back to article NTT demos double-sided see-through smartphone

Japanese mobile operator NTT DoCoMo and computing giant Fujitsu gave smartphone fans a glimpse into the future of mobile computing at this year’s Wireless Japan show, demoing a prototype Android device with a transparent, double-sided touchscreen interface. The as-yet-unnamed device features a petite 2.4in, 320x240 QVGA …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.
  1. petur
    FAIL

    Just because they can

    doesn't mean it is practical. In fact, it looks like a very clumsy way to operate a phone...

    1. pip25
      Thumb Up

      Re: Just because they can

      I don't agree. One of my main gripes with touchscreens is that my finger is obscuring the general area that I am trying to touch, and without any tacile feedback, the accuracy of my "clicks" decreases substantially. If I could see my own finger BEHIND the screen instead of in front of it, this would not be an issue. It's like one of those behind-the-screen trackpads, only more usable.

    2. Mondo the Magnificent
      Meh

      Re: Just because they can

      Agreed and yes, it does look a little clumsy when compared to a vanilla touch screen phone

      My first thought is how well that screen will display under direct sunlight on a sunny day..

      Bear in mind this is a prototype and who knows, maybe it will take off? But I certainly won't be queuing for one

      1. petur

        Re: Just because they can

        I'm quite good at predicting where my finger will end up in the 0.2 seconds that it is obscuring the icon/... before the actual touch.

        But most of the time my finger is as big or bigger than the area I want to tap, so accuracy is bad anyway. Which is why I hold on to my n900 with resistive touchscreen, so I can use stylus/fingernail,... when accuracy is needed.

    3. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Just because they can

      Congratulations on having no imagination.

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Design over application, yet it is strangely enticing in a 'let me try that' karma sutra kind of way.

    1. Ken Hagan Gold badge

      Re: strangely enticing

      Yes. To give credit where it is due, this could have been done some time ago and wasn't, so it has novelty and non-obviousness in its favour. It has, as I see it, two ergonomic advantages.

      Firstly, by distinguishing between front and back dragging, it provides a natural way to express a desire to "rotate" the UI object. It probably does this rather better than a conventional touch-screen gesture.

      Secondly, fat-fingered users will appreciate not having to see through their own hands. This, however, will be much less of an advantage once they scale up the display.

      Time will tell if it is all worthwhile, but it is certainly interesting. At least someone appears to believe that innovation involves coming up with new ideas rather than simply copying what everyone else has been doing for hundreds of years. (Rounded corners, indeed!)

  3. Bob Vistakin
    Mushroom

    Apple will innovate this now - you'll see it in a few years time

    Their photocopiers are whirring away busily innovating, and the lawyers too on their rewriting history work so they can sue a few years after they launch it. Well, when you're plumb out of ideas but have a bank overflowing with the spoils of your iSheep fleecing what else can they do?

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Megaphone

      Re: Apple will innovate this now - you'll see it in a few years time

      No need, they've already been investigating something along these lines well over four years ago (this article is dated March 2008) But I'm sure Apple haters like you will still claim Apple is copying NTT if they actually did introduce something like this...

      http://www.trendhunter.com/trends/apple-transparent-displays-patent#!/photos/16125/1

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Two-Sided... opinions

    On the one hand, you'll get people complaining that it looks stupid, is unnecessary and will never catch on.

    But then the same people will proclaim that they want those transparent, 2-sided touch screens like on Minority Report, Avatar and Avengers. Why won't people hurry up and invent them, god damn it?

  5. John Smith 19 Gold badge
    Happy

    Cool looking tech turns out to be a PITA to use.

    I'm shocked.

  6. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Aren't transparent screens harder to use?

    Can't watch the video as I'm in the office, so can't see how good or bad it is.

    You'd need the right colour background to see whats on the screen as your black text wont show up well if you are in a room with dark walls.

    You can also fake your transparent screen with this bit of software:

    www.littletinbox.co.uk

  7. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    But who will think of the Porn?

    Honey? What are you looking at?

    Nah... I don't see that selling very well.

    No privacy!

  8. samlebon23

    When I read in the title saying "see-through", I thought I could see through women's skirts. Too bad.

This topic is closed for new posts.

Other stories you might like