Some good points but...
Can we have the same survey for Android devices please? Just to keep some semblance of journalistic balance.
Brimming over with problems? A little rash but I don't care one way or another. My ancient Nokia 6310i has just had a new battery and and internal 'de-fluff'. Should be good for another few years.
I got some strange looks last night when I used it on the tube to Richmond. It seemed that everyone else were Fanbois/Fangirls using their iDevices and they not just young hipsters. I expect that some of them had never seen a dumbphone in years.