Re: Business logic versus finance
"But then there's the financial engineering behind this deal. The debt behind this deal is staggering..."
@Charlie Clark, the financial engineering is brilliant if you do the maths. It's been widely reported that Dell needs to finance $40B. Assume a 10% interest rate to keep it simple; or $4B a year in interest.
Currently, EMC annually pays out $3.5B in dividends and stock buy-backs. But to pay out that $3.5B, EMC pays the US taxman $1.4B, assuming a marginal rate of 40%, and forgetting the state taxmen for the sake of argument.
So compare $4.9B annually for dividends, stock buy-backs, and taxes, to $4B in interest, and you see $.9B for additional R&D, SG&A, or price cuts to win deals.
So that "staggering debt" comment in the media is simply wrong-headed jealous competition FUD [we didn't think of it first].
But, what this deal highlights is the dysfunction of the US Corporate Tax Laws. Pay a dividend, it's a profit, and pay 35% to 40% income tax. Pay interest, it's an expense and a tax deduction.
At the end of the day, this type of a deal has got to drive all those "tax the greedy corporations", Wall Street Occupiers, and libs crazy. And the financial engineers deserve a bonus.