Reply to post: Re: Time to solve one of those "10^77 years" IT Security Cracking problems

How much faster is a quantum computer than your laptop?

Michael Wojcik Silver badge

Re: Time to solve one of those "10^77 years" IT Security Cracking problems

Breaking conventional cryptography requires a class of quantum computer that Shor's algorithm

Asymmetric cryptography, and that statement (the requirement for Shor's algorithm, i.e. a true QC) hasn't been proven. There may be better conventional algorithms for factoring, for example. Nor is ECC proven to be NP-hard, at least the last I checked.

For symmetric cryptography, the best QC attack is Grover's algorithm, which effectively cuts the key in half. That's pretty much useless if defenders are using a decent key length to begin with, unless the QC is much faster than a conventional computer at conventional computation as well.

And then we have post-quantum cryptographic algorithms, which are finally becoming feasible with the RLWE family.

And then there's the question of how many encrypted messages are worth pointing a large and very expensive QC at. Particularly when there will almost certainly be better attacks available: protocol flaws, implementation flaws, social engineering, suborning one of the keyholders...

Quantum cryptanalysis is mostly a big fat non-issue.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon