back to article Apple, FBI: YES we're, er, looking into the NAKED CELEBRITY PICS. Aren't you?

The Federal Bureau of Investigation and Apple are examining the theft of a large cache of naked celebrity photos, thought by many to have been snaffled from the fruity firm's iCloud backup silos. As El Reg reported yesterday, the photos depict Jennifer Lawrence, Kate Upton and around 100 others are thought to have been stolen …

Page:

  1. DrXym

    I smell lawsuits

    One of the most grievously annoying things about all these cloud services is how pushy they are. Install DropBox and it helpfully assumes you want to upload photos by default - I was caught out and had to disable it. I'm sure iCloud is just as pushy with new iPhones.

    And since none of these services see fit to allow the end user to encrypt the data before uploading it means that anyone can log in from another computer and steal everything that is there. A computer literate person might understand the risks and nuances of cloud storage but clearly a lot of people including celebs do not.

    So it'll be interested to see where the sueballs land. I am expecting Apple will find itself on the receiving end of a lawsuit from some of those affected if it transpires that a) it didn't delete pictures when it should have, b) it didn't ask the user about their cloud sharing options in every circumstance, c) the cloud sharing options were defaulted to an unsafe setting d) the option to disable the sharing was buried in the settings or accompanied by scary vague warnings to discourage changing it e) the service was inadequately protected.

    Apple had better hope the leak was from somewhere else.

  2. jubtastic1

    Problem with the iCloud theory

    OK, so assume you've brute forced the targets username and password, log into iCloud.com and... there's no access to the photo stream or device filesystems.

    No problem!, just set up one of your devices to sync with their account details, and voila! a flurry of modal alerts are sent to every device attached to your targets account warning them that a new device has just signed in to their account. All these celebs ignored those alerts?

    1. 100113.1537

      Re: Problem with the iCloud theory

      " All these celebs ignored those alerts?"

      Almost certainly, yes.

      As do very many people when they get a message on their smart-phone thingy because so many different things send you alerts all the time you get used to just clicking them all off. That is one of the problems - the systems are set up by (and for) relatively tech savvy people and that leaves a lot of room for less aware people to get ripped off.

      In one sense, that is how Apple have been so successful - keeping a walled garden around their hard/software has removed the need for many people to get down and dirty with their devices. But it puts a lot of trust in the supplier and leaves people very unaware of what is really going on under the hood.

  3. Britt
    Pirate

    Nuggets

    There is a screenshot doing the rounds of someone explaining that what was released and how it was gathered.

    No tech details but there is a small group of people who hack and share amongst themselves, only way to get into the group is to buy in with fresh photos.

    Seems one member decided he was bored and could make a few quid of the pictures.

    Authenticity of claims not confirmed, but they do fit with the range of ages to the pictures and how so many were gathered.

  4. Stuart Castle Silver badge

    titillation.

    I love the way the media have gone for the titillating aspect of this (ie 'slebs showing tits) and largely ignored the more serious aspect of the story. Namely that using Find My iPhone, the hackers could easily have located the 'slebs and done things to them, maybe even killed them.

    1. Darryl

      Re: titillation.

      Celebs aren't usually very hard to find, even without technology.

  5. MartinBZM
    Paris Hilton

    I just got this letter

    ... to Cease and Desist from posting my pics online.

    Apparently someone in the digital information gathering community got sick looking at them.

    Clueless like --->

  6. Deimos
    Holmes

    list of suspects

    So - long time-frame, multiple devices, multiple O/S and quite a small group of prime clickbait.

    1. was it a "free WiFi" access point at the Emmy or Oscar awards ?

    2. someone in the NSA cloud monitoring team just got his prize swag stash onto a USB stick and out of the building ?

    3. it really was that simple password vulnerability on the "find my iPhone app" plus said celebs moving photos from other sources to their icloud (or getting them sent from people with other devices) ?

    4. a cynical attempt to either sell a security service or discredit Apple ?

    just my very non comprehensive list, any better suspects ? but please remember "Investigating or commenting on any high profile leak is like trying to hug a hedgehog, the harder you try the more pricks you encounter" and I'm just the first....

  7. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    We don;t speak to the NSA we just make their work easier

    Unlimited password retries ?

    WTF Apple, that is insane if true. You can't even blame stupid users if the system has, in today's world a wide open door.

  8. Peter Clarke 1
    Paris Hilton

    My Misunderstanding

    This is a NEWS story? I thought it was publicity for the Cameron Diaz film Sex Tape???

  9. Phil_Evans

    'Apple does not limit the number of password entry attempts users could can make when attempting to access their iCloud accounts'

    Well that's a red rag to a bull then.

  10. RobertD
    Facepalm

    Solution...

    Everybody should publish everything online now. Hey presto, no more privacy concerns or cyber crime. Oh wait, I'd be out of a job. More thought required.

    1. chivo243 Silver badge

      Re: Solution...

      the real solution would be to have all these celebs post pics with out any make-up! We would all gouge our eyes out. 10lbs of pancake base will make Arnold the pig look good.

  11. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    And this is a technological innovation company!

    Heads should roll for this embarrassing episode.

  12. K
    Facepalm

    We've been hacked.. Its the first thing people always scream.

    But a large number of data breaches are inside jobs.. wouldn't surprise me if it was some System Admin just trying to get his rocks off and then decided to take a copy home with him! I've had this on our internal network, staff Sync up their phones and wham, suddenly they've dumped all their private pictures onto the network.. accessible to anybody with admin privileges.

    But I'm a nice guy.. I warn staff when this happens. Right after I copy them off... for umm evidence!

  13. Andrew Jones 2

    So given that the problem was with the find my iPhone web service, does this finally explain what happened several months ago when numerous Austrialians woke up to find their iDevices had been remotely wiped overnight?

  14. my fingers stuck
    Linux

    and the morale of this story is?

    dont use cloud storage, why not get a cheap domain with hosting setup a ftp account, voila! your own private cloud stage, not at the mercy or control of a an american behmoth.

  15. JustNiz

    Dont feel sorry they WANT this.

    Seriously, what normal person takes naked pictures of themselves anyway? let alone puts them on a network storage service, even if it is meant to be private.

    There's only one reason celebs are taking naked pictrures of themselves and putting it where it is likely to get hacked... its because there is no such thing as bad publicity, especially when backed up with fake moral outrage.

    Newsflash people: They WANT the pics to get hacked and the media and the more lame-brained amongst us keep feeding right into it.

    1. Truth4u

      Re: Dont feel sorry they WANT this.

      I think some of them might just be dumb and have the hots for themselves.

    2. Steven Raith

      Re: Dont feel sorry they WANT this.

      JustNiz has clearly never been in a relationship where either partner travels a lot or is otherwise further away than is inconvenient for IRL nudeys (IE getting your kit off).

      Steven R

  16. JaitcH
    FAIL

    This is IOMPOSSIBLE ...

    Apple says it is infallible. Mmmm ...

    At least Android users can encrypt their stuff.

  17. Mark 85

    One has to wonder....

    if there's no such thing as bad publicity, perhaps these celebs use a non-effective password intentionally. The idea being, their account will be broken into, the pictures grabbed and published. They can then scream "don't look at those"... and everyone will go look at them. Or maybe not but something just smells bad about this whole thing whether it's intentional, a PR ploiy that ran amok, or absolutely rotten iCloud security.

  18. Truth4u

    I felt good when I had a NAS. I liked it so much I bought another and now I have two. Imagine how good I feel now?

    What's iCloud?

  19. Chippy55

    I'm 95% certain these celebutards wanted their nudies leaked in order to get their Q Rating up, because in Hollywood, "All publicity is good publicity". They don't have any problem appearing nude before a camera with two dozen grips and lighting technicians staring. Tell me you've never heard of the casting couch where "stars" (lol) have to sleep with old men who run the studios and then - Voila! - she's the star of a movie.

    What's the difference between Hollywood and the porn industry down the street? Not a whole lot.

    The FBI and the Secret Service (not the drunk johns) can determine the IP Adress in a matter of a few hours. So unless someone is arrested today and ends up doing hard time, this is all a big publicity stunt concocted by attention hungry "starlets" who want to get on the front page. It's all bs.

  20. Inachu

    I went I saw

    I visited those links to view the pics but not as for porn purposes.

    I went to rate them in the mere fact on how valid/fake they were.

    I would say that 95% of the pictures there are all real.

    Sadly the one with the girl showing off her bum looks more like a medical condition.

    She should get that looked at. Seriously!!

Page:

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Other stories you might like