* Posts by Ledswinger

3138 posts • joined 1 Jun 2012

BT bemoans 'misconceived' SUPERFAST broadband regs

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: hang on@ A Non e-mouse

"I thought this was already impossible as this was why BT became all these fragmented groups so they couldn't cross-subsidise."

In theory yes, in practice very much no. In most regulated businesses that a (competent) regulator wishes to see prevented from dodgy transfer pricing and cosy intra-group sales, the regulated business has to be a separately accounted legal entity, filing its own statutory accounts. OFCOM never required BT to do this with Openreach, and as a result they are wholly dependent upon BT's management accounts. As a result it is very difficult indeed to know the truth, even as the regulator - ultimately they have to trust that BT are telling the truth. As an outsider it is impossible, because BT will qualify information they provide to OFCOM as commercially sensitive, and that then doesn't go into the public domain.

My personal opinion is that this new OFCOM ruling is pointless - any competent management accountant can massage management account numbers to prove black is white, and there's no statutory evidence to the contrary in a complex group. BT's complaints are probably to disguise their ongoing satisfaction that OFCOM still haven't had the cojones to force the demerger of Openreach, and it would look like bad form to be seen publicly springing open the bubbly.

5
0

Crap broadband holds back HALF of rural small biz types

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Pity the poor rural business

"We risk seeing the emergence of a two-speed online economy resulting from poor rural broadband infrastructure."

Given that there are 3x as many urban SMEs as rural, and these urban businesses employ 7x as many people and generate over 10x the turnover, any logical analysis would conclude that the focus should be on the quarter to a third of urban SME's with broadband problems, rather than the rural tiddlers who (presumably) hope for the rest of society to pay for urban utilities to be expanded to the countryside?

4
30

Samsung's first Tizen smartphone is HERE ... by which we mean India

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: @PNGuinn: Where's my Sailfish?

"Personally, I'm watching Jolla / Sailfish."

Unfortunately watching is all you can do, as for mere mortals there's no way of loading it on to an existing phone. If you're a developer, willing to hack and put up with a part finished product then yes, otherwise it's a firm no.

If Jolla want Sailfish to see any serious adoption then they need to release some fully functioning phone images for a handful of popular kit with large user bases (Sammy S3 and S4?) in a manner similar to (but hopefully more user-friendly) than Cyanogenmod. When you've got a few thousand early adopters on board you can build your reputation, brand and experience, and get much better feedback than developers can offer, but as things stand it seems from the outside that Jolla have followed Nokia's "mañana" approach to software development. When the tech sites are full of chatter by the early adopters about how excellent (hopefully) Sailfish is, then they would create the sort of traction for more mass market approaches. I would have thought if the device images were full functioning they could even sell it - I wouldn't expect them to be able to charge a very high price, but if you sold 7,000 downloads for a tenner that'd pay for a developer for a year (and I'd guess Jolla's accounts are currently notable for a complete lack of income).

Come on Jolla, get your @rse in gear! There's ten quid on offer in this house. Individually that's not much, but it's probably a lot more than your total sales income last year.

2
0

What will happen to the oil price? Look to the PC for clues

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Fracking

"Saudi pumps oil to crash the market to drive fracking out of existence."

Not for that reason. Most of the costs in resource extraction are in the capital and setup. So once you're in the game, you keep pumping all the while each barrel makes a marginal profit, even if you're losing money overall - this applies to fracking as much to conventional oil exporters. Eventually, if you keep losing money you go bust, but until that time it makes financial sense to keep pumping. There's also the fact that the Saudis and all other oil exporters have huge public spending budgets based typically on a minimum oil price of $80. As a result, these countries are running huge budge deficits at the moment, because they can't reign in the bread and circus spending that keeps the hoi polloi anaesthatised (and avoids them toppling undemocratic governments).

The other thing is that the oil price collapse needs to be seen in the context of collapsing iron ore, copper and other commodity prices. Fundamentally the world has geared up over the past two decades for a "one time" Chinese infrastructure build that has inflated world demand and inflated prices. As China both runs out of money and out of opportunities to productively invest, the demand for concrete, energy, steel, copper falls dramatically. This has knock on effect in consumer demand. The West (and Japan) are debt-addled and can't take over the economic baton, so you have the mother of all slow downs taking place.

Even if OPEC could force the price up, they'd reduce demand further (and further again by multiplier effects), so that the reality is that they'd not get much more money.

3
0

Euro security agency says MORE crypto needed in gov policy

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: UKIPpers take note

"It worries me that we need protecting from our own governments ..."

Why? Nothing has changed in hundreds of years, in that government is by the few, for the few. Laws are enacted to increase the power of the state to do the bidding of the state, and we now have some token pretence of choice every few years, between parties with the same policies, run by a like-minded parliamentary elite most of whom have never done a proper job for any length of time. The Labour front bench is studded with millionaires pretending to be men & women of the people, and is a mirror image of the Conservative front bench.

In centuries gone by the threat that government "protected" you from was famine, or Napoleon. Early last century it was Bolsheviks. Then it was the great depression. Then back to the red peril. Since then we've had various other things that government needs to act to protect us from, including terrorists and climate change. I wonder what government will be busy protecting me from in fifteen years time? Aliens or comets seem the most probable.

decades gone by

7
0

You go fast, but we go 'further' and 'deeper' – Voda tells 'Speedy' EE

Ledswinger
Silver badge

"Skodafone" To use this as an insult shows that you've probably not driven a Skoda for may years.

4
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: What is the point?

"the big problem with rural areas is the NIMBY types, they don't want masts near them"

I doubt it. That's a problem in urban and suburban locations. In most rural areas the most likely problem is the subscriber density and traffic volumes that are too low to justify the cost of the mast plus backhaul and power connections. I'd also guess that the mast can be shrunk in size and cost, but the real deal breaker is the cost of any new backhaul. Throw in the ongoing 4G roll outs, and the stretched technical resources, and I'd suggest that NIMBYs are a relatively small problem.

4
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

"20Mbps is not broadband according to the FCC"

And what would Vodafone or the rest of the world care? The FCC do a bad job of regulating US telcos and Vodafone have no meaningful US presence since the sale of their Verizon stake.

To a large extent Vodafone are right when they talk about the bandwidth demand of mobile devices, and even for fixed line, most of the world aren't seeing anything like 20 Mbps.

4
0

Bloke in Belgium tries to trademark Je Suis Charlie slogan

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: WELL DONE

"Well done for having the guts to show the cartoon,"

Just a pity that it isn't funny.

4
17
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Interesting graphic

"Ayatollah Khomeini is Shia Muslim, you ignorant oink."

If you're playing Grand Pedant, you might want to get the spelling right, it's "oik". Not to mention you need "was", rather than "is".

Unless Ayatollah Khomeini is a post, a bit like Dalai Lama. Or a clone. Are clones allowed under Sharia law?

6
0

Windows 7 MARKED for DEATH by Microsoft as of NOW

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Interestingly for once...

"wont be released until all the PSoS terminals are updated to Windows 8.1."

Is that the now-unsupported-for-security-updates vanilla 8.1, or the still-in-support-until-MS-change-their-mind 8.1 Update?

The question should give a clue to how badly this will end, because your vendors will try and lock you in (with expensive day rates and change clauses), and Microsoft will already be plotting to end support for 8.1 Update as soon as they possibly can. Whilst the obvious solution is to foreswear all Microsoft products, and support your own Linux build, I can't think of any examples where this has actually worked. Anyone?

I recommend you go back to paper and quill.

1
2

Lenovo hopes to say Hello Moto to smartphone cash

Ledswinger
Silver badge

"if they do have a vanilla install"

Maybe to start with. Seems to me that as soon as a company starts getting pretensions, and chasing higher margins, then they start seeing a "need" to differentiate themselves, and if you're a marketing dweeb, that means putting a custom skin on Android, and after that filling the phone with duplicate apps.

Which means that the Lenovo branded handsets stand a low chance of being bloat free, but the newly aspirational Moto brand will stand no such chance, and will soon be cruft central.

0
0

IBM ushers in BIGGEST EVER re-org for the cloud era, say insiders

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Impressive

Reading the article, I'm left with the impression that IBM are moving from a three silo model to a circa eleven silo model. Either the journalism's not up too much, or Ginny has been listening to the management consultants talking bollocks about matrix organisations again.

I work for a large complex business. Originally run on country lines, the board sucked on the consultant's Kool-aid, and we adopted a chaotic matrix structure. Now nobody knows who does what, who's accountable for what, we have multiple teams sniffing around the same customer deals, we talk about "collaborative working" and never do it.

Good luck with that.

5
0

Tesco tosses loss-making Blinkbox into TalkTalk's basket

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Alternatives

Chromecast: "only a 20" TV, haven't tested it on a larger one"

Generally works well on our 42" display. At best, you'd never know it wasn't off DVD under the telly, although I did have one instance where there was a bizarre fractional second hesitancy every five or six seconds that made watching the content a challenge, and if your broadband (or wider web) is playing up then you may as well not bother. Probably helps that we're on 100 Mb/s VM cable.

0
0

MI5 boss: We NEED to break securo-tech, get 'assistance' from data-slurp firms

Ledswinger
Silver badge

"If Cameron had the sense god gave a goose....."

....we'd all be pleased with the marginal improvement. I'm no spring chicken, but I can't recall a more lightweight, ineffectual PM since, well, ever. Look at his latest endeavours to dodge a TV debate. I care not for the things, but for a politician to run away from one, strewth.

6
2
Ledswinger
Silver badge

"And yet all the snooping did fuck-all good in Sydney or France."

Or in the London 7/7 bombings. Or the botch 21 July attempted bombings. Or the June 2007 attack on Glasgow airport, and linked attempts to detonate car bombs in London. Or the Boston marathon bombs. Or the murder of Fusilier Lee Rigby. Or the Madrid bombings.

And whilst I can't comment on the Madrid cases, in almost all the other cases the assailants were on the radar of the security services beforehand, just like the vermin causing grief in France.

33
0

Saudi Arabia to flog man 1,000 times for insulting religion on Facebook

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: What does it say about Twats in the Quran?

""...which is praised as the West's partner in The War Against Terror (TWAT)."....50 lashes for the twats

OK, I'm happy to hand over Tony Blair for his 50 lashes, on condition that it's filmed in HD so I can enjoy every stroke. In slo-mo. And notorious twat David Cameron can also be handed over as well for suppressing the Chilcot enquiry report.

1
1

CES 2015: The good, the mad and the POINTLESS

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: You've got me brimming

"That alone would be worthwhile to upgrade my LCD for. If they come in with decent pricing, I'm interested"

"decent pricing" on a new launch product? Maybe you'll get that at a decent price by 2019.

0
0

Users shun UK.gov flagship digital service

Ledswinger
Silver badge

" Far better than the old sites its replacing,"

But it's just a portal to other sites, each with its own logic and purpose. So if you search on self assessment, gov.uk comes top of the list, but then merely directs you off to HMRC that has its own identity, logic and design. If you search on taxing a car then something similar happens, and then you end up at the DVLA's self service web site (which is delightfully painless given the poor reputation of DVLA, or painless until you get stung for hundreds of quid).

Given that gov.uk is generally a bit pointless I suppose it doesn't matter that (eg) NS&I and industry regulators seem to be outside the scope of gov.uk.

3
0

Euro Parliament: Time to rethink DRIP, other snoop laws

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Fat chance

I would suggest that the ongoing unpleasantness in France (which may yet trigger similar outrages elsewhere in Europe) will be used by security services as grounds to get their national governments to tell the EU commission to go swing. And that will occur whether data retention has any relevance or not to the sad events in France or not.

7
0

Toyota to Tesla: we can play the free patent game as well

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Could be useful

"Id be unsurprised in the overall efficiency of leccy to fuel to wheel wasn't at least as good with syndiesel in a modern TD as electrolytic hydrogen in a fuel cell."

Be unsurprised. I work for a company with large and pioneering investments in producing H2 from electricity, and that's exactly the situation. Fuel cells produce heat and power, that gives them their high theoretical efficiencies. But unless you can continuously use all the heat and all the power, the efficiency nose dives. And you're right that methanation (converting H2 to CH4) is the only logical application of dissociation of H2O, because most spark ignition engines can be converted to use CH4, and CH4 is easy to store and handle.

Sadly the end to end system efficiency as CH4 is still diabolical (if better than H2), and you'd need to cover the planet with wind turbines and PV to get anything useful from it, and the costs of doing that are not credible.

0
0

FBI boss: Sony hack was DEFINITELY North Korea, haters gonna hate

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Yeah...

...we'll believe you, given your track record. Not.

30
2

It's 2015 and ATMs don't know when a daughterboard is breaking them

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: It's hard to feel sorry for the victims

"You realise any losses the bank incurs are recouped one way or another through you being a customer?"

To an extent. Or they just get the government to bail them out, and keep paying the obscene bonuses typical in financial disservices.

But when the banks' crooked City gamblers repeatedly get fined billions by regulators for an ever changing kaleidoscope of new and novel frauds, and they then repeatedly stuff customers, shareholders, or the state with all the losses, they don't need to change their rancid, thieving culture, so why worry about a few tens of millions in ATM or card fraud?

1
0

Elite: Dangerous 'billionaire' gamers are being 'antisocial', moan players

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Just like real life then?

I wonder if he'll eat, shoot and leave?

If he's Bill Gates he'll eat shit and leave.

5
2

YES, we need TWO MEELLION ORACLE licences - DEFRA

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: ....and they say the public sector is cut to the bone.

" If heads don't roll, lessons will not be learned."

Culture survives the elimination of individuals. What's needed is the complete closure of DEFRA. As far as I can see they don't do much of any use, other than refuse to accept scientific evidence on everything from BSE to bovine TB, fail to fight effectively for British agriculture in Europe, at the same time ignore scientific advice on fisheries whilst still selling British fishermen down the river, etc etc.

I'm with the badgers, and I vote for all of DEFRA to be gassed in their offices, or be trapped in cages as they commute to and from work, and then shot by marksmen.

6
0

Sardine fishing in Kerala: Who benefits from mobile phones?

Ledswinger
Silver badge

@TheOtherHobbes

"You clearly know nothing about actual information science and have no business 'educating' anyone here."

I think Mr Worstal has just delivered you the academic equivalent of a wedgie, and well deserved it is, too.

So, how about you bugger off back to the warm, fluffy pages of the Graun? Seems to be where your understanding of both technology and economics originated, to judge by your generally anti-corporate, anti-market, pro-state posts?

8
2

Whew, US cellcos... Better find a new revenue stream, QUICK

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Reason for M&A @ Charles 9

"So put it this way, if it's between going to the big telcos and simply disappearing, which would you prefer?"

Your argument is fatally flawed. Buggy makers went bust because even the earliest cars were better value investment for buyers - the demand for transport never went away, the customers simply went from the buggy maker's shop to the car maker's shop. In terms of this topic, mobile communications, where are you suggesting the customers for mobile communications go? It's not like somebody's come up with telepathy.

Punters either need to pony up for LTE (which industry are claiming they won't), or industry needs to accept that there isn't an economic demand for LTE across the whole mobile market. Maybe some fraction of the market does have an economic demand (that is, desire for a product and the willingness and ability to pay for it), but that means that MNOs need to position themselves as mass market 3G providers using existing assets, or they can try and take a smaller, premium market position offering LTE - if the economics stack up.

1
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Reason for M&A have nothing to do with cost savings

"too expensive to keep customers, yet not expensive enough to get the revenues you need to invest in improving yourself."

I'm intrigued by this idea. Where do you think that the customers that a fragmented industry "can't keep" go? LTE is being driven by technology, the industry, and to a small degree regulators, but the message that industry are giving is that customers won't pay a necessary price to provide the toys they want.

Hey! Mobile operators! Welcome to the real world, where customers want the world, they want it yesterday, and they want if for free. And as happens with good but expensive ideas elsewhere, maybe networks need to accept that if LTE is something that customers won't pay for, they shouldn't invest in it.

M&A won't help unless it increases the customer density. But that reduces competition and moves market power to the telcos, which doesn't seem very desirable to me.

2
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: When will they learn

" to get that fast and reliable connectivity, you eventually have to plunk down for more infrastructure: either more spectrum or more cells"

Only as a matter of commercial choice. I see no evidence that LTE will lead to better coverage, nor to any cost effective proposition to replace my fixed line broadband, so my network may as well stick to the current 3G H+ (when you're lucky) offer, and eschew the development of a 4G network.

Eventually such an approach produces a two tier market, with those valuing high speed mobile data paying their way, and those prepared to tolerate the current mix of price and service able to stick with that. Seems to me the problem is only for telco's playing "keeping up with the Joneses" by investing in 4G for which there's not a genuine economic demand.

5
1

Cheap Android phones? Bah! How about a $29 mobe from Microsoft?

Ledswinger
Silver badge

"And just $29 ?!?!?!? Amazing."

Where have you been for the past few years?

If you want a basic Nokia phone for voice calls then they were cheap as chips long before this - for example, if available in your market look at the Nokia 106, currently being sold for £9 (brand new, major retailer) in the UK. That's less than $14.

If you're not hung up on Nokia, then an Alcatel 10.10 will set you back £5 from the same retailer, less than $8.

2
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: No 3G? Useless in some parts of the world...

"Main area is emerging markets, such as Africa."

So they hope. But there's two problems:

Firstly that all emerging markets have seen what you can get for $30 from a Chinese no name, and by any reckoning if you choose well you'd have something equivalent to the first or second generation iPhone or a Nokia 5800. Evidence the world over suggests that the lower battery life of a smartphone is something the vast majority of users will tolerate for the extended capabilities. And even off grid, developing markets have credible options like small, simple PV trickle chargers that are next to useless in frigid and sunless northern climes.

Secondly, in their desire to keep the name Microsoft "exclusive" (hah!) they've created a situation where even if this new cheapy phone is a success, there's no brand upgrade path. Microsoft must have a special strategy department dedicated to snatching defeat from the jaws of any potential victory.

4
1

Samsung forks 4K with Tizen tellies

Ledswinger
Silver badge

"We want to sell you UHD devices..."

Arguably they don't want to sell UHD tellies at all, because if they did they wouldn't be taking a punt on Tizen. There's no theoretical reason that Tizen couldn't deliver, but based on the precedent of the depressing standard of TV UIs and firmware, the dreadful ad-loaded programme guides and privacy concerns, the lack of software support the moment it leaves the factory, the weak functionality, tumbleweed strewn proprietary app stores, painfully slow processors, inadequate input options........

All these things make me hugely dubious of any maker introducing a new OS.

3
0

Want to shoot FIREBALLS from your wrists, SPIDER-MAN style?

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Better out of the wrist..

Buy the kit, hack it a bit to release a single tube and you can find out which is better. You might want to wrap that flameproof cuff round your nads, of course.

0
0

Zuckerberg asks the public to tell him where to go in 2015

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Hmmm.@ Lost all faith

"When someone publishes a picture with faces in it, every single person is blurred out and only when that person agrees to it (opt in not out please), can a specific face be un-blurred."

Oh, come off it. If you really want privacy you wouldn't be on Facebook in the first place, and if you valued your friends privacy you wouldn't be posting their pictures.

3
1

30 years ago today, the first commercial UK 'mobile' phone call was made

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Memories

"A load of show off's still saying 'I'm on the train' in loud and obnoxious voices."

It's things like that make me yearn for a pocket signal jammer. Not continuous or wide area, just a pen sized, on-demand device that can cut twats off in their prime.

0
1
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Meanwhile back in the early 70s@Bloakey1

"and I oft times wombled far and wide carrying silly weights and wearing silly clothes that got heavier and wetter when it rained"

Yeah, but that was back in the days when you were the dangerous chap delivering Milk Tray to ladies, right? I believe surprise was important then, so phoning ahead was not really part of the task. For my part...well, it doesn't matter what my small part was in the grand scheme of those days, but I'm glad I'm not doing that (white collar, office-ish) job now, what with all three remaining MODPlod probably wetting themselves over the insecurity of digital data, and every man jack traipsing in and out with gigabytes of storage in their pocket.

1
0

If BT gets EE, it will trigger EU treasure hunt for fixed lines

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Quad play

"So tell me, where is BT's monopoly?"

You've not heard of this "Openreach" operation, I take it?

2
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Jargon!

"When the beancounters start reading El Reg...."

You haven't noticed the increasingly populist nature of the Reg? The car reviews, the TV reviews, the hand blender and hairdryer reviews? And a move towards more graphical content, bright colours and baubly HTML? And an increasingly international editorial stance. All of which has a cost, in particular the quality of the commentariat, where there's now more than a few posters who appear to know nothing about anything, and would be better served over on SpeakyawbraneBook.

This change has a distinct smell to it. Many other formerly specialist sites have gone down this route - build a strong reputation in your niche, establish a community (that's us), prettify, diversify, and build the eyeball count, then sell out.

Purch Inc could do with a decent business IT publication, having swallowed the more hardware focused Tom's and Anandtech, so maybe that's who will be running the Reg by sometime in 2016. Could somebody please start up a UK focused, rather cocky, red-top tech web site to take over the true mantle when the Reg finally passes over into the corporate world?

14
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

"Lets hope the current management has at least one working braincell unlike those back in the 90s"

'Fraid not. Two reasons for that:

1) All corporates who believe that M&A are a road to riches and success are misguided - transaction costs are high, there's a distraction from running the core business, you invariably end up with asset writedowns and goodwill to pay off, and integrating two large businesses effectively is a skill rarer than hen's teeth. Admittedly BT get access to the mobile market when this goes through, but they could have got that through a virtual MNO deal (buying some OFGEM firepower if the MNO's balked at agreeing a MVNO deal).

2) Companies have strong and enduring cultures that persist across generations of management. Look at how BT still have an arrogant, state monopolist mindset. Or how energy or water companies still offer standards of service biased towards the dismal standards of the public sector that they supposedly left twenty five years ago. Similarly BA's poor industrial relations. Even in the purely private sector corporate cultures persist for decades - for example John Lewis customer service, or (before they deservedly went bust) Comet's decades long attitude of "stuff your consumer rights, you're not getting your money back", or Ford's iffy reliability accompanied by an excellent parts organisation.

So I think we'll see the same old story. BT have a tame regulator who won't hold them to account, so that's on their side. They're buying from a moderately distressed seller. And they have vast market clout, and a big bag of cash. They've previously agreed FTTC as the limit of their fixed line broadband obligation, and suddenly it all becomes clear why they liked FTTC. Hook up the cabinet as backhaul connected to a multitude of small aerials fitted to the adjacent street furniture, and they're laughing - those cabinets suddenly become hugely valuable commercial assets, despite being paid out of the Openreach "regulatory" settlement, and not needing planning permission. Suddenly LLU grinds to a halt because "there's no spare capacity at the exchange", so that'll be competitors and business customers f***ed.

BT's customer-hating and inept management will be undoubtedly be able to snatch some small defeat from the jaws of this huge victory, but overall our former national telecoms monopolist will have just reconstructed itself, with (at best) a single second tier competitor in the shape of (perhaps) Vodafone/Virginmedia. As a big picture strategic play, BT's management have played a blinder here and I tip my hat to them if they pull it off, unfortunately this strategic success is very one sided and the only beneficiaries will be BT management and shareholders, with the losers including all mobile and fixed line customers and all competitors.

11
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

In theory....

BT should be charging the same for backhaul to competitors as to its own business, and thus the advantage to BT, and disadvantage to the likes of 3 UK would be minimised. Unfortunately with OFCOM very much a "failed state" amongst regulators, there's no transparency on this at all, and we can expect BT to run rings round the OFCOM numpties and ensure that its business is favoured over competitors.

The simple solution would be for government to refer the proposed transaction the Competition & Markets Authority, with a strong steer that Openreach needs to be demerged from BT's other businesses (or at the very least legally and financially separated, with proper public reporting of related party transactions). Probably about time that the VM cable empire was subject to similar rules on third party access as well.

Sadly snow-covered pigs will be flying in hell before the bunglers of Westminster or at Southwark Bridge Road do anything useful. And the net result when they enthusiastically rubber stamp BT's plans will be reduced competition in all fixed and mobile markets, and higher customer charges.

22
0

Robox: How good could a sub-£1k 3D printer be?

Ledswinger
Silver badge

@Dave 126

"If I was Games Workshop..."

...I'd be investigating the prospect of printing some more nerdy customers to buy my overpriced plastic trinkets? Or offering the patterns for sale, but keeping the designers producing new designs that the "committed" have to keep forking out for.

When you think about it, Games Wankshop are in the same place as physical music retailers were fifteen years or so ago. They don't need the distribution channel, nor even the manufacturing, the product potentially could be sold purely as printing patterns. Keep the shops but instead of selling stock just have a 3D printer for those not willing to make the investment, and with a primary function as nerd meeting chambers to keep the Warhammer brand alive (or perhaps undead).

0
1
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: ready for the mainstream?

I'm not sure they will ever be ready for the (home) mainstream - the 3D printing technology can be perfected, but the fundamental restriction in home use is that spare parts or duplicates are very occasional needs, and for anything original, preparing a design pattern requires creativity and technical skill, as well as some application.

Most of us couldn't be arsed to work out and remember how to program a VCR - can you see this same market sitting over AutoCAD Home 3D to produce a unique, well, anything? Anybody who's done any (pencil) technical drawing knows that software only automates the dragging of a pencil, not the thinking. I suppose it's a ready market for those who want to 3D scan and print some more Warhammer figures (you'd get your money back quickly enough on those), but that seems a bit of a niche market?

1
0

German minister photo fingerprint 'theft' seemed far too EASY, wail securobods

Ledswinger
Silver badge

"The stuff to do this is available from your local Maplin's for a handful of pounds, and will get you into most of these systems"

But the day to day use of fingerprints is not really about security is it? My bank don't use it as part of their 2FA, my employers don't use it as part of their 2FA, and I can't think of any instance that a fingerprint is acceptable, other than low threshold smartphone access control and the school uses you mention (where the risks of error or fraud are outweighed by the benefits of recording access, not replacing lost cards, not having pupils carrying cash etc).

I'm sure other readers will have experience of (eg) corporate IT that might use built in fingerprint readers, but I've worked reasonably widely and think I'm correct to say that's an absolute minority of companies.

If you accept fingerprint ID as a simple but not very secure access control for low value applications it isn't that bad, and probably no less robust than the sort of enterprise password policies that cause half the staff to write this months password on a post it fixed to the monitor.....

5
0
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: In a sane world

" Simpler people are still stuck at the "but my mate here can't unlock my phone and I can! See? It's working!" stage, and there are no signs that would change anytime soon."

But it depends what you're trying to protect, and how much resource the "attacker" is willing to deploy. Compared to the probable alternative of a four digit PIN, a fingerprint reader is potentially still more secure at protecting the average Joe's phone data against casual access (noting caveats about bypassing fingerprint readers). But if you're a "high net worth individual" (aka a rich b*****d), with sensitive financial data on the device then you'd be a fool to rely on your fingerprint.

2
2

Internet Explorer 12 to shed legacy cruft in bid to BEAT Chrome

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: I can still

"Sadly, it will have the m$ tainted legacy still and no one will use it unless forced to at gunpoint"

If only that were so. But many people will use it other than at gunpoint - eg the hundreds of millions of unlucky corporate users being force-fed by their IT colleagues. And the big chunk of all home users who choose not to (or don't know how or why to) install non-IE solutions. Worth bearing in mind that the browser ballot screen has now disappeared from new WIndows installs in Europe, so that's a market of 500m people that won't have all new machines actively offering alternatives.

The market share for browsers varies widely depending on whose numbers you believe, their definitions of the market and their method. As far as I can see IE probably still has a majority share of browsing, and will continue to do so in the PC market, even though it deserves nothing more than an unmarked shallow grave.

1
1
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Corporate ActiveX anyone@ Harri Koppel

Have a downvote in response, since you're evidently not clever enough to see that my comment on a legal need for IT audit isn't statist, simply a practical response to the persistent failure of corporates to address IT security. Moreover, if you've read any of my other posts you'd see that I'm avowedly opposed to most forms of government interventions, and that is why I proposed IT audit rather than prescriptive legal forms of compliance or retribution.

But rather than trade insults, let's hear your ideas for preventing the continuing data breaches at major corporations? The 250 million user records in the handful of major examples I listed (ie excluding the breaches not known or not publicly disclosed) show that companies concerned could have learned from experience and good practice, but have chosen not to. If they aren't going to fix the problem, and government won't act, is your solution to do nothing, or to mumble some cobblers about "market solutions"?

10
2
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Corporate ActiveX anyone

" A few more incidents as big as Sony and they will find money to replace insecure in-house legacy web garbage."

The persistent failures to secure customer data suggest otherwise. TJX was hacked in 2007, Sony PSN in 2011, Target was hacked in 2013, Neiman Marcus the same, and Home Deport still got hit in 2014, along with plenty of others.

Now cast your mind (or rather web browser) back to 2010, and search for the Verizon 2010 Data Breach Investigations Report. Have a scan of it. A good piece of work, as relevant today as it was then.

So corporates have the answers on a plate (and have had for years). They have seen the wolves tear into other members of their pack. They've seen the financial pain and embarrassment caused. But they choose to do nothing. Hacks will continue, lazy corporates will simply strike cheap deals with the credit record agencies as a "solution" for hacked customers, and go back to doing what they've always done, of preferring to put money into marketing rather than IT infrastructure.

You can pass all the laws you want and nothing will change until independent IT audit is a legal requirement, requires the auditor to be changed every two years and legally bans IT auditors from disclaiming responsibility for any failings that they fail to identify but that subsequently come to light.

8
1

Key to Windows mobe app sales? Er, LOW MEMORY, of course

Ledswinger
Silver badge

$9.99 apps?

I'm interested that the modal value for app purchase is $9.99. Seems very high to me, given the value-free cruft that afflicts all app ecosystems, and the prevalence of freemium business models.

Anybody have any insight into what's really going on here?

0
0

Tesla parades sleek model body and fab batt at Roadster fans

Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: As a concept

" It's worth noting that the populace should not be paying for these infrastructures or services any more than we should pay for petrol stations."

Why not? The populace might not want to, but that's immaterial. The only thing you can suggest they "should" be paying is the operating costs, and a fair rate of return on capital employed (including commercial risk).

0
1
Ledswinger
Silver badge

Re: Drag coef of 0.31 - why so high?

Well, primarily because (if the photo's accurate) even with the new version they've simply stuck with the formula of shoving a battery and a motor in a Lotus Elise, which is fundamentally a twenty year old design conceived for a power to weight ratio of 200 hp/tonne. Why mess around spending thousands more hours in the wind tunnel when that would make no material difference to the handling or acceleration?

Regarding the contributors to the 0.31 cd, at a semi-educated guess, it's because aerodynamically challenging essentials such as wheels and wheelarches, windscreen wipers, doorhandles, cabin air intakes, wing mirrors etc are proportionately a smaller contributor to the overall drag of larger vehicles. With an Elise based body design you've got a very small car, and unless you can magic away the lumpy bits designed around the size of a human, then you'll struggle to make a road legal smaller car have a materially improved cd. If there were a free lunch from improved aerodynamics, then car companies would have been onto it some years ago simply to improve fuel economy to meet CAFE or to gain a marketing advantage.

1
1

Forums