back to article New Google vid-call app

Google has released “Duo”, a simple one-to-one video calling app that runs on iOS and Android and can make calls between the two operating systems. Duo needs just a phone number to make a connection, so is a bit of a swipe at closed calling ecosystems like Apple's FaceTime. Google says it's designed the app to figure out when …

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Why is this better than Skype?

    iOS and Android users already have this.

    1. MrDamage Silver badge

      Re: Why is this better than Skype?

      Why hand over all your details to an amateur in the data slurping game, when you can hand them over to the professionals?

      /coat.

      1. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: Why is this better than Skype?

        Why hand over all your details to an amateur in the data slurping game, when you can hand them over to the professionals?

        Exactly. First of all, you won't know who is listening (or, as it's Google, who isn't listening), secondly it means you have agreed for everything you talk about to be kept into perpetuity (read their conditions for once - it's in there) and thirdly, that so-called "ease of use" by using your phone number means that Google can complete its database of global mobile phone numbers.

        It puzzles me that there are no other, more open alternatives - is this field really so patent encumbered? The only one I have found is Jitsi, and I wasn't impressed the last time I used it on OSX as both its GUI and setup process was in serious need of a cleanup (plus it is multi-platform by using Java, and I'm not a big fan of that approach).

        Maybe I ought to check on its status again, and see what sort of help they need to make it better.

        1. Dan 55 Silver badge

          Re: Why is this better than Skype?

          Wire, unfortunately no Linux client but it can be used in a browser too.

          1. AMBxx Silver badge
            Boffin

            Open Alternatives

            Shame there's no extension to SIP that allows video calling, or maybe there is??

            1. Anonymous Coward
              Anonymous Coward

              Re: Open Alternatives

              Shame there's no extension to SIP that allows video calling, or maybe there is??

              There is - you can carry it via a jabber/xmpp link but I think there's also something in SIP as an Asterisk server can comfortably handle it, and video-capable SIP phones are not even that hard to find.

        2. simmondp

          Re: Why is this better than Skype?

          Look at Wire, not open source, but a good raft of platform support as well as it works with my Chromebook (the acid test)

    2. paulf

      Re: Why is this better than Skype?

      @ DougS

      "Why is this better than Skype? iOS and Android users already have this."

      Native Skype for Windows Phone walked behind shed, shot heard. iOS, Android will also lose their native Skype apps

      I think the standard comment wondering how long it will be until Google kill this new product applies here also.

      1. Dan 55 Silver badge

        Re: Why is this better than Skype?

        What seems to be happening with the Skype client is removal of support for older versions of desktop/mobile OSes, but it will carry on working on the newer versions.

        If you don't want to update your OS then you've got to stay with an older Skype client. When that stops working on your older OS in 2017 due to network changes, you either update your OS and use the latest Skype client or stop using Skype.

  2. Dan 55 Silver badge

    Have they solved the Chatroulette problem?

    Knock Knock

    Who's there?

    Don't look or you'll go blind.

    1. MrDamage Silver badge

      Re: Have they solved the Chatroulette problem?

      Isn't the knocking sound coming from under the desk of the person trying to make themselves go blind?

  3. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I like to have a wide choice in botnet communication apps.

  4. 1Rafayal

    I am surprised that Google hasn't tried to do something in this area before now to be honest.

    Dont know if it will be a Skype killer, as much as people hate Microsoft they do like Skype and the thing is damn near ubiquitous these days. Either way, I would be interested to see where this ends up, especially the knock knock feature.

POST COMMENT House rules

Not a member of The Register? Create a new account here.

  • Enter your comment

  • Add an icon

Anonymous cowards cannot choose their icon