Re: @Alien8n
@Alien8n,
I did mention the need to kill key characters elsewhere in the posting.
@Simon Harris,
I love the idea that dystopian futures are an excuse not to make our own lives better.
You seem to have pointed out quite a number of films more than TV series and yes there are many examples of both TV and films being dystopial. However my concern is valid because the writing trends elsewhere and notably more so to me recently, have been rather against what Gene R. wanted from Star Trek. We can assume the writers, producers and directors will be somewhat experienced in the genre and thus will bring their own interpretation to the series. However dark can also be viewed as a criticism of many ST films, but especially so of the TNG films.