back to article So, what IS the worst film ever made?

Our piece last week on Eddie Murphy's cinematic train-wreck A Thousand Words - a possible nominee for the worst film ever - had El Reg commentards queuing up to recount their celluloid nightmare experiences. And chilling reading it made, to be sure. Inspired by your litany of cinematic shame, we've decided to run a poll this …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.

Page:

  1. Greg J Preece
    Mushroom

    TERMINATOR PISSFUCKING THREE!

    If you read the previous comment thread, you saw this coming.

    1. I ain't Spartacus Gold badge

      Re: TERMINATOR PISSFUCKING THREE!

      Sorry, but in a universe also containing Terminator: Salvation, you can't use the word worst about Terminator 3...

      1. Greg J Preece

        Re: TERMINATOR PISSFUCKING THREE!

        I honestly don't get why people thought T4 was worse. It was still shite, but compared to the utter travesty of T3?

        1. I ain't Spartacus Gold badge

          Re: TERMINATOR PISSFUCKING THREE!

          I didn't mind Terminator 3. It wasn't good, but I wasn't bored, and wanting to gnaw my own legs off, just for the distraction. T3 had a few fun moments, and I liked the 'upbeat' ending. It's just mediocre.

          The only time that I've even got close to being as bored in a cinema to sitting through T4, was when a mate insisted we see Eraser ('classic' 90s Arnie) - after his birthday curry and several pints. Our entire row fell asleep after about 25 minutes, all except poor me, who can't sleep in a seat.

          Just imagine if T3 hadn't existed? You'd have gone into T4, expecting it to be good, and rather than just pissing on your dreams (as T3 did), T4 would have taken a flying leap from a trampoline, done a triple somersault, and then flung a large, malodorous turd upon your dreams, from a great height.

          It would be as terrible as if someone like Mel Gibson, would have taken a classic like 'Edge of Darkness', gutted it of all its drama, character, wit and acting talent, and then remade it as a film set in America. And that's a laughably ludicrous idea. No-one would be that stupid!

  2. Daniel B.

    I'll nominate:

    Pootie Tang

    American Cyborg: Steel Warrior

    Manos: The Hands of Fate

    I think the other bad movies were so bad, my brain erased them from existance.

  3. thesykes

    hmmmm

    the worrying thing is ... I have a few of those mentioned sitting on the Sky+ box, ready for me to enjoy... I'm actually looking forward to seeing some on them even more, just to see if they really are that bad.

    My nomination... the first 30 minutes of Twilight... I gave up after that... and possibly Blair Witch... maybe it isn't that bad, but after all the hype that preceded me watching it, I was seriuosly underwhelmed.

    Oh, and Into The Wild.

    And The Ghost (not Ghost, never seen that).

  4. Minophis
    Unhappy

    Highlander: The Source

    Watching this was one of the most painful experiences of my life.

  5. jef_

    Another call for Avatar

    Just awful. Patronising and crass. C'mon, let me vote for it.

    Anyone see The Idaho Transfer? That's my most recent sh!te film.

  6. Stuart Castle Silver badge

    Three for me.

    In order of release:

    The Grifters: Badly written story with unbelievably unlikeable (and badly written) characters that were badly acted. And I normally like this style of film.

    Se7en: Good first half, then becomes totally predictable. I actually predicted the ending halfway through my first viewing. I can't believe anyone didn't.

    Avatar: Looks pretty. Sounds good. Good use of 3d. However, it could lose about 2 hours of footage without losing any actual story. Bought the blu ray to see if my opinion was affected by the fact that the power failed for 40 minutes in the middle of the film when I saw it at the IMAX, and they locked us in. It wasn't. Watched the blu ray once, and haven't been tempted to again.

    An honourable mention should go to anything directed or written by (apart from Toy Story) M Night Shymalan. I kept watching his films for a while to see if they improved, but he cannot (IMO) write believable characters.

  7. fixit_f
    FAIL

    D.A.R.Y.L

    Watched it a few weeks ago, what a pile of shit.

  8. system11
    Meh

    Charlie's Angels 2.

    I have an incredibly high tolerance for bad films, but this one was terrible enough in the first 15 minutes to get me to turn it off. I can't even think of another film I can remember turning off before the end.

    1. Cpt Blue Bear

      Charlie's Angels!

      Dear God! I haven't seen the sequel but the first has to be a candidate. It's so bad that if I never see Cameron Diaz's arse, Drew Barrymore's tits or any of Lucy Lu again it will be a million years too soon. Bill Murray phoned his performance in (from an all night bar by the look). Fortunately, I saw it on a free ticket or I'd have been really pissed.

      1. Minophis

        Re: Charlie's Angels!

        You're nominating Charlie's Angels for the worst film ever made!

        Clearly you haven't seen Charlie's Angels 2: Full Throttle

  9. Notas Badoff
    Thumb Down

    Blind me! Blind me NOW!

    Nightfall (1988)

    Billed as "The greatest science-fiction story ever told", yes, it was, really, but then it was *filmed* by... I have not the words sufficiently maleficent.

    Walking out witnessed one fellow surrounded by 4 of his recently ex-friends whining "sorry guys..."

    BTW: large birds pecking out the eyes of a living person might stroke some viewers' happy place, but most of us were pleading for pain-alleviating blindness much before that scene.

    1. Daniel B.

      Re: Blind me! Blind me NOW!

      And this is one of those movies my brain had deleted from memory. Yes, most of what I remember from that one was the eye pecking scene. GROSS.

  10. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    'War of the Worlds'

    The Spieberg version

    For numerous crimes including:

    Starring Tom Cruise trying to be all serious

    Regulation voice of god voiceover by Morgan Freeman

    Setting it in modern America for no very good reason at all

    Reusing a perfectly good scene from 'Jurassic Park' but with worse effects

    Where no soldier dies on screen despite losing all the battles

    The most slappable child actor in history (the boy)

    Dakota 'MY EARS!' Fanning for two hours of dialogue that can be summarised as 'AAAAAAAAAAAAH"

    A bloody horrible movie from start to its very protracted ending.

    1. Daniel B.

      Oh the irony

      The Tom Cruise one was much closer to the book than the original... But then Spielberg had to stick that damn annoying girl...

  11. Minophis
    Devil

    Femme Fontaine - Keller Babe For The CIA

    Teenage Cat Girls In Heat

    Chopper Chicks in Zombie Town

  12. Dan Caugherty
    Mushroom

    Manos, the Hands of Fate - or - Monster A Go Go

    Another MST3K fan chiming in for Manos, the film that answers the question: "What kind of horror film would a west Texas fertilizer salesman make?"

    The answer: A really really bad one.

    What blew my mind about the film was not just that it was so awful (and such ripe MST3K material). It was that, yes, an entire hour of footage was deleted by the MST crew in order for it to be shown. (Yes, the consarned thing runs for over 2 hours.)

    And Monster A Go Go is just pathetic tedium from start to finish. Also jaw-droppingly terrible.

  13. Anonymous Coward
    Alien

    Skipping ones already mentioned (Jaws 4, Moulin Rouge):

    Broken Flowers - truly skin-crawling stuff.

    Blair Witch Project - how quickly we forget.

  14. NickT666

    The Roller Blade Seven

    All of the above are cinematoc gold compared to the experience that is "The Roller Bade Seven". Honestly, you've got to see this to believe it. It's so utterly shocking that my girlfirend actually had a row with me about making her watch it and stormed off. Don't get me wrong, I like crappy B Movies, but at best this is a despicable excuse for a film. The main gang dont wear roller blades, and there arent seven of them. By far and away the worst film I've ever seen, and I've seen such gems as "Surf Nazi's Must Die", "Vampires vs. Zombies" and "The Nymphoid Barbarian in Dinosaur Hell" (yes, really) ...... Watch it if you dare - they even made two sequels!!!

    1. Red Bren
      Paris Hilton

      Re: The Roller Blade Seven

      You got yourself a username just to mention this film!

      We only rented it because of the (lack of) costumes the actresses were (not) wearing...

  15. Bodhi

    Romi and Michelle's High School Reunion. A pathetic vehicle for the unfunny one from Friends to be.....the unfunny one from Friends.

    Dishonourable mention to Indy and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (for obvious reasons).

  16. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Really really bad!

    "Zombie Strippers" with a title like that you KNOW it's gonna be pretty bad. but this turkey exceeded all expectations for stupid plot, idiotic dialogue and abysmal acting, if ti wasn't for the nudity I wouldn't have survived the first reel.

    If you do feel the need to watch this first ensure you are too drunk or stoned to inflict violence on your viewing equipment.

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Really really bad!

      That film is amazing! (for all the wrong reasons).

      I particularly liked the attempts at social commentary. I watched the DVD extras (I borrowed it, I promise) and thought it was hysterical how the cast all seemed to think it was a serious work of art (either that or they are spectacularly good actors, but felt the need to hide it for the main feature).

  17. Ikoth

    Hell Comes To FrogTown

    Unspeakably bad.

  18. cliveski

    Hmmmm...

    I vote:

    Little Miss Sunshine

    The Secret of my Success

    Uncle Buck

    The Phantom Menace

    Fargo

    1. cliveski

      Re: Hmmmm...

      Not to mention:

      Nacho Libre

      Sahara

    2. Audrey S. Thackeray

      Re: Hmmmm...

      If you didn't have 'The Phantom Menace' in there I might think you'd misunderstood the question.

      And even that is good fun for kids - or so my colleagues who are 'blessed' with offspring inform me.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        I have children

        And they hate the Phantom Menace.

      2. cliveski
        Happy

        Re: Hmmmm...

        "If you didn't have 'The Phantom Menace' in there I might think you'd misunderstood the question."

        No, I just have weird ideas of what makes a good film I guess! Those are all movies I had to stop watching after 20 mins (with the exception of Secret of My Success for nostalgic reasons!). I have enjoyed far worse films - "Brother Where Art Thou" and "Withnail and I" are two of my faves for instance :-)

    3. dogged

      Re: Hmmmm...

      Hey!

      The Secret of My Success has Helen Slater in it and is therefore exempt from all criticism.

      Oh, that 80's schoolboy crush...

  19. Marty
    Coat

    OMG, the list is endless of films that can qualify for the worst film ever...

    you could categorise them for why they failed.... for example Jaws 3 & 4, some of the WORST special effects ever... so bad it makes the entire film a joke.... Jaws 1 is still one of the greatest films ever.

    then you have got a movie like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, It tried so hard, but the original was such a classic that a remake had a hard job to live up to, it was only ever going to be terrible to a fan of the original.. so you can make a collection of bad remakes, or remakes that never should have been made.

    then you have got the moveis that just self indulgent twaddle... eyes wide shut, I am looking at you...

    then you can look at the ones that are poor because the budget wasn't there to make it good, I can think of a few movies that the script was good, but the poor acting and crappy filming made it bad, imagine a film like "the usual suspects" take out hte incredible line up of actors and replace them with your typical "b" movie cast. imagine how crap it would be if you had Barry Williams play Verbal Kint and Jamie Kennedy as Dean Keaton? imagine If they made the godfather movies with Tony Danza instead of Al,

    again, some movies can be made bad by throwing money and hollywood at it... Take Mad Max for instance. Austrailian movies have never really been taken seriously, but the original Mad max movie was in a class by itself. Mad Max 2, followed on quite well, but ffs, beyond thunderdome, with all the backing of hollywood, that polished all the grit out of it and made it possibly one of the worst movies ever...

    you have a bunch of movies, supposed to be based on historic events but bend the facts so bad that the truth becomes an out and out lie... you have a movie like U571, that Hollywood will have you believe it was because of the yanks the enigma machine was cracked. Not even a nod to Alan Turing or Bletchley park was made...Take a look at pearl harbour, so many historical inaccuracies totally destroy the authenticity of it all, add to that the movie Titanic for the same reasons..

    too much meddeling... look at the starwars franchise. back in the day, gotta be one of the all time best films. until george lucas went back and started "fixing" things to how he originally intended. fair enough, once... but there has to be 4 or 5 revisions now... LEAVE IT ALONE. and please let me try to forget "the phantom menace"...

    so, the worst move ever has to combine, crap script, both not enough and too much budget, crap acting, scrap camera work, crap editing, crap continuity.... it needs all of the above to make an improvement,,,

    for my worst movie ever, my vote goes big time to Mega Piranha ( http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1587807/ )

    they didn't have enough budget for a good cast, but had enough that they splashed out on some expensive looking animatronics, but ran out of cash for the CGI... The script was so cheesy, you could smell it... the camera work was as wobbly as the script.. It was so bad it went past funny to painful to watch...

    I'll get my coat, because something stinks around here...

    1. Sean Timarco Baggaley

      @Marty:

      "then you have got a movie like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, It tried so hard, but the original was such a classic that a remake had a hard job to live up to"

      Er, no it didn't. All it had to do was bear more resemblance to the book than that godawful Technicolor version. That saccharine "Disney Lite" 1970s excrescence was an insult to both the eyes and the intelligence.

      The remake was a lot closer to Roald Dahl's original book, which, like all fairy tales, was supposed to be dark and twisted! About the only thing Tim Burton added was the 'flags of nations' gag and the Willy Wonka back-story with his dentist father. It makes the character more likeable. Tim Burton and Roald Dahl were a very good fit.

      (I could have done without Johnny Depp playing Wonka though. He doesn't have much range as an actor.)

      1. dogged

        Re: @Marty:

        Johnny Depp's Wonka came across as a real child molester. It was just unpleasant.

  20. Skizz
    Devil

    My nomination...

    "Sex Lives of the Potato Men"

    I did watch it all. But only in the hope that there might be some redeeming scene that made it all worth the torment. There wasn't. Started low, went downhill rapidly from there.

  21. Munchausen By Taxi

    How about...

    Ballistic: Ecks vs. Sever.

    Yes, I did watch it and it was dreadful.

    Even Lucy Liu and Antonio Banderas couldn't save that pile of poo.

  22. CynicalOptimist

    Nicholas Cage remake of The Wicker Man

  23. naeem
    Boffin

    recently..

    has to be the Thunderbirds film..had to leave the cinema after 20 minutes - it was actually hurting my brain to sit there and watch it,

    in general - anything by the clueless and talentless Adam Sandler - someone please stop him making fillms.

  24. Nick Davey
    Thumb Up

    I nominate

    Fallen - a movie that is rendered completely pointless by the end... I'm actually ashamed that I didn't walk out of the theatre. Skyline has been mentioned, that was awful. Pathfinder with Karl Urban is the worst thing I've ever seen him in.

  25. x3mxs
    FAIL

    Space Balls 2

    That was a real con!!

    The posters outside had Rick Moranis dressed in a Vader-like uniform same as the 1st movie, but once the film started was a crappy high school crap thing!!!

    I walked off the cinema 20 mins in!

  26. Jon Whiteoak
    Thumb Down

    Tom Cruise

    Two Tom Cruise films, Interview With The Vampire and Vanilla Sky.

  27. Richard 45
    Mushroom

    Well, you did ask

    Anything that Channel 5 broadcast. Other than that, in increasing order of crappiness:

    Remake of The Italian Job (Mr Napster jumps in front of the camera, blows a raspberry straight down the camera, then hops off again). Utter drivel.

    Remake of War of the Worlds.

    51st State (completely taken up by Samuel L. Jackson wondering how the hell he got himself into such a god-awful film)

    Human Traffic (billed as "the last great British film of the 90s" - it wasn't)

    The the absolute star, possibly *the* worst film I've ever suffered is a Canadian Sci-fi film, so you can probably guess how bad it is. Earth Storm http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0491764/

    They didn't even bother to simulate zero G for the space shuttle, nor invent artificial gravity. The inside of the shuttle looked like someone's shed, probably because it actually was someone's shed. Sci-fi without any shred of science. Acting straight of the Ikea Academy of Undramatic Art. Plot holes bigger than the Grand Canyon.

    1. Munchausen By Taxi

      Re: Well, you did ask

      The War of the Worlds remake was pretty good, as long as you miss the first ten minutes, watch the next half hour and then miss the rest of the film.

    2. ArkhamNative

      Re: Well, you did ask

      Earthstorm is one of those, you know, "SyFy Original Movie" films. They really are absolutely ire-inspiring.

  28. Alan Esworthy

    Abysmal

    "She Freak" from 1967. Burn every copy. Before viewing.

    I'd like to think some of the cast/crew paid the producer to be omitted from the credits.

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0062259/

  29. Flocke Kroes Silver badge

    Gabriel

    Dark (they could not afford lights), dull and depressing.

    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0857376/

  30. Nick Ryan Silver badge

    * Impossible Mission 1, 2, etc (bugger all relation to the series)

    * Gor - 1 and 2, somehow the 2nd was worse, not sure how - must have been through just reusing clips from the first film. So bad they're almost good.

    * Star Wars Episode I, II and III.

    * Twighlight (1, 2 and 3) - just used "special power" crutches for plot and 2 and 3 are nothing more than remakes of number 1 with pretty much the same "plot"

    * Animals United - a host of "stars" were utterly unable to rescue this

    * Titanic - it sinks, end of film, done with the whiny singing and wooden acting yet?

    * Mega Shark vs Giant Octopus - shits'n'giggles it's so bad with green lights and lockers to simulate a bridge on a ship / sub / etc.

    * The Chronicles of Riddick - at least Pitch Black made a little bit of sense, but this one was just conan remade in space. Badly.

    * Fast & Furious (all of them). They remade this? Why? But then could generally include anything starring Vin Diesel in this list...

    * The Patriot - but again, pretty much anything with Segal in it could be in this list as well

    * Stargate (1994) - dull, dull and just dumb. The series was better though

  31. Daniel B.

    The Doom Generation

    Someone made my brain recall this. I was fooled into believing this was either a Natural Born Killers type of movie, some corny reference to the Doom videogame or something like that. It isn't. The whole thing turns boring 20? 25? Minutes in and nevr really recovers.

    In fact, the ending *improves* the movie because at least something happens!

  32. Nexox Enigma

    This is easy

    "The Room" - try to avoid watching it without the Rifftrax audio commentary.

Page:

This topic is closed for new posts.