48 posts • joined 2 May 2013
Rampant, It was convincing until 'Strong IP'
Read your history, IP is only enforced once vested interests have established themselves.
Rampant - good points
You make some very good points, all of which should be subject to open and frank discussion.
I will take the liberty of responding in reverse order cuz I keep scrolling up and down. (surely someone has a patent on keeping track of argument)
Sigma. Nikon and Canon.
Two big players developed a (possibly unique and wholly innovative) new system, it probably took them years and cost many $.
Sigma (allegedly) ripped them off, except N & C had many years to develop their products and bring them to market, no doubt using the 'Nikon' or whatever brand to sell them, me as a professional photographer can't risk using some upstarts (Sigma) kit cuz my clients want to have the confidence that I know what I'm doing, they want Nikon or nothing. Sigma (whether they ripped off the tech or developed it independently) will always be at a disadvantage because they are second to market.
So holding a patent is not the advantage, commercialising it first with a reputable brand is.
Copyright isn't a con - I agree with that (surprisingly) I do question its usefulness, surely an album of Bailey prints is worth more if David signs each one individually in ink (or blood), is the unsigned one produced in the same printers worth less ? what about the one produced down the road, sold for half the price that doesn't have the 'official' stamp ? (where is the value, the print, the printer or the blood ?)
'I would have to recoup that (minus additional production costs) in a single sale.'
Isn't that how Van Gogh worked ?
Isn't it true that the 'unlicenced' copies (because he died a long time ago) and prints produced by TD&H maximise his popularity which is reflected in the desirability of an original, withou this popularity would his paintings be worth any more than £30
Would you have left the security of your job for the 'wild west' without copyright protection ? I don't know, would you still be subject to the lawnsprinkler if you hadn't. That is an individual decision.
Would you still be in business if the rules were changed ?
Before the rules were imposed (usually arbitrarily by a King in favour of an individual) there was a free for all yet commerce still thrived.
Sorry for the long post but copyright and patent is a big issue.
There are vested interests who wish to keep and stengthen IP
There are vested interests who like the status quo
There are vested interests who would like to weaken IP
There are vested interests who would like to abolish IP altogether
And there is someone who asks who really benefits from the IP system and where is the evidence.
To the Mystery Thum Downer
I offer this
show me yours
VinceH - a fair point
(who is the mystery thumbs downer then ?)
I write software as well, I'm fairly sure that some of the assembler I write has been written before (and I've been doing it since the late 70's), just how many combinations of 0's and 1's can you get, jeez I just want the value on a pin.
Do you carve your software from raw logic, deep in the mine where no one has been before, where unique logic conditions are there to be found and utilised by only those who can grab that monopoly first ?
If you work for a company then they own all your output (even the stuff you do at home for fun), You work for yourself, you get to keep what you do plus all the stuff your employees create.
Give us a clue then, how much of your stuff has been used (without your permission) by others ?
How much of that stuff would have been used if the users had known that you could enforce payment ? How do you value the lost revenue ?
I'm glad that you have been in business for more than 25 years, I assume that you have worked bloody hard to make it the success that it is and that rather than relying on the one idea you had 25 years ago to pay your pension, you have continued to innovate and improve your output, if so you rightly deserve the rewards of that hard work.
I asked for evidence that copyright/patents encourage innovation/creativity/enterprise.
'I doubt I would have ever bothered' isn't evidence, in fact I think you would have persevered (and succeeded) whatever obstacles were put in your way.
A thumbs down is not evidence Vince
I'm already in range
I take it you are in favour of patents/copyright, fair enough.
Can you point me to any evidence that patents/copyright promotes invention/artistic achievement rather than stifling it.
Any evidence will do, just provide me a link or two.
I missed the story about monkey photographer copyright discrimination but on the Apple animated sidewalls story I made a comment with this title
'Patents and Copyright should be scrapped (Trademarks are ok though)'
and gained 2 upvotes so there are at least 3 people who think the same.
If three people come onto the register and say that 'Patents and Copyright should be scrapped' we got ourselves a movement.
The Register anti-patent and copyright movement . . . and all you gotta do to join is to sing it the next time it comes around on the guitar.
Patents and Copyright should be scrapped (Trademarks are ok though)
This is one example of why patents and copyright should be scrapped, they do not (as some people believe) protect the inventor so that he can reap the benefits of his new invention, they are soley to protect the interests of a select group at the expense of everyone else.
If you write a wonderful new book/piece of music (possibly using a new (non-derivative) character set or set of never before heard sounds) and you don't want anybody else to benefit then keep it to yourself.
If you invent a (non-derivative) new machine and you don't want anybody utilising your ideas, then keep it to yourself.
Will this put a dampner on any new stuff ?
If I come up with something new then I have first user advantage, anybody I choose to share this idea with will be subject to contract of non-disclosure.
Most 'new' ideas are derivative and time dependent, if Edison hadn't invented the lightbulb when he did then someone else would have done (or allegedly did)
The USA got to be a world leader in innovation by ignoring GB patents, Japan did likewise, China also.
Once a country matures, vested interests move to ensure patents are upheld to stop newcomers utilising the advantages those interests used in the first place.
If I have bought a 'scope then it is mine to do with as I wish however if I do something that is outside of the Ts&Cs of the supplier (such as opening it up) then I have no room for complaint if it doesn't work properly afterwards.
This includes changing some of the 1s and 0s in the memory.
That I could read a website where someone has done just that and do it to my own bit of kit is irrelevant.
One of the reasons why a manufacturer disallows 'unauthorised upgrading' of equipment is that of liability.
If I was in business I wouldn't home bake 'upgrades' , nor would I use any equipment in an 'unauthorised' manner, if someone dies because of a bit of kit that was used properly according to the manufacturers terms and conditions then I want the supplier/manufacturer to be held responsible.
If I blow myself up cuz I was tinkering with my own kit, that's my fault and I bear responsibility.
I used to work for a company where we sold conversion cables for our kit to be used with a variety of other devices.
We published the schematics of the cables so you could make your own if you wanted to, in the main engineers bought the ready made cables because they couldn't be arsed to roll their own and also they didn't want the liabilty if they messed up.
Homebrew people wouldn't buy the cables anyway (no loss there) and if we didn't publish proper spec then they would hack it themselves, possibly causing more support calls (more cost there))
More 'user' SPB stuff
More home HW hacks would be good (whatever happened to the robot lawnmower ?), especially if they have frikkin lasers.
You could start by doing an article on this guy (warning, it currently runs to 41 very long pages and takes more than a weekend to read it all), there is some serious power tool pron to exite the jaded (including doing things with angle grinders I'd never imagined such as using an angle grinder on wood, WTF!).
Its all b******s and we know it
The rise in 'phone crime' was due to insurance companies not paying out until a crime ref no. was provided, the fall is due to phones being categorised as 'household' items and not needing a crime ref no. to payout.
The 'Phone Crimes Unit' will be disbanded unless they can
a. show a rise in crimes.
b. they can lobby loud enough.
What we really need is a pin code in designer jeans (anybody remember them) to stop muggers leaving you standing there on Clapham High St. trouserless clutching your brick sized vodaphone.
Re: Why is this an article?
I agree, MickyDees has a university in London (and very nice it is too), the canteen is a real McD's where they try out new lines, if they are popular then they get rolled out to the rest of the country.
Are recordings fungible ?
If my neighbor and I both record the same program at 9pm on tuesday, does it matter which copy either of us watches ?
It seems that this service allowed me to watch programs that I haven't recorded (but my neighbor has) which is where I would agree that it is a re-broadcast and indeed falls foul.
If they were to make me press the record button for each program that I want to watch and only allow me to watch what I had previously recorded (irrespective that they only keep one copy for all of the people who recorded it) then that would be a PVR in the cloud and should be allowed.
Money creation in the modern economy
Banks don't work like your economics text books told you.
'One common misconception is that banks act simply as intermediaries, lending out the deposits that savers place with them.'
'rather than banks lending out deposits that are placed with them, the act of lending creates deposits'
'In reality, neither are reserves a binding constraint on lending, nor does the central bank fix the amount of reserves that are available'
Soveriegn Government finances don't work like household accounts either.
Perhaps it were the Sun wot dunnit
Interesting set of articles
One would have to assume he has copies of everything that crossed his desk and more from the first 'raisings of doubt' and rebuff to his final exit.
If you see him shopping in the supermarket again then please respectfully pass along my thanks and support, he is one very brave individual in a sea of cowards.
Asking the wrong people
Of course the NSA can't find the emails, those at the top ordered them deleted. He should be asking GCHQ who were tasked with spying on Americans on their own soil to get around Constitutional sensitivities, GCHQ have a record.
Just like GCHQ have a record of all the transactions that went through the Tehran Strip Club.
Just like GCHQ have copies of the FIFA emails regarding the successful Qatari bid for the World Cup (including Swift transfer records)
Agency for Good/Agency for Evil, (AfGAfE), just what is the taxpayer benefit of these agencies since it is the taxpayer who pays the bill ?
Fascism is Left Wing (the socialist melding of Corporatism and the State)
The vast majority of NSA employees are just part of the bureaucracy, they have no knowledge of what their employer is up to (although they are grateful for their mediocre paychecks). Those at the top have no idea what those at the coalface do for a living other than when they say 'can it do this' the answer is always, 'yes but it will need more funding'. (those at the top really like their big paychecks)
Those doing the actual work of Intelligence gathering are mightily pissed off that they are tasked with the grunt work of information gathering. (though their paychecks are nice, this isn't what they signed up for)
That is why Snowden left.
Information <> Intelligence
Information = Snooping (and that is un-constitutional as well as immoral)
So Bankers will be jailed ?
“IEEPA makes it a crime to wilfully violate US sanctions on designated countries such as Iran. Individuals and companies who evade US sanctions and misuse our banking system to further their illegal activity not only undermine the integrity of our financial markets but also threaten US national security interests.”
As Eric Daniels was in charge of Lloyds when they were running the Tehran Strip Club can we expect to see him wearing an orange jump suit by this time tomorrow ?
The agreement not to prosecute wouldn't have anything to do with him agreeing to buy that barrel of donkey **** that was HBOS over a weekend without any due diligence just because the PM at the time asked him to ?
The Feds probably asked this guy to bail out GM again and he refused, now he has a price on his head.
Live Long and Prosper
A restricted calorie diet can make you live longer (if you are a mouse)
From the abstract
group 1) a nonpurified diet ad libitum (all you can eat when you want it)
group 6) 40 kcal/wk of the diet fed to groups 3 and 4 (approximately 65% restriction)
Mice from group 6 lived longest of all.
The longest lived 10% of mice from group 6 averaged 53.0 mo which, to our knowledge, exceeds reported values for any mice of any strain.
Beneficial influences on tumor patterns and on declines with age in T-lymphocyte proliferation were most striking in group 6.
Significant positive correlations between adult body weight and longevity occurred in groups 3-5 suggesting that increased metabolic efficiency may be related to longevity in restricted mice.
Mice from groups 3-6 ate approximately 30% more calories per gram of mouse over the life span than did mice from group 2.
These findings show the profound anti-aging effects of dietary restriction and provide new information for optimizing restriction regimes.
The problem with HFT seems to be frontrunning actual bids/asks
Rather than reduce the tick (increasing the spread) or implementing transaction taxes, how about reduce the frequency of the execution clock and execute trades received in parallel at the end of a clock cycle ?
Removing the ability to cancel a trade mid cycle would be a good idea as well, you bid and you buy, if you bought in error then you can sell on the next cycle.
A bit like the SimmStick
Around 1994 "Antti Lukats, an Estonian"* came up with the idea of the SimmStick, here's some pictures
It made use of the 30 pin Simm format of PC memory modules at the time. (the pinouts were different)
I've still got a DT003 PSU board with a SIMM100 board with an Atmel AT90s8535 on it, in its day it was a well cool way of playing with the AVRs.
The advantage was that you could mix analog and digital MCUs with relays etc. using the base board as a bus.
*He was always referred to on forums as such, I don't know why.
Re: What's 10,000 light years across and smells of gamma radiation?
It smells like napalm in the morning.
1 $ 1 Vote is Great...
If your name is 'Benny the Buck' or 'Old Yeller'
Tom Perkins would be outvoted everyday of the week, how many dollars can Tom bring to the table, Old Yeller could double it (QE to infinity)
Re: The Meritocracy IS The Problem
A link would be handy wouldn't it !
The Meritocracy IS The Problem
You need to read 'The Rise of the Meritocracy' by Michael Young.
Here is what Michael had to say about people (Tony Blair in particular) using the phrase he coined back in 1958
First of all Brid-Aine Parnell,
'This would solve an awful lot of the human race's current issues.'
No it wouldn't.
If I discovered a cheap and abundant energy source today and published it to the world, the entire global economy would collapse tomorrow.
If my country discovered a cheap and abundant energy source today and sought to exploit it, my country would be bombed back to the stone age tomorrow.
To the poster who said that if enough money was thrown at the problem (controllable fusion) then it could be achieved in short order.
How much money do you need ?
Mervyn King demonstrated, with a simple keypress, that he could conjure up 375 thousand million pounds, just like that.
Ben Bernanke creates 80 thousand million dollars every month (Janet Yellen will in all likelihood increase this rate)
Throwing money at the problem will not help (as money is only virtual), only throwing productivity at it will help
Average western production worker given all the tools available is probably reaching a leverage of > 4 to 1 however productivity per worker has peaked, GDP has continued to rise because this drop in per productive worker has been masked by increasing the no. of workers (the UK has been importing them), this cannot continue indefinitely.
Peak productivity per worker is reached around 30 years old, average age of UK worker is past that.
The question of can we achieve controllable fusion turns out to be not one of physics or even economics, it is a question of maths.
Parking Eye - a bit disapointing
My other half couldn't get out of a Parking Eye monitored carpark whilst she was using my car (we are named drivers on each others cars as well as being insured to drive any car not belonging to us)
They only sent two demanding letters before giving up, for the amount they were demanding (it rises over time) I thought it would be worth at least three with the last one being in red.
Very amateurish and disapointing outfit
Huawie, GCHQ, BT21CN and the NSA
When the contract to manufacture 21CN hardware for BT was given to the Chinese, Huawie didn't know (or care) what backdoors were hardwired in, they had a spec and a price.
Later, BT discovered that the Chinese Gov had hacked Martlesham after 21CN had been running for some time, this meant that Chin.gov had the same access to the packet data that UK.gov and US.gov had hardware access to.
Queue UK/US.gov outrage over Chin.gov spying.
The UK and US governments think it is ok that they should spy on the most intimate details of their own citizens and are willing to compromise the data collected by outsourcing the manufacture of the data gathering devices to the lowest bidder.
They frighten you into paying up because of the bogeyman of 'terrorism' yet will only buy kit on the basis of the biggest kickback.
GCHQ and the NSA are corruption incarnate (BT is just a whore), they have 'NEVER' prevented a terrorist outrage and yet they manage to burn through billions of dollars of taxpayers money keeping themselves in gold plated tax free jobs.
Perhaps we should just close them down and spend the money on reducing child mortality in the grim bits of the world.
Two Questions ??
If the atmosphere is warming (irrespective of cause) woudn't it also be expanding and would that expansion be measurable ? (ie will the playmonaut have to ascend to a higher altitude to reach space)
I understand the mechanisn of the greenhouse effect (greenhouse gas being more opaque to IR than plain air). Does CO2 laden air have the same transparency as plain air on incoming solar radiation ?
These are genuine questions that I hope someone can answer
Re: Such a waste of time and paper.
Whilst you make valid points about habitat destruction and pollution, campaigning about family planning in Africa and Asia will do no good. They already practise family planning, they plan on having large families because lots of their children will die before they reach 5 years old and they need some surviving children to look after them when they get old.
If you want to reduce what you see as 'overpopulation' then providing clean drinking water, vaccinations against common childhood diseases and a rudimentary social safety net will reduce the propensity for large families within two generations.
Of course if you do that then where will you source the young productive people to provide for your old age.
read the bit in Legal Framework (it is the same in the UK)
Not even Snowden understands what he has stolen
Snowden thinks it is a civil liberties thing with Governments spying on their own people.
The security agencies have been slurping all data for years, not just personal but corporate.
That includes the banking system laundering money from drug dealers and terrorist regimes through the City and Wall St, where it originates and whose pockets it finally lands in.
Follow the money.
Re: Guys, it is about adding stuff to the tech, not copying it off.
Why bother ? It's much easier just hacking the Chinese who put the spyware into the original chips at source.
There is a war on (always has been) between security services,
It gets interesting (and more lethal for the locals) when the interminable internecine conflicts arise, these can only be solved by outside mediation (Good Friday)
Spooks will be Spooks.
Why stop Miranda ?
They stopped him to verify that it was really Miranda and not someone else traveling on a genuine passport in the name of Miranda.
Six Israelis had genuine passports.
Buy an old (circa 1960's) rotavator off ebay, they are great fun and are brilliant at tearing up the soil. Mine is a Clifford and weighs a ton, there is nothing more satisfying than running it over my allotment and plowing in the monster weeds. Mostly I grow potatoes so I can use the furrowing tool I made from an old metal shelf.
"If the Chromecast could tap into the Play Store to stream purchased content, or even on a rental basis, it would be a winner."
Can it not do that right out of the box ?
I buy a movie on the playstore on my mobile, watch it in a chrome browser window and send the output to the chromecast for the kids to watch on TV whilst I do more important stuff like read the Reg.
(isn't that what it's for ?)
Are BitCoins Currency ?
No, they are a tradeable commodity just like rice, beans, gold or dollars. The attribute that sets them apart from rice etc. is the ability to transfer them from one person to another without any physical contact.
I imagine the cops sold him some 'stuff' in exchange for some bitcoins, when he accepted physical delivery of the aforementioned 'stuff' they nicked him.
Just Sack the Person at the Top
First time it happens and a CEO goes, all the others will think 'there but for the grace....', the second time it happens will be the last as proper security would be implemented across the board.
The Admiral Byng solution is the only way
I ain't Spartacus - with all due respect
I ain't Spartacus - with all due respect, you're wrong.
As the monopoly currency issuer a Government doesn't need to borrow any money in order to spend.
The fact that they do so has its roots in the gold standard (whereby a King had to have gold in his treasury in order to wage war)
The Bank of England was set up by a private group of wealthy men specifically for the purpose of financing, at interest, the Government of the day.
Today the BoE is wholly owned by the Government, any interest gained by the bank on loans made to the Government are returned to the Government in the form of BoE profits.
The Government spends money into existence and taxes it out of existence (net neutral)
The inflation that you speak of is coming from the private banking sector, they create money in the form of credit/debt (credit from the word credo meaning faith). The bank creates £100 (at todays value) which it lends to you, there is now £100 extra in circulation and so the currency is devalued, the interest you are charged covers both the risk of not getting it back plus the reduction in value (otherwise the interest rat would be the inflation rate)
eg. the bank lend you 100 units to purchase 100 carrots but the increase in the supply of units means that each carrot increases in price to 1.1 units, in order to pay back the bank you must give them 110 units plus the insurance premium.
All that is missing from BitCoin is a credible futures market (paradoxically, gambling on the future price of a commodity creates stability)
'But if individuals can't make money from creating IP, there will be less of it created. So to generate those ideas we give an exclusive but limited time license to the person who created the IP'
Once again during a discussion about copyright someone makes this statement, can anybody offer evidence in favour ?
This paper offers evidence against.
( overview of paper here http://www.case.edu/magazine/fallwinter2010/copyright.html )
Re: Population growing exponentially ?
Overpopulation stories are usually associated with cries of exponential population growth. (ie. total population doubled in X years and doubled again after a lessor period of years)
Fertility rates are falling (see the graph), when the fertility rate falls below 2 then people dying are not replaced. (rate above 2 means population is growing)
Start with 100 couples, they each have 2 children so the total population will be 400 people. The 200 children form 100 couples and each have 200 children, total is 600. These children have 200 children between them but 200 old people die, total population remains at 600 and the average age of the population will settle out around the middle
If the fertility rate falls below 2 then over time more people will die than are being born and the population will fall, average age will rise until eventually the last old person dies and thats it.
Look at this graph
Germany, Italy and China are well below replacement rate
The UK is closer to replacement rate but that is only because we import people from countries that have a high birth rate (their children become westerners in one generation and adopt our low birth rate)
Look at the birth rate of the countries that the UK imports people from, high at the moment but falling. At some point in the future we will run out of source countries and our population will age and die (just like G, I and C)
It's not speculation, it's maths
Population growing exponentially ?
see this graph here
when the line reaches 2 the total world population will start to fall, slowly at first and then a little quicker, before you know it there will be too few people and they will be too widely spread to save the human population.
Re: It's always about control
As I stand upon Southampton Dock (in my summer frock no less)
The furore is not about guns
It is about why you think it is acceptable to allow someone you have never met to tell you what to think and how to act.
If I were to gift you a 3d printer, the consumables and the plans, would you make a gun and kill someone ?
Or would you discard the plans and create something that benefits yourself and those around you ?
You make your own decisions.
You are responsible for your own actions.
You abdicate responsibility (and any benefits that may accrue) when You allow Others to make Your rules for You.
Re: 'Because copyright is an enabler for markets'
Rather than down voting why not provide some evidence for or against ?
'Because copyright is an enabler for markets'
I've heard this argument used many times but I've never seen any evidence in favour, only grand assertions.
Google 'copyright as an enabler' and you get an opinion from the Publishers Association and a paper by Sobel in favour of DRM
Re: The sad thing about ID cards
I don't want your stinkin ID cards because I have every reason to believe (as a law abiding citizen) that those in 'authority' will misuse them.
If I am suspected of wrongdoing then there are existing laws to detain me until I have proven who I am. I don't see why I should have to identify myself to every jumped up 'official' who demands it.
Why do I need a passport ? I don't leave the country and if I wanted to travel in Europe I shouldn't need one any as we signed up to 'the free movement of goods services and people'.
Having ID does not enable you, it restricts you because the issuer could withdraw it at any time.
Page 3 of your UK passport
(NOTES 7 Caution This passport remains the property or Her Majesty's Government in the United Kingdom and may be withdrawn at any time.)
Age restricted sales = ID card preparation
Over the last couple of years there has been a clampdown on underage sales of alcohol, tobacco, aerosols, knives, OTC medicines, magazines, videos, video games etc.
Most retailers have a TASK25 policy (Think,Ask,See,Know) whereby if it is suspected that a customer is under 25 then ID must be asked for (failure = disciplinary), this is conditioning a whole generation to carry ID and think it is ok to be challenged at any time.
ID cards are still on the agenda, they are just waiting for old farts like me (why do I need ID, I know who I am and isn't it bleeding obvious from my attitude that I'm a Brit) to die out and they can get on with it.
- JLaw, Kate Upton exposed in celeb nude pics hack
- Google flushes out users of old browsers by serving up CLUNKY, AGED version of search
- GCHQ protesters stick it to British spooks ... by drinking urine
- China: You, Microsoft. Office-Windows 'compatibility'. You have 20 days to explain
- Something for the Weekend, Sir? If you think 3D printing is just firing blanks, just you wait