* Posts by John Robson

1524 posts • joined 19 May 2008

Fears of fiber cable cuts, rogue drones menacing crowds at Super Bowl 50

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: There isn't an acceptable terrorism loss rate...

"So you believe that terrorism is just another form of crime? Sorry but that's incorrect. Terrorism is an act that attempts to instill terror in a population "

So you are giving them the victory?

Ignore them, they are an insignificant threat compared with those we have decided are "normal" and acceptable.

0
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: More groundless fear-mongering from an Agency that stages 'terrorism'

"Spare us your 'statistics', okay? There isn't an acceptable terrorism loss rate no matter what you personally believe."

Yet there is an acceptable automobile related death rate?

And an acceptable gunshot death rate?

Terrorists are so low down on the actual threat list for human lives/health that they really shouldn't be significantly considered.

Of course if the fibre gets cut and someone is streaming online from a remote control aircraft... then all hell will break loose - no ad breaks, how are the players going to get their rests?

9
1

Blighty's Parliament prescribed tablets to cope with future votes

John Robson
Silver badge

A tablet - for a vote?

Really?

A cross on a bit of paper is too hard?

For the cost of this system I'll even help the employment figures, we can employ someone to count those bits of paper...

1
0

Pentagon fastens lasers to military drones to zap missiles out of the skies

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Is it a bird? Is it a plane? No it's a UAV circling over my missile silo.

And of course you wouldn't open fire with the SAM until you wanted to launch the ICBM...

0
0

Space podule outfit inks Arizona launch deal

John Robson
Silver badge

a few pumps and cylinders could be added

To bring the helium back again - but then you'd probably have to lose a passenger (or the pilot)

0
0

NASA rockets datasets into Amazon’s cloud with Avere

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Exsqueeze me?

You know what - they might have done the sums on this one...

And they might have a pretty good handle on the data that they are shifting - they've been doing it long enough.

I'll wait and see, but of all the "move it to the cloud to save money" stories we see - this is the one of the few cases I can see being well researched.

2
0

For fsck's SAKKE: GCHQ-built phone voice encryption has massive backdoor – researcher

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: They all have the same flaw...

It's VoIP - That rather implies an IP connection, so why not use an out of band crypto key exchange?

0
0

Amazon cloud increasingly powered by hot air

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Quick sum...

But that's the normalised *demand* - not the normalised capacity.

I am working on the assumption that windmills just throw everything they can at the grid...

0
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Quick sum...

The 150 megawatt facility on Fowler Ridge in Benton County, Indiana starting pumping out electrons on the first of January when it made over “1.1 million kilowatt-hours of renewable electricity.”

https://www.google.co.uk/search?hl=en&q=150MW*24h&meta=&safe=active&gws_rd=ssl#safe=active&hl=en&q=150MW*24+hours+in+kwh

3.6 million kWh

So it's running at <30% nominal load, which seems about typical.

Why don't they just call it a 50MW facility?

EIT: Actually seems to be quite high!

The normalised load factor for UK onshore wind farms declines from a peak of about 24% at

age 1 to 15% at age 10 and 11% at age 15. The decline in the normalised load factor for Danish

onshore wind farms is slower but still significant with a fall from a peak of 22% to 18% at age 15.

On the other hand for offshore wind farms in Denmark the normalised load factor falls from

39% at age 0 to 15% at age 10.

From http://www.ref.org.uk/attachments/article/280/ref.hughes.19.12.12.pdf

Of course not having to deal with the humidty and sea air of northernm europe probably helps.

Maybe it should be called a 20%150MW farm?

1
0

Russian Pastafarian wins right to bear colander

John Robson
Silver badge
FAIL

Re: Fighting talk!

@Goit - "Another anonymoron"

Yes, I'm clearly anonymous... That's why I have the AC icon and the name Anonymous Coward...

An Atheist is claiming that there is no such thing as a God - not that they doubt it.

0
1
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Fighting talk!

"You are asking to prove a negative. It simply doesn't need to be done. FAIL"

Why would that not need to be done.

I can't just declare that I don't believe my tax bill, or overdraft statement.

If I really think they aren't valid then I need to demonstrate that.

Atheism is a faith position.

Apathy is not - although many people won't want to admit that they are apathetic rather than atheist...

1
8

El Reg mulls entering Robot Wars arena

John Robson
Silver badge

Depends on the rules...

There used to be different weight limits for power sources.

Best of the earlier series from my memory:

Casius (the original flipper IIRC)

Razor (ridiculously damaging claw)

Hypnodisc (Deciding that power wasn't everthing if you can build some energy in a weapon)

Before HD came out I had started to settle on a chinook style hypnodisc-esque weapons system because building energy in a flywheel was always the most obvious way to inflict damage.

4
0

Huffing and puffing Intel needs new diet of chips if it's to stay in shape

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: IoT

"What IoT systems do you know have passwords longer than 8 characters? ;-)"

None - but my point was more directed at the more data centres than the password...

0
0
John Robson
Silver badge

IoT

Doesn't that really mean more data centres for all the centrally accessible personal data hidden behind the password: "Password123"

3
0

Ground control to Major Tim! Brit's spacewalk halted after NASA 'naut takes unexpected leak

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Thicko me

Although also cooling them down from their own extertions - they can't lose any heat by convection or conduction, and they are exerting themselves quite significantly!

0
0

Google API spring cleaning ends after four and a half years

John Robson
Silver badge

18 months

is a decent grace period for all the non-professional users of the API...

It make life much easier, and really costs very little (assuming that the API is monitored for abuse)...

So you end up with much happier tech savvy users, who then encourage other people to use your advert generator^W^W search engine

0
0

World Bank: What do the poor need – clean water, or email ... take a guess

John Robson
Silver badge

You say "of course"

I'm not sure that's always something you can reasonably assume.

It is in many areas, but not everywhere...

0
0

Evil OpenSSH servers can steal your private login keys to other systems – patch now

John Robson
Silver badge

Private key on the server???

Wha'

Why is it ever transmitted - surely the appropriate way to do auth forwarding (which is useful) is for the server to pass the auth requests back to the client (which may pass them back to the next client etc.) until it's at the machine with the private key

1
0

Aircraft now so automated pilots have forgotten how to fly

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: A bit of editing might be useful...

The issue with that analogy - and the analogy is being discussed - is that drivers aren't nearly as well trained, or continuously assesssed, as pilots, and there is always a safe position available: stopped! That isn't possible with aircraft.

The issue on the roads is that there are a large number of people who massively overestimate their own skills, and the damage they cause is frequently to those outside their vehicle....

5
0

TalkTalk outage: Dial M for Major cockup

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Gone but not forgotten

Just talk to you rank and recall the monies.

The DD guarantee is good at times...

2
0

Council of Europe gets tough on net neutrality

John Robson
Silver badge

The two services (residential and commercial) would have been sold with different traffic management policies - so that's fine.

What I find slightly odd is that they can't now traffic manage - for instance - P2P download traffic to be of a lower priority than VoIP traffic.

That's basic QoS management, and appears to be banned under these rules.

I am absolutely with them that no one VoIP provider should be preferred over any other, nor should one streaming audio provider be favoured over any other, nor should any streaming video provider be favoured over any other, no HTTP(s) source.... no BT source...

But the idea of prioritising VoIP and streaming over HTTP(s) over BT is a sane method of traffic management IMHO.

0
0

We know this isn't about PRISM, Matt Warman MP. But do you?

John Robson
Silver badge

Why would he get it - he's a politician...

7
0

Sigh ... c'est la vie: France mulls mandatory encryption backdoors

John Robson
Silver badge

Access to the hardware...

Certainly - here is the hardware...

What do you mean you can't access it - it's in your hands?

No I can't unlock it for you...

No, that's software, not hardware....

Godbye.

1
0

Kentucky spies stricken: Ban on web snaps of horror accidents mulled

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Attack on free speech?

I'm not convinced this is an attack on free speech - you're free to post said pictures (if you still think it is in good taste) after an hour - but you allow an amount of time for the families to be notified in the proper manner.

It's an hour, not a week, and certainly not "never".

I'd go with the victim exclusion, but I can't see why the "professional" media should be any different, nor first responders (although they might want to email it to the paramedics, but I would guess that facebook isn't the way they do that) - stuff still hurtles around (anti-)social media pretty fast - wherever it was taken from.

A location and a stock photo would be adequate for the news media for the first hour...

Of course legislating for sense is never going to work...

6
2

SpaceX makes rocket science look easy: Falcon 9 passes tests

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: would be thrilled to see

Cross feeding is also called Asparagus staging in KSP - and is a remarkably good way of getting stuff off the ground.

0
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: How many times?

"But if you're going to be sitting on top of it... do you trust it?

I for one would love to know..."

As opposed to:

"sitting on top of two million parts -- all built by the lowest bidder on a government contract."

I don't know - but I'm probably not cut out to sit atop an experimental firework...

(Yes, this is a repeated response, to a repeated question in a different thread)

5
0

Discworld fans stake claim to element 117

John Robson
Silver badge

Are you saying that Discwolrd doesn't have a mythological basis?

It might be modern, but it's still myth:

Myth - from the Greek word mythos (μύθος), which simply means "story".

16
1

Live-streaming paper plane drone takes to the skies

John Robson
Silver badge

Having been lent a 3.0

These are really good fun, but you need plenty of space...

0
0

Reverser laments crypto game protection, says wares dead after 2018

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: A month.

So if they are looking for a month's protection - why not say that, and release the keys after some amount of time - a year maybe?

2
0

The designer of the IBM ThinkPad has died

John Robson
Silver badge

Typing on one now....

Well, the Lenovo version...

Got two in the loft at home, and a docking station...

3
0

Researcher criticises 'weak' crypto in Internet of Things alarm system

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Optional

It came from the "remote control via pocket computer"

There isn't any indication that any of the comms are encrypted and there is a tendency in devices nowadays to be WiFi only - often not a recent version, forcing all devices to drop to a lower standard...

That this has ethernet is one good point IMHO - of course the rest of the security is still needed

0
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Optional

Hardly technophobic..

I can see the benefit of having some devices on WiFi - mostly user devices, but I doubt that an ethernet port shouldn't be significantly more expensive than a WiFi chip and antenna.

My NowTV boxes aren't mobile, they don't need the mobility of a WiFi connection, neither does an alarm system - which is presumably wired in to the house...

My Blu Ray player has an ethernet port on the back... One of the things I looked for when I bought it...

The benefit of using wires is that the airwaves need be shared by fewer devices. Wires make good a spatial division multiplex and avoids all the issues of whatever the latest wireless security issue is, as well as not limiting your next gen router to an older WiFi speed, compromising the remainder of your devices.

0
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Bah!

Which is great - assuming infinite battery life...

And the thing should be SSL'd even over the WLAN - as someone mentioned above the light bulbs are leaking wifi credentials - as is Windows 10. Pretty sure a kettle did it recently as well...

Given that it probably insists on either WEP or an open wifi network....

Oh well - whatever happened to devices having an ethernet port :(

1
0

LogMeIn adds emergency break-in feature to LastPass

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: why trust a third party?

That server - it ought to be Sftp ;)

6
0

HaLow, is it me you're hacking for? Wi-Fi standard for IoT emitted

John Robson
Silver badge

1km

Hmm - at what kind of data rates - I could do with this an an option, cheaper than a 3G contract to send a continuous 128kBit stream, and with a 1km range I could find an appropriate friendly fixed line to use...

0
0

Here's your Linux-booting PS4, says fail0verflow

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: loss leader...

Hence the idea of paying for the linux "game"

2
0
John Robson
Silver badge

loss leader...

I know they try to make money on the games rather than the hardware, but why not release a Linux "game" that will reboot the machine to linux - then you can sell it (and the hardware) to the HPC guys and home enthusiasts...

5
0

North Wales Police outsourcing deal results in massive overspend

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Motorists stay clear of North Wales

"But, as is quite evident, there's an endless stream of idiots all too happy to follow them. So, my point: how do hidden cameras help deter dangerous driving and/or speeding? "

Well, it would increase the likelihood of detection significantly - and that would mean that people wouldn't expect to get away with it.

It wouldn't take long for people, even the idiots you reference, to work out that if they speed then they *will* get busted, and therefore pay the appropriate price.

At that point it becomes an easy decision NOT to speed.

Currently the chance of detection is so small that there is no deterrent value.

0
1

Getting metal hunks into orbit used to cost a bomb. Then SpaceX's Falcon 9 landed

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Bah! - the people at NASA might have considered the various options

Yes, but the HP startup didn't produce (trying to think of something good and complex that HP produce....), erm... all their products.., cough, from that garage.

They produced something small and simple, and did it well.

This is a somewhat different challenge. Can I suggest that you try a higher orbitting station in kerbal and see what the issues are?

0
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: STS comparison

"I don't think that the comparison of the STS with the Falcon 9 is valid; the STS had to cope with re-entry but the Falcon 9 doesn't, which will make a big difference in the refurbishment costs."

Well, it does have to cope with reenty - that's what the third burn is for.

It doesn't have to cope with reentry from orbital speeds however...

0
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Falcon 9 vs New Shepard

Reddit images:

Flight paths

Rocket comparison

3
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Bah!

"A proper space station would house people without the need for excessive special training. It would have enough gravity to make life relatively simple and provide proper windows so the visitors could see why they built the damn thing in the first place."

Has enough gravity - well, the ISS experiences about 90% of the gravitational force that we do on the surface - the thing is, it's in freefall - that's kind of required for an orbit...

You could set up a fast spinning station, but then you have lost half of your usable surfaces within the structure...

Windows of course are a rather delicate point. Both from a "resisting air pressure against the vacuum of space" and from the "a grain of sand could shatter this" perspectives. That's why there are 7 holes in the ISS YouTube.

"And it should float higher than a gnat's whisker away from the atmosphere, so it doesn't need so much shoving to keep it aloft. Which means we need better lifting engines so people can get there."

You can either keep boosting the ISS a little, or spend an inordinate amount more fuel *every* time you transfer people/cargo...

I'm again going to suggest that the people at NASA might have considered the various options regarding altitude, and decided on where it is for a reason...

1
1
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Party Trick

See earlier posts - and consider how many people are thinking about it at SpaceX.

The structure has strength and rigidity in the required direction already, and both of the current private enterprises are doing it the same way...

2
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Real numbers would be interesting

"but sitting on the pad does the fact the rocket underneath has done 17 trips already make you feel more or less confident?"

More confident than (and I quote):

"How do you think you'd feel if you knew you were on top of two million parts built by the lowest bidder in a government contract?"

I really don't know - but I'm probably not cut out to sit atop an experimental firework anyway...

8
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Real numbers would be interesting

Not all payloads are the same - the largest payloads will always require the first stage to be forfeited, but slightly smaller payloads afford the spare capacity for some 'descent fuel' to be carried as well.

(Slightly lighter payloads don't have enough spare fuel to return to base, hence the barge landing option)

Of course given the cost of the stage it might be more economical to split the big payload in two and assemble it in orbit?!

As for designing things for reuse - it's a good thing that cars are single use items... and planes... and bikes.... and shoes....

Oh, wait a moment.

They don't have to be very much heavier, certainly not when compared with the all up mass of the rocket.

8
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Ballistics

Landing might be patchy...

if doing that then why ditch stage 1 - why not use it to slow and land?

BTW - it's not (yet) man rated, and it's certainly not public rated.

The cost would also be stratospheric...

2
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Very much agreed

Down Goer with fire still coming out as if was an Up Goer, and the right end pointing towards space.

25
0
John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Not the first falcon landing.

The article seems to think that there is no opportunity for the Falcon 9 engines to be modified to cope better with repeat lauches.

These engines will be tested, I expect to destruction...

The next set, well that depends how fast they break these ones...

10
0

IT bloke: Crooks stole my bikes after cycling app blabbed my address

John Robson
Silver badge

Re: Common sense

You define the circles yourself - so I have several covering my local estate - there are only three paths out, but all it says it what estate I am on.

Same around my office.

Not that any of my local rides are publically shared, nor do I record them any more...

0
0

Xen Project blunder blows own embargo with premature bug report

John Robson
Silver badge

Hope the patch can be applied fast?

And without taking down whoever it is that uses AWS?

(I've lost track of the people who use it, not implying that no-one does)

0
0

Forums