Reply to post: Re: There are 2 parts of caller-ID

Pai guy not too privacy shy, says your caller ID can't block IP, so anons go bye

Christian Berger

Re: There are 2 parts of caller-ID

"Carriers that fail to do this, get dropped from the interconnects."

That's essentially non-enforceable.

1. Interconnects are contracts and cost money. There's even billing involved, so it's card to break those contracts.

2. The telephone network is far from being star- or tree-shaped. If someone gets a telephone call from an odd number, there is no way of knowing if it's a legitime call from abroad or just a wrong number.

3. It's virtually impossible to find companies that do send wrong Provider-Asserted Numbers. We've tried that, and so far we could only go one other company, they then say, that they already got those numbers from another carrier who is abroad.

People act as if this would be a big problem. It's not. For decades telephone networks were electromechanical. There it was utterly impossible to trace a call without putting lots of work into it.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon