* Posts by Globetrotter2011

4 publicly visible posts • joined 31 Dec 2010

BT confirms broadband upgrades for rotten boroughs

Globetrotter2011
FAIL

!03%!

Sorry I disagree.

I rang and spoke to Porter Novelli at least twice and emailed then on at least two occasions to ask if we would be ok using a single computer on a single but dynaic ip address to put the votes up to the site. Likewise I called them and discussed concerns some of the voters had raised about vote rigging after reading the magazine article. On each occasion I was told that everything was fine and that BT were encrypting the votes being sent so they could not be intercepted and were using that wonderful captcha facility so they knew it was a human entering the votes... and..... and... oh... nothing else then! No checking of Ip addresses just monitoring voting patterns. What was that going to prove. When we did events we got 100 200 votes where as some days we got none so how anyone could make sense of that kind of data god knows.

http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/broadband/362962/revealed-how-bts-fibre-rollout-could-be-rigged

I was told that it dint matter about the IP address they were looking for postcode and only allowing a single vote per house. I must have put at least 400 votes from my one Ip address then about another 150 from a new ip.and a few of the other members had done likewise.

Having had an email with at least 900 other emails included in the email then to have someone try to drag it back again by sending out another email asking for it to be withdrawn! I did start to wonder if I could actually believe anything about this farce. Bt would not talk to us directly at any time (nothing new there then).

I guess you could try and put rubbish in and click not a bt user then it would be lost and did not check their records. I have been told that this is what was happening with a lot of the strange voting.

How you manged to get two votes for one address is amazing, I never managed to do that!

Re the towns that had votes removed they should have been instantly disqualified instantly!

Yet at least one of them went on to win!!

As only about 12% seem to sign up for the service it has been a total flop and nothing more than a publicity stunt which I worried about to start with but thought they would never get away with that.

Sorry I am not accepting anything favorable has come out of this competition.

I and over 1400 other users are up in arms at the poor standards and practices that have been adopted throughout the competition

As far as Infinity goes, they can stick it as far as....... Infinity!

If I get one more call offering me Vision I will scream the exchange can hardly support broadband let alone their poor mans cable.

BT Just how much damage has this done to you?

Ok there are 6 winners and thousands of looser's with millions of customers.

These are your customers, so I guess the biggest looser here is BT?

Globetrotter2011

12%

Based on the 12% signup for Infinity in towns that have been upgraded It's laughable when you think most of the winning villages will have mabe...... 160 to 170 people signing up to the service based on the approx 12 % sign up. Bet Bt cant wait to get ALL that revenue!

I am pleased for Baschurch who seemed to collect votes in an orderly manner and teh website showed a steady flow of votes. The irratic voting on Dec the 30 by other groups was nothing short of a farce.

Glad its all over

BT........................ words fail me!

Globetrotter2011
WTF?

We were robbed!

So the Race to Infinity is over and BT have congratulated everyone on a good fair contest.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/Design/graphics/icons/comment/happy_32.png

Like Hell!http://www.theregister.co.uk/Design/graphics/icons/comment/wtf_32.png

This is not sour grapes just dismay that this competition ( con) was allowed to run at all. We all played by the rules and can say we carried out all our voting in a honest manner. Knowing that they voting system was flawed (as shown in the link below) perhaps we should have just cheated as it was apparent that this was happening on December the 30th by the top groups.

The voting on the December 30th was a joke! with towns obviously sitting there typing in any rubbish to get a vote. I was told that someone tried voting for a pub in one of the areas that had got 100% votes and found they hadn't voted!

The voting system was called into question by the computer press back in October.

http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/broadband/362962/revealed-how-bts-fibre-rollout-could-be-rigged

http://www.theregister.co.uk/Design/graphics/icons/comment/gates_horns_32.png

The whole competition was a joke from the start but we all hoped our concerns were just that, and that things could not really have been allowed to go the way they did. We are the highest scoring medium sized town that achieved the 100 votes and have nearly 6000 lines on the exchange. All those above us had around 1000 to 3000 lines, but what have we got from the competition nothing. In fact it has cost me personally something like £350 and a friend another £100 to stage this advertising campaign for BT.

I asked many times ( via Porter Novelli) if Bt could check that people were not cheating etc and was told that Bt were monitoring the voting system very carefully and that one town had some of their votes taken away or cheating. I wonder if they then went on to win?

Having spoken to some of the other campaign groups we all feel let down by the poor organization of this competition and the manner in which Bt have tricked us to pay out for their advertising.

We did hear that Bt were to announce another list of some 20 to 40 new towns that would be getting upgraded in early January but nothing so far.

http://www.techradar.com/news/internet/bt-to-trial-1gbps-broadband-in-2011-912950

Having spent hundreds of man hours, tramped around for miles in snow ice and freezing temperatures to get votes let alone the financial hardship, I am furious that we have just been cast aside.

Unless something changes pretty soon and Bt at least try to help a little I suggest that we all ditch Bt as an Isp , its just a pity we still have to use their hardware to get to the house.

BT http://www.theregister.co.uk/Design/graphics/icons/comment/dead_vulture_32.png

Campaigner for our local town will I ever help Bt in any other scam they try to run. Never!http://www.theregister.co.uk/Design/graphics/icons/comment/joke_32.png

BT fibre-up-your-exchange poll in 6-way Mugabe style pileup

Globetrotter2011
Thumb Down

The race to what? No Winners?

What!!!

Not Impressed

Blewbury are showing more votes than they have lines! the site shows 1277 out of a possible 1236 !!!! http://www.theregister.co.uk/Design/graphics/icons/comment/wtf_32.png

Yesterday votes were being banged on faster than the system seemed to be able to display them.

Its pretty obvious that the whole campaign has now been called into question. We rang a campaign in this area and never expected to win. We did however play by the rule's even though the press reported the shortcomings of the race to infinity web site months back.

http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/broadband/362962/revealed-how-bts-fibre-rollout-could-be-rigged

How can this have been allowed to continue. Hopefully the press will show it for what it has been a complete sham.

There are no true winners except for BT.

This exercise has cost us a lot of money an a lot of wasted time shame on you BT!

http://www.theregister.co.uk/Design/graphics/icons/comment/fail_32.png