back to article Now Uber sued for textual harassment

Taxi app turned lawsuit magnet Uber last week was sued by Donna Giacomaro, a resident of Levittown, New York, for text message harassment, in violation of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and New York state law. The complaint, filed in the Eastern District of New York, alleges that Uber last month began sending …

  1. Blake St. Claire

    Holy Shit

    If Uber were public I'd be shorting their shares like there's no tomorrow.

  2. Mark 85

    Hmmmm... interesting. The wife told me the other day that she suddenly has an Uber App on her cell phone followed by "What's an Uber?". There's no Uber here or even close by.

    1. Diogenes

      As did my SWMBO. While she was thinking back, it dawned on her there was an unclosable popup on a webpage. She came to me because this thing was asking for permissions. App uninstalled lickety split.

  3. TrumpSlurp the Troll
    WTF?

    Interesting approach

    We think you stole some documents.

    Please show these to the court so we can prove that you did.

    Isn't this like telling a suspect "we think you nicked some jewels, please bring them down to the station so we can nick you"?

    Ok criminal and civil, but still........

    1. I ain't Spartacus Gold badge

      Re: Interesting approach

      There are different standards of proof. So in civil court the judge or jury decide on the balance of proof, whereas in criminal trials it's beyond reasonable doubt.

      Also juries aren't supposed to take any notice of whether you testify or not in criminal cases. I don't know if that's true of civil law.

      So if you refuse to disclose documents and have similar tech to the company you just left, the civil judge/jury might well decide against you. Whereas for a criminal trial, that might not be enough to prove guilt. Given his company was valued at $700m, if he's nicked that data wholesale and discloses it to the civil trial, the case against him in a subsequent fraud trial is going to be rather easy to prove. Hence pleading the 5th.

      That's not going to help Uber in this court case against Waymo. But presumably they can then sue him to get the money they paid for his company back, and then if he still refuses to reveal data, that helps them easily win against him. Unless of course they already knew the data was nicked, in which case, oh dear what a shame.

  4. spacecadet66

    Not that my impression of Uber is of anything but a sack of bastards, but this being the USA (*), 39 civil lawsuits in just over six months doesn't sound like that much. Really, my question is why so _few_ people are suing Lyft in contrast.

    (*) If my understanding of history is correct, this is a habit we inherited from Britain, so don't get smug yet.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      The tradition in the UK was been that civil litigation risks such horrendous costs that only the rich and powerful could afford to sue. This has been loosened a bit more recently with small claims tracks nd contingency fee arrangements, but the US is still in a class of its own when it comes to suing anyone on a whim for anything - but we're catching up fast, unfortunately.

  5. handleoclast

    Have things changed

    or is it still the case in the US that you pay to receive an SMS not to send one? In which case I'd be after every penny Uber has.

  6. Alistair
    Windows

    Up here frozen north, most SMS are 100% free nowadays.

    And the litigation issue - is a result of 1) allowing legal beagles to advertise on prime time TV with terrorizing images (they are; you only need to see one or two) and 2) permitting legal beagles to do contingent fees. (we don't get paid till you get paid). Sadly -- the lawyers up here have gotten into that business as well.

    (Late paying your taxes? CALL US NOW or the Government will seize your bank account, house, car, etc etc etc) -- things like that ... while this is technically true there is a *rather* long process to any of those seizures for an individual, and if you haven't a lawyer by that point you really really are deserving of everything that lands on your head.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like