back to article Wanted that Windows 10 update but have an Intel SSD? Computer says no

The Windows 10 April 2018 Update is not proving to be the smoothest of installations for PCs containing certain Intel SSDs. Systems with Intel 600p and Pro 6000p SSDs are experiencing crashes and users are finding themselves staring at a UEFI screen after rebooting. Microsoft has recommended afflicted users reinstall the …

Page:

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Flakey

    That the model of harddrive you have makes the difference between working and not working..

    IBM Compatible anyone????

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Flakey

      "That the model of harddrive you have makes the difference between working and not working.."

      Which as hundreds of other models work just fine implies the issue is the HDD, not Windows.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        WTF?

        Re: Flakey

        "Which as hundreds of other models work just fine implies the issue is the HDD, not Windows."

        So it works on other versions not the brand new version? So it MUST be the hardware.

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Flakey

      "That the model of harddrive you have makes the difference between working and not working..

      IBM Compatible anyone????"

      Hardware variation has always been a problem.

      The worst part is when manufacturers change components without changing model numbers, which can lead to software failing on 'models' that have been exhaustively tested for many months, as the guts of the current production model being shipped do not match the nominally identical units used for testing.

  2. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Wanted? I thought it was foisted regardless?

    1. James O'Shea Silver badge

      It just doesn’t show on some systems.

      Whether this is a good thing or a bad thing is left as an exercise for the student.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        "It just doesn’t show on some systems"

        Yeh right, the one's without an internet connection maybe, this update is truly persistent.

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        "It just doesn’t show on some systems."

        If you do a manual update, it shows up. If you leave it as Auto Update, you don't get it.

    2. gerdesj Silver badge
      Trollface

      "Wanted? I thought it was foisted regardless?"

      You mean one day I'll run $ yaourt -Syu and find myself mashing ctrl-c really, really quickly and taking a long hard look at my mirror lists??

      Karma to burn

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        "...$ yaourt -Syu and find myself mashing ctrl-c really, really quickly and taking a long hard look at my mirror lists?"

        And people wonder why Linux isn't more popular.

  3. James O'Shea Silver badge

    Not just Intel SSDs

    I’m running Win 10 in, among other installations, a VM running on a Mac with a Samsung SSD. Win 10 updates to the April Update on almost all systems not in VMs. It updates on systems in VMs, including running on Macs, as long as the host systems are running from spinning rust. It doesn’t like VMs running on SSDs. It doesn’t like some SSDs, not long limited to Intel SSDs.

    If this wasn’t heresy, I’d say that Microsoft may have made an error or two in their installer, but we know that they never make mistakes, so this can’t be true, right?

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Not just Intel SSDs

      To summarise,

      It is CRAP.

      nothing new there then.

      MS really hates us users don't they?

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      'as long as host systems running spinning rust'

      Sounds like a way to cripple updates. Useful bit of info to know!

    3. Paul 129

      Re: Not just Intel SSDs

      Typical MS upgrade. Some hardware is more compatible than others.

      The round of updates that affected even windows 7 made 7,8,10 all incompatible with a little tplink usb-3 hub of mine. (spinny icon of wait and a black screen, not the spinny dots) Its unfortunately a normal part of updating windows. Whats not normal is how we are all stuck with a 6 monthly reinstall of windows on top of itself. Maybe a rollback, and another hard reinstall, all automagicly taking care of your programs and data.

      The wonder is, that it doesn't leave more machines unusable.

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Intel SSD owners rejoice!

    1. Tom 64
      Pint

      Intel SSD owners rejoice!

      I'm rejoicing. My Samsung just got a lot faster with the latest update.

  5. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Why are MS' updates so shit ?

    I understand that MS cannot possibly ensure that their OS updates will work with all combinations of PC hardware.

    BUT, after decades of doing this, why can't they simply, clearly tell the user WHY the update has failed ?

    They expect us to wade through 45MB "human readable" log files to find a clue or run a special app to give another clue. And that app crashed on me.

    AND why can't they detect when updates have failed and DISABLE the automatic re-download and attempt at installing THE EXACT SAME, FAILED UPDATE, oVER AND OVER AGAIN ?!

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Why are MS' updates so shit ?

      Yes, but at least you get a helpful sad face now.

  6. ell.gol
    FAIL

    This is just one of the many problems caused by the April update. Avast av got completely crippled too by the new version of Windows. Just check the Avast forum, it's full of people claiming it has completely stopped working on their machines and all that after they had updated to the new version of Windows.

    1. Def Silver badge

      That's pretty much par for the course with Avast! these days.

      Since they started stuffing it with bloat and popping up notifications all the fucking time it became worthless, and disappeared from all my machines.

      1. Bert 1
        Thumb Up

        Gaming mode

        Run Avast in "Gaming Mode"

  7. mark l 2 Silver badge
    FAIL

    It is not like SSD are a new technology that MS have had to re-write the OS to support. They worked under the previous version of Windows 10 yet somehow this 'feature update' breaks a previously functional system.

    1. John Brown (no body) Silver badge

      "It is not like SSD are a new technology that MS have had to re-write the OS to support. They worked under the previous version of Windows 10 yet somehow this 'feature update' breaks a previously functional system."

      Yes, because either it's a standard interface and so Windows should fall back to a generic driver, or the manufacture provides the driver using the Windows API. The latter can fail if the driver writer uses non-official APIs or MS changes the APIs without notice, neither of which should happen. Since other commentards have reports other SSD with similar issues, maybe it's MS changing the APIs in ways they thought might not damage anything.

      1. leexgx

        its quite annoying even basic things like sound cards don't work after a feature upgrade (some older sound blaster cards no longer work , max windows 10 version 1705 in 1803 stuff just braking )

        just don't understand why they have to tweak with the driver and software model that breaks stuff that has been working for over 6 months to 10 years fine (yes braking windows 10 compatible devices and software that has only just recently come out and MS blames the device or program maker for not following MS guidelines when MS keep on changing it between versions)

        i had to install Win10 LTSB on a one system because each new feature upgrade was causing new problems

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Because lot of that stuff that was written was shit . Remember 10 years ago in XP era programs that demanded to be ran Admin mode or it failed ? Hell to this day you still have software (bitttorent) That demands to be ran as Admin, not in admin mode. Bittorrent wont even install right if I'm not logged in as admin. MS allowed sloppy coding and use of undocumented API. windows 7 comes around and things changes. I have 32 bit software from N4.0 that runs fine on windows 10, yet software from the XP era shits it's self

          1. leexgx

            comments about drivers and stuff been made badly does not make sense

            a device that has been working on Vista, 7 and windows 8 has generally always worked, with windows 10 a Program or driver can break after a feature upgrade when it was working perfectly fine before

            why is MS changing the rules every single feature upgrade comes available, at this point MS is going to be forcing developers to go back to the old days where all support files are baked into program directory again (but this does not help old unsupported but perfectly working hardware from been broken by MS)

        2. Christian Berger Silver badge

          It's a special thing about most closed platforms

          "just don't understand why they have to tweak with the driver and software model that breaks stuff that has been working"

          Essentially when you are writing software for the less traveled areas like device drivers, you will find some bugs in the API, either stuff not working as documented or stuff missing you can get via side effects.

          On a modern Free Software project you'd just submit a bug report the bug would be fixed within hours to days and you can get an experimental patch rather quickly. This doesn't work in commercial environments. There you cannot simply send something to another company. There is no public mailing list you can subscribe to and submit your bug report.

          So people make workarounds. If they are lucky, the workarounds will still work once the bug is fixed, if not the piece of software breaks.

          1. src

            Re: It's a special thing about most closed platforms

            My laptop is affected by this kernel bug reported over a year ago. No sign that anybody is interested in fixing it:

            https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=195471

            1. Christian Berger Silver badge

              Re: It's a special thing about most closed platforms

              "No sign that anybody is interested in fixing it:"

              To be honest that does look a lot like a design problem of your laptop.

      2. leexgx

        if this install brakes on my system i going to be using LTSB after

        currently using windows 10 pro with it set to Semi-Annual (Not Targeted witch is CBB) 15 update delay + 120 days wait after its feature upgrade is available for CBB (Semi-Annual (Not Targeted)

        15 day delay is due to MS in the past releasing updates that break stuff

      3. Chronos Silver badge

        maybe it's MS changing the APIs in ways they thought might not damage anything.

        FSVO "anything," as in "this is our massive pool of unwilling beta testers. Nothing mission critical here."

        1. Boothy

          @AC ...XP era programs that demanded to be ran Admin .

          One of the issues with a lot of XP era programs was that they were not following MS guidelines for NT platforms. Often being apps, or games, from Win 9* that had been ported across/tweaked to run in XP (or newer), or simply written by people who hadn't taken into account the differences between the old 9* platform, and NT OSs like XP.

          A common issue I've seen with a *lot* of older (or just badly written) programs (utils and legacy games), is when the program has config data (often in .ini files), and they put these in the programs installation dir, rather than where they should be, i.e. under user space (e.g. in AppData, or even Docs).

          The programs usually want to open these with write access, but as they are under the protected Program Files area, they need admin rights to do this under XP/Win7 etc..

          A simple work around is to install these programs to somewhere that isn't protected, like D:\Apps or D:\Games instead.

          Doesn't work with everything, but I've found quite a few old apps or games will stop asking for admin rights after doing this.

  8. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    To say...

    To say Windows 1803 is not the best of Microsoft Updates, is an understatement.

    It's not very good at knowing how much disk space it needs to install this update, but > 20GB of free space on drive C: is a good ballpark, < 10GB isn't enough. Good luck with smaller SSDs.

    After 13 attempts it still didn't stop attempting to install itself, it's so persistent if it was a person, you'd take out an injunction against them, to stop them stalking you.

    Sausage Machine, Conveyer Belt ...the usual shite.

    1. Tom 35 Silver badge

      Re: To say...

      Just think of all the cheap windows 10 tablets with 60 GB SSDs...

      1. This post has been deleted by its author

  9. Tom 35 Silver badge

    Looks like we have an MS fanboy

    Looks like someone downvoted every post.

    1. tirk
      Facepalm

      Re: Looks like we have an MS fanboy

      Two of them now - the entire MS QC team have been re-tasked to dealing with this it seems.

      1. Fungus Bob Silver badge
        Devil

        Re: Looks like we have an MS fanboy

        Not the QC team, just SatNad and Gates.

        1. ChrisC

          Re: Looks like we have an MS fanboy

          Naah, whilst I may not have have much admiration for Gates or Ballmer back in the day, I get the feeling they were far more in tune with what the OS meant to PC users than SatNad will ever hope to be, and that they'd be feeling a bit narked at how much damage is now being done to the reputation of Windows, so would find it hard to justify downvoting comments like these. SatNad OTOH, yes, I can all too easily imagine him sat quietly in his office, seething with rage at the thoughts of so many people completely failing to get onboard with his masterplan for Windows, clicking away on the downvote buttons every chance he gets...

          When I now find myself looking back on the Gates/Ballmer era I realise just how good we had it back then in comparison to today, and how good, relatively speaking compared with SatNad, they were to us as end users of their products. Windows was still something of an unholy mess, but at least when stuff got changed it largely seemed to be for the right reasons, and there was still a sense that MS under their leadership understood that the OS wasn't really something to be tinkered with on a whim.

          I find it really difficult to believe that SatNad has that same level of comprehension, therefore can't get why so many of us feel rightly miffed every time the sodding W10 update screen pops up and our hearts sink as we wonder what new mysteries await us once the update process has ended, and therefore has no compulsion to start steering Windows onto a different course to the one it's on right now, headed straight for the largest, most jagged hull-plate ripping, pile of rocks in existence, from where the only way is down...

  10. Nolveys Silver badge
    Windows

    Just Had Fun With This

    A machine with a NVMe would download the Fall Creators Update, display the message "updating, do not turn off or reboot..." for half an hour and reboot. If the user stared at the screen at boot the error message "Something went wrong, but we won't tell you what" popped up for a split second before an odd, graphical pre-boot menu gave the option to boot normally. The process would then restart.

    It turned out that there's a problem which causes the BIOS SMART test to fail, even though the drive works fine. This is reported to the operating system which fails without saying what is going on.

    The problem can be "fixed" by disabling SMART in the BIOS. It sure would have been nice if the OS or BIOS had bothered to tell me what was wrong rather than having me aimlessly wondering the internet for hours and hours...

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Re: Just Had Fun With This

      You know that Win 10 is supposed to run with UEFI, not BIOS?

      1. Nolveys Silver badge
        Windows

        Re: Just Had Fun With This

        You know that Win 10 is supposed to run with UEFI, not BIOS?

        Don't try to teach an old NolVeys new acronyms. Just replace every instance of BIOS in my post with "A giant bag of barely-functional binary blob shit".

  11. elvisimprsntr

    Precisely why I am still on Windows 7.

    Even then, I only run Windows in a NAS VM for the one application which the developer insists on using .NET. Everything else is either macOS or Linux.

    1. codejunky Silver badge

      @ elvisimprsntr

      I seriously dread having to upgrade from windows7. For anything not games related I use linux so that isnt a concern but I do keep a win7 partition just as a gaming machine. The only ray of light I saw was steam supporting linux and my single player stuff on wine. But I am not convinced all of my titles can be run on linux.

    2. Daniel 18

      "Even then, I only run Windows in a NAS VM for the one application which the developer insists on using .NET. Everything else is either macOS or Linux."

      Seems to me the last time I loaded something that wanted .net into WINE, it sent me away to download a .net package from the distribution repository... If you don't need a full VM, WINE may let you run it under Linux/WINE.

  12. cb7

    Space

    "Just think of all the cheap windows 10 tablets with 60 GB SSDs"

    Just think of all the cheap Windows 10 tablets with 32GB persistent storage.

    TFTFY

  13. Usermane

    Will be cheap ssd?

    I am looking for some cheap ssd for my laptop with Kubuntu, maybe will be lucky thanks to MS.

  14. MJI Silver badge

    This downdate is causing hell here

    And why our next system WILL be multi platform.

    Large custom written WIN32 application talking to a database server using various stuff over IP (I write the software but we buy in a popular server with native ISAM access and very well emulated SQL access).

    Vertical market so big fish in a puddle.

    Anyway the LAN changes have buggered up the data server client and stopped it working, and since SAP bought Sybase support has been ruined.

  15. d3rrial

    Linux woes

    And here I thought the bi-weekly sudo pacman -Syu was scary.

    Ha!

  16. Eddy42

    "Redmond is also attempting to block the devices trying the update again"

    Am I the only one who thinks it's amusing that Microsoft are now trying to find a way to block Windows updates?

    The entire user-base has been trying to find a way since the release of Windows 10 - if you find a way Microsoft could you let the community know the secret...

Page:

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon

Biting the hand that feeds IT © 1998–2019