* Posts by Max

1 publicly visible post • joined 25 Sep 2008

'You can't use Google' - EU Parliament

Max
Thumb Down

Hmmm

>That sounds rather benign, but the effect is that it is the European Union which decides what is lawful content and what is not, rather than national authorities. [...] It might also mean of course that content not to the taste of the Commission might be declared unlawful - not a power we might want them to have.

The EU doesn't decide on anything - it's an overarching collection of its component institutions (council, commission, court and parliament).

This is a parliamentary vote on proposals to set up a regulatory framework - it is the member states who can decide what is lawful or not. The two referenced directives (2002/21/EC and 2002/22/EC) are about universal access - they don't set out lawfulness of any particular content.

To be honest, if you're drawing on a UKIP MEP for an understanding of how civil law works, you perhaps oughtn't be writing about it.