* Posts by Paul Hovnanian

2000 publicly visible posts • joined 16 Mar 2008

Voice assistants failed because they serve their makers more than they help users

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Lights, FireTV and heating

Heh. We used to have an old bronze ship's bell outside the back door. At dinner time, my mom rang it and we'd come down. Or out of the tree fort in the woods. At least half a mile or better range. No vocal chord straining required.

ChatGPT has mastered the confidence trick, and that's a terrible look for AI

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: It doesn’t know what it’s talking about, and it doesn’t care

I don't know about golf, but linux has a 'yes' command.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: It doesn’t know what it’s talking about, and it doesn’t care

Excellent observation.

And as we climb the corporate hierarchy (see the Dilbert Principle) it should be increasingly easy to replace the higher ranks with simple shell scripts.

San Francisco investigates Hotel Twitter, Musk might pack up and leave

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: No, way, they beat us?

"There is also the tax situation. People that live at work effectively pay half the tax that people do that have a separate place to live."

Bingo! We simply can't have people escaping the residential development market (where they negotiate as individuals with less clout) and have a large employer use their economic power to carve out a bit of living space for their employees.

It's not just the developers, but the tax base they represent for a city. Businesses are often given tax cuts to keep them in town. The lost revenue being recoverable from residential properties.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: No, way, they beat us?

New shed? Just call it a remodel.

Years ago, when working for the power company, I went to identify a service location for a new(?) waterfront mini mansion. Upon arriving, I noted that the building (under construction) was pretty close to the lake. And I asked the architect if this was going to cause code problems. He informed me that this was not a new house, just a remodel. From about 400 square feet to 6000. He pointed to a patch of ancient-looking linoleum flooring in one corner of the laundry room. The "old" house.

Peekaboo: Once-hidden galaxy revealed to be window into cosmic history

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Age vs stellar size

So, we are looking at a very young galaxy populated by large, young, metal poor stars. And it's much closer (20 million light years) than most of the other young, metal poor galaxies. So then it's a new point on the graph of galaxy creation dates. Galaxies in the local neighborhood are still being born.

We get a change to tweak our current understanding of galaxy birth.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Age vs stellar size

Theory states that very large Pop III stars burn through their hydrogen/helium fuel very quickly generating the metallic elements. And then they go nova or supernova, distributing these components to seed newer generation stars.

The existance of this galaxy may provide evidence for a new stellar evolution route. Where smaller, old stars hang around for billions of years. Not burning through their fuel quickly and, as a result, not producing great quantities of heavy elements.

Washington DC drags Amazon to court for 'yoinking' driver tips

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

"Wage theft is very common in the U.S."

True. But the tax and financial systems here have a vested interest in maintaining the idea that labor and wages are two separate things. If labor was afforded a value*, then a shortchanged worker could just file a contractor's lien against the employers property to recover the agreed upon amount.

*A bit of a Marxist idea, granted. And it would devastate our tax system in that my giving an employer $100 worth of labor in exchange for the same in wages could be written off as an expense, making my income tax liability zero.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

"It's like bribing the state."

Sort of. It's about maintaining eligibility to continue to participate in government contracts. Something one is not permitted to do with a criminal conviction on their records.

It's sad that our justice system pursues some people into court and eventually prison to demonstrate that "justice has been done". Even when such efforts result in a net cost to society. But others are allowed to pay some amount to be determined to erase that bad mark. Payment as a punishment is OK, but wrong is wrong and that should stand on a record by itself.

Rackspace confirms ransomware attack behind days-long email meltdown

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Aim for the moon, fall into the Black Hole

"Rackspace is owned by Apollo"

Are we certain it isn't the Kerbal Space Program?

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Improper use of commas.

The panda eats, shoots, and leaves.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Is this more of an attack ...

... on Exchange than on Rackspace?

Had all of these Exchange servers been sitting on customers' premises, would the attacks still be possible? It would be a matter of attacking systems hosted on different subnets, behind a wider variety of firewalls. But as these have to interoperate between different enterprises, they are already exposed to the Internet. Or how would Company A send a messsge to Company B?

US chip group: $52b is not enough, we need an extra $30b in federal funding

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

$30 Billion more

Hookers and coke got hit by inflation as well.

San Francisco lawmakers approve lethal robots – but they can't carry guns

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Daleks

Exterminate! Exterminate!

'What's the point of me being in my office, just because they want to see me in the office?'

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Interesting to note

From the article:

"According to the LSE research, while C-suite level executives in many large businesses are asking for workers to come into the office a specific number of days per week, 'in practice they are being ignored, with managers often favouring a remote first approach that satisfies local operational needs.'"

It's the executives that want the butts back in the chairs. While the managers (closer to the actual work force) are OK with remote work. It's these managers that are responding to the need to get actual work done. While the execs may have other priorities. Like explaining to the board of directors why they had to pony up for a shiny new headquarters building. Or having to face the cities chamber of commerce snd explain why they are not doing their part to keep the real estate market overheated.

Block Fi seeks bankruptcy protection as 'shocking' FTX contagion spreads

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Hard Currency

"The only "value" they have is some perceived rarity"

Which, in the beginning, wasn't a bad thing. Fixed money supply, whether due to being backed by gold or some software enforced limit prevented central banks from diddling with the economy (in theory). But when the exchanges became banks and started making loans, they descended to the same level of mistrust that fiat currencies have. Lower even. Because although our Federal Reserve is only a quasi-governmental institution, they to have to explain themselves to Congress from time to time.

SBF answered to no-one but SBF.

AWS joins the water positive gang, claims it will be there by 2030

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

I can see this ...

... ending badly. At least on my side of the pond (sorry). Our municipal water utilities have always taken a dim view of people bypassing the water meter (their revenue) by installing rainwater cisterns for irrigation and other gray water uses.

They backed down on rain barrels. But anything of a significant size is a significant prermitting headache. Not that they are completely wrong in principal. Parking lot and rooftop precipitation diverted from the local groundwater inputs can affect stream and lake levels.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

My cars and my gas heating are all water positive (just ignore the CO2 for this excercize). Where do I go to apply for my "good boy" points?

Elon Musk to abused Twitter users: Your tormentors are coming back

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: "Vox Populi, Vox Dei"

That's why we have a Constitution. With enumerated civil rights and clearly(?) defined limits on what the majority and/or government are permitted to do.

Just because one group can obtain 51% of the vote doesn't mean they can overstep those limits and oppress the 49%.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

"Vox Populi, Vox Dei"

But that's the essence of democracy. That which is held dear to the soon-to-be tormented classes that populate(d) the Twit-verse.

I guess the actual process involves the silencing of opposing ideas by deplatforming. And then submitting a sanitized ballot to the plebiscite with limited choices for a thumbs up/down. You can have Spam, bacon, eggs and Spam. That's not got much Spam in it.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: And to think that 30 years ago...

Imagine if the Monty Python argument sketch was written today:

"An argument is a connected series of statement intended to establish a proposition."

Downvoted.

"Argument is an intellectual process. Contradiction is just the automatic gainsaying of anything the other person says."

Downvoted.

[etc]

Epson zaps lasers into oblivion, in the name of the environment

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Greener printing

Well, there goes the price of the green ink refills.

US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around homes

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

No poles in my neighborhood. Underground wiring.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

"nothing stops police from using these small, cheap cameras to watch anyone's — or everyone's — homes without limit."

A 12 foot hedge.

Twitter is suffering from mad bro disease. Open thinking can build it back better

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

"there are networks of many thousands of high value accounts sharing knowledge and insight"

and

"who are corruptible and often have dubious intentions with no sense of civic duty"

I suspect that both are true in many cases. And without assurances that they can continue to pursue their agenda, they'll be leaving for more amenable venues. And I think Musk didn't know the extent of this sub rosa network.

Hey, GitHub, can you create an array compare function without breaking the GPL?

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Some functions are very simple

It can be done. Not practically for a system that trains on a few billion cat pictures and attempts to find cats in some input. But for a restricted training dataset*, when training the neural network, it's possible to save a link to each instance of each training input that results in some change to a 'neuron' weight. And backtrack through deeper layers of the network.

It's a question of whether it's a requirement of the system. And if your AI is providing decisions in a process regulated by some three letter agency and they ask, "What did you base this decision on?" You had better have a list of pilots' trouble reports or whatever it is before you go fiddling with the systems.

*Which arguably GitHub is.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Some functions are very simple

I think the law has already dealt with AI "creativity", intellectual property and patent issues in some sense. If it doesn't pass through a human, it's not novel.

I can read Github packages for insights into how certain problems have been solved. I can even teach myself how to code. But if that knowledge doesn't pass through a person's mind, it must be attributed to it's source or training dataset.

Strange that Github can't trace its Copilot output back to a source package (where the authorship and license resides). Several AI systems I've worked on provided just such an "explain your reasoning" function. After all, it's just a database and walking through the relational links is just another SQL query. Humans, on the other hand, are always having strange stuff pop into their head. In fact, I suspect that such untracability may be a design feature of some AI.

Just follow the instructions … no wait, not that instruction to lock everyone out of everything

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

In a land far, far away

At a time long, long ago, I worked for an outfit and administered a system which was critical to production. I had produced a set of diagrams, notes and other instructions on how the Beast worked. Which servers were where and what to do in the event of a system crash. These were contained neatly in a three-ring binder on a bookshelf over my desk.

Our IT department, always looking to expand their baliwick, asked that they be given access to these notes. Just in case I was unreachable, hit by a bus or some such thing when the system went down.

"Will a Xerox copy do?" I asked.

"How about you just save a document on one of your servers", was the reply.

"Oh, you mean the crashed server that you are attempting to bring back on line? Think about that for a sec. At least with a hard copy, you can read it with a flashlight while trying to find the main breaker."

And they let these people run around with floppy disks ...

Go ahead, be rude. You don't know it now, but it will cost you $350,000

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: You get what you order

I roll visitors up in the rugs. Two birds with one stone.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: You get what you order

"They refused to buy any insurance they weren't legally required to buy. They knew first hand what a massive scam the whole industry is."

Liability insurance can be. If the terms are open-ended, you are just paying for someone else's eventual benefit.

If a visitor trips over a loose rug and takes me to court, in the discovery phase they determine that my net worth is $1 million. They sue me for $1 million. If the court finds that I have a $1 million liability policy, I get sued for $2 million. If I try to hide the existance of a policy, I could end up sitting in a jail cell on contempt of court charges.

Husband and wife nuclear warship 'spy' team get 20 years each

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Damn!

And there I was, ready to hand over the details of a turboencabulator to the Chinese for millions.

With potential hurricane approaching, NASA leaves mega-rocket on launch pad

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Maybe

... if it gets knocked over, they can buy some time to work the bugs out while they build up another one. Without any finger pointing.

Sort of like leaving the keys in a leased car when the payments become too onerous, hoping that it will be gone when you come out in the morning.

Microsoft hits the switch on password-free smartphone authentication

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Microsoft on smartphones

So this affects like what? Four people?

Version 252 of systemd, as expected, locks down the Linux boot process

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Boot security

That's nice. But why does it have to be lumped into the same package with the init subsystem, networking, audio, kernel logging, user home directory mounting and the kitchen sink?

Have I forgotten anything.

Unofficial fix emerges for Windows bug abused to infect home PCs with ransomware

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Relying on the unreliable

"So the basic security messages have to be repeated endlessly if we are not going to miss informing the late entrants."

I would think that these warnings would repeat for every suspect file, for all of eternity. The last thing I want, as an experienced user, is to miss a popup and think that I'm OK opening something. Because I'm smart and know all this stuff already.

The easiest people to con are often the highly educated ones.

US orders safety recall of Tesla Cyberquad-for-kids ATV

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Ah well ..

... It looks like lawn darts for the kids again this Christmas.

Rent-calculating software biz accused of colluding with 'cartel' of landlords

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge
Mushroom

Re: Intention is irrelevant

Oh, so you're the one.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Intention is irrelevant

"bought a gallon of gas lately?"

There's some truth to the instability claim. When the underlying resource price goes up (crude prices), petrol goes up. When the crude price drops, some outlets try to hang on to the higher price. It doesn't work. The spread between the highest and lowest prices increases. Discount outlets cut their prices, even though the "average" area price stays high*. And our FTC (the consumer watchdog) actually watches this metric for signs of market manipulation (refineries withholding supplies from discounters).

*In our area, the "average" price is advertised by an outfit called Gas Buddy. They take frequent surveys of advertised prices and publish the average. Problem: The high priced stations just sit empty, or selling the odd pack of cigarettes at the cash register. The discounters have lines of people waiting at the pumps. In fact, My favorite station (Costco) occasionally has a line of delivery trucks refilling their tanks. The price spread today is well over $1.00/gallon.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: This classic 'market forces'

"It's 'as high as the market can bear'"

Until it's a union doing the negotiating. Then watch the capitalists scream.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: If most of the major property owners are using this

"public information displayed in the vacancy advert."

Assuming that potential renters are agreeing to pay that rate. It's not "rent charged" until someone moves in.

How I made a Chrome extension for converting Reg articles to UK spelling

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge
Boffin

Re: Cant spell or count

"Also, they need to learn how to count."

One, two, three, ... many.

That ought to do it.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge
Trollface

It could be worse

It could have been an app that implemented the writing guide of The Grauniad.

Liz Truss ousted as UK prime minister, outlived by online lettuce

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

"that people have vaguely fond memories of."

Dwight D. Eisenhower here. Perhaps the secret is to select a bald leader.

Collapsed Arecibo telescope to be replaced by school

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Nice thought, but ...

... isn't the site located some miles away from the nearest town (Arecibo), through the mountains? And there are some other instruments up there, still working. So perhaps keep it in reserve for possible future observatory work. There's the University of Puerto Rico campus in town. Perhaps a better site for a bunch of STEM students.

Musk says Starlink will keep providing free service to Ukraine

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Universal Service Fund

"I wonder if Starlink will get something"

Shirley, you jest. All that money was promised to the incumbents. And reallocating any will trigger a response akin to taking a cookie from a toddler.

"or they are threatening him with prison."

Not until they can seal a deal to line up someone else to launch NASA payloads.

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Universal Service Fund

Musk's comment may indeed have been triggered by the refusal by our FCC to fund Starlink rural access. But what he needs to understand is that this fund was negotiated between the US government and the incumbent telecoms. For the benefit of the latter. It is not to be shared with newcomers who might seek to put up a few microwave towers. Or satellites.

The FCC rejected Starkink's application, claiming that they failed to demonstrate the ability to provide the promised service. Well, Ukraine can serve as that demonstration. But it won't matter. Because the telecoms have repeatedly failed to demonstrate the same sorts of service delivery despite the reciept of piles of cash.

Laugh all you want. There will be a year of the Linux desktop

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Just in time ...

... for the last remaining person to actually do work sitting at a desk. This isn't how I thought we'd win the war. But technically it's correct.

Financial watchdogs want to know what traders are talking about on WhatsApp

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Off channel comms

In my day, we had to make shady deals on the golf course.

Now you kids get off my lawn!

Lab explores dystopian future of AI helping cops catch criminals

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

ED-209

"Please put down your weapon. You have 20 seconds to comply."

No, working in IT does not mean you can fix anything with a soldering iron

Paul Hovnanian Silver badge

Re: Mandatory tech support

And your point is?

https://youtu.be/h5aEVGkkgVo