back to article Dammit, Foxconn: Where's our 1 MILLION-strong robot ARMY?

Foxconn's much-vaunted robot army will do little more than insert screws, polish parts and assist human workers, it has been claimed. A report in the Taiwanese press has suggested that "Foxbots" are nowhere near sophisticated enough to replace real people in Foxconn's factories, which have been the scene of worker suicides. …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    "...screws, polish[es] parts and assist[s] human workers..."

    At least the workers are getting some benefits then ;-)

  2. NoneSuch

    Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?

    Can't wait for the first Foxbot to slash its own hydraulic lines. That'll make 'em take notice.

  3. imanidiot Silver badge

    Not really surprised

    "locking screws, components and polished appearance", meaning exactly what cheap and readily available automation systems do.

    Automation takes an investment (plus a lot of time investment in development of product specific tooling and programming) that needs to pay back. Such an investment is only worth it if the cost of labor is significantly more than the depreciation of the equipment used. The labour for Foxconn is currently still cheap enough that significant investments in automation systems are just not worth it.

    The main reason for the investment in "Foxbots" now is probably more about quality than about labour costs. (Robots tend not to leave fingerprints, smudges and scratches on parts like meatbag workers tend to do)

    Look at what most growing companies in the western world goes through when growing. It starts of producing small numbers of parts with significant portions of manual labour. As labour cost per product starts rising, more automation is introduced. Until a point is reached where a significant portion, if not all, production is automated. Labour cost is the most significant driver behind automation. Foxconn has access to cheap labour, so has little drive to automate right now. If pay per hour keeps rising, more automation will be needed to stay competitive.

    1. Alan Brown Silver badge

      Re: Not really surprised

      "The labour for Foxconn is currently still cheap enough that significant investments in automation systems are just not worth it."

      And once it _is_ worth it, the factories are best sited where the logistics are best.

      Generally that means closer to consumers than suppliers, or where energy costs are lowest. Either way, china will lose its advantage.

  4. dotdavid

    Sadly, the unhappy Foxconn cohort will get no robotic reprieve from life as an iAssembler, as it looks like the Foxbot has only the most basic of skills.

    Sadly for the Foxconn cohort, who will retain their jobs? I would have thought they would have been reasonably happy about that.

    it's a lot cheaper and easier to replace human beings with robots, who aren't known for forming unions or attempting suicide

    ...and can work almost 24/7 without getting tired or needing breaks, and have maintenance costs lower than a (even low) full-time wage, and will perform repetitive tasks in exactly the same way each time resulting in less defects - all of which can reduce costs and help Foxconn outbid competitors. I doubt unionisation and even the allegedly high rate of suicides are the primary factor in this drive towards automation.

  5. John Smith 19 Gold badge

    Frankly not very impressive robots

    At least from what I've heard.

    Assemble a watch not tricky enough for you?

    The Swiss worked out selective compliance SCARA robots about 30 years ago.

    When each one needed a PDP 11 to run it.


    1. Alan Brown Silver badge

      Re: Frankly not very impressive robots

      The swiss may have worked the robots out years ago but 99% of the swiss "watchmaking industry" consists of buying in, polishing up and packaging movements which have been manufactured in china.

  6. Volker Hett

    So they are just good enough for what Foxconn makes for HP, Dell and others then?

    Beer, because even Holsten Pilsener is as good or better than real ale given the price!

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2019