camp but the iPhone?

I've had my Touch since the first week it came out, and I can only say that I will be happy to upgrade it for newer features and HSDA (probably to a HTC Polaris or a 3G iPhone), but am in no rush to do so...

And for the person saying no GPS is a loser, the HTC Polaris is essentially a Touch+ with a GPS, but no sliding keyboard...

By the Power of Power, IBM goes Power System

Robert Hill

@Peter Gathercole

The components are the same or very similar, but what has always been the differential has been the interconnects - the mainframes having a highly unique high-speed backplane, the SP/6000 having the SP High Speed Switch, and the rest using cluster interconnects. Each uniquely suited to do it's own thing for the target market (mainframe = Hulking Giant with lots of users, the SP/6000 series for parallel scientific work, and the clusters for commodity applications and mid-range databases).

Robert Hill

AS/400? PAH! Noobie...

It's still a System/32 at heart...with 8" floppys, a band teletype printer, and a single 10GB harddrive...

Creative threatens developer over home-brewed Vista drivers

Robert Hill
Dead Vulture

Alternatives to Creative...

OK, people have asked, so here you go:

Top of the price list is probably the new-ish Razer Barracuda AC-1 Gaming Audio Card - most stuff Razer makes is actually pretty decent, even the keyboards they source for Microsoft, but their support is rumoured to be bad at times. Very gaming oriented, so not sure I would use it for the last word in audiophile music or computer synthesis, but excellent for gamers. Has some issues with 64-bit VISTA, but not 32-bit at present, apparently.

http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?WebProductID=519889

Next on the hit parade, the Asus Xonar D2X Ultra Fidelity 7.1, in two flavours of bus interface. Asus does most hardware right, and it's not too badly priced. Working 64-bit VISTA drivers, needs a well-documented registry hack with a few motherboards to avoid resource conflicts. Very solid, very good sounding, lots of features.

http://www.scan.co.uk/Products/ProductInfo.asp?WebProductID=763587

And a "budget" option, the HT Omega Striker 7.1 DTS Connect, which has a decent soundchip (the same as in the Razer for double the price), and supposedly good support. Has only recently had good VISTA drivers come out, but supposedly are now OK including 64-bit VISTA.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16829271001

If you want computer music or HTPC use, then the M-Audio Delta Audiophile 192 are the best you can easily buy, have working VISTA 32-bit, and beta 64-bit (which they say they are committed to perfecting). Works out of box with Ubuntu and other Linuxes. I've used the older Audiophile 2496 for years, and loved it for music and synthsis. Would be using it now, but out of slots in this mobo for now...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16829121008

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16829121120

The point is, there are LOTS of options to avoid the indefensible Creative corporate shenanigans (OK, ^$£*-ing shite). I was primed to buy a new pair of their 2.0 speakers (the T60s I think), but not after this - I'll stick to M-Audio or Altec Lansings, thank you very much. Any manufacturer who refuses to upgrade drivers to make you buy an upgrade simply deserves the loss of business...M-Audio 2496s have been out around 5 years, and THEY got working VISTA drivers...

A dead, diseased bird, because that's what needs to be put in the bed of every Creative executive...

Mac is the first to fall in Pwn2Own hack contest

Robert Hill
Jobs Horns

Not really a Safari issue?

I first thought this was a damning indictment of Safari, a non-battlehardened browser, then I realized that the ability to reverse telenet into a PC wasn't browser-based, but OS-based.

OUCH!

So OS X allows remote telenets from TCP-IP sessions it has established without further verification of the other party, eh? No additional log-ins needed?

That is a gaping hole, a whole lot of hole, if that is truely the case.

Bad flaw Apple...very bad flaw.

Apple orders 10m 3G iPhones - analyst

Robert Hill
Jobs Halo

@Dave

It is both speed and latency...for those of us that actually USE smartphones as something other than Facebook terminals, like synch to the office Exchange servers for emails, edit documents we download, and then send them on, 3G will be a massive upgrade. On my HTC Touch 2.5G phone, I now start my phone synching, and then get a coffee and a shower if I know I have docs with attachments to download.

Now with Apple thinking of Exchange compatibility, and a 3G model coming out, AND HTC dropping the ball on the video drivers on their new phones, I think I can wait until June to upgrade to an iPhone - and I can't believe I just said that, I've never owned an Apple product in my life. But that says as much about my current opinion of HTC's refusal to license the correct drivers for their newer phones from Qualcomm as it does about the appeal of Apple...

Yahoo! cuddles Google's bastard grid-child

Robert Hill
Boffin

CPU efficiency can benefit both....

Given greater CPU work for a given set of hardware, certainly costs and electical power usage are reduced. But increasing the total CPU work available can also enable new levels of data analysis and algorithms that were unfeasable without the horsepower for them. A decade ago I helped a major airline upgrade from an SGI sever to a cluster of IBM SP2 supercomputers and massive storage arrays - and they began using data an entire magnitude larger and more complete in their load forcasting calculations. They did re-write the software (had to paralleize it explicitly as they moved from SMP to MPP, and change the calculations to use more granular data), but the notion of what they were doing didn't change - just the data and ability to sift through more of it. Apparently they gained quite better results, once they tuned the new forecasting system's parameters.

Google's riches rely on ads, algorithms, and worldwide confusion

Robert Hill
Thumb Down

Ad Score == Consumer Credit Score

There are a ton of paralles between your AdSense scores and your Credit Score. Both are blackbox. Both are designed to be hard to game. Both are basically unappealable. Both end up costing you more money if they are bad.

To treat Google different because they use a similarly obscure function as banks, credit rating companies, credit card companies, etc. is just plain ludicrist.

You expected Google to "answer your questions" for scoring? Huh. I have a good idea then: call Lloyds TSB, HSBC, Citibank, GE Money, Equifax and a few other financial firms and ask them to discuss their credit risk scoring models in detail. Just "answer a few of your questions". Your ears will ring with how fast they hang up the phone on you.

Google spent a lot of money to build those models, and they have a huge impact on company performance. Why on earth you expect them to discuss them so that they can be reverse engineered or tuned escapes me totally...and your need to repeatedly castigate them about their non-disclosure reeks of someone being paid either by the word, or by the contrived controversy.

Once more, an El Reg journo with no comprehension of the outside world methinks...thumbs down on the article, even if the fundamental explanation of AdWords was nice to read.

Shell says still 'undecided' on massive offshoring plan

Robert Hill

@Campbell

Great points, but I think it misses one key issue:

When you outsource, you will INEVITABLY lose internal expertise, both at the developer level, but also at the strategic management level. And THAT will erode competitive ability down the road - not in the next year, but maybe 3 to 5.

I have written so much about the falacies of outsourcing that I find my fingers just can't write any more...let's just say the only ones making money at it are the outsourcing companies themselves, and it is foolish of Shell not to realize that.

Adobe pulls bug-riddled Photoshop update

Robert Hill
Pirate

Adobe rips off the UK consumer badly...

Adobe needs to clean up their UK pricing policy before they can EVER be considered a company worthy of your coinage. For purchasers in the UK, they literally charge almost the same number of UK pounds as they do in US dollars - for a product that you DOWNLOAD off their site, requires almost no support (and they give little support for), and has almost no UK development staff. But hey, we are from the UK, we have a lower standard of living than the US historically, but somehow Adobe feels they should just charge us double. *&!^ that, asshats.

Apple, who HAS UK stores, physical product distribution costs, real UK-based support costs, etc., only charge 10-20% premium for UK software and even hardware prices over US. Hmmmm? How can they do it?

I want to know how many Bently's the MD of Adobe UK can drive, or if he just trades them off for his Ferrari every other day on his way to their offices. It's sickening, really...unless UK consumers wake up and stop being abused, Adobe will just keep ripping us off and laughing all the way to the bank.

Go buy LightZone instead of Photoshop/LightRoom, get rid of Flash for Silverlight, go explore the wealth of other options, from vendors that actually don't laugh at how much they can exploit the UK buyer...

And just keep passing those cracked Photoshop CDs around...Adobe actually deserves a bit of piracy to lower the effective cost of their goods here in the UK...maybe someday they will wake up and put them in-line with real, currency adjusted, US prices...until then, they won't get a tupence of my money. And they shouldn't of yours, if you have ANY pride and live outside the US.

The skull and crossbones, from my last comment of course...

New NetApp logo already used by lubricating genie shop

Robert Hill

It IS different...

the colors are inverted...and a different shade of blue. Probably enough to get them a legal reprieve.

I just really want a job in "branding"...I've never been paid to masturbate before...

You just know those guys laugh all the way to the bank...and the ski slopes...and their yachts...etc.

Portsmouth student peeled in potato laptop scam

Robert Hill
Paris Hilton

Absolute idiocy...

£600 for something out of the back of a car??? Even PC World (rip-off kings of High Street) will sell you a brand new laptop, with warranty and in a box, for £600.

People, if you are going to get scammed, at least fall for deals that LOOK worth your while!

Paris, 'cause not even she is that dumb...

BOFH: Vampires!

Robert Hill

We couldn't live without amanfromMars....

amanfromMars's problem is that LSD use has really declined since he was younger...it's easier when others share the same trip...or, as Ultraviolet Catastrophe once wrote, Trip Harder...

N.B. - pending predictable comment: amfM will respond that he has no knowledge of LSD - but that is just a cover, as he may not remember his own experimental treatments...

Apple's Time Capsule: is its HDD really 'server grade'?

Robert Hill
Boffin

You don't WANT a "server" drive for this application...

Go take a look at StorageReview.com, and read their benchmark tests. The fact of the matter is, most "server" tuned drives perform much worse under single user loads than their desktop mirror models (such as this Hitachi and the Ultrastar server-clone). The firmware in server-drives is tuned for large numbers of pending I/O requests, and they scale a lot better when 4-8 people being to hammer them than when one person is using them. So for a single-user, low pending I/O load backup drive, the desktop drive will almost certainly outperform it's "server"-tuned cousin, and at a lower cost.

Moreover, many server drives are tuned to give up on time-out pending read requests in a way that makes sense when used in RAID configurations, not when used as a single disk. That helps their performance under RAID, but can allow them to give-up reading data in a single disk mode that CAN still be accessed if given time.

Reading through all the comments in this thread, I'm just really suprised how many people seem not to know this stuff, but claim to work in IT and read El Reg...

N.B. - those Hitachi's ARE good drives, I have a couple arriving soon for my own desktop system, which is on 24/7 and is a media server...

Vote now for your fave sci-fi movie quote

Robert Hill

Wow, so few comments on 2001...

but it got a lot of votes anyway!

I tied between Bladerunner (cause I re-watched it two days ago) and 2001, just because they are both so classic. 2001 just seemed to have more menace, more atmosphere, because of what it portended. But Batty's monologue was a better acted part, so it depends upon if you want to applaud the director or the actor. Given their careers, Kubrick has to beat Hauer as the tie-breaker.

But Rockhound's quote is far funnier, and a few Ripley and Hudson quotes get used far more often!

But - what, no Clockwork Orange quotes to even choose from???

"I've been out, helping people like..." - Alex

Most useless gadget ever?

Robert Hill
Thumb Down

Sony 300 CD disk changer...

Sounds good on paper, even sounds good when listening as its Sony's ES line and has a nice optical digital out. And it's even well built.

Of course, you WILL have to type in the name of every CD and every track to actually know what you are listening to on it's front panel LED display, as you can't actually see the disks...

At 300 disks, let's say 10 tracks per disk...yep, 3000 titiles to type...using a either a plug in keyboard, or worse, the front panel dials. Which of course, only the most anal person would DO, meaning the rest of us just shove a couple of hundred disks in and hit SKIP a lot until we find something vaguely listenable.

And you can't relocate the machine with the disks inside, or they will move about and get scratched.

All in all, a device that appeared just as CDs had reached their logical conclussion...thank god for streaming media players today. Especially ones that use gracenote and other on-line title sources...

US funds exascale computing journey

Robert Hill
Alert

@The Other Steve

The problem with Linus is that he really lacks perspective...there is an assumption that just because he is such a well known name, that he has deep insight into the way people/groups/governments actually use computers. Reading his side of the debate, I honestly feel he just doesn't have a handle on large scientific computer, or even very large database issues. (I've participated in commercial work on CM-5s, SP1 & 2s, nCubes, etc., so I will claim some experience in this stuff).

The issues of data locality, high speed switching networks, and parallel software patterns are very real, and there is still a great deal of research to be done. The heartbreaking fact of course, is that so much of what gets done resembles the same stuff we were dealing with in the early '90s - i.e., no real breakthroughs yet. Evolutionary changes, yes, but no real breakthroughs.

But certainly hoping that a big pile of commodity parts is going to solve it is rather unrealistic. The only people that have a handle on that approach are Google, and only for very specific problem sets, and only using masses of brainpower to solve each programming pattern. Hardly a generallsable model, at least yet.

Where is the icon of Linus with horns? I'd best just batten down the hatches, cause I'm sure the linux faithful will be beating down my post forthwith...

Google encourages 10 teams to rocket to the moon

Robert Hill
Alien

Mach 25...

Just keep that number in your head...that is about the minimum speed they must get to to get into Earth orbit. The X-Prize winners only had to hit about Mach 3.

Achieving orbit is still not that easy, and moreover is FILLED with failures. Lots of launchers have operational success rates in the 60-75% range, even the ones that have been around a bit, and were built by teams with lots of testing and large budgets.

This will not be a layup - exotic methods might prove interesting, as the lander really doesn't have to mass very much (there is even a prize for crashing, really). Even Gerrard K. O'Neil's railgun might be an option. Maybe a ballistic launch, and a Hall-effect thruster for the moon rendevous?

Big and dumb, or small and interesting? Hmmmm, should be interesting.

The icon is obvious, because aliens have already been to the moon...

China plans 'deep-sea base project'

Robert Hill

Trieste...

"*Impressive, but some way short of the all-time record, achieved in 1960 by the US's bathyscaphe Trieste which, with its crew of two, hit the bottom of the Marianas Trench at 10,900m (35,800ft)."

Yes, but Trieste wasn't REALLY American - it was built by a French father and son, who built it in...the city of Trieste, France. They could not keep paying for it's improvements and upkeep however, and sold an interest in it to the US Navy. Flush with the cash of the Americans, the Frenchmen made some further improvements, and with the son piloting, he and an American Navy officer decended once, and only once, to the bottom of the Marianas Trench. They disturbed some flatworms as they touched down, proving that life could exist at amazing depths, but conducted no other science. Hence, no one has returned, because we just didn't learn a hell of a lot.

If the Chinese need undersea tech, they certainly don't have to buy it from the US, they can always head to France and other EU states...

Latest China scare torpedos 3Com takeover

Robert Hill

@Anon Coward

Yes, the sale of 3COM is just an excersise in corporate greed and VC cash. If it wasn't profitable, then the deal would not be so highly valued, and BAIN would certainly not be involved. Bain only gets involved when they see outsized returns on their investment - so there certainly is money being made, and to be made in, 3COM. So, no, 3COM is not about to wither and die...the execs and board just want to take their pile and move on to their private compounds and gated communities. And they know the economy is headed downwards towards recession, and now would be the best time to do it for the next few years possibly.

And yes, should a Chinese national company get control of 3COM, it would be outrageously easy for them to install keyloggers, secret backdoors, and all kinds of nasties on a whole generation of equippment that would then be used by US military and commecial interests. That's hard to DO in something like a PC, where the basics of the CPU, Northbridge, Southbridge, etc are all made from existing silicon, but a lot easier to hide in embedded systems that happen to act as data gateways. They would even know which shippment is being sent to what customer...so they could easily target selectively. Already Chinese agents have attacked US government and commercial interests with serious data attacks (the Chinese LOVE espionage, especially commercial variety) - so giving them the final QC check on industrial and military routers and comms gear just doesn't seem smart, does it?

Well, maybe it does to you. I would say such things are part of strategic technologies, and should be carefully controlled.

Robert Hill
Thumb Up

About time...

Kudos to some American government body for actually doing THEIR JOB and ensuring that corporate greed and VC cash don't eclipse sound policy. Somehow, somewhere, they actually figured out that selling the keys to the basic internet infrastructure to a government that is repressive and on a collision course with ours for world resources in a decade or so was a BAD IDEA.

Give the guys on that team a few cookies...

Porsche to challenge London CO2 penalty in court

Robert Hill

@Frank Bough

Nope, not when I am a landscape photographer as a hobby, and often take my truck where you are too lazy and pantywaisted to ever get to. And considering I lived on the Yorkshire Moors (Meltham) when I had the Discovery, I can certainly show you a lot of landscape YOU couldn't even walk without breaking your little thin ankle, or ripping one of your painted fingernails. If you've seen the Top Gear when Clarkson takes a Disco up that mountain, well, mine has done similar.

The Freelander is just a compromise - now that I live in central London, the Disco is just too big to park easily. Otherwise I'd get another in a second. Or a Defender, 'cept my gf won't be seen dead in a Defender...

Robert Hill

Hah - 4x4s with turbodiesels rule!

Once and for all, let's stop screaming about 4x4s and the environment - even under Red Ken's ruinous rules, 4x4s with turbodiesels (which is the engine that most real 4x4 off-road users want anyway) can be shown to be eco friendly. Or at least no worse than the majority of other cars.

My 2005 Land Rover Discovery turbodiesel had decent CO2 emissions, and gave me a combined, measured 27 mpg in mixed highway / city driving. In what is admittedly a 4000 lb square box with permanent 4 wheel drive. It "only" got to 60 mph in 10.8 seconds, and while it would happily cruise at 90 mph on the M1 motorway, it really couldn't break 100 except downhill. But my point being, 0-6 in under 11 seconds is all you really need anyway, and we all have to admit that no one should be breaking 95 on the M1 anyway.

It's not about 4x4s, it's about asshats that feel the need to put stomping huge V8 petrol engines in them, even though they are among the worst engines to actually take offroad. For those people, may I suggest an Audi S6 estate?

I got rid of the Disco when I changed jobs, and have waited to buy anything because of these new rules. Now I can safely look to the Freelander turbodiesel, and know that I have avoided the congestion charge madness of the £25 band...

Space-bubble Bigelow looking to buy fifty Atlas Vs

Robert Hill

OK, answered my own question...more details here:

He bought the bubble technology from NASA, which abandoned it's Transhab plans. It has an integrated micromideorite protection in the form of 5 carbon/foam layers, which are equivalent to 12 cm of aluminum. Not too shabby.

More details here:

http://www.astronautix.com/craft/nautilus.htm

But I'll tell you what is scary - the final sentances:

"Bigelow had several dozen subcontractors, often more than two on each subsystem, in order to reduce risk and identify the best and lowest cost solution through actual hardware evaluation rather than endless engineering study and paperwork. The entire development was kept very secret, and firm technical details were extremely scarce."

Wasn't that the way the Thunderbirds and their island base were built also???

Robert Hill

YIKES!!

Not sure the Atlas is the best launcher for this stuff, and the fact that it is not man rated should worry some people that may take a journey. Launchers fueled with most cryogenic fuels always have the potential to explode, as opposed to launchers fueled with more complex compounds. Of course, the more complex compounds don't give you the lift per pound of propellant, and are usually vile substances and toxic...but they can be safer in the rocket. The shuttle is of course cryogenically fueled, as was the Saturn V, but they were designed as man-rated from the start, with all of the additional reduncancies and checks that that entails. Post man-rating a satellite launch vehicle? Hmmmm...

But the big question is micrometorites and space debris - I am just not sure how much protection you are getting in a Bigelow inflatable bungalow. Nor how much cosmic ray and radiation shielding exists.

Still, I wish him well...someone has to brave the frontier!!!

London Congestion Charge becomes CO2 tax

Robert Hill
Stop

TfL is SO broken...

If you don't think so, you haven't been to New York, Madrid, or a score of other places. I think NYC is the best demostration - fares are half (no surprise there, everything else is too), all lines are four tracks, so that they can run all night and still do maintanance, and the cars are air conditioned, even if old. The trains are longer, larger, and handle more people - in short, it is just more industrial-strength. That is what London would really, really need to move people onto mass transit in large numbers.

But my favorite TfL message had to be this past weekend, when the loudspeaker was shouting at us to notify that "planned engineering works" had basically crippled most of the western tube lines towards Hammersmith, AND YET there was still a "staff shortage" on the remaining lines, further crippling westbound service. And after nearly a half hour wait in Shepards Bush, we finally got a train...

And oh yes, Ken is an idiot...never mix your policies, they always have unintended consequences. If you want to stop congestion, have a congestion charge...if you want to enforce CO2 emissions, have a well-defined tax for that. But mixing is always a bad idea...just like during a long night at the pub. This will be a disaster, unavoidably...

Feds, NASA bracelet space shuttle spies

Robert Hill

@Martin Usher...

SS = DEATHTRAPS???

Hardly. You are frankly a pampered puss if you think that any exploratory vehicle that has a 130 launch record with only two losses is a deathtrap.

You want to see deathtraps? Go look at the survival statistics of the early 1400 - 1600 seafarers, around Columbus' time. Or even look later, into the 1700s - basically, they would have been THRILLED to only lose two out of a hundred ships at sea, even when it was "commercial", and not exploratory. The entire industry of insurance had to be invented by Lloyds of London, just to spread the risk of what was then the commercial, well-known business of shipping in the 1700s - because so many ships were being lost. Two in a hundred journys? Hah! They lost that many just getting clear of territorial waters...

Your comment just re-inforces the belief that our society has become overly comfortable, overly secure, and overly cautious...like a middle-class house cat who never strays from his porch. The shuttles are a fantastically successful vehicle, and they are one of a kind design. We will certainly miss it when we retire it. There is nothing else by anyone else that can do what it does. It is only because of pantywaists that we have not built an updated shuttle to the same design. "OHH, we might LOSE a few...better not build any more and improve them!!!" Everyone knows that evolutionary design is the way to minimize progressive risk - just ask the Russians with the Soyuz, whose basic design hasn't changed in 30+ years - but it's reliability has only increased.

And as for them being expensive, we could build a whole fleet of shuttles for what 6 moths of the war in Iraq costs...I think they were orignally a bit over a billion each, but we obviously have to inflate that to today's dollars.

But that's OK, feel free to believe that any exploration of the unknown that may risk life is too costly for you to consider, or that any vehicle that has some inherent risk is a "deathtrap". You probably drive a Volvo too...the only unfortunate thing is that people with opinions like yours have blunted the one edge we did have in space, a manned, re-usable heavy lift capability. Something that everyone else has tried to design, and has failed at, but which we are just giving up, because we lost two. I guess we should have put the brakes on Apollo when the first capsule burned on the pad and killed the entire crew too, huh? And I guess that guy Columbus really should have stayed at home...after all, he might lose a couple of ships (which he did).

Toshiba touts oddball handset that's also a modem

Robert Hill
Paris Hilton

How do you...

How do you spell "Usability Testing" in Japanese?!?!?

I don't think Toshiba knows either...

It's cute, and looks like it was a nice and inspired design for a design engineering student's final project. But someone should have known better than to actually PRODUCE such an unusable keyboard.

This gets a Paris from me as well, because I rarely have a chance to use her...er, her icon that is.

Rendition lawsuit targets aerospace giant Boeing

Robert Hill

@Jeff Dickey

I was going to write something, but Jeff wrote it all better. Very well said, Mr. Dickey...very well said.

R

Germans debut kitesurf-powered autonomous windjammer

Robert Hill

@Nìall Tracey

Nice points you brougth up about the death of sailing ships being tied to their cargo loading.

However, where this idea falls down is that these modern cargo ships have no keel form at all, and are therefore unable to use the kite for much more than anything but dead downwind. On a traditional sailing vessel, there is some keel (even if it is not a full-on fin keel), that generates forward propulsion when on a reach.

If this idea proves workable, we will need a change in ship designs to give us back some element of keel form to allow a wider range of wind angles.

Robert

Tiscali sets 200,000 TV subscriber target

Robert Hill

Tiscali is HORRENDOUS BB

Run, don't walk away from Tiscali. I have recently been migrated from Pipex to Tiscali, on the 8 Mbyte super-premium plan...and service has become abysimal. Want to watch a YouTube video? Er, get ready for pauses, glitches, and just unmade connections.

If I try to download ANYTHING, I can actually watch the sawtooth wave forms of the traffic shaping cutting in, routinely. On an 8Mb "unlimited" connection that I rarely download anything that large on.

Pipex was SOOO much better, I miss them. I may have to try BT soon enough...

Robert

Police launch hunt for bogus bobbies

Robert Hill

@lamfanboy

You really have NO idea of what a "police state" is do you?

It is NOT a state where people obey the police (or even their impostures).

It IS where the police can be the ones setting the laws, determining guilt, and executing punishments - with no legal recourse.

Even as policed as the UK is, that is quite not the case, as recent payouts by the Met and UK governments for police transgressions have proven. In a true police state, the officers that shot Menezes wouldn't have even undergone an investigation. In fact, in a real police state his shooting never would have made it into the papers or TV newscasts, as the police would have detained all the media and confiscated all cameras.

In historical terms, both the US and the UK are remarkably free from police malfeasance...for proof, try visiting North Korea or Iran or even Russia right now and criticizing the police or government. Go ahead, and tell us about it when you get out of jail in 15 years...

Robert

Europe too cynical for iPhone

Robert Hill

@Anon Coward

I moved to the UK from the States almost three years ago, and I too couldn't see the value in a system that began life as a cut rate version of a voicecall.

Three years later, I am hooked. SMS is a great way to cut out "telephone tag", like an email, but is delivered to a device that almost everyone here has on their person constantly, so you know they will get it quickly - unlike an email.

It also generates a delivery reciept when it is delivered to the recipient's phone, something that rarely works on email.

Lots of times i will send a text to schedule a phone call, just to ensure the person will be free. Some people see that as polite.

And the other major fact about texts are that they are VERY constrained in terms of how much attention you will require from the recipient. They know when they look at a text that it will be brief, and they can do it when they choose. Answering a phone call they have neither of those - they have to answer it then or play phone tag, and they have no idea how long it will go. So in some ways, texts are just more polite, and take less time.

Texts don't replace phone calls - they just give another channel. One that is very different than either emails or voicecalls, and has it's own set of uses.

Robert

Page: