Reply to post:

US government: We can jail you indefinitely for not decrypting your data

T. F. M. Reader

How can they know the hash value of a file unless they have access to it's decrypted content?

Maybe they did decrypt the drives and do have the unencrypted files, but

a) do not want to admit it (because top secret);

b) are afraid that without disclosure of the exact (top secret) procedure defence will accuse them of fabricating the data ("Your Honor, the prosecution claim these are the drives' contents, but they have not shown how exactly they arrived at this conclusion...");

c) think 'the old razzle dazzle' should be enough (because think of the children) to avoid disclosure of capabilities;

d) hope that 'the hashes match' will become a useful precedent on record - better than 'here are the decrypted files - look at this filth'.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon