Feeds

* Posts by Ken Hagan

4296 posts • joined 14 Jun 2007

PEAK IPV4? Global IPv6 traffic is growing, DDoS dying, says Akamai

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

@Martin-73

Exactly right, which is why it is so frustrating when people say

"One concern has been firewall penetration, as NAT provided an additional layer of security by separating the address spaces naturally."

That's just FUD. NAT *is* a firewall plus address re-writing rules. IPv6 does not increase your exposure to the wider internet. Your ISP (well, A&A, certainly) will offer you a pre-configured router that has all this sorted out for both protocols.

Probably worth adding that IPv6 also has a "link-local" address range (non-routed, exactly like 192.168.x.y). You can configure all your domestic services to listen only on link-local addresses if you want belt-and-braces security.

2
0

That glass of water you just drank? It was OLDER than the SUN

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Lorel: Genesis actually very confused on the matter

Genesis isn't confused, just badly punctuated. I think it has been accepted for quite a long time that the opening chapter contains two separate creation accounts, rather badly bolted together.

0
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: "But we're still in the dark about how it rained down on us"

I'd be careful with the jokes you make there. You were part of northern France rather more recently than palaeozoic times.

1
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Panic!

"Can HO2 (can't do subscripts) even be made - no matter how much you blast the atoms in a collider?"

Out in interstellar space, the rules are different. We can see spectral lines from species that are energetically unstable but which continue to exist because they can't fall apart without a third party to carry off some of the excess momentum.

Whether HO₂ falls in that category I couldn't say. Sorry, but I'm really only posting this to point out that Unicode contains a full set of superscript and subscript characters. The bit about interstellar space was just a hook. (True, though.)

Edit: Looks like I should have read some of the other replies before replying. At the bottom of the wikipedia page mentioned just above is a link to "List of interstellar and circumstellar molecules" which includes hydroperoxyl.

0
0

BT claims almost-gigabit connections over COPPER WIRE

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: A polished turd

The context was quite obviously "What can you get down the existing phone line, by whatever means you like?" and it is indeed the case that the answer to that question 20 years ago was 56k and is now nearly three orders of magnitude higher. Obviously the means have changed, but equally obviously the original question deemed that irrelevant. (That's your "man in the street" perspective versus your "El Reg reader" perspective at work.)

0
1
Ken Hagan
Gold badge
Coat

Re: I really wish they'd hurry up and offer us this gigabit internet speed

At 80mbit, it will take 12 seconds to download each bit. Literally minutes might be enough to pull down a whole byte. The headers alone would take an hour or so for each packet.

If you're within walking distance of the exchange, might I suggest you stroll down there each morning with a memory stick?

0
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Oh please, not the tired old "640K" crap

"All the data we download and upload has to serve us meatbags in some way. Some of it acts as input to our brains."

This is a fair point, but I'll have a go anyway. How about a family of four, each watching a different HD video? Your mileage may vary but each of those channels /might/ be over 25Mbit/s after compression and your 100Mbit pipe will struggle to deliver all four without glitches.

On the other hand, a gigabit pipe will handle a set of 4K channels comfortably, so video probably won't be the reason that (eventually) gigabit isn't enough. Perhaps some kind of multi-player, immersive virtual reality? I don't know how much they use.

0
0

What the 4K: High-def DisplayPort vid meets reversible USB Type C

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Nirvana

Logo upwards, eh? So which direction is that for a socket that's mounted sideways.

And whilst I'm here I'll strongly second the comment about mounting ports upside down. My experience is that this happens roughly 50% of the time.

1
0

JINGS! Microsoft Bing called Scots indyref RIGHT!

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: IT angle?

" I've never heard of anyone promoting the idea of dividing Germany again though, have you?"

They aren't very loud, but they certainly exist.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_active_separatist_movements_in_Europe

Prior to the nuclear stalemate, re-arranging European boundaries every 50 years or so was pretty much de rigeur. At the present time, the excuses for centralisation (financial and defence) are pretty much covered by the ECB and NATO. (Obviously one of these insitutions is currently working rather better than the other, but the official line is that both are here to stay.) That leaves the way wide open for the larger nation states to fragment in line with regional preferences. We have Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia as examples so far. (Ukraine is a work in progress.)

2
0

Microsoft splurges 2½ INSTAGRAMS buying Minecraft maker Mojang

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: WTF?

"If MS shift it to .NET and make a free plugin for VS Express, they have just captured pretty much the entire next generation of application developers."

That would imply that the next generation of developers are currently owned by Oracle, since Minecraft is all in Java. Oracle might like to think that, but I don't believe it is a fair statement.

It also implies that a plug-in API would be easy. It might, but all the existing mods are version-specific and Mojang have never published an API.

It also implies that forcing the entire Minecraft community onto Windows isn't going to fragment that community. It certainly will.

To cut a long story short, I find it hard to see how MS-Minecraft can be any more profitable than Mojang-Minecraft, and we know that the latter struggles. I think MS paid about $2.5 billion too much.

6
0

spɹɐʍʞɔɐB writing is spammers' new mail filter avoidance trick

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Odd...

I fail to see why rendering HTML in an email client is any more stupid than rendering HTML in a web browser. Given a sane rendering engine, both are safe. Given a reckless rendering engine, neither is safe.

2
1

Scottish independence: Will it really TEAR the HEART from IT firms?

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: It will be business as usual.

"...all three main parties will have no choice but to make a manifesto commitment against..."

...which, after the election, would turn out to be no more binding than the commitments that all three parties have made at the last *few* elections to reform the House of Lords.

3
1
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: What’s in a name?

"Liz isn't going to be happy if she is booted out as Scottish head of state and forced to sell Balmoral!"

I thought the SNP's current plan was to retain Liz as Queen of Scotland (which, historically, is correct because she's descended from James IV) and, I presume, to remain part of the Commonwealth. This may not be their long-term plan, but they were at pains to separate the monarchy from the sovereignty because Scots hate English Tories much more than they hate "English" monarchs.

1
0

Microsoft tells judge: Hold us in contempt of court, we're NOT giving user emails to US govt

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: If MS loses

"There will be this brand new country with no treaties"

IANAL but I suspect (*) that simply isn't true. A company can't walk away from a contract it doesn't like by transferring ownership to someone who didn't sign on the dotted line. Equally, I suspect that Scotland is under all the treaty obligations of the rUK and will enjoy all the benefits of those treaties as well until and unless all parties to the original treaties agree differently. Anything else would just be a get-out-of-jail-free card for a sovereign state that wanted to be shot of its own history. (There are several debt-ridden countries who'd like that, but as Argentina are demonstrating on a daily basis, the rest of the world isn't so keen.)

(*) Of course, if this were a sane referendum, voters would actually know the answers to these questions before they voted. But that's getting a little off-topic...

0
0

Straight to video: Facebook to add 'view counts' to autoplay newsfeed vids

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

"Now Mr Z, give us a settings to STOP the videos from autoplaying. I for one don't want it."

That is not a setting that you should trust Mr Z to provide. Your browser authors will have provided such a setting and they can probably be trusted to keep it working each time they update the code.

3
0

Snowden shouldn't be extradited to US if he testifies about NSA spying, says Swiss gov

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Would the US risk a diplomatic incident?

"It is realistic to assume a risk of US interference (unlike Assange)"

Not if he travels in a diplomatic bag. I feel fairly sure that he could be delivered to the Russian embassy in Berne if Mr Putin felt that it served his purposes.

2
1

SHIP OF FAIL: How do we right capsized institutions we thought would NEVER go under?

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

"was carried out personally by Richard Feynman"

Feynman's own essay on the subject is quite clear that he was tipped off by someone else and merely provided the media presence necessary to put the evidence into the public domain. I'll stick my neck out here and say he'd be a little upset at the way popular culture has deified him. He enjoyed the limelight, but he'd have hated the thought that personalities might be bigger than either evidence or a decent bit of research by a competent nobody.

15
0

Chelyabinsk-sized SURPRISE asteroid to skim Earth, satnav birds

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Unless its orbital period is some convenient multiple of 1 year, we have nothing to worry about even if it precisely crosses our orbit next time around. We won't be there.

The real concern surely comes from the occurence of two near misses within 50 cross-sections within 18 months.

3
0

Shitty what? Almost half of MPs have never heard of Tech City

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Ah but if you read the quote from the spokesdroid at the end of the article you'd know that it operates everywhere in the UK, so they were probably just "out" when you were there.

1
0

Jimbo tells Wikipedians: You CAN'T vote to disable 'key software features'

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: @lurker

"He invented movable type which made things easier and cheaper. Someone else would have come up with the same idea sooner or later."

Probably. The Disc of Phaistos is generally reckoned to have used movable type. It predates Gutenberg by about 3 millenia.

0
0

Twitter: La la la, we haven't heard of NUDE JLaw, Upton SELFIES

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: mass hack?

The victims are celebs with media reputations to protect, so it is likely that at least some of them are lying when they say the pictures are fake. The victims are also celebs rather than techies, so it is likely that at least some of them are making false statements (about deletion, for example) without even being aware of it.

With all due respect to the celebs concerned, I don't think we can believe a word they say.

1
0

Windows 7 settles as Windows XP use finally starts to slip … a bit

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Why is Win 8 and Win 8.1 seperated?

"because they are considered totally separate Operating Systems as far as patching goes"

and yet MS also consider them to be the same OS for lifecycle purposes. (Win8 dies in a year or so.)

It is odd, though, that all the growth in Win8.x is happenning for x=1. Win8.0 is basically flatlining, with a hard code who were happy to jump into Metroland but not willing to adopt the almost imperceptible changes that came in the latest service pack.

2
0

BBC: We're going to slip CODING into kids' TV

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: "Coding" may not result...

"Oddly enough , teenagers can and do do more than just chase the opposite sex. "

Frequently using one activity as cover for another.

Just like adults.

0
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: The kid I saw on the BBC News this morning...

HTML may not be programming but CSS certainly is and by the time you've added SVG and JavaScript I think you are well past what you could expect junior school kids to cope with.

Based on most of the web-sites that I encounter, you are well past what the average "web developer" can cope with. (Web-devs who actually have a clue must really hate the average member of their profession.)

5
0

Australia deflates Valve with Steam sueball

Ken Hagan
Gold badge
Thumb Up

"Valve have breached Australian Consumer Law by telling Australian consumers that they do not have a right that the law expressly grants them."

A big thumbs up to a legal system that prohibits this. In my experience, *most* EULAs and similar "agreements" are worded along the lines of "Your local law may override some of the following terms and conditions, but we aren't going to tell you which. Agree now, or else the deal's off.". This makes the EULA as a whole more an act of bullying rather than an agreement.

4
0

Rubbish WPS config sees WiFi router keys popped in seconds

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Another dumb question

Why don't all router manufacturers use one of the several FOSS firmwares? This would mean they have more features and security updates for free. (They'd still have to contribute drivers for any bleeding edge hardware they used, but they must develop that anyway for their own purposes.

None of them actually sell the software, or enhanced add-ons. I can't see the economic argument for spending extra cash to produce a shoddier product.

1
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: WPS stands for... (Jen Barber version)

"What doesn't it stand for..."

Wireless Protected Setup, it would appear.

(Seriously, guys? Hard-coding zero as the key? I assume that the WPS specification actually forbids this, so is there a case to be made that the vendor in question made a dishonest claim when they said they supported WPS?)

2
0

iCloud fiasco: 100 FAMOUS WOMEN exposed NUDE online

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Slow learners

Indeed. I think El Reg's advice is very misguided...

"Vulture South recommends readers lock down or delete their explicit photos whenever possible"

Whereas *I* simply recommend that you don't take them in the first place. My policy is so simple that even a celeb ought to be able to manage it. El Reg's advice presumably requires some expertise in IT security, and even the NSA doesn't seem to be able to manage it, so how the hell are celebs supposed to?

8
0

Google flushes out users of old browsers by serving up CLUNKY, AGED version of search

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

"I spend a lot of time on client locations and systems, and very few offer me the option to use my own laptop on their network."

Fair enough, although it cost us bugger all to provide a separate free WiFi on site for visitors. However, have you priced up mobile broadband recently. Unless you spend a lot of time on site watching videos, your usage will be fairly light and so quite cheap. Also, if you spend a lot of time on client locations, you probably spend a fair amount of time travelling, too.

2
0

Virgin Media blocks 'wankers' from permissible passwords

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Merde!

Passwords should only be seen by the person who created them. The fact that Virgin cares about profane passwords (though only English profanities) suggests they are storing them in the clear for the use of their own support staff.

24
2

Britain's housing crisis: What are we going to do about it?

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Abolishing the green belt would hurt

The problem lies with all those people whose houses adjoin the green belt. Since, under current law, they are immune to some jerk building an eyesore on the other side of the fence, these properties have a higher market value than others. Since the laws have been around for donkeys, it is almost certain that the properties' current owners have paid that higher value when they bought it. If you simply abolish the planning laws at a stroke, you wipe that out at a stroke. Abolition is an attempt to transfer thousands of pounds from the pockets of voters into the pockets of developers.

I say "attempt", since this is almost certain to face a legal challenge, just as the proposed HS2 route did. HS2, however, affected relatively small numbers of people along a single route. Green belt abolition would affect far more.

1
3

'Stop dissing Google or quit': OK, I quit, says Code Club co-founder

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: So they asked her

" So they asked her to take the same stance any reasonable business or organisation would take"

Except that I presume she wasn't being offered the big fat compensation package that any reasonable business might offer.

0
1

Premier League wants to PURGE ALL FOOTIE GIFs from social media

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Do not piss off fans

I think it is more like "Do not make copyright law the subject of mainstream pub talk, or else the whole show is over.".

Let's be honest here, most *normal* folks tolerate copyright law and most probably reckon it serves a useful purpose in allowing artists to make a crust. However, if it stops them enjoying their footy with their mates then IT SUCKS AND MUST GO IMMEDIATELY REGARDLESS OF THE CONSEQUENCES.

This may be where the Premier League's gravy train hits the buffers, a bit like the music industry.

4
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: IANALBIPOOTI

IANAL But I Poke One Of Them Intimately?

So, you aren't one yourself, but you are fairly knowledgable because your other half is?

Only joking, but I'd be genuinely grateful for an explanation, since I haven't seen this one before.

3
0

The internet just BROKE under its own weight – we explain how

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Thoughts from a mere user ...

This is getting silly.

Maybe we're pampered here in the UK, but I have half a dozen routers collecting dust on a shelf nearby, some going back over a decade, none costing more than a few tens of pounds and *none* of them have no firewall. So, just to illuminate the discussion, can someone please name a router (not a modem with a single port, which you'd have to plug into a PC, which all have firewalls these days and have had for about a decade), which is IPv6-capable, which doesn't have a firewall?

Sorry, but since the firewall is just software, and routers all run Linux, where the firewalling capability is free, and since IPv4 routers even at the cheapest end of the market have had proper firewalls since forever, and since IPv6 support is going to require a slight tweaking of the vendors preferred Linux image anyway, and since failing to include a firewall *might* be grounds for a case of negligence against the provider, I just can't imagine anyone producing an IPv6 router without one. So I'm rather minded to say "put up (examples) or shut up".

6
2
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Please refrain from NAT66

" but requires updating all your hardware and software and relying on a daemon on one box correctly informing everything else it needs to be updated."

Every desktop OS has been able to do this for donkeys years, and apps couldn't re-implement the network stack even if they wanted to. So for your PCs the hardware upgrade is going to cost you nothing. The OS upgrade will cost the same and the rest of your software will be half as much again.

There may be some devices that will require an IPv4-capable LAN, but I doubt that many of them need to talk to the internet, so a dual stack LAN and IPv6-only WAN is now perfectly viable and has been for many years.

3
2
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: We need IP6

Ah, yes! The famous compatibility between IP versions. We wouldn't want to lose that.

1
1
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

"NAT, itself, however, evolved into a critical part of networking and much is built around it, not least the idea of a central device controlling access in and out of a network."

Firewalls and routing rules predate NAT by several years and both clearly involve the idea of a central device controlling access in and out of a network. I respectfully suggest that you present a fresh argument.

"The problem is that those pushing IPv6 view NAT purely as a work-around - a band-aid covering a problem of limited public IP addresses."

Perhaps they were around when the NAT RFC was published, and read it. I'm afraid that NAT *is* just a band-aid around limited public addresses.

Furthermore, not a lot of the coverage here is bothering to mention *why* the number of global routes has now passed 512K, so I'll let you into a secret. It is caused by people buying up small allocations of IPv4 one corner of the globe and using them in another. The address space has become horribly fragmented and the IPv4 internet is going down like a 99%-full hard disc using the FAT file system. And of course the reason everyone is still on IPv4 is because NAT has allowed them to punt this problem into the long grass for almost 2 decades. Well done NAT.

7
4

Govt control? Hah! It's IMPOSSIBLE to have a successful command economy

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Red Plenty...

That tendency to deadlock indecisively might have been partly inspired by Stalin's own well-known methods of dealing with people who decided wrongly.

2
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: yeah but what about the jobs...?

"Another robotic task?"

There would always be "connoiseurs" who claimed to be able to tell the difference between a robot and the real thing. More darkly, there would always be some who did it for reasons of power over another rather than the physiological response.

1
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: "Mega Corp" proves command and control can work!

"Command and Control DOES work. BP, HSBC, Ford etc all perform over decades, and typically out perform."

That's partly because you've just chosen the ones that haven't gone bankrupt yet, and partly because they aren't a complete society. The comparison just doesn't stand up.

1
0

Awooga: August Patch Tuesday incoming – with two remote-code exec bugs in IE, Windows

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Pro

The actual bulletin (link in the article) certainly suggests that several consumer editions are not affected.

0
0

Microsoft throws old versions of Internet Explorer under the bus

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Fix the installer first

"My perfectly legal Windows 7 VM is stuck on IE 9 because Microsoft wants to install some kind of spyware to let me use IE 10 or IE 11."

Get over it, dude. If you use a computer with a non open source OS, you handed over the keys to the kingdom on the day you installed the OS. Since we're talking Windows, MS could have built in spyware in the original release, or they could have slipped some in as a security fix under Windows Update (if you've applied *any* updates since installation, which I hope you have). Whatever *named* package you are worrying about, if it is from Microsoft then it doesn't increase your risk of being spied on, even if it says "Microsoft Shafter for Windows" on the tin.

4
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Of everything

"IE is the underdog we have to pitty,"

I'd rather target a recent IE than an older webkit. The problem is not IE, per se. The problem is that Microsoft don't make their recent improvements to IE available on OSes that they claim to still support. I don't suppose it is even the fault of the IE product managers or developers. I'd be amazed if these decisions were not handed down from Stevie B, in a desparate and demonstrably self-destructive attempt to wring a few more upgrades out of "customers".

1
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Product to Service

"Google gives away Android ..."

...because most of it was originally free.

And in any case, one of the frequent gripes about Android is that they *don't* give it away free. Instead, you are frequently left with the version that your product shipped with, bugs and all.

2
0
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: Product to Service

"Believe it or not, once upon a time that you might charge money for that was absurd."

Ah yes, the good old days when total vendor lock-in was just taken for granted as the only conceivable business model, if only because no-one except the original vendor had adequate documentation to write programs.

0
0

Now even Internet Explorer will throw lousy old Java into the abyss

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: but not Vista?

I'm puzzled too, but for a different reason.

" Only IE8 and later will get it, and then only when they're running on Windows 7 SP1 or Windows 8.x."

What sequence of dodgy upgrades do you have to dance to end up with IE8 on Win7sp1?

1
0

Simian selfie stupidity: Macaque snap sparks Wikipedia copyright row

Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: So the monkey owns the copyright

"And if I record a movie with a camcorder or a concert with my phone, then I own the copyright?"

Yes, you do. Come back after you've googled "derivative work".

4
2
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

Re: The debate reveals that Copyrights are unnatural.

"but often they just happen to be in the right place at the right time"

In the case under consideration, the right place was a remote part of Borneo and the right time required a fairly prolonged stay. I'd call that fairly heavy investment, but maybe you spend months lurking in tropical rain forests as part of your day job.

7
1
Ken Hagan
Gold badge

"For example, if I photocopy an A4 page using a normal photocopier in the normal way, do I own copyright in the photocopy? Probably not."

Probably. You could argue that it was a derivative work and that others should not be allowed to copy your copy without your permission. They'd have to go back to the original. However, none of this sophistry would exempt them and you from obtaining the permission of the original creator if the page you copied was itself a copyrighted work.

2
0