* Posts by DavCrav

1811 posts • joined 19 Nov 2007

Trumping free trade: Say 'King of Bankruptcy' Ross does end up in charge of US commerce

DavCrav
Silver badge

"What will Wilbur Ross's minions do then to help bring the jobs home and have US-owned companies staffed by US workers exporting US-made products?"

And this is your problem. If the US starts a massive trade war with the rest of the world, why the hell would everybody else allow US companies to export stuff from the US to their countries, and why would they allow US companies to repatriate their profits from said business?

15
0

Welcome to the Wipe House: President Trump shreds climate change, privacy, LGBT policies on WhiteHouse.gov

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: I'd offer the world an apology for the garbage that is "American First"

"Honestly ? If the choice was between your sort and Trump, I'd chose Trump every day."

Well, you are part of the problem, with all due respect. You prefer Trump over someone who insults Melania Trump. OK, but the Donald sexually assaulted a bunch of people, didn't just call them names. Oh no wait, he did that too, mocking a disabled reporter. You prefer Trump to this person, whom you don't know, when he's said one thing and Trump said so many things? You remember him getting into a Twitter war with Meryl Streep? I mean, Jesus, you want someone with such a fragile ego and a quick temper (not to mention really small hands) to be in charge of a country? A nuclear-armed country? ARE YOU FUCKING INSANE?

I would say that, since Trump is so unsuited for the job be president, a random person off the street is probably a better choice than him.

7
4

Why Theresa May’s hard Brexit might be softer than you think

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Plausible

"She cannot be bothered to be remotely honest: "Her logic, she said, was that UK had voted overwhelmingly to end open borders". Voted overwhelmingly? What was the difference between the "leavers" and "remainers" - a few percentage points?

About 1.3 million votes as I recall."

Which out of about 35m votes, is a couple of percentage points. Thanks for agreeing.

14
2

Why the UK is unlikely to get an adequacy determination post Brexit

DavCrav
Silver badge

If the UK doesn't, the US won't

The author writes some stuff, but the reality is that the law itself has nothing to do with it when it comes to things this important. The US will likely get adequacy, because it's politically difficult not to. (Although now Trump is in, less likely than before.) If the US gets adequacy it will be difficult for the EU to argue that the UK is not also adequate without tying themselves up in knots.

So three options:

1) neither US nor UK gets adequacy;

2) both do;

3) EC punishes UK for Brexit.

2
0

Bitcoin breaks US$1,000

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Sudden crash coming again?

"But then I look at the traditional monetary system and think "what is, when get right down to it, the actual difference?"."

You might not see the difference, but most other people do. The fiat bit of fiat currency, means that a government declares that you must pay taxes in that currency, and acts as a lender of last resort. This creates a base demand for that currency. In the UK, and I expect in other countries, it is illegal for employees to be paid in tokens other than cash (to effectively outlaw the company store), so there's also a big demand from there.

In other words, pounds are wanted by people in the UK because otherwise they go to jail for tax fraud. What is the underlying asset and demand for bitcoins?

10
5

Barcodes stamped on breast implants and medical equipment

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: But how to know if someone has an implant?

"(as a result of discovering that velocity and gravity don't always mix very well)"

I was under the impression that the problem was precisely that velocity and gravity mix very well indeed. As do all of the bits of your body afterwards.

7
0

Tesla set to up prices by 5% in new year because of 'currency fluctuations'

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: This is an opputinity not a problem

""I see no reason why a self driving car can't connect to a phone and make a payment. My VW can connect to a phone, all it needs is some simple software to make a payment."

How about I take advantage of that connection, hack it, and pwn your car?"

Why on earth would it be anything other than read only without physically bridging pins? Oh yes, for 'convenience'.

0
0

Chinese boffins: We're testing an 'impossible' EM Drive IN SPAAAACE

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: One suggestion

"is that the energy being consumed causes the centre of mass to shift slightly. This is observed as motion.

Doesn't Einstein confirm this ?"

E=mc^2. If the object weighs one kilogram, the right hand side of this is 1 x (3 x 10^9)^2=9 x 10^{18}. That's a lot of energy, so you'd need a serious amount of energy to alter its centre of gravity in any measurable way.

0
0

Landmark EU ruling: Legality of UK's Investigatory Powers Act challenged

DavCrav
Silver badge

"Good to see that David Davis is unwavering in his anti-snooping stance, and can't be bought off by a cabinet position..."

Now I hate David Davis as much as the next man, but in this case it's because of collective ministerial responsibility I would guess. It's unseemly having part of the Executive suing the Executive for something.

4
0

Amateur radio fans drop the ham-mer on HRD's license key 'blacklist'

DavCrav
Silver badge

"If I recall correctly, in the UK there is such a thing as unfair contract terms which renders them invalid. It makes me wonder what your remedy would be if they cut you off regardless, though."

If the court strikes out part of the contract and they enforce it anyway, then they are either breaking the contract, in which case standard contract law of compensation and restitution applies, or a particularly animated judge might suggest contempt of court as appropriate.

7
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

"IANAL, but I'd hoper that fails to meet the minimal criteria of a legal contract: it sounds more like buying a lottery ticket that a commercial transaction."

Utterly unenforceable in UK courts. Consumer Rights Act 2015 takes care of it.

11
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Retaliation (?)

"but I can understand that people working in support might get sick and tired of some of the crap they have to put up with."

Well, ah diddums for them. But revoking their access to things they paid for, and then extorting them afterwards, are crimes.

If I buy a car and post a negative review of it afterwards, and then the company disables it remotely and tells me to go fuck myself, what do you think their chances would be of winning the resulting court case? Software already gets a free ride from the courts, so maybe they'd be OK in this regard: the whole rubbish around mercantability, fitness for purpose, refunds, ownership, etc., needs to be extended to software as soon as possible.

35
0

Did webcam 'performer' offer support chap payment in kind?

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Oops

"Even my friend (a female teacher) said if it had of been a male teacher, he'd have most likely been sacked immediately as a minimum, whereas she got off with basically some free holiday time, and a bit of embarrassment!"

Nowadays, the children could, and probably would, have been arrested under revenge porn legislation...

9
0

View from a Reg reader: My take on the Basic Income

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: housing benefit

"On the other hand it is still true to say that housing benefit ends up in the pockets of the landlords, isn't it? And that housing benefit is effectively a subsidy/benefit to employers paying low wages?"

Partially. Without Housing Benefit, housing costs would fall, but not massively so. However, since they cannot fall to zero we would still need Housing Benefit, and the hard limit is for landlords to lose money. You would perhaps see a reasonable drop in house price inflation, but the reality is that housing costs are high because of supply and demand. Prices rise until enough people refuse to live somewhere that the supply of houses matches the number of people wanting them. The rest either leave high-demand areas or accept a lower standard (size, number of occupants, etc.) of accommodation than they were previously wishing for.

If you fix supply you get house price inflation. If you fix prices by fiat then you get massive shortages and corruption. There's no real way out of this.

3
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Here's what I'd like to see discussed about UBI

"Instead, I'd like to see someone from the hardcore anti-UBI side answer the question of what's the alternative if there is massive structural unemployment in our society."

OK, I'm hardcore anti-UBI, so I'll bite. You are the one suggesting an alternative system to the current one. It is therefore up to you to explain:

1) how to transition from one system to another without financial collapse;

2) how to pay for UBI without eye-watering tax increases.

Part of the reason that people support UBI is that it reduces admin. Not really: our current admin is because some people need more benefits than others. The author of this article, consciously avoiding any numbers in his argument as to why we should upend society for his benefit, gets considerably more in disability benefits than standard unemployed people. Which level is the UBI to be set on? If disabled people can live on it, everyone else will be having a party, for a month or two before the economy collapses.

Even £200/wk is £10k/year, multiplied by roughly 50m adults yields £500bn/year. Children get nothing, of course, because sod 'em, and we already cannot afford that bill. That is the same order of magnitude as total UK expenditure: OK, the benefits bill can be reduced, but not eliminated, as £200/week cannot get you accommodation in many parts of the country, so we take say £100bn off the benefit bill. This gets you down to roughly half of total UK government expenditure. So, taxes will have to rise by 50% to pay for this: basic income tax at roughly 30%, plus 15% NI, VAT at 30%, and so on. And that's true only if the economy doesn't suffer for it, which of course it will in the short term, even if long-term it works.

Of course, foreigners can't be able to claim it for obvious reasons, so we would have to leave the EU to implement this. Which I guess is not the argument that it was last year when I was talking about this.

I would be convinced of UBI only if someone can actually show me how to implement it without such massive downside risks that I would prefer large-scale unemployment instead.

1
1
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: No basic income without basic accommodation

"Most of the benefit budget is taken up by Housing Benefit, which ultimately ends up in the pockets of landlords."

This isn't remotely true.

https://fullfact.org/economy/welfare-budget/

Housing benefit: £26bn

Child and tax credits: £30bn

Disability benefit: £37bn

State pension: £92bn.

Have you tried seeing if things are true before saying them?

4
0

Stupid law of the week: South Carolina wants anti-porno chips in PCs that cost $20 to disable

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Oh, that'll work

"Without killing the computer itself? What about suicide circuits?"

If you pay $20 to remove it, it must be removable.

Also, replace the component with it on with one from a non-SC company?

2
0

Don't panic, friends, but the Chinese navy just nicked one of America's underwater drones

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Much missing of the point.

"From China's point of view the US are operating in Chinese waters. The rest of the world may have decided new islands don't make territorial water, but did China ever agree?

Fundamentally its just not very clever of the US, sabre rattling in dispurted territory, just like allowing Russias neighbours to sign up for Nato wasn't clever. Both look like aggressive moves if you look at it from the other party's POV."

Let's try that again: From China's point of view, they make an outlandish claim to just own everything, and then get pissy with anyone who doesn't agree.

Just like allowing Russia's neighbours to sign up to NATO, from the other guy's point of view: I used to keep some downtrodden indentured servants locked up in my basement but they managed to escape and are clubbing together so I cannot kidnap them again.

4
1
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Meh

"Chinese were already experts at power politics and playing the game of chicken when american indians were still chasing the buffaloes, european sea-faring nations were using log rafts, and both believed the Earth to be flat."

Oh shut up. The Chinese government are not superhuman. A nice nationalistic diplomatic spat with the US might help then distract from their impending debt crisis for a bit, perhaps? Propping up their moribund SOEs with a firehose of cheap loans only makes things worse.

2
4
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Message to all Chinese naval commanders.

"China could demolish the USD with one keyboard button push."

Not really. People say this because China holds a lot of US debt. But they cannot really do very much with it. They can try selling it at firesale rates, which would just make a lot of other investors very happy to buy perfectly serviceable US debt at bargain-basement prices.

Or they could refuse to buy any more. Well, then the US sells to other people, at a slightly raised price. Meanwhile, China has to work out what to do with its foreign currency reserves.

5
2

$17k win for man falsely accused of a terrible crime: Downloading an Adam Sandler movie

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Sandlerised

"If Adam Sandler is so universally despised as he seems to be on these comments, how is it he continues to produce movies?"

I don't know if you have noticed, but Register readers are not representative of the general population.

Having said that, Adam Sandler is useless.

3
0

Apple Watch sales go over a cliff: Down 2.8 meellion per quarter in a year

DavCrav
Silver badge

"don't enhance personal productivity"

Is that a euphemism for 'is useless'?

6
0

Internet Archive preps Canadian safe haven to swerve Donald Trump

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Over reaction?

" The US will still have rule of law, and the various Houses and courts will continue to play their parts."

This would be a Donald Trump White House, a DT-appointed Cabinet, republican-controlled Houses of Congress, and a Supreme Court to which he will appoint one, possibly a couple more Justices.

Yeah, don't necessarily count on it.

6
1

UK's new Snoopers' Charter just passed an encryption backdoor law by the backdoor

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: In other news...

"If they are operating in the UK they have a legally mandated provider side backdoor now."

You mean, if they have an office here. If they are based abroad, why exactly would they give a fuck what British law says?

30
0

Give BAE a kicking and flog off new UK warships, says review

DavCrav
Silver badge

"but they design the sections to actually fit neatly together."

There's a difference, particularly in government contracts, between 'designed to' and 'actually do'.

2
0

Ofcom to force a legal separation of Openreach

DavCrav
Silver badge
Headmaster

"fibre-to-the-premise"

Why do people insist on thinking that the word 'premises' is plural? Fibre-to-the-premise would be laying fibre up to the previous statement about laying fibre to the premises, or something. El Reg isn't the only offender in this regard.

9
3

Donald Trump confirms TPP to be dumped, visa program probed

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: oh yea..

"Our tolerance for those who speak and write English as a second language is probably why English took over from French as the world's lingua franca."

I don't know about the US, but in Europe I find that non-native speakers frequently have a better standard of English than most natives.

16
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: oh yea..

"It is important to remember that English is a second language for many people. I worked for many years in a very large office building where our workforce included people from 94 sovereign states. It was part of our culture to accept that smart people from diverse backgrounds can bring skills that more than compensate for "second language" level written English. It worked. As long as emails and internal documents were readable and their intent was clear, spelling and grammar were of very little concern."

1) The mistakes that were made don't appear to be those of an educated but non-native speaker: irregular capitalizations, missing demonstrative pronouns, and so on are the errors here, whereas for example a Slavic background would find missing or misplaced articles (errors like 'we need the jobs', for example), those with European languages would not remove demonstrative pronouns like 'that', or misspell 'meant'.

2) I would guess that it is highly unlikely that someone railing against the H1-B scheme is himself a skilled immigrant.

3) Regardless of the background of the person, badly spelled and ungrammatical comments look really bad when placed in front of a potential employer, at least if that employer can themselves spell. (I was in a bar yesterday and on the 'Help Wanted' advertisement in the bathrooms, helpful patrons had made five corrections to the spelling and punctuation.) Good grammar and good diction are significant factors in employability.

18
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: oh yea..

[O]h yea[h]..

H-1B visa program needs to be looked at bad[ly]. It was me[a]nt to be a way for companies to get workers if there [were not] enough to fill the need of the job. It has turned [into] a way for companies to fire American workers and bring in cheap labor at the expense of the American worker[, who] has to train the cheap labor how to do their job. Just like a lot of [laws] that [have been] abused[,] and this is [one] law [that] should be canned.

Corrections are given in []. It has often been posited that better education would be how Western economies differentiated themselves from those with a cheaper workforce. Some work still needed in that respect, evidently.

43
5

Kids' Hour of Code turns into a giant corporate infomercial for kids

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: As a Dad

"I dont think rationing time is necessary as I was never rationed time on computers when I was a kid and the result is im now a competent IT guy with over 20 years of hands on experience (even though im only 33).

However, I do think it is important to ration the software kids have access to and have faith in their curiosity.

I didnt have access to games in the same way kids do now. My primary source of games was cover disks and competitions."

I agree that it isn't necessary, but only because I don't think there's much in common between people who played a lot of games when they were children. Ignoring the fact that the plural of 'anecdote' is not 'data', of the people I know who played a lot of games when they were a child, we have

One STEM professor (me);

One junior civil servant office worker;

One former bricklayer;

One who works in a logistics company;

One who was murdered in a gang feud with a brother in jail.

So a bit of a mixed bag, really.

1
0

China gets mad at Donald Trump, threatens to ruin Apple

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: And theres the deficit

"Why do you think Apple, with it's mountains of cash, issued billions in bonds rather than dip into their cash reserves?"

Because the cash is sunning itself on a beach in a tax haven, and debt has favourable tax status.

24
0

Race for wireless VR headset heats up

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Lucid dreaming

This is just a side comment, but I only recently discovered that people *don't* lucid dream very often. I have them regularly, at least once a week, both knowing I am dreaming and being able to influence the environment. I thought it was entirely normal until I was talking to my partner and she said she never or almost never had them. Apparently this is the more common situation.

In the last lucid dream I had, a couple of days ago, I demonstrated to my interlocutor that it was a dream by forcing the sky to go into a grid pattern like the Holodeck from Star Trek, then jumped 30 feet into the air and hovered for a few seconds. I have also explained, in various dreams, to other characters (I think this is the best word in this case) that they aren't real as this is just a dream. Once I realized I was in a dream when I decided that the best way to do what I needed to do was to switch to third-person view, so I could more easily see around me.

A recent piece of research explained that gamers are much more likely to have lucid dreams than non-gamers, which might explain it.

3
0

Spain's Prime Minister wants to ban internet memes. No, really

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: I don't understand.

So, in Spain can I still has memes?

3
0

Drubbed Grubhub bub scrubs anti-Donald-dubbed snub sub-hubbub

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Simple questions, simple answers

Bombastic Bob claimed:

"I don't believe he exhibits any racism, bigotry, nor misogyny"

I don't know where he's been living the past year or two, but here are a few direct quotations from the Donald:

"What can be simpler or more accurately stated? The Mexican Government is forcing their most unwanted people into the United States. They are, in many cases, criminals, drug dealers, rapists, etc.”

Sounds a bit racist-y to me.

“You know, it really doesn’t matter what the media write as long as you’ve got a young, and beautiful, piece of ass.”

Sounds a bit misogyny-y to me.

“If I were running ‘The View’, I’d fire Rosie O’Donnell. I mean, I’d look at her right in that fat, ugly face of hers, I’d say ‘Rosie, you’re fired.’”

Sounds a bit misogyny-y to me.

There are more. Many more. Face it: he has said a lot of outrageous things, that if you said them in a workplace you would get fired. And that's all the original e-mail said.

5
4

Robot solves Rubik's Cubes in 637 milliseconds

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: As for that time...

"Since the robot in the video would be totally unable to solve a 4x4x4 cube, I'd say that the complexity in this case is "worse than exponential"."

Now I see what the previous commentator might have meant: the nxnxn cube, whether finding the optimal solution is in P. I very much doubt if it's in NP, and since the symmetric group on n points has order n!, I would hazard a guess it's not soluble in O(a^n) time for any a>0.

0
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: As for that time...

"Has anyone learned if finding the optimal solution to any Rubik's cube is considered a P or NP problem?"

I'm going to take a wild stab in dark and say you don't know what P or NP is. Because if you did you would know that solving any specific problem is very much in P. In fact in C: constant time algorithm.

1
0

Angry user demands three site visits to fix email address typos

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: So you didn't fix root cause

"Yes the user was a dick, but you fixed the symptoms rather than the cause."

I don't think IT support is allowed to fire the bursar.

24
1

Trump's taxing problem: The end of 'affordable' iPhones

DavCrav
Silver badge

"As an IT worker in the US, I'm quite happy that President-Elect Trump will make it harder for a foreigner to compete with me for a job."

OK, but have you noticed how most of the world's consumers don't live in the US? You think they will be 100% happy with your protectionism, and won't, you know, do the same?

29
1

Brexit judgment could be hit for six by those crazy Supreme Court judges, says barrister

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Was'nt one of the " reasons" for these referendum reasserting the soverignty of Parliament?

"The 16-page propaganda leaflet sent to every household before the referendum said:

"The referendum on Thursday, 23rd June is your chance to decide if we should remain in or leave the European Union." and "This is your decision. The Government will implement what you decide."

IANAL but that seems pretty bloody clear to me and any attempt by an unelected cabal of lawyers and bankers to overturn the democratic result is likely to go down very badly."

Indeed, you are not a lawyer. If you were, you wouldn't spout such rubbish.

3
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Thursday's explosive anti-Brexit judgment

"The "once in a generation decision" leaflet that was sent to every household in the country to explain the referendum had been quite clear. It read:"

Again, yet again, that was a Government leaflet. Like a manifesto promise. The Government can only carry out things that it has the legal authority to do. It doesn't have the legal authority to execute A50 without Legislative approval, as was clear before the judgment, and has been confirmed now.

17
1
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Media and entertainment

""It's not bound by the arguments the parties put forward," continued Callus, of media and entertainment law practice 5RB"

What does this even mean? And what insight has a media lawyer into constitutional law?"

It means that the Supreme Court can set judicial precedent, in other words, make law, in cases not foreseen by the body of law currently at hand. That said, I do not think that this situation qualifies as there is a quite clear legal status of the referendum, and that is of expensive opinion poll, nothing more.

As for lots of people voting, turnout was 72%, lower than elections pre-1997. It's not unprecedented numbers of people voting.

43
6

We're great, you don't understand competition law, Google tells Europe

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: How about making things a lot simpler...

"...and instead of trying to make incomprehensibly abstract laws about how to regulate "competition" between advertisers, just make some simple tax laws which force all these companies pay a decent amount of tax in all the countries in which they operate."

We have regulations. You might not see why this one is useful but lots of people do. Do you see why company stores, private police forces, debtors' prisons and so on are not allowed any more? Those are very real things, outlawed by abstract laws.

2
0

'Inventor of email' receives damages from Gawker's collapsed empire

DavCrav
Silver badge

As I don't have $750k to give Shiva Ayyadurai, I will refrain from saying that he didn't invent e-mail and he's full of shit, and leave that to the Wikipedia article on him.

13
0

Brexit may not mean Brexit at all: UK.gov loses Article 50 lawsuit

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: @ werdsmith

""This is your decision. The government will implement what you decide," a pamphlet issued by the government at the time said.

That sounds a fairly solid statement."

Yep. But it's NOT UP TO THEM. Jesus Christ, the High Court has just ruled on this, and you are commenting on an article which says that the Government doesn't get to decide, only Parliament.

For the love of God, it's like people have no idea that the Government and Parliament (Executive and Legislature) are two different things. In issues of domestic law, the monarch doesn't get to decide, and hasn't done so since 1689. Parliament is the only body that gets to implement and repeal domestic laws. It was the Glorious Revolution, and the Bill of Rights 1689.

I know that facts aren't so important nowadays but Jesus, get an education.

16
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: Re:

" If you abstain in a democratic vote, you're stating that you're happy to go along with whatever the majority decide. So that's 2:1 in favour of Leave."

Fuck off. That's a complete pile of rubbish. How can you agree to be in favour of leave if you don't know Leave would win? You cannot be in favour of both positions.

You are talking drivel, and it's embarrassing.

15
2
DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: By "project fear", I presume you mean the inconvenient facts

"Could you point us to one of those "facts", so I can learn ?"

People said the pound would tank if UK votes to leave. UK votes to leave, pound tanks. There's a fact.

Leavers said they wanted to 'take control' (whatever that means) so that the UK Parliament and UK judges are supreme. So when a UK judge rules that the UK Parliament should be supreme in this process, idiot Brexiters moan about it. (I can use the word 'idiot' quite correctly now, because at least these people have now been shown to be completely full of shit by this decision.)

Maybe the Leave voters who are moaning should shut up and accept the ruling? Parliament will vote, you lost, get over it?

15
5
DavCrav
Silver badge

"But the BIG difference is that MPs now know how their constituents voted in the referendum. And most areas of the UK - outside of London, Scotland and NI - voted to leave."

I live in Birmingham, where it was 50.5/49.5. So which side do you want to vote with in order not to be thrown out at the next election? It has 25-odd constituencies, so will make a difference to the vote if it's close. I don't envy MPs' task in places where the vote was tight.

7
0
DavCrav
Silver badge

"The country voted to leave the European Union in a referendum approved by Act of Parliament. And the Government is determined to respect the result of the referendum."

Well, grand. But in the UK, the Executive doesn't get to enact domestic legislation on a whim, backed by referendum or not. The legislation passed for a referendum could have, but explicitly did not, state that the referendum was binding, merely advisory. Thus standard procedures apply, and legislation such as A50 need to be voted on by by Legislature. What they do is up to them but, you know, they were elected as our representatives to decide on UK law and they will.

It's the only legal option. We wouldn't want the Government to override Parliament and use Royal Prerogative to push domestic legislation, that way lies dictatorship.

124
11

Smart Meter rollout delayed again. Cost us £11bn, eh?

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: What's the advantage to the consumer?

"It's like the weird attitudes people have towards lightbulbs. I want a 900-1200 lumen bulb in a e27 fitting, with 10-20k hour lifespan. My options are a filament bulb (100 watts, 1 euro), CFL (23 watts, 2 euro) LED 900 lumen (12 watt, 12 euro) and LED 1200 lumen (17 watt, 20 euro). The CFL are head and shoulders above the others, but get pretty much all the hate. The LEDs will pay back their additional costs at roughly a euro per thousand hours(20 cents per kwh) , so for normal use after about 6 years. Which is around the lifetime of the bulb."

1) I'm surprised that you claim that an LED bulb lasts no longer than a standard incandescent bulb, but OK.

2) Your LED bulbs are ludicrously expensive. Even in Brexit Britain, with a pound that's worth nothing, I can get LED bulbs for about €7.

3) CFLs are not liked because of the light they emit, the time it takes to warm up, and the presence of mercury.

4) I think your calculations are way off. A 100W bulb uses €1 of electricity in 50 hours at 20c/kWhr. An LED, with your wattages, uses at most a fifth of that, so you say more than 80c every 50 hours. After a thousand hours the difference is more than €16.

1
0

Obey Google, web-masters, or it will say you can't be trusted

DavCrav
Silver badge

Re: The whole mechanism sucks

"What about foreign states?"

They also have the heavy mob. You know, US, Israel, Russia, are all known to do wetwork on foreign soil, and the others probably do too.

1
0

Forums