back to article Google will throw open lid on music locker service today

Google is expected to barge into the music industry this afternoon with the launch of its own music locker service, without prior approval from record labels. The search and ads giant is expected to open up on its locker service at its I/O developer conference, the Wall Street Journal said, citing those omniscient people …


This topic is closed for new posts.
  1. Michael Souris

    Steaming mode?

    Steaming mode? Do you mean streaming mode? Or stealing mode?

    1. Ian Michael Gumby Silver badge

      Huh? No theft occurs...

      Look, I'll make this as simple as possible.

      US copyright law allows someone who bought a CD to make a copy for personal use.

      Here's how Google can most likely legally introduce a streaming service and still profit from it...

      You sign up and upload your music. Assuming that you have a legitimate copy, when you upload a song, google can check to see if the recording exists on their server, and take a hash of the file. If it matches, the retain one copy of the file and then just track the ownership of the file. If they don't match, then they keep multiple versions.

      Google makes money by tracking you and your musical tastes. The more they know, the better the targettingof ads and the more they can charge advertisers. At least in theory. At some point there is going to be some diminishing returns... But I digress.

      The point is that they could offer such a service and still be legal and not have to worry about the record industry...

      In fact, they could use such a service to find out who the 'freetards' that would be a selling point to the record industry...

      1. Gizzit101


        Currently in UK copyright law, there is no provision for fair use, or for format-shifting. Technically, anyone who rips a legally purchased CD to play on a mobile device is a lawbreaker.

        Possibly this is why the Amazon cloud-locker, and from the looks of things, this new Google Music service are not available in the UK.

        Incidentally, where is the Hargreaves report on UK copyright law review - I understood they were scheduled to publish by end of April 2011. I'll be very annoyed if it doesn't pave the way for the legalisation of format-shifting, which in turn will allow this kind of service to be offered in the UK.

    2. This post has been deleted by a moderator

  2. Anonymous Coward

    Oh I'm sorry

    But I couldn't let this pass ....

    >>> allowing users to upload their own music files for listening in steaming mode. <<<

    That would be for those less talented or less listenable uploads then

  3. Nigel Brown

    I just have to butt in here

    >>> allowing users to upload their own music files for listening in steaming mode. <<<

    Given some of the utter turds that make up the Top 20 these days, I'd say this is spot on.

  4. Dave Murray

    Music starts for Google party...

    the Goo Goo Dools obviously.

  5. Jimboom

    Ultimate internet/PC related playlist

    Project Pat- Good Googly Moogly

    U2 - Still haven't found what I'm looking for

    Mediaeval Baebes- Dance of the Trolls

    Cosmic Gate - Firewire

    Weird Al Yankovic - Don't Download This Song

  6. lone_wolf
    Thumb Down


    so you can upload music you legally own, for you own personnel usage, but cannot then download it? so using this as some sort of back to the original copies is useless then....

    other than streaming to a smart phone with all the data caps involved in that what's the point....

  7. Jamie Jones Silver badge


    If you are streaming, you ARE downloading

  8. Jim 15

    I tried to apply for an invitation to the beta last night ...

    ... guess what? "We're sorry, this service is only available in the USA currently"!! Why wasn't I surprised?

This topic is closed for new posts.

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2020