* Posts by John Sager

806 publicly visible posts • joined 28 Apr 2008

Restoring your privacy costs money, which makes it a marker of class

John Sager

I do have a Gmail acct but I run my own mail server at home & scrape Gmail and my main mail service into it periodically . Same with calendar, I run Davical on Apache/postgresql. For access when I'm away, WireGuard VPN works fine. Granted, you need tech chops to get it all working, but it's a useful privacy boost.

IPv6 still 5-10 years away from mainstream use, but K8s networking and multi-cloud are now real

John Sager

Re: Is this the most sensible Gardner report ever?

Security at your router/firewall for IPv6 doesn't have to be any worse than what NAT supposedly gives you for v4. A couple of iptables/nftables rules and an ultimate 'DROP' policy in the FORWARD table will give you that. Of course the wifi router makers need to get on board with v6 which they haven't done hitherto because there is 'no demand'. Perhaps pressure from ISPs that are going to v6 will persuade them to get their act together.

BT to phase out 3G in UK by 2023 for EE, Plusnet, BT Mobile subscribers

John Sager

Re: Hmm...

Apparently Vodafone's Sure Signal is due to be turned off soon. Guess who's phone hasn't got WiFi calling on Voda :(

Windows 11 still doesn't understand our complex lives – and it hurts

John Sager

Re: web Teams works on Linux

I use the Teams app on Linux for one reason only. When we were denied the pub last year one of our Friday night group set up Teams for a weekly online pub session. It's worked fine for me on my laptop though it did choose the onboard camera rather than the USB one last week. One of the group with Windows says Teams messes with his Outlook when both are running.

Containers have security problems and flexibility issues. VMs will make them viable

John Sager

No obvious 'winner'

I only voted now (16:15BST 23/6/21) as I don't have a dog in this fight. Interesting to see that when I voted it was exactly 50/50!

Open standard but not open access: Schematron author complains about ISO paywall

John Sager

Re: Difficult to agree with this more

I've purchased and worked from a number of specs, some of which are missing enough technical detail to make implementing them involve a large degree of guesswork

Standards ought to have an accompanying Rationale document that explains why certain design choices were made. When the process of defining the ADA language was running, the team I was in was writing a compiler (not for ADA) and we were interested enough to get the docs for the four candidates. All had a Rationale doc to describe how the choices were made for various language features. This must have aided immensely the various ADA compiler writers at the time.

A hotline to His Billness? Or a guard having a bit of a giggle?

John Sager

Not anything like that. I once found it impossible to find the reference book for the SPARC instruction set, so in pure frustration I emailed Scott McNealy, pointing out that Intel had all this stuff on their website. He emailed me back and the book arrived by return of post. I don't suppose I would get the same response from good ol' Larry.

Realizing this is getting out of hand, Coq mulls new name for programming language

John Sager

Re: Just call it ...

Yes, but we weren't talking about the programming language as such, we were talking about, and lampooning, the weak-brained fussbuckets that like to take umbrage.

The best time to plant a tree is 20 years ago. The best time to build a semiconductor foundry is 5 years ago

John Sager

Re: Is this fair?

We used to call them Seagulls - fly in, shit on everyone & fly off again.

Ireland warned it could face 'rolling blackouts' if it doesn't address data centres' demand for electricity

John Sager

Re: Lucky Ireland

they just mean you don't have to turn them on as often

Which trashes the business case for the backup power stations. If they only generate electricity for part of the time, they only get a fraction of the revenue. The business case for installing renewables should include costs associated with the backup plans, but it doesn't as that would show up "green energy" for the racket that it is

BT promises firmware update for Mini Whole Home Wi-Fi discs to prevent obsessive Big Tech DNS lookups

John Sager

If this is supposed to be a link integrity check, it's a criminally stupid way of doing it. My ISP sends LCP echos to my border router every second in the PPP session to monitor link integrity, delay, etc. That's the proper way to do it.

Global Fastly outage takes down many on the wibbly web – but El Reg remains standing

John Sager

Re: implications and questions

I got that about a week ago. I thought it was my own network because I've been experimenting with nftables (definitely nicer than iptables but doesn't support as many targets). But it turned out to be external.

Oracle hits UK reseller with lawsuit for allegedly reselling grey market Sun hardware

John Sager

I had a SPARCStation 2 as a desktop (or rather side-table-top) machine for several years before I persuaded TPTB to let me buy a PC running Linux. I stuck with SunOS 4 rather than 'upgrading' to Solaris. That was a very capable machine for its time.

China reveals plan to pump out positive news about itself. Let's see what happens when that lands with social media fact-checkers

John Sager

Re: It'll take more than that

Yup. We judge you by your actions, not by what you say.

NASA to return to the Moon by 2024. One problem with that, says watchdog: All of it

John Sager

Re: I did it my way

We all wish for things we can't have. That kind of political pie-division has long been a feature of US politics, though NASA does seem to suffer more than most. I guess it's the supposed extra kudos that attaches to SPACE!!

UK Computer Misuse Act convictions declined last year despite pandemic explosion in online criminal activity

John Sager

Re: Incidentally

What would be an appropriate sentence? 10 years in Club Fed versus a caution speaks more to the US predilection for heavy sentences. I agree a caution seems a bit light for that one.

Where a particular crime involves several offences the CPS would most likely go for the one with the heaviest tariff that has a likelihood of a conviction. A CMA offence probably isn't it.

Bitcoin is ‘disgusting and contrary to the interests of civilization’ says famed investor Charlie Munger

John Sager

Re: Insert meme here

At least fiat money doesn't take an increasing number of power stations to make.

Where meetings go to die: Microsoft Teams outage lets customers skip that collaboration call they've been dreading

John Sager

Work? What's that?

My only use of Teams is the Friday evening virtual pub session with friends that has replaced the weekly IRL session since we were placed under house arrest. That mostly works, even though it's still work time in the US, but there are occasional glitches. Nice of MS to do a Linux client too.

OK so what's going with these millions of Pentagon-owned IPv4 addresses lighting up all of a sudden?

John Sager

Re: 1/4 per cent sounds like a class A block of addresses

From what I've seen looking at info for that AS on the net, that the "175 million" addresses includes lots of subsets of 11.0.0.0/8, so actually there are only 16-odd million new addresses.

Bank of England ponders minting 'Britcoin' to sit alongside the Pound

John Sager

They would be better off thinking about how to destroy bitcoin. It's a resource disaster and that will only get worse as bitcoins become harder and harder to mine.

Quality control, Soviet style: Here's another fine message you've gotten me into

John Sager

Re: Not a translator

I can imagine it's difficult and stressful, especially when the syntax isn't the same.

I once heard Eric Laithwaite relate an anecdote. He had been to a conference with simultaneous translation, and he was listening to a translation of a German speaker. Suddenly the translator stopped while the speaker went on. Eventually Laithwaite heard the translator mutter "the verb, man! the verb!" before finally trying to pick up again at the end of the sentence.

John Sager

Re: Such value for money

I was giving a talk once to a meeting in a well-known Scottish town, and a local had been deputed to meet me at the station. So we identified each other and went out to his car - a Lada. I have never heard so much gear whine in my life! It was far worse than the whine from the transfer gear on old Minis. I don't suppose the Russians thought it worthwhile to spend effort on helical gears.

SpaceX's Starlink: Overhyped and underpowered to meet broadband needs of Rural America, say analysts

John Sager

Re: Current user here

Perhaps that's how it should be, but here East of the pond, the news we get regarding muni fibre in the US is usually of the cable companies indulging in endless lawfare to prevent it.

SQL now a dirty word for Oracle, at least in cloudy data warehouses

John Sager

"low code" - LOL, we've been there before

Remember all those tools that sprouted decades ago that were supposed to make programming redundant? Didn't happen did it. This one is almost guaranteed to go the same way, largely because it's a Larry lucre levitator rather than an attempt at a genuine business productivity tool.

Boffins revisit the Antikythera Mechanism and assert it’s no longer Greek to them

John Sager

Boffinry at its best

The paper is well worth reading, plus the supplementary info. The CGI videos in the latter are fascinating. It would take a talented clockmaker these days to build one, and the team propose to do just that using methods from those times. I will be very interested to see the result.

Rookie's code couldn't have been so terrible that it made a supermarket spontaneously combust... right?

John Sager

I thought of Purgatory after I posted, but too late to edit.

John Sager

Re: Typo? Or me being dense?

Chilled is just above 0C, frozen is more like -40C for a warehouse.

John Sager

What's your upvote/downvote ratio though? >1 heaven, <1 hell. Not sure what =1 is...

Hacking is not a crime – and the media should stop using 'hacker' as a pejorative

John Sager

Re: My current annoyance is "gift" as a verb

OED isn't an Academie Française type prescriptive document. It's real job is to describe current and historical usage with contemporary examples. I should think the keepers of the OED shudder at some of the usages they do document but then all languages (including French despite the AF) change at varying speeds.

Choose your fighter! March Mammal Madness pits poor, innocent critters against each other in mortal combat

John Sager

Re: Honeybadger!

You aren't allowed to pit honey badgers against any other animal (it's a completely unfair contest whichever way you look at it), except certain classes of human. I know which classes I mean but you may have other ideas. Note that I'm classless...

John Sager

Reality is more interesting

I've got video of fox versus otter in our garden (search 'fox encounters otter' on YT). The result was inconclusive, but otter versus carp was as you would expect, a few pink scales...

Scottish rocketeers Orbex commission Europe's largest industrial 3D printer to crank out 35 engines a year

John Sager

The intention is that weaknesses will be eliminated by doing away with welds and joining

Metal 3d printing is all weld, though I suppose pendants might quibble about sintering.

Facebook and Apple are toying with us, and it's scarcely believable

John Sager

Section 230

Just make them publishers, with all that that entails. They can't be common carriers as to carry anything and everything without editorial control would lose them most of their advertising customers.

John Sager

Re: Luxury goods

Yep. They are 'Veblen goods', artificially rare & expensive so ownership is supposed to say something about the owner. It says 'tosser' to me though. I have a Citizen Eco Drive watch I bought many years ago at Argos with £100 off. It loses 30 secs every 4 months or so consistently so it's easy to reset every so often. It has everything I need in a watch, but no gold or diamonds, so no-one is going to steal it unless they value its performance like I do.

UK watchdog fines two firms £270k for cold-calling 531,000 people who had opted out

John Sager

Re: Lots getting away with it

I used to get missing digit ones, but they've got wise to that now. Most now look like regular 0+4+6 or 0+3+7 numbers. Sometimes I recognise illegal digits inside them. As our phone signals 'international' (not always reliably), I see those with apparent UK numbers and even some that are genuinish overseas numbers. In any case, they all go to the answer machine unless they are in its phonebook. I really can't be arsed to string them along. The TPS is not fit for purpose unless & until UK phone companies can block spoofed numbers. Dunno whether it's a technical, commercial or political issue that they can't/don't.

Europe promises all-out assault on batteries to counter China’s lithium-ion domination

John Sager

Grid applications? ROFLMAO!

The Oz battery was a vanity project by Elon Musk. It's useless as storage for the grid for any reasonable length of time. What it does do, and I think this may have been unexpected, is provide second-by-second frequency control. Apparently the installation makes good money doing that.

Battery tech isn't going to get more energy dense or even much more energy-cheap in a big step, so energy storage on the scale of even Dinorwig is not going to happen soon. And Dinorwig only works for 6 hours or so at full chat.

You would expect a qualified electrician to wire a building to spec, right? Trust... but verify

John Sager

Re: You would expect a qualified electrician to wire a building to spec, right?

Well it would now, sadly. Also the modern 3 phase colours are rubbish. Try distinguishing them in anywhere not lit with a portable sun!

John Sager

Re: The neutral doesn't join up with anything on the switch!

A bit related. The fan in the bathroom failed, and in investigating I discovered that the original installers used delta 3-phase cable - 3 phases and earth - to wire it. So they used brown as the live but grey for the neutral and black for the switched live! Not very professional since there is proper 4-wire with brown, blue, earth & the 4th (red?) available.

I suppose, since I'm not a 'qualified elecrician' that I shouldn't have been working on the bathroom circuit. Naughty boy!

China showing signs of brewing IPv6 eruption

John Sager

Re: and?

I doubt it. There will be translation to allow V6 hosts to talk to V4 endpoints. You may hope that this would bar spam etc but that would be optimistic.

Lenovo ThinkPad Carbon X1 Gen 8: No boundaries were pushed in the making of this laptop – and that's OK

John Sager

I use the Trackpoint and have done ever since I had a HP laptop at work with one. I can't get along with trackpads - I've had so much trouble with hovering & the thing thinks I want a click. I have a E595 and the only thing I use the pad for is vertical scrolling.

UK comms regulator: Could we interest sir in a bespoke broadband speed estimate?

John Sager

Re: Speed guess?

a 70Mb/s connection is almost always going to be lovely, easy to deal with bursty traffic :)

Not when I start watching 4k telly on iPlayer or Amazon. This is going to be more prevalent too. A mate has just got FTTP after suffering crap VDSL for years (Al!) and he's now thinking seriously about a 4k TV.

Chuck Yeager, sound barrier pioneer pilot, dies at 97

John Sager

Re: The Right Stuff

One word. Disney. Says it all ☹️

UK coronavirus tier postcode-searching tool yanked offline as desperate Britons hunt for latest lockdown details

John Sager

Re: Cloud all the way

Yes, that's one of the few times Cloud makes sense. They should have realised that there would be a gynormous spike for a few hours so spin up a lot of capacity then ramp it back down tomorrow. Thankfully Guido had captured the list so that's where I discovered how stupid the tiering is.

No, the creator of cURL didn't morph into Elon Musk and give away Bitcoins. But his hijacked Twitter page tried to

John Sager

Bitcoin spam

Definitely on the up ATM. I'm getting quite a few and some scrote used my email address as the 'From' so I got lots of bounces from MTAs all over the globe ☹️

Brit accused of spying on 772 people via webcam CCTV software tells court he'd end his life if extradited to US

John Sager

Re: Team America: World Police

He's allegedly broken US computer misuse laws and the US wire fraud laws, so they would be tried in the US. So far the UK authorities have not charged him with anything as I understand it.

Hydrogen-powered train tested on Britain's railway tracks as diesel alternative

John Sager

Hydrogen economy is a bit like fusion power

'In the next 20 years'. Hydrogen has all sorts of problems. About it's only redeeming feature is burning it or consuming in a fuel cell produces only H2O.

It's a small molecule so it leaks much more easily than methane or propane.

It's light so the energy density - Joules/kg - is low, also see next point - storage cylinders are heavy.

It won't liquefy easily so practical storage is just gas at pressure, so energy density - Joules/litre - is low

No distribution infrastructure so that's a large capital cost to get it going.

I saw the BBC report - said it took most of the day to fill it with enough H2 for 100 miles... Admittedly it's still an experiment but it looks very much at the 'alpha' stage. Certainly nowhere near the basis for production.

The power of Bill compels you: A server room possessed by a Microsoft-hating, Linux-loving Demon

John Sager

Re: Not met a demon

I ran a SPARC 2 as a desktop for several years. Lovely machine for the time, stayed with SunOS 4 though. Eventually though I persuaded the boss's boss to spring for a PC, that then ran Linux.

Google, Amazon pass on UK Digital Services Tax by hiking ad prices, fees at same rate the government takes

John Sager

Re: re: so it'll be interesting to see what the new competition regime makes of this

How do you pick 'National Champions' though? Benn wasn't very good at it, and would you trust any of the current lot? All those govt support for industry things just became boondoggles for smart grifters. I give you DeLorean and Strathearn.

You *bang* will never *smash* humiliate me *whack* in front of *clang* the teen computer whizz *crunch* EVER AGAIN

John Sager

Re: With great power comes great incompatibility

Nice site. He's even got Wylex plugs, which my parents' first house had. According to my dad I re-wired one of those accurately when I was 3. A good start to a tech life.

When you bork... through a storm: Liverpool do all they can to take advantage of summer transfer, er, Windows

John Sager

Don't have that problem. But then my kit is a bit earlier in the alphabet. So, Reg, have you yet seen borkage from the Big L?