The Register® — Biting the hand that feeds IT

Feeds

* Posts by ysth

49 posts • joined Tuesday 4th March 2008 00:25 GMT

ysth
Devil

You can determine whether there's been compliance with candor and good faith simply by noting you are dealing with the U.S. Government.

I'll let you all decide which way to take that.

ysth
FAIL

Nothing to see here

Um, this is part of what cloud means, at least in AWS's visualization of it. If you have something to "repair" when an instance goes away, you are doing it wrong.

ysth
Devil

Code that includes thousands of macros

Is he talking about the Perl 5 source?

ysth
FAIL

Re: Big tech companies promote "copyleft"? That's new to me.

You are making the same error that the article made. Copyleft is not the opposite of copyright, it is copyright used for a particular kind of purpose.

And I get the feeling there is general ignorance of RMS's positions on *non*-software IP - something I'd like to see change.

ysth

Is that true?

I also would question the truth of that - though I would say the dividing line is that free/libre software will fix the first part; just open source may not.

SaaS too certainly doesn't have to - by day I'm a closed-source SaaS developer, and almost all customer data is exportable; where it's not, it's because I'm so busy :)

ysth

Re: What does "support" mean though?

Agreed; "support" doesn't mean anything more than security updates for a version of the OS that no one develops for any more; it would be surprising if it meant supporting older hardware for newer OS or application releases.

ysth
Headmaster

Wobbly?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wobbly

ysth

I was going to suggest...

I was going to suggest "MexiPhone", but that's way better!

ysth
WTF?

I have no idea what you just said.

What is this article about?

ysth

Re: Headline is very misleading

No, they were out and out paid (but lost more than they gained, as it happened). Just as Barnes and Noble was paid to drop their anti-competition complaint against Microsoft (and may also come to regret it).

ysth
FAIL

Headline is very misleading

The headline is very misleading; there is nothing in the story about ASUS getting "paid", the way Nokia is being paid for its Windows Phone efforts.

ysth

It's all about the license

It's all about the license. And there is room (and desire, apparently) for both free and non-free licensing.

ysth

Re: A PR failure?

Think of a website with a Donate button; should that be opt in? The first time you visit, present you with a confirm dialog "Would you like to see the Donate button?" and store the result in a cookie?

I haven't tried 12.10 and am unlikely to any time soon, but it really doesn't sound like that big a deal.

ysth

A PR failure?

Lots of people buy things from Amazon. Lots of people use Ubuntu and wouldn't mind doing something easy to support it. Seems like they've just made that possible. Is that such a big deal?

As a search tool, the new feature sounds useless, I admit. So think of it as a Donate button - except that it donates Amazon's money, not yours.

ysth

Re: Lost the plot

I said the same. Then a co-worker inspired me to actually try it - to just install 12.04 and live with it for a couple of weeks. So I did, with just the stock 12.04 experience, no tweaks, no add ons, and I adapted. It's really not that bad.

ysth

Obligatory google calendar complaint

Why oh why do they refuse to support floating times? There's a *reason* they are in the iCal specification.

ysth

Making this make sense

Karen Sandler's keynote at Linux.conf.au 2012 ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XDTQLa3NjE ) gave me for the first time some insight into *why* Gnome Shell/Unity/Metro are heading us in this direction.

Still don't like it.

ysth

Who is MWR Infosecurity? No wikipedia page; not much web presence at all other than their thin website.

I'm a little baffled by this; are there some other permissions the app should use when displaying advertisements besides the permissions the user granted? What do these users who weren't informed of something (not sure what) expecting?

ysth
Devil

A security startup with $26M in funding and a bizarrely hand-wavy business model makes a first splash with a planned expose of Android weaknesses? Do you smell Microsoft? I do.

ysth
Terminator

Oh, Florian

"Google must have consented to this action because" just doesn't pack the same punch, does it?

ysth

Where's the joke? :)

ysth
FAIL

Err, security number one priority? no

The memo repeatedly places availability before security.

I'm not going to say anything about Office 365. Really, I'm not.

ysth

The intended use is not the problem here

Well, at least not the major problem. I actually believe carriers when they say they only want to use CarrierIQ to help customers. But in a world where police feel free to seize and strip data off your phone without a warrant, it doesn't help that the information would have been only transfered to the carrier after encryption, or how well they protect anonymity in handling the data. They have to not log it in the first place.

ysth

"extremely difficult to understand their plan"

While Buffett seems to understand IBM's plan very well...to continue to convince companies to voluntarily submit to vendor lock in. That's something that's worked very well the last 20, 30, 40 years. But it's an idea whose time has passed. Pity Buffett doesn't get that.

ysth

paradox?

I don't see the paradox. Perhaps you meant irony?

ysth

DRM or not is orthogonal to license vs. own.

ysth
Facepalm

Err, I don't do facebook, but isn't it against their TOS to share your password?

ysth
Pirate

roadmap

I had the pleasure of talking and listening to Monty for quite a while at OSCON, and MySQL may have an uncertain roadmap but the same is not true of MariaDB.

ysth

liable for arrest

"Failure to appear before the committee would have meant they'd broken US law and were liable for arrest."

And, if they grabbed a bunch of Google's cash and fled the country, they'd be in danger of being charged with embezzlement too. And suppose they hijacked the plane and ordered it to take them to China to start a new Internet Empire on the other side of the Great Firewall? Then there would have been serious diplomatic consequences. Should they actually succeed in taking over a majority of Chinese internet traffic, they could then expand their new services to Europe and the Americas, replacing the Google "monopoly" with a much bigger, better, global one.

ysth

Already too late?

Aren't any of these "security issue" TLDs already an issue with a poisoned DNS server?

ysth

Tie to FTC probe?

So far I see *nothing* tying this to the FTC probe other than journalists' assertions.

To me, it seems much more likely to be tied to the Nortel auction (and Google's general position in the patent wars). That's something lobbyists will be able to help.

(I'd love it if Google chose to "invest" 3.14 billion on getting software patents abolished and fixing other problems in the patent system...)

ysth

Imaginary?

Yup, imaginary. Cookie cutter "claim charts" with no actual content. This is bullying with the threat of an, at best, dubious lawsuit, nothing more.

"expert patent troll/lobbyist Florian Mueller", I think you meant. To be fair, I'm pretty sure he was never in the SS.

ysth

Re: The lesson (call it myth if you want) of MS vs OS/2 is vitally important today

> It's all a giant conspiracy.

Thanks for responding. I guess your conspiracy is my well-thought out plan. Or rather, Microsoft's.

Do you think they don't have one? Or that they do, but some of the components I mentioned are not part of it?

ysth
Megaphone

The lesson (call it myth if you want) of MS vs OS/2 is vitally important today

The lesson (call it myth if you want) of MS vs OS/2 is vitally important today.

However much there might be to criticize in IBM's handling of OS/2, the fact is that it was killed off by a very well planned campaign of FUD and viciously anti-competitive practices by Microsoft. It is really disappointing to hear in the comments here some of the memes designed by MS for their campaign:

http://groklaw.net/staticpages/index.php?page=ComesExhN03#E1116

And we are seeing exactly the same kind of campaign today against Android. All the lawsuits, all the astroturfed press, all the backroom arm-twisting for royalties from Android device manufacturers, the buying off of Nokia: it's all part of the campaign to give MS a chance to catch up on the mobile market they missed.

ysth
Thumb Down

Yet another cite of anti-Android lobbyist FM?

Muller may well say that's why there are so many lawsuits. I and others would say there are so many because many of them are filed for the principal reason of fueling anti-Android news stories. Which ironically enough is also the reason he makes his claim.

ysth

Funny...

That's how Stallman works too, I understand :)

ysth
Thumb Down

Surely

Surely you could have made your point without holding someone else up to ridicule?

ysth

F U D warning

A couple of points:

Microsoft is advertising this as a lawsuit against Android in general, when it in fact is particular to certain ebook reader interfaces. While I'm sure they have some basis for the lawsuit itself, the positioning of it as part of their greater anti-Android campaign is just more Microsoft FUD.

Remember SCO's "the hidden cost of Linux"? Now we have Microsoft's "the hidden cost of Android", and it's equally nonsense.

Secondly, Florian Mueller's name comes up again and again in these baseless Android attacks, and his motivations, financial and otherwise, remain very murky. Please, report the news (and this lawsuit is clearly news), but do it without treating him as a primary source or giving him more of a platform to stand on.

Thanks!

ysth

Routers running Unix?

I have trouble believing there are any routers running Unix.

ysth

new version every 12 to 18 months? not so!

Mozilla has released a whole lot more versions than that, just not major versions.

Chrome isn't really comparable, since they don't make the same distinction of major vs minor.

It's arguable which is the better approach, both for users and for web developers. Sounds like Mozilla is edging towards a compromise position. Will that be better than the extremes? Only time will tell.

ysth

Encouraging?

Seems like this will only encourage the parent in a weaker financial position to take a deal worse for them than they would otherwise have reached.

ysth

"avoiding the temptation to trawl the web's lower depths."

"Surfers might have protected themselves by regularly backing up important data, using anti-virus defences or (perhaps best of all) avoiding the temptation to trawl the web's lower depths."

The latter is nothing more than blaming the victim, and not appropriate.

ysth

And this is different from other Facebook apps...

And this is different from other Facebook apps just exactly how?

ysth

For now it is free

"Presumably, Oracle is not letting any of the code in the extension pack out under the GPU license, but for now it is free"

As usual in these things, the chains are free; the keys will cost you.

To Mark C Casey, I've never used shared folders; scp and rsync work just dandy. Drag and drop of files seems like a really idiotic thing to waste time getting working.

I almost wish Oracle had done something scarier and provoked a fork of the open source version; I hate seeing oracle branding more and more each day.

ysth

Will this be the time it's finally worth the $ for someone to do away with U.S. software patents?

Will this be the time it's finally worth the $ for someone to do away with U.S. software patents?

How much in campaign contributions would Google have to make? $10 million? $20m?

Compare that to the billions software patents end up costing end users every year. If we had an unbought government, it would be already done. Failing that, all it takes is one company to see more of the downside than the upside.

ysth

no unified patching solution?

"The core of this patching issue is that the software industry has, so far, failed to come up with a unified patching solution that can help home users on a large scale; that is, encompassing all software programs."

*cough* sudo aptitude update && sudo aptitude full-upgrade

ysth

Correction

The site has reset the passwords of those users whose passwords were publicized by the crackers, not those of all users. While we'd like to have done so for all users, getting the notification emails out to just the more at risk group is proving to be quite a hassle.

ysth

CDN, anyone?

Makes no sense for individuals to try to serve large files whose demand may spiky.