back to article UK crime-busters knock hiphop site off the Internet

The UK’s Serious Organised Crime Agency (SOCA) has moved on a popular hip-hop news and track-exchange site, RnB Xclusive, and is threatening those trying to access the site with criminal investigation. The site, described by TorrentFreak as a popular blog posting news, commentary and links to music, has been seized by SOCA and …

COMMENTS

This topic is closed for new posts.

Page:

  1. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Looks like SOCA are doing a fine job of fighting serious crime and protecting the public.

    1. Jedit Silver badge
      Joke

      Well...

      ... they just rounded up a bunch of gangstas!

    2. This post has been deleted by its author

  2. a33a
    Stop

    "SOCA has the capability to monitor and investigate you, and can inform your internet service provider of these infringements."

    Jesus Christ, talk about scare mongering. The IP info and access time table is just unnecessary. SOCA trying to imply they have powers (and laws) that they don't then?

    1. Arrrggghh-otron

      Don't forget to leave them a nice comment in their server log files... (as suggested on slashdot)

      http://rnbxclusive.com/SOCA_Are_Wankers

      or

      http://rnbxclusive.com/You_really_don't_need_to_threaten_innocent_visitors_to_this_site_do_you

      Feel free to get creative...

      1. Sir Runcible Spoon

        Sir

        Feel free to get creative...

        Done.

      2. This post has been deleted by its author

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      ACS Law tried something similar with IP addresses, and the courts were really impressed by that.

      FFS they can't even cobble together a single web page without errors. Not very inspiring in what is supposed to be an "elite" police unit.

      1. Dr. Mouse

        For anyone who wants to leave them a message

        Assuming you are running Linux:

        Put your message, using only alphanumeric characters and spaces, into a file called socamessage, then run the following command:

        cat socamessage | sed -e 's/\s/_/g' | (while read L; do wget -O /dev/null "http://webwarper.net/ww/rnbxclusive.com/$L"; done)

        If you have a long message to send, it can be split over several lines.

        This will also anonymise, although only through a single proxy.

        My own just let them know my displeasure at the Serious Organised Crime Agency threatening to investgate the probably innocent visitors to the site, and asking why they don't have better things to do (like investigating SERIOUS ORGANISED crime)

        1. Arrrggghh-otron

          Communications Act 2003?

          I've just realised that it isn't just me that thinks the message displayed is threatening, and I had never been to or heard of the site before today...

          Does this mean that the CPS will be prosecuting whoever at SOCA was responsible for the threatening web page? I mean if it works for a twitter joke with no intent then why not this? Or is a threat to enforce legal powers that (I'm told) doesn't exist, exempt it from being threatening?

    3. Danny 5
      Go

      teehee

      I checked out the site just for that purpose, being Dutch myself, my check poisons their results.

      Let's all check them out!

      I'd like to see them investigate me :)

      why can't the rest of the world do what we do? downloading (movies and music) is legal here.

  3. Big O
    WTF?

    Priorities in check then

  4. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    FFS !

    SOCA try dealing with scrap metal theft, that's a SERIOUS ORGANISED CRIME PROBLEM !

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      That, and that every farm, inside a 50 mile radius of my current location, has had some sort of heavy machinery stolen (we're talking tractors and jbc's.. 100k+ items), in the last 8 months.. but crack on guys, go find the software and entermaint pirates.. nevermind that we have 3 or 4 civilain patrols, circling our farms and industrial areas, with not a word from the local cops.... and god help anyone they stop that looks a bit suspicious...

    2. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Similarly fuel theft. Just about every transport firm and building site round here has been targeted.

      A pair of lads came unstuck one night at a local lorry park though when they got spotted by a driver having a kip in his cab.

      I gather they had a pretty sophisticated set up - a transit van full of drums and electric pumps.

      According to one of the drivers they got a "severe kicking" and their van trashed. He said they didn't bother involving telling the police as they would have turned up far too late and charged the drivers with assault.

      These lads were well known locally for selling cheap diesel, so it probably wouldn't have been the hardest crime to investigate.

    3. teebie

      Or just...crime, in general?

      Instead of matters of civil law

  5. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Record Companies Paying Police ?

    Seems like Virgin were paying the police:

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/law-and-order/9061383/Private-firms-give-UK-police-forces-millions-of-pounds-to-investigate-crimes.html

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Sad really, when Robert Peel invented the police force, it was this exact sort of behaviour he was trying to wipe out. Peel's police men were assembled to replace the ad-hoc city guards and watchmen, who were usually beholden to the local magistrate and were generally a bunch of bullyboys and criminals, who would gladly take payment to lock up people for being in some rich idiot's bad books.

      Full circle...

    2. ACx

      Virgin? The biggest distributors of illegal files in the UK? Well, that takes some balls. We realise they actually host pirated files for free distribution, right?

      No, Im not substantiating that, but any one who thinks about VM and its services should suss what is insanely wrong here.

  6. Christoph

    Expect a whole load of faked links directing people to that site and getting them on the police records. How are little old ladies going to react when they see that kind of threat when they were looking for pictures of fluffy cats?

    1. cosymart
      Holmes

      Think of the children

      And dirty old men looking for fluffy pussy's.

      1. The Fuzzy Wotnot
        Facepalm

        *BANG* A Quantum Leap style flashback to 70's TV and there, right at the forefront of my memory, Molly Sugden's bizarre pastel coloured rinse!

        Thanks a lot! It took years to shift the horrendous chimera images of pussies and Molly Sugden, now they're back in a flash!

  7. Dazzz
    Trollface

    Well now they have my IP address, hope they have fun with all the ones they are collecting :-)

  8. Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

    SOCA? Really?

    So what's the reference to pro-music.org doing on the page? Is UK law enforcement in the habit of shilling for special interest groups?

    Given the language and that strange reference, I'm thinking that this might be a fake.

    1. huwOS

      One would think so, but it isn't.

      SOCA press office confirmed it was genuine.

      1. Eddie Edwards
        Facepalm

        Yeah, the "SOCA press office confirms genuine" meme is on Slashdot too. So who called them? I'm not seeing an actual *quote* from the SOCA press office in this story, or anywhere else.

        This is so obviously a hoax I can't believe people are giving it the time of day. SOCA wittering on about young musician's rights? "Fraud" in the first place (for a link site)? "Recordings stolen from the artists"? Stolen? I thought it was fraud? And then "visit pro-music.org". Please. This is a blatant troll. And boy did it work well.

        People of the internet, turn your bullshit filters back on.

        1. Eddie Edwards
          FAIL

          Wow, I was wrong, this is real. Apparently SOCA have become internet trolls.

          Better take my bullshit filters in for realignment. You think you understand the world and then something like this happens.

  9. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I was aware that 'making available', ie uploading it was a naughty (thought it was only a civil offence though), and probably running a website knowingly hosting copyrighted material is probably a bit dubious.

    Is downloading a file from a website a criminal offence?

    1. Paul_Murphy

      >Is downloading a file from a website a criminal offence?

      My understanding is no, but making a copy-right protected file available for others to download is.

      Of course others such as Cory Doctorow and Jonathon Coulton or Woodie Guthrie have no issues with their files being spread far and wide since it means more fans.

      I wonder how long before the mafRIAA try to get downloading a file to be a crime though - you can bet they want it to be.

      ttfn

      1. Jedit Silver badge

        Woody Guthrie?

        I'm sure he hasn't complained about his files being spread far and wide, but I equally doubt he's voiced his support either - what with him having been dead for going on sixty years, and all.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          Re: Woody Guthrie?

          While I expect SOCA would want to bang up his boy for what he might have brought into Los Angeles, where their spiritual home would appear to be.

    2. Vic

      > Is downloading a file from a website a criminal offence?

      It can be.

      The notorious section 107 of CDPA88 turns copyright infringement into a criminal offence if it is performed in a commercial context.

      Quote why SOCA is wasting valuable resources investigating civil infringements is beyond me, though.

      Vic.

  10. Keep Refrigerated
    WTF?

    Seriously?

    This take-down notice looks like it was written by a 12 year old. No reference even to the statute upon which the site was taken down? Some vague statement about young penniless artists.

    What's the betting that the site owner is going to be released and charges dropped after a real judge looks into this? The only thing that surprises me is its not accompanied by a press release to The Sun that the site owner may have child porn stored on his servers.

    Really, this just makes SOCA look like amateur stooges hired by the MAFIAA. Not professional at all. But I suppose theres no danger of Tony Blair writing a letter to drop the investigation here, is there?

    1. Anonymous Coward
      Anonymous Coward

      Tony Blair?

      1. The Original Cactus

        IIRC, when he was PM Tony Blair asked SOCA to kindly please stop investigating bribes allegedly paid to BAE by Saudi princes, in the interests of national security. SOCA complied.

        1. Anonymous Coward
          Anonymous Coward

          I remember that now.

          National security you say, sir.

          Of course, sir.

          Can I stand up straight now, sir?

  11. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I'm concerned that even the fusking police think that the songs were "stolen" from the artists. I'm even more concerned that, despite this apparent grand-scale theft of songs, there is still a metric shit-tonne of mass-produced, lowest common denominator, well, shit being pushed out by "artists" every day. You'd think they'd be locking up their songs in bank safes to prevent this kind of crime happening (coincidently also preventing the crime of these songs being inflicted on the general public).

    1. WonkoTheSane
      Trollface

      Title goes where?

      "mass-produced, lowest common denominator, well, shit being pushed out by "artists" every day"

      Or "Complete & utter Cowell" as I like to call it.

  12. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Looks like BS to me

    As others have noted, the text looks like it was written by someone quite young. Aside from that, the nameservers never changed, so it's still with rackspace.

    Look at every site that the UK/US government have taken over in the past and you'll note that they redirect the nameservers, and THAT is how they "take over" the website.

  13. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    lets have fun

    Everyone hammer the site from as many Ip address you can and confuse the shit out of them.

  14. kain preacher

    Odd thought

    It's dot com site hosted by go daddy , Could go daddy just say see you when you come to America and serve us ?

  15. irish donkey
    Megaphone

    SOCA Crime Figures

    Last year we solved 1 million crimes. Give us all a bonus please.

    One million downloads stopped. = 1 million crimes solved.

    Never mind the low level crime like car theft, scrap metal theft, low level fraud, pissed teenagers kicking off, child abuse, wife beating and MegaCorp tax fraud. You know the stuff the that really pisses people off

    SOCA because we go after the real criminals.

  16. mitch 4
    FAIL

    Web Standards

    Well for one they don't follow web standards. The new "SOCA" site is littered with errors, some of them don't even make syntactic sense.

    http://validator.w3.org/check?verbose=1&uri=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.rnbxclusive.com%2F

    I would think if they are going be posting professional messags about how they can trace you they could at least make a attempt to look professional and do things right.

    1. Andrew 59
      Facepalm

      lol

      Well done... Now they've got to investigate w3.org :)

      1. Miek

        and http://netrenderer.com/ too ;)

      2. Anonymous Coward
        Anonymous Coward

        Re: lol

        i feel it is my civic duty to ensure govt websites are accessible by the disabled...

  17. FatBloke
    Devil

    Incoming

    Just waiting for Anonymous to fire up...

  18. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    Straight Outta Suffolk

    It's true, there is an epidemic of agricultural machinery theft. Where I live pieces of machinery & fuel is regularly stolen (sometimes from inside secure areas- thieves will cut through locks easily enough). Only at the end of last year our family farm had a load of spare parts taken from a shed to the value of £6000 for scrap. No-one saw anything. The police never seem to catch anyone or bother to investigate (the some of the thieves are probably from outside the local area).

    1. Tegne
      Black Helicopters

      The level of police interest depends on the area

      My wife works for a vehicle tracking company who regularly assist a number of police forces around the UK who set up tracked honey traps for Farm and Industrial machinery.

  19. Anonymous Coward
    Anonymous Coward

    I really don't think this is genuine.

    "The majority of music files that were available via this site were stolen from the artists."

    I can't see SOCA making this absolute statement no crime has been proven and copyright infringement is not theft. surely SOCA would know this.

    " If you have downloaded music using this website you may have committed a criminal offence which carries a maximum penalty of up to 10 years imprisonment and an unlimited fine under UK law.

    Utterly untrue.

    "SOCA has the capability to monitor and investigate you, and can inform your internet service provider of these infringements."

    Visiting a site proves nothing so this threat is baseless and surely no government organisation would say something so ridiculous.. Also WTF is my ISP supposed to do?

    "You may be liable for prosecution and the fact that you have received this message does not preclude you from prosecution."

    Another baseless threat straight out of the TV licensing's playbook.

    "As a result of illegal downloads young, emerging artists may have had their careers damaged. If you have illegally downloaded music you will have damaged the future of the music industry.

    As a result of illegal downloads young, emerging artists may have had their careers damaged. If you have illegally downloaded music you will have damaged the future of the music industry.

    Visit pro-music.org for a list of legal music sites on the web."

    Blatant MPAA style propaganda and an advert for an industry website?

    Please don't make me laugh.

Page:

This topic is closed for new posts.