* Posts by ThomH

2033 posts • joined 18 Jun 2009

FORCE Apple to support BlackBerry hardware, demands John Chen

ThomH
Silver badge

I think this is the wrong sort of burden

The suggested neutrality rules for carriers prohibit what they can do. Packets are inherently have equal priority; the primary offense is taking action to perform market-restricting traffic shaping.

Chen wants not to prohibit something but to force it; he wants to put a positive burden on Apple, Netflix, etc to develop software they weren't otherwise planning to.

I don't foresee that leap being widely supported.

6
2

LEAKED: Samsung's iPHONE 6 KILLER... the Samsung Galaxy S6

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Why should Apple be worried?

I don't think Apple should be worried: the difference in Samsung's release schedule and Apple's routinely means that one manages to launch a newer/faster/shinier flagship than the other. It's business as usual. It's expected.

It's now been, what, four years since Android became number one? And eight years since the original iPhone came out? Apple is doing fine and Samsung is still doing spectacularly by any fixed measure, even if less spectacularly than for the last few years. But that's Android diversification and ever-ongoing phone commoditisation for you.

23
1

Pull up the Windows 10 duvet and pretend Win8 and Vista were BAD DREAMS

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Not too sure

At my most recent publishing role, now five years ago but out in the real world and completely unconnected to anything in tech, every desk was kitted out with a thin terminal that presented a Windows desktop from a server upstairs. It was running Server 2008, I think; for me to know that it was likely in the 'winver' box so I'm not clear whether it was virtualisation or just headless multi-user on a single OS instance — nothing ever happened that would make it clear. Not that it matters so much when it's all in-house anyway.

Being run on a sufficiently fast internal network, the only thing that felt odd was that everything was rendered at 8bpp, but this was the sort of publisher where we spent our days just poring over text so it was no real impediment.

The terminals were very cheap (but not in the shoddy sense); certainly a lot dumber than a Chromebook.

0
0

'Yeah, I'm like, SO backing Microsoft over Google, YAH'

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: #JeSuisLeRameau @theodore

There's a difference because there are a huge number of people that find the depiction of Mohammed offensive but there's no significant group that considers the depiction of Jesus offensive. So if you make any evaluation of potential offence then the outcome will differ.

Thought of a really funny joke but are sensitive to people's feelings? The joke will probably have to be funnier if it's about Mohammed to make the one consideration outweigh the other.

Just aiming to offend? Then don't bother with Jesus.

Would prefer above all else not to offend? Then stick with Jesus.

However there's absolutely no difference in my mind as to the protection that each cartoon should be given. Both should be equally protected in a secular state.

0
2
ThomH
Silver badge

Re: #JeSuisLeRameau

My only problem with Charlie Hebdo is that I don't seem to get the joke. But there are lots of riotously popular comedies that leave me cold so that doesn't necessarily mean anything. If freedom of speech is used as a cover just to offend minorities then that's worthy of reproach but the principle of the freedom itself is still worth defending and, again, possibly I just don't get it.

A sad part of the whole thing is the huge number of people that have seized the opportunity for reductive us versus them rhetoric; I think possibly you originally came across as one of those.

2
0

Grand Theft Auto 1997: 'Sick, deluded and beneath contempt'

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: GTA Prequel - Before They Went Bad

If we're covering precursors then let this be the obligatory reference to Turbo Esprit, Durell's 3d free-roaming city driving game for the usual three 8-bit suspects.

0
0

US and UK declare red-team CYBER WAR – on EACH OTHER

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: So are we saying... @Afernie

Which is fine, but a bank, a commercial concern that is in business to make a profit should be paying for that oversight itself, just like they pay accountants to conduct audits on their financial operations. Why should we pay for government to carry out a security audit on banks to allow twats like David Cameron to be seen to be 'doing something?'

The counterargument is that should these institutions fail then the cost for you and I would be huge, just as it was in the 2007–2008 financial crisis. So we're paying for preventative care in order to reduce total expected lifetime costs.

I guess the fact that we keep paying at all comes down to a resigned acceptance that the industry is a net benefit rather than a net cost in a country with limited natural resources and no significant manufacturing base. Not the healthiest position to be in but there it is.

0
0

This $10 phone charger will wirelessly keylog your boss

ThomH
Silver badge

... so that's a Caesar cipher? I guess it'd do for any completely indiscriminate group attack.

1
0

Google crashes supposedly secure Aviator browser

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: "Users concerned enough with privacy would probably be..."

I heard that it did that once but the government covered it up.

2
0
ThomH
Silver badge

Re: All are a 'real estate grab' minefield

Apple's service provides things like direct Wikipedia suggestions, links to film trailers, etc. It's for Safari's "smart" autocompleting address bar. These things are on by default even if you select DuckDuckGo. The direct UI allows them to be switched off but it's hardly straightforward in explaining itself. Which doesn't appear to be all that accidental.

So there's clearly a vested interest on Apple's side in serving those autocompletes. I'll bet they're monetising them in exactly the same way Google monetises its entire search engine. But they are, technically, optional.

(source)

0
0

Android users are massive wan … er … smut consumers

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: but are they really?

You'd want to weight against browser stats for other sites, surely, not sales statistics?

0
0

Anonymous vows to avenge Charlie Hebdo massacre by blitzing jihadist sites

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Whose freedom?

While I agree that freedom with limits is in practice greater freedom than freedom without limits — e.g. it's fine that I'm not allowed to steal because the principle in general frees me from a lot of burden by facilitating shops — I'm not I want Anonymous policing anything for me. Accountability is important too.

3
0
ThomH
Silver badge

... and there are no skyscrapers in Africa?

6
1

French Google fund to pay for 1 million print run of Charlie Hebdo next week

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Let's have some Charlie spam

Just because three pathetic little European criminals claim to be doing something for a particular region of the world, doesn't mean we should target that region of the world.

I vote for a Google Doodle, including the full range of Charlie's targets.

(per released details, at the time of writing, all three were raised and educated in France. The birth country has been released for only one: it was also France)

10
6

20 years on: The satirist's satirist Peter Cook remembered

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: "greatest British comedian of all time "

What a blessed generation the baby boomers must be, to have had both candidates for greatest British comedian of all time amongst their ranks.

6
4

FBI boss: Sony hack was DEFINITELY North Korea, haters gonna hate

ThomH
Silver badge

@Roger Kynaston

Evidence is a verb according to the OED and according to Merriam Webster, and has been since at least 1610. Even Wiktionary knows it.

The Dictionary of Modern Legal Usage entry on evidence (noted as a transitive verb) is available via Google Books.

I agree: Lynn Truss would probably be sad if she read this thread.

1
0
ThomH
Silver badge

... and apparently the FBI doesn't have the same idea of the burden of proof as I do

If the party that makes an accusation cannot or will not evidence it, I don't believe the accusation.

9
3

Apple's 16GB iPhones are a big fat lie, claims iOS 8 storage hog lawsuit

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Untouchable

You're inventing false claims from thin air.

In the US courts Apple has: been found guilty under antitrust law of ebook price fixing; lost the attempt to establish that Amazon can't call its an 'App Store'; lost an attempt to compel various rumours sites to reveal their sources; been successfully forced by Creative Labs to pay royalties for use of hierarchical menus in iPods; failed to win a patent case againt HTC; failed to win a patent case against Kodak; failed to win a patent case against Motorola.

Apple has ended up settling rather than going to court in the US: with resellers who argued that Apple were illegally driving them out of business; an antitrust case about cold calling employees of competing companies; a class action over the reliability of early MagSafe power adaptors; a class action about price switching, where gift cards couldn't buy the number of songs indicated due to a price change; the trademark case with Cisco about use of the iPhone mark; a class action over iPod battery life.

So Apple has been successfully prosecuted by the US government. It has lost cases started against it by other companies. It has lost cases it started against other companies, it has had to pay out for cases started against it by groups of consumers.

9
1

OnePlus vs Micromax: Dream of Google-less Android now further away

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Sounds like an opportunity for Linux for phones

The problem being that phones are very much about user interaction and Linux is just a kernel. So Linux solves the hardware interaction problem but that's all. It'd be more appropriate to say that FirefoxOS or Ubuntu Touch or Sailfish or something else is the smart choice and leave the Linux component implicit. But even then: where are the apps and where are the cosy carrier agreements you need to launch a mass-market phone?

3
0

Internet Explorer 12 to shed legacy cruft in bid to BEAT Chrome

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: It's a mess

More likely someone doing the typical mediocre developer rubbish of deciding they're so clever that they can learn a framework not by reading the documentation but just by poking around, and then being surprised when all the things that they figured out empirically and all the code that seemed alright when they ran it a few times fails under a different version of the framework because they're relying on a whole bunch of things that were never API guarantees — many of which the documentation probably explicitly offers the correct approach for. But, you know, developers are too clever to need to read things, right?

If anybody here has never worked with such a person then you have my envy.

33
1

Reg man confesses: I took my wife out to choose a laptop for Xmas. NOOOO

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: @Tom 13

The original poster is referring to whatever drivers he had installed for an "old but functional graphics tablet" no longer working under the latest OS X. This is exactly a third-party hardware compatibility problem. Apple didn't make that hardware, somebody else did.

0
2
ThomH
Silver badge

@Pascal Monett

The author said, and I quote exactly: "I don't touch the damn thing unless I have to, it applied it's UI 'improvements' and rendered hardware obsolete on it's own."

4
6
ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Sometimes the reason OsX doesn't work @AC

The administrator's password is required to install all OS updates. Major versions are not pushed automatically, you have to go to the App Store and select to download them, supplying your store login credentials.

The Mac definitely did not install Yosemite "on its own".

5
14

Fake Android The Interview app actually banking Trojan

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Installing an app from a random torrent is definitely smart

It's unclear to me from what I can find online how Android/Badaccents actually works but I think it's safe to assume that the payload is exploiting a security flaw elsewhere in Android or in the specific banking apps, rather than Google having thought it'd be smart to extend bank account details to any installed app that asks.

0
0

Toffee, Apple? U.S. fanbois get their sticky fingers on Nork-teasing flick The Interview

ThomH
Silver badge

... and who didn't already purchase it from Google or Microsoft. The macrumors.com gossip (i.e. not deliberately anti-Apple) was that after the cinemas pulled out, Sony wanted it to be an iTunes exclusive and went elsewhere only when Apple (initially) declined involvement.

0
0
ThomH
Silver badge

Only if making a loss was the objective. That all the major chains have declined to show it somewhat limits income — it had a budget of something like $44m and made only $1m in screenings during its opening weekend due to the limited release.

There's also the likely future employment prospects for Amy Pascal et al in the corner of not-such-a-great-set-of-circumstances.

0
0

Space Commanders lock missiles on Elite's Frontier Devs

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: No offline? Screw you guys, I’ll play with myself instead. @Tsung

It may be more that fans of a 1984 game are more prone to ask"if this game requires a server, will I still be able to play it in 30 years?"

13
0

Microsoft kills its Euro pane in the a**: The 'would you prefer Chrome?' window

ThomH
Silver badge

Apple which has recently ended a half-decade class action re:media player lock-in and is still fighting a case on e-book price fixing, having lost to the government? I'd say the US legal system is doing its due diligence.

That all being said, look to the top. The big Microsoft antitrust suit concluded under Clinton. Then Bush came in and everyone — including Microsoft — got somewhat more of a free hand. Even most of the penalties initially imposed against Microsoft in '98 just sort of quietly vanished on appeal.

3
1
ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Waiting for Google to be forced to offer searches on competiting engines...

Competition law protects the market. As per Roland6 and others, it defines that the wrong is using a monopoly position to distort competition.

So how come Sun didn't get in trouble because Solaris never offered you a browser ballot? Because that was not abuse of a monopoly position. How come Apply don't get in trouble because OS X never offers you a browser ballot? Because that is not abuse of a monopoly position.

Look at the consequences.

Microsoft built a majority market share with a shoddy browser then took steps to lock its platform down and walked away. What effect did the long life of IE6 have on every other part of the internet's technology stack? How much money and how much time was spent dealing with IE6's peculiarities?

Suppose Apple had built Safari not to be especially standards compliant, then baked it closely into the core of OS X and taken market measures to lock out the competing browsers. What effect do you think that would have had on the internet's technology stack? How much money and how much time do you think would be spent dealing with Safari's hypothetical peculiarities?

So, given that the remit is protecting the market, which of those companies was it correct to take action against?

3
0

The STEALTH Plug-in Hybrid: Audi A3 e-tron Sportback

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: What happens to the grid ...

In the worst case what happens is: no benefit for the environment. But it buys the ability for the environmental problem to be fixed centrally. So if cold fusion were discovered tomorrow then they could just plug a couple of those into the grid. Or maybe they'll come around to the idea that new fission stations are the thing environmentally? Renewables don't exactly have a lock on being a better solution if we're optimising for that.

1
1

It's nearly 2015 – and your Windows PC can still be owned by a Visual Basic script

ThomH
Silver badge

It's nearly 2015. What Windows PC?

19
10

Google pushes 'go' on Android Studio

ThomH
Silver badge

I'd rate Android Studio as about a million times as good as Eclipse, and I've also used RubyMine at work so I understand the value of the JetBrains IDE as a transferrable skill. But...

IntelliJ is built in Java. So to use it you have to expose your machine to Oracle's vision of a runtime. Ironically for a just-in-time compiler, it seems to have absolutely no concept of just-in-time launching. Let your machine be forever burdened with Java overhead at boot regardless of what you intended to do that day.

It's also quite visibly not native software. It makes a pretty good stab at hitting a middleground between the OSes and is nowhere near Swing-level awfulness but expect normal cues to be absent and to go ignored. Git integration is one of the obvious examples: you may have your machine set up with an SSH key and all your other appropriate configuration but Android Studio comes with its own embedded version of Git that'll ignore all of that and insist you supply Google's software with your username and password. Presumably just using the Git you already have proved to be an issue across targets.

Then there's the real blight: that emulator. The default is painful and only a computer nerd could love the labyrinth of third-party options and associated manual configuration. Guess what? Being a developer doesn't automatically mean loving configuration. For me HAXM is a default install and lots of people love Genymotion but it feels like an issue is that the first-party tool just isn't up to snuff.

Other grab bag complaints: gradle wants a network connection before you can build anything. There's still no nexus between the IDE and the package manager; the one can know that you're trying to use API 21 and the other can know that API 21 is available but you're the agent that has to transfer the knowledge.

But I think Google can advance in leaps and bounds when it wants. Android 1.6 was awful. Even 2.x retained significant issues, both technical (no accelerated drawing) and in the user interface (that menu button that nobody ever spotted). So probably the future's bright.

2
0

Wheels fall off bid to sue Apple over iTunes anti-piracy shenanigans

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: how long? @circuitguy

I don't think Apple had much left in its witness buying off fund this month, since it overspent on helping to cover up the faked moon landings, sheltering the person that really shot JFK and pretending that Obama was born in the US.

6
0

LA schools math quiz: $500 Chromebooks or $700 iPads for students?

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: The schools will "choose"

I understand that it's the school's budget but that even iPads were considered justified because the third alternative is textbooks, which are even more expensive. California, like the other states I'm aware of, requires that textbooks be approved before schools can purchase them, which creates something of a captive audience for the publishers and gives them significant extra costs to defray (especially in terms of risk).

Which seems to be similar to the process for hardware but I guess the fact that Chromebooks and iPads have a huge external audience limits price jacking.

3
0

Ten Mac freeware apps for your new Apple baby

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: You should try pressing ctrl in addition to cmd+shift+4 @JDX

Command+shift+control+4 and select an area.

Open Preview and the command+n File menu will have become "New from Clipboard". So select that or hit command+n for an atomic create+paste.

0
0

First in line to order a Nexus 6? AT&T has a BRICK for you

ThomH
Silver badge

To me it sounded more like AT&T's "value adding" Android customisations may not be functioning correctly; meanwhile the demo units usually run a completely different software configuration full of tutorials and guides.

3
0

Windows Phone will snatch biz No 2 spot from Android – analyst

ThomH
Silver badge

Chromebooks accounted for 35% of US B2B laptop purchases during the first five months of 2014 per NPD. So Microsoft has been losing its grip on businesses at an unprecedented rate. If Microsoft is focussing effort on trying to segue its business computer hegemony into phone success then it might be better advised not to take so much for granted or it may end up without dominance anywhere. And, yes, I feel old just being able to type that. Things change, I guess.

5
1

Nexus 7 fandroids tell of salty taste after sucking on Google's Lollipop

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: android

I use mine rarely because I use it for relatively limited things — web, email, Netflix, Hulu and application development — so I'm in the habit of turning it all the way off when I'm finished. That being an accepted difference between you and I, it's still speedy and working perfectly.

I'm a very casual developer so haven't tried the Lollipop beta and am still running ordinary 4.4 but I'll probably accept the over-the-air upgrade without compunction when it becomes available. My experience from owning an iPad is that these kinds of complaint tend to be very much about edge cases; I can think of uncountable iOS updates that reportedly had users up in arms but which were completely uncontroversial from my subjective point of view.

7
1

Microsoft adds video offering to Office 365. Oh NOES, you'll need Adobe Flash

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Why Flash?

Netflix is now available via the HTML5 premium video extensions — most controversially the encrypted media extensions which either (a) seek to corrupt the aim of open standards to allow consumption anywhere; or (b) accept that DRM is the trade-off for some content access and try to make it less vendor-dependant. Depending on where you sit.

If you're accessing Netflix through a browser and your browser isn't IE11/Windows 8.1 or Safari/OS X v10.10 then, yes, it's still Silverlight powered.

But I think a huge proportion of access is now probably tablets, TVs with native clients, set-top boxes, video game consoles, etc, etc, etc. Not Silverlight places.

0
0

Countdown contestant pays homage to IT Crowd's Moss

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: "Not available in your country. Sorry."

Haven't you noticed the increasing number of articles from El Reg's San Francisco office, full of American spellings and terms? I don't think there's any intention to be a British publication for British people.

5
5

LIFE, JIM? Comet probot lander found 'ORGANICS' on far-off iceball

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Secret mode? @Dave 126

Xenon 2, naturally.

Actually, I didn't know the cheat. But how many games were really famed for their music before the PC could keep up?

1
0

Anonymous ‪hacks the Ku Klux Klan after Ferguson‬ threats

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: "Hacking"?

If I were asked to guess the KKK's password then I'd be happy those text boxes usually don't let anybody else see what you're typing.

4
0

The Nokia ENIGMA THING and its SECRET, TERRIBLE purpose

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: 5. A marijuana vaporizer

You could sell geographic distribution information to kebab vans?

9
0

Microsoft .NET released from its Windows chains... but what ABOUT MONO?

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Licence

The repository is up at https://github.com/microsoft/dotnet and says:

.NET open source projects typically use either the MIT or Apache 2 licenses for code. Some projects license documentation and other forms of content under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0. See specific projects to understand the license used.

.NET Core uses the MIT licence. The .NET Compiler Platform remains Apache 2.0. For comparison, Mono components are primarily licensed via one of the GPL, LGPL or MIT X11 licences.

So I think that's one barrier to trust overcome.

8
0
ThomH
Silver badge

Re: The last throw of the dice? (@asdf)

What's wrong with managed code? Is it virtual machines in general or just Microsoft's approach?

I think the Android switch from Dalvik to ART is interesting: Google is switching from just-in-time to ahead-of-time compilation, compiling on the device at the point of app installation a lot like a traditional make install but from an intermediary byte code rather than from source. It's being promoted as a performance win, eliminating any remaining user-noticeable distinction between 'managed' (in Microsoft parlance) and 'unmanaged' code.

I've seen it argued that such an approach should ultimately prevail everywhere because it resolves the same security issues as an MMU without requiring all those expensive context switches every time a system call is made. That is, given the semantics involved, a proper compiler can generate code that is guaranteed safe to run as ring 0. I have no independent opinion on that other than that it sounds reasonable at a brief parsing to someone who doesn't do anything closely related for a living.

6
0

Vodafone: For Pete's sake! Apple’s 'soft' SIM's JUST AN EE SIM

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Sounds like Vodafone is unhappy @BristolBachelor

You're not a huge distance from arguing that a CD player could not be more consumer friendly. The simple fact is that — with a hypothetical perfect software SIM — it would be more consumer friendly not to have to carry multiple if these things around, not to have to try to obtain them in foreign languages when you have better things to do with your only seven days in the country, to have the cross-network pricing options clearly tabulated free of marketing puff, etc.

Of course, what Apple supplies is nowhere near the hypothetical perfection. Not even close.

1
0

SO LONELY: Woman DARED to get rid of her iPHONE - Apple DUMPED all her TXTS

ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Oops!! @"if it doesn't send, then Apple could try SMS"

The multitude of people to have suggested that appear not to use the service. iMesages are more like Google Hangouts than text messages. If you own the connected phone then you can add a phone number as one of your addresses but after that you'll receive all messages sent to you via your phone, your iPad, your Mac, etc. It's multi-client instant chat. The issue is that your Apple friends end up sending you chat messages when they want to send you text messages, which makes a difference only once your phone can't receive them.

You most likely still receive them on your iPad, Mac, etc. They're still received. There are still receipts being returned.

Unlike the average tech blogger, normal people are perfectly happy to mix and match brands, including to wander in and out of iPhone ownership over the years.

An iPhone will resend as SMS if it can't send as an iMessage but that's mainly about non-data mobile connections still being more widely available than data connections per the frequencies at play. It's a failure-to-send fallback.

2
0
ThomH
Silver badge

Re: Oops!! (@Marketing Hack)

Apple doesn't "force customers to register to get something as basic to mobile telephony as SMS messages if they leave Apple". See my other message below. I'm a recent departee. I haven't registered. I still have other Apple devices which receive iMessages sent to my email account. I've had no interruption in texts from my Apple-owning friends.

Though with further hindsight I can only assume that's because I wiped the phone before handing it back (it was a work phone so will now be somebody else's; contrast with if I'd broken it and bought something else or just put it into a drawer). Otherwise how could Apple know?

1
2
ThomH
Silver badge

Re: I find this side of Apple extremely distasteful.

It'll look appropriately awful. But I think the issue may already be technically fixed. I switched away a couple of months ago and all of my Apple-toting friends' messages are now just arriving by regular text message. I didn't inform Apple, I still use some non-phone iMessage-enabled devices, I kept the same number with no discontinuity of service. I don't know what the applied logic is but I appeared not to lose anything in the switchover.

2
0

Forums