Re: I wonder how long before Ecuador ends up on the "state sponsored terrorism" list
"The Taliban which we are trying our best to destroy has never attacked any country outside of Afghanistan. It has attacked plenty of people who have invaded or tried to invade the country but never committed any terrorist atrocity outside of Afghanistan."
True. The Taliban themselves have never attacked, but there were terrorist training facilities being hosted within the country, so you could argue they were liable for them. Problem is, the Taliban is not really an organisation. It's really a series of warlords who have a generally similar outlook. However, they are different, fought each other to some extent and have varying degrees of 'nuttiness'.
"The only way to actually defeat the Taliban would be to take a leaf out of Hitlers book to see what he tried and failed with the Jewish population. Obviously this isn't going to happen, so we'll never defeat them. We never defeated the IRA in all of those years, so why do people think we'll win against the Taliban."
This is the problem with wars. Very often wars are not actually 'won'. They often (especially these days) end up more as a stalemate, which is why a political solution has to be agreed in the end. The IRA didn't win, but neither did the UK. So, after a while people (on both sides) realised a negotiated settlement had to be reached. Same will be true of Afghanistan, Syria, Libya......all of them.
"Off topic: But why destroy poppy fields in Afghanistan when we are spending money to grow poppy's in the UK for pharmaceutical use? Why not allow the Afghans to grow poppy's (afterall they've had plenty of experience) and use that instead? We'd save money destroying the crop, save money protecting the crops in the UK (farmers themselves aren't allowed to harvest said poppy fields), and probably get it a lot cheaper!"
This is all to do with politics and money over common sense. The 'war on drugs' is lost and always will be. No matter what you do, removing illegal drugs from the streets is a fight we will never win, even remotely. We are more awash with drugs now than ever before. So, what do we do? Same as any other war....negotiate a settlement. That will undoubtedly mean at least some drugs become legal. It may take some time, but it will happen in the end unless they want the 'war' to continue. Getting the Afghans to grow the poppies is never going to happen, as there's good money for companies doing it in the UK and elsewhere. Money wins. Also, it's rather hard to justify giving a poppy contract to your 'enemy' the Taliban!!
It's nothing to do with practicality and everything to do with money and power.