* Posts by Paul Shirley

1840 posts • joined 19 Jun 2009

Windows 10 build 10041: 99 bugs on the wall, fix a bug, add a feature, 114 bugs on the wall

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: You'd be surprised, I certainly was

One thing we learned from the Win8 fiasco is how determined 10's Microsoft is to impose change on Windows look&feel. So desperate to become relevant on mobile, they ignored the sheer ugliness of the resulting desktop, ignored public feedback and we've recently heard insiders claim they ignored 80% unfavourable feedback from their own employees.

They tried so hard not to look like IOS or Android and succeeded. Like or loath it, Googles flat icons look good (but are so cryptic I struggle to use the apps), IOS at least looks well drawn (in a childs toy way). Microsoft just look amateur and lacking in visual cues.

While the functional parts of Win10 are still in flux, the UI is heading in only one direction. It remains to be seen if enough pressure can be applied to force change. My bet is they'll need catastrophic take up of Win10 upgrades before that happens. Which means I'll be risking the security of Win10 with even more 3rd party fixes, I'm already running multiple UI hacks to make 8.1 acceptable :(

6
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: As far as this article is concerned I have no problems with the general tone........

Very wrong, it's pretty clear they're fuglyfying at least the icons and if we don't comment on that hard and often that's what will ship. I hope someone is saving the old icon resources right now ready to hack them back in over this eye bruising mistake.

I can live without pretty but nothing needs to be this pointlessly fugly and waiting won't magically make it look better. Some things need stomping on fast and vigorously, Microsoft still aren't good at listening.

27
2

Apple's portable power podule patent promises paroxysms of fanboi joy

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: I don't get it

@Steve Todd:"AND communicates with the fuel cell pack at the same time"

Now explain why that's A: not obvious, B: not required to fulfil it's function (how else would you detect fuel level?). Both are grounds for invalidation.

9
0

$30 Landfill Android mobes are proof that capitalism ROCKS

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Have you had a closer look at that 'landfill' recently?

gotes:"A few years down the line you find that less and less apps are supported"

What actually happens is Google removes a permission or 2 with each release, borks up some other support (usually claiming 'it was never meant to work that way') and generally breaks existing apps. Some apps will be fixed, some won't. In some ways it's better to *not* upgrade Android devices, my old Xperia never performed properly after upgrading past Gingerbread.

But the poor manufacturer update support will be a massively more dangerous problem for this market. I can afford to store no sensitive information on my phone, I have a more secure PC for that. These devices are going to be the only computing device for many and handling sensitive data. And they won't be secure enough.

1
1

Honey, I shrunk the Windows footprint

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Don't stop there

@Big Ted

My wife's Linux box comes in and out of sleep mode in seconds and isn't tied to anyone's cloud. Think I'll skip crippling it with cloud based crapness. Oh, I turn my PC off when it crashes, start:stop time isn't something I work about, Microsoft's inability to have working sleep mode on so many desktops does Anjou me.

11
6
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Windows Phone?

512mb ram was already a problem for universal apps, most of us aren't going to risk dealing with floods of complaints when resource heavy apps fail on under specced devices. We'll just continue writing for desktop mode and leave universal for toy apps.

Luckily for Microsoft most users only use toy apps on their low end devices, just a pity their strategy will create a further dumbed down PC experience. As if the metro fiasco wasn't enough damage.

5
1

$17,000 Apple Watch: Pointless bling, right? HA! You're WRONG

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Paying for sex?

So basically you're strapping an "I couldn't get laid without money" sign on your wrist?

3
0

Quantum computers have failed. So now for the science

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

re: "information propagation is limited by the speed of light"

Spooky action is what you have to assume if Bell's inequality is a correct description of reality and there's no hidden variable carrying the entangled state. But if this theory can supply that hidden variable then superluminal information transport is not needed, the state was always there waiting to be measured.

Got to say it's a hard sell, but not necessarily harder to believe than other interpretations of quantum behaviour.

Can I say 'pilot wave theory' and suggest this is not exactly new.

0
0

Ouch! Google crocks capacitors and deviates DRAM to root Linux

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: It is just an elevation

Surely the point is with write access to even a single arbitrary page table entrie you have unrestricted access to *physical ram*, then you could map any other processes ram into your address space and modify privilege bits at will.

1
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Double the cost?

@paul Crawford

We live in a world's where Lenovo were prepared to ship malware on PCs because margins are too slim on the hardware. 20% on the ram really is a significant overhead for most of the devices shipped.

6
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

@thames

It probably can be fixed in firmware by adding the right guard pages around critical structures but knowing where those pages need to be will require ram manufacturers input, component databases in each os and probably won't happen.

What's more likely is they'll need to reduce power saving tweaks (like under volting and reduced refresh rates) and everyone gets lower battery life on their laptops. No idea why they think more than a tiny minority of desktop machine are using ECC.

10
0

Microsoft: You'll get the next Windows 10 build when we're GOOD AND READY

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: "It was validated by our test automation."

Rival_product_A_doesn't_work_test. Passed

Rival_product_B_doesn't_work_test. Passed

Rival_product_C_doesn't_work_test. Passed

17
8

Oi. APPLE fanboi! You with the $10k and pocket on fire! Fancy a WATCH?

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: So at least that answers the question..

I think you're on to something, the iWatch, a codpiece that tells time!

Fully consistent with rumours apple are entering the other penis extension market with cars ;)

1
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Really?

@ac if you're smart enough you don't have to grow up... something Steve Jobs came close to demonstrating.

6
0

Windows XP's market share grows AGAIN!

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: We just

The 'new' Start menu isn't so much fugly as crippled by design.

Without hierarchical menus it's reliant on search on well populated systems and the users perfect memory of app names.

It wastes a large chunk of space on the tile interface - even if you remove ALL the tiles.

The actual menu part seems to totally lack any configurability - haven't found a way to add shortcuts to it yet and that's part of what I want a start menu for because many of my tools don't show up without it. Sure, you can do some rearranging of the tiled area but we said no to the start screen, sneaking it back in as the only working bit is not acceptable.

Microsoft need to give up playing bait&switch with this, just promise never to disable Classic Start Menu and stop wasting time on anti features.

As an upgrade, I doubt there'll be any advantage sticking with 8.1, if there is expect MS to update 8.1 till its removed! Win10 isn't very different to 8.1, a better backend with a different fugly, impoverished UI pasted on. Equally as in need of 3rd party UI fixes. 8.0 is already abandoned.

6
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

"lot less painful to jump to W10 " until they remember there's no free win10 upgrade from xp!

Though it remains possible that will change if xp numbers continue to hold up :;

6
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Until Microsoft loosened it's grip on win7 install media last week it was probably easier to find an xp install disk lying around, probably also easier to find one online without hitting pirate sites.

7
1

Don't pay for the BBC? Then no Doctor Who for you, I'm afraid

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

cant see the BBC or terrestrial tv surviving this

The most likely outcome is the BBC abandoning terrestrial broadcasting for some or all of their output, as the only viable way to shift users to CA capable platforms. That puts them in a really bad bargaining position with the cable+sat platform owners, utterly incapable of coercing viewers to actually pay for their channels, let alone pay enough extra to cover the carriers profit margin. The idea this will increase BBC income is beyond optimistic.

Secondary effects are it becoming unsupportable to impose obligations more onerous than existing commercial channels have. Looking at some of the fckwits making stupid decisions inside the BBC today, that's a recipe for catastrophe. The many commenter claiming they don't watch BBC may actually stop watching.

Still, it's likely to happen, this is a key part of how the gov clear the airwaves ready to sell off TV bandwidth to the mobile industry.

0
0

Firefox 36 swats bugs, adds HTTP2 and gets certifiably serious

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Problems with XP?

To save everyone 20s searching ;)

https://ftp.mozilla.org/pub/mozilla.org/firefox/releases/35.0.1/

0
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Have they stopped

The ui vandalism is up there with win 8. Tried a vanilla install yesterday while trying to fix the plugins 36 broke and it took a couple of minutes trying to guess where the About menu was hidden. They've evolved the ui past useless into wtfville. I dread the day they break the addons that restore sense to the madness.

9
0

The Order: 1886 – Round Table gaming's all right on the knight

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

"constantly changing depth of field"

One of my triggers for motion sickness ;(

QTEs make me feel sick a different way ;)

4
0

Microsoft leaves the Rooms. How will Windows Phone OS users make to do lists?

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

the Verge nailed it

I think the Verge has it right, being Winphone only is a fatal flaw for any social application. Not fitting the new MS vision of getting their cloudy offerings onto other platforms signed it's death warrant, why try to port it and it's unlovely interface when they have Skype already ported and plans to make it a jack of all trades trojan.

...just a pity my hate for Skype is increasing with every update Microsoft makes. I really didn't need the advertising, or it firing up the browser when it thinks I *really* need to see one.

3
1

It's not easy being Green. But WHY insist we knit our own ties?

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Comment isn't free

Free market advocates don't consider any of that as distortion. A perfect market simply makes choices that humans might decline. The rest of us impose regulation on free markets in response.

0
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: @Tim99

"I think many people could achieve a similar standard of living with just a part time job"

But the downside of extreme labour specialisation is the masses condemned to unskilled work because the process requires nothing better, with pay driven too low to make life comfortable on part time hours. Their cheap labour undeniably makes me richer but it's not quite so clear it works well for them, that's not something economists tend to worry about.

4
4

'Giving geo-engineering to this US govt is like giving a CHILD a LOADED GUN'

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

block moderate, timely, precautionary action - WTF did you expect?

Some idiots never learn, let a crisis build and governments will eventually make excessive and dangerous responses... and rape your wallet with taxes along the way.

Obstructionism is not free of consequences.

0
0

Cortana to form CIRCLE OF LIFE in Windows 10

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

wow, Android support...

...so I can start the day talking to the android phone next to my bed in the morning?

I fear ms will be disappointed when I don't rush out and replace my phones and tablet with win10 devices, even if it works much better than the utterly incompetent google now ;)

Or allow Cortana to infest my PCs. Given their history deeply embedding unwanted and insecure apps in the core os that might become a problem :(

2
4

BBC bins pricey Windows Media, Audio Factory goes live

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: I thought I'd never see the day...

Microsoft VC1 was evaluated on what the rest of the world had already patented. Didn't end well for Microsoft's wallet!

0
0

Russian revolution: YotaPhone 2 double-screen JANUS MOBE

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: no sd slot, no removable battery, 550 quid

£550 buys a lot of external battery packs for a basically £300 phone. That's a high price for convenience.

2
0

Microsoft explains Windows as a SERVICE – but one version remains a distant dream

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Rolling releases

"Much of that software is seen as crucial by many of Microsoft's customers"

What worries me is how much software will be seen as crucial by *Microsoft*, so critical to Microsofts plans users aren't allowed to remove or control it. Or how much "as a service" really means enhanced "lockin" to Microsoft, their cloud and the MS products I have no need of.

6
0

Ofcom can prise my telly spectrum from my COLD, DEAD... er, aerial

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: @Neil Barnes

That graph is deceptive. In large parts of the EU almost no one uses over the air broadcasts. The UK is pretty unusual in it's high use of aerials. Ofcom are rigging the numbers by using EU stats.

2
2
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: "Broadcast is efficient"

The massive problem with going to IP broadcasting is things like live sport that sometimes millions of viewers want to watch live and in real HD. Not timeshifted, not delayed by buffering and not breaking up at crucial moments because bandwidth goes MIA and not the piss poor resolution we normally see.

IP has miserably failed to deliver that quality of service to audiences that large so far and there's little sign of it improving in any short timescale.

I'll agree most of the DTT bandwidth is wasted on complete crap and many of those channels aren't any better than internet channels but if this sell off to profiteers goes ahead we'll lose them all, the good with the bad.

13
1

Behold: The touchy-feely future of Office on Windows 10 fondleslabs

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Windows 8 does not have the new APIs

It's another signal that 8.1 is going to join 8.0 in 'essential updates only' mode shortly after 10 ships. MS really want to forget Win8.x ever existed and this is just deliberate neglect.

They intend neglecting it to death, starved of updates, starved of killer apps.

0
0

Valve set for OpenGL BIG REVEAL at upcoming conference

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Are AMD and nVidia on board?

I have a bad feeling AMD & nVidia are too busy with DX12 right now. I'm sure Khronos announced a big change in approach for OGL as well last year that will also need their attention.

Also not seeing Qualcomm or ARM mentioned, it's pretty unthinkable launching a new graphics API without mobile support.

Oh well, new toys to play with whatever happens ;)

3
1

GROUPTHINK HIVE MIND informs climate change believers

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

what's most depressing

... Is the reality or not of agw hardly matters. The technology we could have started creating 25+ years ago to deal with the problem would have made us all better off *even if there's no problem*. Instead we ended with denial shortchanging us of investment and believers pushing through any desperate political fix they could as time ran down.

We know it's worth dumping carbon fuels, it's probably really worth bankrupting many of the suppliers along the way and taking out their corrupt states and terrorist support. None of it depends on agw. But we just have bickering aresholes delaying like it was an Olympic sport.

Sickening tribalism.

18
11

Chipotle insider trading: Disproving the efficient markets hypothesis

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Efficient Markets Hypothesis ...

"all the publicly available information"

If they claim that then they're based on a fiction to start with.

1
0

Quantum of Suspicion: Despite another $29m, D-Wave doubts remain

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: "only faster for certain classes of algorithms"

... Of course D-Wave can't run Shor's algorithm. Search for quantum annealing or adiabatic computing... So cryptography's safe from it ;;

0
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: "only faster for certain classes of algorithms"

"If it's able to solve a particular problem in a time which is very very improbable"

D-Waves problem is every time they claim that, someone comes along with a faster algorithm on a classical computer. The speed improvements they claim were never 'improbable enough' to convince anyway.

3
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

The problem with D-Wave is it doesn't seem to be faster for the algorithm it supports than non quantum solutions. So slow it's debatable it's taking advantage of quantum effects for the actual computation. Even worse no one knows yet if that's because it's just a bad quantum annealer or quantum annealing itself is a dead end.

One thing is certain, it should never be confused with a general purpose quantum computer.

4
0

You must have at least 8 inches for Windows 10 to go all the way

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

the screw turning on desktop apps

This is how they plan on forcing devs to write Modern apps instead of desktop versions, make sure large chunks of the market can't run desktop apps. They couldn't get anyone to choose modern over desktop willingly, not users, not devs, so its time to apply pressure.

Again Microsoft's dream of the same apps running on everything is revealed as the same apps running dumbed down on everything. Modern apps may well run on the desktop now (as they always should have done) but it ain't pretty and it ain't a good use of my valuable screen space.

I'll be hanging onto my rich and densely packed desktop ui and continuing to ignore the wasteful toy modern versions. Both as a dev and a user.

4
0

Apple CEO: Fandroids are BINNING Android in favour of IPHONES

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Strange that...

"Bit the same with battery life - Apple look for efficiencies and Samsung have to fit a larger battery! ;-)"

...and others fit 8 core BIG-little CPUs to improve power consumption without harming performance. Sometime more of the right sort of core really is the answer ;)

3
1

'YOUTUBE is EVIL': Somebody had a tape running, Google...

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: You're misreading SOPA

...and what extra powers SOPA did hand to copyright owners were almost designed for abuse by the traditional copyright pantomime villains, rather than helping artists. Rotten all the way through and no amount of 'big copyright' PR is going to change that.

'Stronger copyright' is a dangerous tool, more likely to be abused wholsesale than help.

7
0

Some Androids can be HOSED by WiFi Direct vuln

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Not sure why that was downvoted

Should Microsoft tell people to use Firefox next time there's a critical IE bug?”

Yes, if they cared about their customers more than their customers wallets.

6
3
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Google stopped caring what we think a long time ago. Because they don't care, they feel no embarrassment over disclosure of things they can't be bothered fixing. They're roughly in the place Microsoft reached in the win 8 fiasco but haven't yet spent long enough pissing off customers for a revolt to start.

But make no mistake, they're firmly in a take it or leave it mindset and making no attempt to disguise it.

6
3

SURPRISE! Microsoft pops open Windows 10 Preview build early

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Read privacy statement

@ken Hagan... Or worried that those of us that do care won't be using the preview normally. Nothing that needs my passwords is going in the win10 vm, no browsing with account logins, I won't be running any dev tools until ms sends us non instrumented builds etc. Not going to be a lot of useful testing from my install with that!

0
0

Planning to upgrade your Lumia to Windows 10? NOT SO FAST

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

is it because they're ARM?

It's hard not to assume this is the fallout from dropping RT and someone remembering too late that shipped Lumias run on ARM.

6
2

Free Windows 10 could mean the END for Microsoft and the PC biz

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: COULD BE LETHAL

@dogged: a free *UPGRADE* for an OS they're likely to abandon after <3 years? They have absolutely no option but to give Win8 users a free upgrade, or face another crippling backlash. For nearly a year there have been questions asked about whether Win9 then Win10, would be charged for or treated as Win8 service packs and the feedback has been pretty clear.

Win7 *UPGRADES* being temporarily free - that's market reality smacking them in the wallet. The $25 upgrade to Win8 didn't work well enough, they have to go cheaper. Or no one is moving off 7 till a few years after it's discontinued. By the end of that free year the market supply of Win7 licences will have dried up and the choice will be Win10 or another OS.

MS are desperate and cannot bully users they way they got used to under monkey boy.

13
12
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Stop and think a bit, please...

"It's just not legally possible to do that, the Windows you've got now is yours and can't be taken off you."

I suggest you read the upgrade EULA before clicking through, it's possible to give away your current rights even if MS cant unilaterally remove them.

You don't own your Windows install, you own a licence to it.

35
9

Windows 10: The Microsoft rule-o-three holds, THIS time it's looking DECENT

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Oops, wonder how THAT got in there?!?

The us gov don't believe there are any jurisdictions outside their reach when a us company is involved. The courts haven't told them they're wrong yet. Might want to hold off trusting them till that happens.

Then decide if you really want your local authorities able to raid your data on Microsoft servers so easily.

8
0
Paul Shirley
Silver badge

Re: Read the whole thing...

"the supported lifetime of the PC" - one interpretation of device. I want to see the small print before upgrading to make sure I'm not giving up my ability to swap out mboard every couple of years. My PC is the collection of parts I'm currently using, not a specific device.

4
0

Pull up the Windows 10 duvet and pretend Win8 and Vista were BAD DREAMS

Paul Shirley
Silver badge

...and so far you can still use the same 'Don't have...' way to a local login in Win10. Don't be surprised if they hide it better (or remove it completely) by launch though. They're raising the friction though, couldn't test download a Store app without handing over a Microsoft account AND give the app permission to rape it, hopefully I'll never need an app enough to actually accept that crap.

8
2

Forums