* Posts by Graham Marsden

5948 posts • joined 19 Jan 2007

Hawking and friends: Artificial Intelligence 'must do what we want it to do'

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

Re: @Stevie - That was exactly the point about HAL 9000 that Kubrick and Clarke made

> I get the distinct impression you are coming to the debate over "2001 ending: Brilliant or Crap?" debate from the benefit [...]

Well you'd be wrong.

I first saw 2001 on the big screen when I was 14 in 1979 and whilst I may not have noted all the subtleties that I later learned about, I understood it.

Just because you didn't doesn't mean I have to share your opinion.

0
0
Graham Marsden
Silver badge

@Stevie - Re: That was exactly the point about HAL 9000 that Kubrick and Clarke made

> it wasn't properly explained until the movie 2010

"No 9000 computer has ever made a mistake or distorted information" - HAL

"[...] there is something about this mission that we weren't told. Something the rest of the crew know and that you know. We would like to know if that is true." - Frank Poole

"Good day, gentlemen. This is a pre-recorded briefing made prior to your departure and which, for security reasons of the highest importance, has been known on board during the mission only by your H-A-L 9000 computer." - Recording in 2001

"I have come to the conclusion that for so many years films were made for the 12 year old mind that, at last, alas, our critics have emerged with 12 year old minds. " - The Lost Worlds of 2001 - Arthur C Clarke.

7
0

Checkmate, GoDaddy – Google starts flogging dot-word domain names

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Devil

And what's the betting...

... this suddenly appears right at the top of the "organic" search results...

2
0

What do UK and Iran have in common? Both want to outlaw encrypted apps

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Big Brother

Re: Die Gedanken sind frei…

Oh, but Call me David is quite supportive of Freedom of Thought...

... Provided you're only thinking things that he approves of, that is.

No Thought Crime, No Crime Think? Double-plus good, proles!

1
0

Dot-word domains 'a shakedown, designed to get money out of people'

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Holmes

It's all a money making scheme?

Damn, how could we not have all realised that and objected before they did it?

Oh, hang on, we did, but they went ahead with it anyway because they don't give a shit what anyone else thinks.

6
0

Peers warn against rushing 'enhanced' DATA SLURP powers through Parliament

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

@dogged

> We don't know what they'd do but - and this is important - neither do they.

ORLY? A quick google of Green Party Policy on Surveillance comes up with:

"The Green Party of England and Wales believes that illegal mass surveillance must be opposed. The Green Party will campaign against such surveillance and will act to protect whistle blowers such as Snowden who oppose illegal intrusion by the state."

http://policy.greenparty.org.uk/record-of-policy-statements.html

I think perhaps you're thinking of UKIP where their policies are vague and ill-defined soundbites which generally depend on what Nigel F thinks will sound good in the media that particular day (unless he's changed his mind again in the last five minutes).

3
0

Frontier wipes credit of Elite: Dangerous 'billionaire' badboys

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Thumb Up

@WraithCadmus - Re: Mostly Penniless.

Ah yes, I remembered the co-ordinates were (-2, -2) but I couldn't remember the name :-)

0
0
Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: Mostly Penniless.

There was also a system in Amiga Frontier Elite where Gemstones were illegal and people would *pay* you to take them off your hands!

All you needed to do was buy a Viper and install a Class III Military Hyperdrive and you could stock up on Gems, Hyperspace to a system which would pay top dollar for them, rinse and repeat until you were stinkingly rich and could afford any ship or equipment you wanted.

Right on, Commander!

0
0

MI5 boss: We NEED to break securo-tech, get 'assistance' from data-slurp firms

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Holmes

"first person in the UK to be convicted of terrorist offences...

"... in connection with the Syria conflict had received advice on how to access extremist training and weaponry in Syria through online contact with other extremists based overseas."

Wow, you mean they didn't write letters and send them through the post...???

5
1

NASA closing on fix for Opportunity rover's 'amnesia'

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Coat

Re: Reinstalling the OS on a >12 year old machine.

And then wait a *very* long time for all the updates and reboots to install over very narrow bandwidth...

1
0

What an ACE-HOLE! This super-software will whip you at poker, hands down

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

@Bunbury - Re: So What?

The Gambler's Fallacy is that dice/ roulette wheels/ coin flips whatever have "memory", ie that if you get a run of Heads the next flip is more likely to be Tails.

Of course (unless you're using loaded dice or double-headed coins etc) this is nonsense since each event is not linked to the previous one, but people still believe it.

4
0

My best bud is a billionaire: Peter Thiel jumps into bed with dope upstarts

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Thumb Up

Re: >empowering consumers worldwide

And let people know exactly what they're buying if they're going to use the stuff.

It looks like sanity is slowly breaking out.

3
0

LICK THAT ATM: Diebold and Corning debug displays

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Thumb Up

Hmm...

Ford Prefect: ”Golgafrincham Ark Fleet. Ship B. Hold Seven: Telephone Sanitizer, Second Class.” And a serial number!"

Arthur Dent: ”Telephone Sanitizer”? A dead telephone sanitizer?"

Ford Prefect: "Best kind."

3
0

Sardine fishing in Kerala: Who benefits from mobile phones?

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Thumb Down

@Tim Worstal - Re: Ok, so...

And, once again, TW cherry takes one small piece of the argument which he can pick nits from and uses that to try to imply that he's refuted the main argument instead of just ignoring it...

2
3
Graham Marsden
Silver badge

Ok, so...

... the whole point of this article is for TW to be able to go "Nar nar ne-nar, nar! Told you so!!!"?

Possibly followed with an implication that, because *this* example has worked so well, we shouldn't to *anything* to try to alleviate poverty since the Free Market will do that so well for itself.

Of course there's the small matter that that article was from 2007.

Here's a quote from one written in 2012 Problems plaguing Kerala's once-thriving fishing industry:

* * * * *

"The state's fish production has fallen by 40,000 tonnes over the past nine years, though the volume of fish caught by mechanised trawlers has doubled to more than 2 lakh tonnes in 20 years, data from the state's Directorate of Fisheries shows. Traditional fishing fell nearly 60% during the period.

"The state has imposed a ban on trawling during the monsoon, but it seldom takes action on illegal trawlers,'' says Peter. "Often, we are out in the deep sea for days on single-engine-driven boats,'' says Arumugam, a fisherman. He says Kerala fishermen sometimes go as far as the Gujarat coast, and even towards the Gulf, looking for a good catch.

Kurup notes, "There has been an 80% decline in cat fish and black fish alone.'' He notes that bottom trawlers throw non-commercial fish and planktons back into the sea. "The seabed over the years will be filled with this garbage," he warns. The tropical Arabian coast is still home to at least 200 species of fish compared with Pacific and Atlantic coasts which have far less diversity.

"We need to device our own marine management systems and support the livelihood of traditional fishermen in the country,'' says Deepak Apte, deputy director of Bombay Natural History Society. Until then, for people like Johnson, casting the net is a game of dice.

* * * * *

In other words the Free Market has also created conditions whereby those fishermen who had benefitted from what TW describes, now find themselves unable to make a living because big, commercial operators have moved in, over-fished the area and screwed up the eco-system.

Again, I ask: Cui bono?

2
4

US kills EU watchdog's probe into EU cops sharing EU citizens' data

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
WTF?

whether requests from the US are “proportionate and necessary.”

The US should *demonstrate* that their requests are "proportionate and necessary" not simply say "We say they are so Ner! And if you don't like it, we'll pick up our marbles and go home... so double Ner!"

8
0

Really, govt tech profit cash grab is a PRIZE-WINNING idea?

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

@Tim Worstal - Re: " I find there's a gaping hole or two in her arguments..."

> I've said absolutely nothing at all about any "trickle down" effect. That being where Steve-o goes and buys a new yacht with his billions and thus provides a living to a few carpenters.

Exactly! Meanwhile his products are being made by the cheapest labour possible, being sold by people who don't get paid much more and the profits go into his bank account and to those who are rich enough to be able to put spare money into shares to get dividends.

In the mean time we get the latest shiny-shiny which will rapidly become obsolete or break down and probably has no servicable parts in it (maybe not even a replaceable battery!) so we're induced (if not forced) to "upgrade" to "benefit" and so it goes on.

Cui bono?

7
11
Graham Marsden
Silver badge

" I find there's a gaping hole or two in her arguments. I'll concentrate on just one here"

Translation: Let me cherry-pick one argument that I can nit-pick and use that to "disprove" her entire case.

Interestingly, TW doesn't mention this bit:

"Some economists argue that the reward for the state comes through taxation. This, in theory, is right. Innovation-led growth should lead to an increase in tax revenue – but not if the companies that benefit the most from innovations don’t pay much tax compared to the income they generate, not only as a result of loopholes but also because of their continual lobbying for tax incentives and tax cuts that they say they need to foster innovation. It’s not a coincidence that groups such as the National Venture Capital Association helped convince the US government to reduce capital gains tax by 50 per cent in only five years in the late 1970s – an “innovation policy” later copied by Tony Blair’s government. (A policy that even Warren Buffett has admitted has had no effect on investment but lots on inequality.)"

TW says "We're only making the observation that if we allow someone who has increased global growth rates so markedly to keep his pile of cash, then this will encourage the next person with an idea that might boost global growth rates to get on with it. This is not a moral nor justice "deserved rewards" style argument. It's a purely utilitarian one regarding incentives that induce people to try."

What he doesn't say is that, rather than the so-called "Trickle Down" effect that is supposed to make us all better off, what we actually get is a "Trickle Up" effect that concentrates more wealth into the hands of a minority, making it *more* difficult for others who want to try to actually get even one foot on the ladder because those at the top can manipulate the markets to undercut newcomers, not to mention leveraging their wealth into political influence.

"economics is is all about incentives and perhaps we might expect a professor of the subject to grok that"

And perhaps we can hope that TW will realise that there's a difference between the incentive to try and the incentive of those who have a monopolistic hold on the market (Google, Amazon etc) to ensure that nobody gets to successfully compete with them.

19
12

You like that E Ink book, huh? How about an E Ink HOUSE

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

Prior Art:...

"Follow the lighted dots on the floor. Your code is red yellow yellow. Whenever you are assigned a path to follow it will be red yellow yellow, three dots side by side - go where those lights indicate."

- Enders Game

0
0
Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Devil

I was thinking the same thing.

How long before huge dicks start appearing on the walls of office buildings full of, well, huge dicks...?!

1
0

ISS Robonaut gets LEGLESS ... in spaaaace

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Coat

Then they found the small print on the box...

... which said *Batteries not included

0
0

Right to be forgotten? That’s not Google’s call – data MEP Albrecht

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
WTF?

WT Everlasting F???

A leading Data Protection MEP has to sign a document threatening him with jail just to find out what TTIP is about?

Something is *seriously* fucked up here!!!

17
0

A Cambridge boffin told me YOU'RE A BIG, FAT LIAR

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Holmes

"A guilty man can always just freeze, but that will rather give the game away"

And an innocent person would never freeze up under questioning, so they *must* be guilty...

0
0

Boffins spy I in your little eye

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

@Chris G

If you're really that desperate to look at another bloke's wedding tackle, there's easier ways of doing it...

1
0

Healthcare: Look anywhere you like for answers, just not the US

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

@Tim Worstal

An article you've written that I can agree with, thank you!

But perhaps you could convince Nigel "I think we are going to have to move to an insurance-based system of healthcare" Farage of this...?

5
0

Zuckerberg asks the public to tell him where to go in 2015

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Mushroom

Take a long walk...

... off a short pier...

1
0

NASA preps lobotomy for Opportunity rover to cure amnesia

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: Necessary XKCD Reference

"My mind is going. I can feel it. I can feel it. I'm afraid."

- HAL - 2001 a Space Odyssey.

4
0

Ghosts of Christmas Past: The long-ago geek gifts that made us what we are

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Happy

@ Zog_but_not_the_first - Re: Elf and safety

> No to mention the lighter fuel refills in small flexible bottle-shaped containers. Snip off the tip, light match and squeeze. Instant flamethrower!

Ah, we went one better: We'd get the Aerosol type refils which came with various adapters to fit different types of lighters. One of these was a cylinder which had a flange at the base and you could take a short (5 hole) piece of Meccano, put the centre hole over the adapter so it rested on the flange, then, with your fingers safely out of the way, use a lighter to turn it into a controllable flame thrower!

0
0
Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Thumb Up

@Triggerfish - Re: You left out flying models

> Remember those balsa jobs where you had to assemble all the ribs and spars cover it in tissue paper and dope it.

Wow, that brings back memories of going into The Model Airport in Bristol and looking enviously at the massive 6' wingspan remote control gliders they had hanging up!

Alas I never got one of those, but I did have one (a KielKraft Conquest) which was a tow-line glider with a 30" wingspan. We had a golf course behind our house in Long Ashton which was virtually unused during the week, so in the holidays I'd take it up there and launch it down the fairways :-)

0
0

Robox: How good could a sub-£1k 3D printer be?

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

I'd say the next market for 3D printers will be the ones where you want short-run or low quantity plastic items which would be too expensive to get injection moulded.

An example would be small Board Games producers who want custom pieces for their games (rather than just coloured wooden blocks/ discs etc) but may only be producing a couple of thousand units.

As always, this may start off as a solution in search of a problem, but almost inevitably people find uses that you would never have thought of.

2
0

European data law: UK.gov TRASHES 'unambiguous consent' plans

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Devil

By continuing to read this post...

... you automatically and irrevocably consent to have your personal information sold to the highest bidder so it's far to late to start making a fuss about it now!

3
0
Graham Marsden
Silver badge

> 51% indicated that they would vote to leave the EU.

So well within the +/- 3% margin that such polls tend to have that the figures are actually the other way around.

1
2

Makers of Snowden movie Citizenfour sued by ex-oil exec

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

Re: Marsbarbrain FrankAlphaXII

Matt, as enjoyable as it is, eventually playing Chase the Goalposts with you, after repeated attempts to make you comprehend the difference between Matt Bryant's universe and the Real World, frankly gets rather tedious.

Please feel free, as always, to declare victory.

1
1
Graham Marsden
Silver badge

Re: FrankAlphaXII

> PS:- just for the reflexive downvoters, you may not like the Matt's opinions and interpretations but that doesn't make them true.

FTFY

(Awaits the next round of Matt Bryant Bingo...)

2
1
Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: Works 4 me

Says the brave Anonymous Coward...

1
0

NSA's Christmas Eve confession: We unlawfully spied on you for 12 years, soz

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Facepalm

"The organization was only able to file the request...

"...thanks to knowing specifically what to ask for, thanks to internal documents leaked to the world by Edward Snowden"

Damn that Traitor! Giving away information that would be of use to America's The NSA's enemies...

6
1

Hipsters ahoy! Top Ten BOARD games for festive family fun

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Facepalm

Re: @Duffy Moon - £499?

And that proves what? Oh, right, that the people on The Apprentice are clueless idiots who have no idea what they're doing and manage to fail utterly at it...!

0
0
Graham Marsden
Silver badge

@LINCARD1000 - Re: RoboRally

RoboRally suffers from the problem that if someone's good at programing, they can generally get streets ahead of everyone and have virtually won the game whilst others have barely got out of their starting positions because they keep falling into holes or getting zapped by lasers etc.

It works if everyone is on a similar level of skill, but if not it can be very frustrating for those who get stuck at the start.

0
0
Graham Marsden
Silver badge

@I ain't Spartacus - Re: Escape from...

The main problems with Escape from Colditz are 1) if you're playing it with someone being the Germans, they get to listen in to all your plans which is hardly realistic and 2) it's possible for you to spend ages assembling the bits for your escape and then someone go for a "Do or Die" (I think that's what it was called) escape attempt, succeed and all your hard work is wasted.

Ok, it may be "realistic" as regards what actually happened, but it's not necessarily always good fun.

0
0

Internet community split on who should run IANA

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Holmes

Well what a surprise...

ICANN thinks that ICANN should run the internet...

0
0

Mysterious STAR set to appear on Christmas Eve above Blighty: The ISS

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Coat

@Danny 14

Neverwhere...

0
0

Q*bert: The Escher-inspired platform puzzler from 1982

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Thumb Up

"a well-practised player...

"could continue ad infinitum on just one credit..."

Yep! With just a pound (10 pence a game!) I could waste spend a whole afternoon playing on Q*Bert and the vertically scrolling shoot-em-up game Xevious :-)

1
0

Doctor Who's tangerine dream and Clara's death wish in Last Christmas

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Coat

Re: Yippee-ki-yay

And who else's mind added the words "Mother fucker" at the end of that sentence?

8
0

FCC: A few (680,000) net neutrality comments lost in 'XML gaffe'

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

Re: If the FCC can't figure this out...

It depends on how much Big Media want to spend...

0
0

Hilton, Marriott and co want permission to JAM guests' personal Wi-Fi

Graham Marsden
Silver badge

Damn right!

I've thought of visiting the States in the past, but there's no way I'm going to go there whilst I'm treated as a Terrorist suspect simply for wanting to do so!

Meanwhile, of course, the real terrorists are laughing their socks off at the way they've got Uncle Sam dancing to their tune...

31
0

GCHQ: We can't track crims any more thanks to Snowden

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Big Brother

Let me edit that for you...

GCHQ: "We can't track everyone any more."

Us: "Thanks to Snowden!"

2
0

Blind justice: Google lawsuit silences elected state prosecutor

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Thumb Down

Ok, so...

... I've just read a three-page article which seems long on conjecture and hyperbole, but rather short on facts.

(Actually I didn't even notice the byline until I was about four paragraphs into reading it and then thought "Hang on, this sounds like [scrolls up] yep, it's Orlowski."

Let's ignore the rhetoric such as "assassinating" and "silenced" and the background which is interesting, but possibly a little over-done and see what it actually says;

Oh, right. Businesses who have vested interests like to get media outlets to publish stories which are favourable to them. Just like elected politicians do (such as State Prosecutors who like to prosecute high-profile, media-friendly cases against kidnappers, paedophiles and such which boost their profile and, thus, their re-election chances) and just like Big Media do by trying to redefine copyright infringement as "theft".

All the rest of it seems to be Andrew bashing his favourite targets (Obama, people who object to excessive copyright enforcement and DCM and those who want laws to be proportionate rather than overbearing).

At least it was published as "comment" (which is only one step above "opinion")...

49
7

Google's first stab at control-free ROBOT car rolls off the line

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Unhappy

Re: a choice

Yes, but those who *shouldn't* be allowed out in control of a skateboard are most likely to be those who would *not* avail themselves of this technology, because they're most likely part of that 80%+ of drivers who think that their skills are "above average".

3
0

Fancy a .trust domain? How's $150,000 sound?

Graham Marsden
Silver badge
Facepalm

The Lads from Lagos...

... want to buy 419.trust...

5
0

Forums