back to article SURPRISE: Telstra STILL wants all its promised NBN booty

The once-imminent deal between Telstra, NBN Co and the government is, once again, less imminent than communications minister Malcolm Turnbull would like. In fact, in spite of what have been interpreted as hopeful signals in the past, Telstra's position has changed not one iota since last year's election brought to power a …

  1. Thorne

    If putting in an inferior system isn't going to be a cent cheaper then why push the inferior system?

    1. LaeMing
      Flame

      Because post-retriement-board-positions-for-pollies.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Too true but I have also wondered why a SUPERIOR system required the purchasing of so many customers with government/taxpayer money, so much for letting the free market decide/choose the best competitor/product in a market.

      If I was Telstra I'd want my money promised by an outgoing government too, why else do you think they made the original deal, it was always seen as a 'win win' for them, government stays, expensive contract honoured, government changes, re-negotiate with the new government knowing you have the upper-hand of a previously agreed upon contract.

      It's all just business and politics as usual

    3. P. Lee

      > If putting in an inferior system isn't going to be a cent cheaper then why push the inferior system?

      Which is why the last government signed the deal, I would imagine. They score points when the current government as to back down.

      Having said that, stop faffing around and go with the original deal. FTTH please.

    4. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Are you retarded?

      11 billion <> >60 billion

      What a fucking dumbarse - people as simple as you should not be allowed access to computers

  2. kartstar
    Joke

    Didn't see that one coming!

  3. Fluffy Bunny

    NBN=Rort

    Just goes to show what a rort the NBN is and always was.

    1. Adam 1

      Re: NBN=Rort

      No. The rort was to privatise Telstra in the 90s without splitting their retail and wholesale arms.

  4. aberglas

    Paying to cut the copper

    The big part of the original deal was to pay Telstra to cut the copper. This had to be done otherwise most people would not use the NBN even if it was provided free, as was discovered in the initial roll outs. For most (70%) households the 5+mbs they get on ADSL was enough, at least for now.

    But that also makes a joke out of the NBN proposal. When you have to force people to use the better system.

    The new Telstra deal should be much cheaper for the taxpayer because they will not need to roll out fibre to each and every home which is the expensive part.

    1. Originone

      Re: Paying to cut the copper

      Instead they will have to either lease the copper network from Telstra or buy it outright and maintain it themselves, both options will be more expensive than laying and maintaining Fibre in the long run.

      1. Mark 65

        Re: Paying to cut the copper

        Nah, just break Telstra into two companies like BT - openreach and retail. It'll fuck their current model and they deserve it with bells on.

        1. desmo

          Re: Paying to cut the copper

          That's what Howard should have done back when Telstra was first sold but he wanted to maximise the money received to provide tax cuts and middle class welfare to keep himself in office. The Gov should have kept the switches and wires and sold off retail. Then they could have sold network access at the same price to all players, giving smaller entrants a level field and benefiting customers, instead of handing Telstra a near monopoly, even though the legislation supposedly guaranteed access for new entrants.

    2. Kiwi_MarkLFC

      Re: Paying to cut the copper

      Hold on - all the KRudd/Juliar fanbois have said that ADSL is too slow and noone wants it...

      All you had to do was build it and everyone would sign up to it...

      So more bullshit from Labour and the FTTH smelly greasy spotty virgin nerds who dont have a fecking clue about what they wibble on about...

  5. Kiwi_MarkLFC

    The answer to that is simple...

    Threaten the wankers at telstra with breakup if they dont comply

    Telstra - worst telco in the world

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like