back to article REVEALED: The sites blocked by Great Firewall of Iraq

The Register has obtained a list of the websites which are still blocked by the Iraqi government despite its decision to lift partial and total internet blockades around the country. Although the Ministry of Communications appears to have gone back on its decision to restrict access to Facebook and Twitter, ISPs have been told …

  1. knarf
    Joke

    Not Too Bad

    Well at least they can still get porn,

    1. Phil W

      Re: Not Too Bad

      Did I miss something or did you?

      "He said: "Porn sites are still blocked, [but] social media websites were unblocked in Baghdad"

      1. knarf

        Re: Not Too Bad

        Nope it was me, speed reading it seem is not my forte

    2. This post has been deleted by its author

  2. Crazy Operations Guy
    Big Brother

    Domain level Blocking

    When has Domain level blocking actually stopped anyone? Even if you were to block all DNS traffic except to controlled DNS servers, then people will just distribute hosts files (And that is not even addressing the issue of VPNs, TOR included). I was getting around domain-level blocking in elementary school, and I didn't have much motivation to do so, how do you think it would fare against a bunch of militants trying to get people to fight in their holy war?

    I wonder when governments are going to realize that censorship of the internet, or any other media, will never work and doing so only fuels uprisings and dissent.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Domain level Blocking

      well yea, but also consider some of these people think genocide and suicide bombing is a good idea :/

      1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

        Re: Domain level Blocking

        >some of these people think genocide and suicide bombing is a good idea :/

        The inventors of the computer thought climbing out of your trenches and walking toward German machine guns waving a stick was a brilliant military strategy !

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Domain level Blocking

          *joke* I am presuming they tried that after inventing the computer? :)

          You are attributing a nations achievements, to a singular reference point.

          I am stating that most terrorists are fucking idiots. To have the mindset to attack innocent people requires a certain lack of intelligence.

          Argue if you like it empathy that's missing, but an intelligent person would see the advantage to have the moral high ground, as a way to gather support.

          1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

            Re: Domain level Blocking

            >I am stating that most terrorists are fucking idiots

            So are most of the people who were prepared to storm machine guns to determine which of Victoria's grandchildren gets to be king of Belgium

            >. To have the mindset to attack innocent people requires a certain lack of intelligence.

            Tell that to the Manhattan project

          2. Vic

            Re: Domain level Blocking

            > I am stating that most terrorists are fucking idiots.

            It's a common mistake to underestimate one's enemy.

            They clearly have a repugnant set of ethics, but if they are truly "fucking idiots", then why aren't we catching them and prosecuting them properly?

            Terrorists might[1] be total cunts, but there's a strong chance that many of them are at least as intelligent as the rest of us...

            Vic.

            [1] It has to be a "might" because many of the people in history that we look up to were technically terrorists at the time...

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Domain level Blocking

      Given the description in the article about the workarounds being to use VPNs and proxies, I think it's safe to say that this is NOT blocking at just the DNS level.

  3. Destroy All Monsters Silver badge
    Headmaster

    God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

    crisis-hit nation

    > 2014

    > Calling Iraq a "nation"

    It's a bloody stump of a colonial area (sort-of a "country"). It may have a sort-kinda authoritarian state apparatus under under Maliki, but there is no nation anywhere to be seen. The Kurds (under a quasi-mafiosi but lesser-of-two-evil kind of leadership) are giving the finger to the freakshow (AFAIK Turkey has already okayed the move, amazingly). Sunni obscurantists are creating a new region around the Syrian-Iraqi border area - good times for rope dealers. Soon you will see ethnic cleansing fanning out from the Shia sectors and the pre-2007-surge cleaning of Sunni enclaves will be scaled out... Meanwhile car bombs and hellfire missiles are going off everywhere.

    No nation here. Nope, sir.

    1. El Presidente

      Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

      Disputed area, perpetual war.

      Pull up the drawbridge, let them get on with it.

      1. phuzz Silver badge
        Mushroom

        Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

        "Pull up the drawbridge, let them get on with it."

        Don't forget the first step, Invade and make sure they have nothing resembling a competent government left (whilst making sure your buddies' companies get rich off of it).

        Then you can sit back and watch the slaughter.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

          That's what I remember from Doonesbury: "Bechtel: for the very best in infrastructure" Of course, age may be clouding my recollection.

          edit: spelling

        2. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

          "Don't forget the first step, Invade and make sure they have nothing resembling a competent government left"

          Come off it, they didn't have a competent government to start with. The deservedly dead Gadaffi killed about a million in his hobby war with Iran, and was caught red handed gassing the Kurds, before starting the first Gulf War, killing another 40,000 people. Iraq's people suffered under years of sanctions due to Saddam's misgovernance, and saw none of the wealth from oil or gas.

          I grant you he was fairly effective at suppressing the inter-group fighting, but that's hardly a reason to vote for him unless you celebrate the values of brutality, corruption and repression.

          1. Anonymous Dutch Coward

            Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

            Sorry, you're mixing up colonels here...

          2. Destroy All Monsters Silver badge
            Headmaster

            Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

            Come off it, they didn't have a competent government to start with. The deservedly dead Gadaffi

            Uh... Ghadaffi (our acceptably-good-guy/bad-guy permamorphist) is starring in another show with Hillary Clinton.

            killed about a million in his hobby war with Iran

            Well, we delivered the goods and the gas to do it because we didn't like people not liking our bastard the Shah or Iran. Basically, we were for Hitler before we were against him. If there were any justice, big radioactive meteors incubating flesh-eating diseases would strike the "West" any minute now. Luckily, there isn't.

            I won't even go into the utterly despicable French/British behaviour post-WWI and Skyes/Pikot, which deserves a separate introduction of the people involved to the Black Box of Pain.

            1. Anonymous Coward
              Anonymous Coward

              Re: God is great and Destroy All Monsters might be his Prophet

              "I won't even go into the utterly despicable French/British behaviour post-WWI and Skyes/Pikot, which deserves a separate introduction of the people involved to the Black Box of Pain."

              Guilty. M'lud. And of course there was the British government's Balfour Declaration, that through a combination of subsequent Goldman-esque politicing and European guilt over The Austrian's activities eventually led to the formation of Israel and the expulsion of the Palestinians. Factor in French, Russian, British and American interference throughout the Middle East ever since, and "westerners" in the most general sense really have a lot to answer for. If the British civil service (past and present) burn in the fires of hell for this and everything else they've ever done then I'll be happy to get a long stick and bag of marshmallows to share with you. But...

              ...what about your lot? Would things have panned out better and more peacefully if the Brits and Frogs hadn't darkened your doorsteps? In both Britain and France we had centuries of epic bloodshed and civil war in our transition from wiping our arses on stones and believing the crap spouted by religious leaders, through to having access to quilted labrador pelts on a roll and going shopping on our sabbath. I suspect that even with the efficiency of modern death machines, the same journey will involve less bloodshed (end to end) for the peoples of the Middle East (not that I'm condoning or excusing the Western interference).

              But we are where we are. How about the people of the Middle East stop worrying about what their neighbours believe, say or practice in their own minds or homes, put the guns and bombs away, and round up and burn ALL religious books, religious scholars, zealots, religious officials and tribal elders? In the meanwhile the UK's foreign aid budget could buy one hell of a lot of Andrex, and the NATO air forces could deliver that - Hercules drops to metropolitan areas, surgical fast jet deliveries to smaller towns, and drones firing three ply cluster packs or JP233's onto isolated rural targets. Global peace would break out as Middle Eastern men were suddenly able to retire for a comfortable dump with a copy of the Arabic version of Viz.

              As softening up work we might have the collected works or Richard Dawkins translated into Arabic and then carpet bomb the whole Middle East with it?

          3. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

            Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

            "Don't forget the first step, Invade and make sure they have nothing resembling a competent government left"

            And the last step; wait for a genuine democracy to break out, stage a coup, put your own dictator in charge and help him kill those democrat terrorists. Then rinse and repeat

            1. Anonymous Coward
              Anonymous Coward

              Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

              "And the last step; wait for a genuine democracy to break out, stage a coup, put your own dictator in charge and help him kill those democrat terrorists."

              That's Ukraine that you're thinking of, where US interference is what toppled the last nationally elected president, leading to instability between factions that might otherwise have been managed.

              1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

                Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

                s/Ukraine/Iran/g

                s/Ukraine/Egypt/g

                s/Ukraine/just about anywhere in S America/g

        3. Psyx

          Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

          It helps if you bomb flat the vital infrastructure, too. Thus ensuring it's a third world nation.

          1. Anonymous Coward
            Anonymous Coward

            Re: God is great and Frank Herbert is his prophet.

            "It helps if you bomb flat the vital infrastructure, too. Thus ensuring it's a third world nation."

            You can't bomb people back to the stone age if culturally they never left.

  4. Tom 38

    Porn sites are still blocked, [but] social media websites were unblocked in Baghdad

    Explains the fighting I guess. Re-block twitter, un-block House of Ron Jeremy, peaceful nation again?

  5. sjsmoto

    I don't think I'd live in Iraq to manage that stuff, I think I'd rather remote in from quite a distance away.

    1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

      > I think I'd rather remote in from quite a distance away.

      I heard their internet links can be a bit dodgy

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        "I heard their internet links can be a bit dodgy"

        I'm with sjsmoto on this. I'd rather somebody chopped through an undersea cable than my neck. And going from liberal, easy going Sweden to mad as fuck Iraq........what's that about?

        1. Yet Another Anonymous coward Silver badge

          The weather is better?

  6. Graham Marsden
    Big Brother

    It's a good thing...

    ... nothing like that would ever happen here...

    </irony>

  7. Stevie

    Bah!

    So they can still see Lolcats at will then? And idiot skateboard fails? And people shooting each other in the nuts with spud guns?

    That's a relief.

  8. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I have looked at the list and they have blocked the news websites Al-Arabiya and Al-Jazeera. Obviously they don't want people to get the news. I hope that the satellites are not blocked so then people can find out proper news. I have friends there and I am worried about them.

    1. smartypants

      Obviously they don't want people to get the news

      Not necessarily a bad thing. The news is too depressing!

      (I accept that the joy of not knowing the news is tempered somewhat by the risk to life and happiness offered by Eternal War (tm) which seems to be blighting the region (and I'm not too happy about our contribution to it).

  9. xperroni
    Big Brother

    Shirley you can't be serious!

    But I thought the Americans had brought DEMOCRACY&FREEDOM© to Iraq! How come they have blocked news websites? Surely this can only be some sort of International Jewish Communist Soviet Jihadist Conspiracy!

  10. Martin Maloney
    Coat

    I just can't help it, folks

    I suspect that some of the resourceful porn sites remain unblocked.

    You know -- the ones that are really eager beavers.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like