Reply to post: Re: Something doesn't compute

US DoJ files motion to compel Apple to obey FBI iPhone crack order

Michael Thibault

Re: Something doesn't compute

>Why is it that critical that someone has access to this one phone?

>How about 14 murdered people, 22 severely wounded, many bereaved families wanting answers, unknown accomplices possibly yet to be discovered.

An arguments based on emotion. Meaning an argument that is entirely context-specific (and so not generalisable) and one which blithely ignores, or is ignorant of, the role of precedence in law.

I'll resist the temptation to go all Rumsfeldian on the 'possibly yet unknowns' tangent.

>What sort of undeniable, ultimately incriminating evidence do they expect to find there?

>Who knows, but if it does point to fellow conspirators you'd sure as hell would want to find out. This is not a game.

And if there turns out to be no evidence?

Isn't the court order having been sought at all based on speculation of there being something (or anything at all) to follow up on? It's a fishing expedition! And in at least two ways. And it is a game. One with long-lasting and far-reaching implications for just about every living soul on the planet--phone or no phone.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon